Showing posts with label Amendment 1. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Amendment 1. Show all posts

Friday, August 7, 2009

They're Still Campaigning

(More on the First Amendment violations of the "fishy" email requests by the White House.)

During the run up to the election, the Obama campaign effectively used electronic media. Most of us know how successful that was in getting out Obama's talking points as well as fund raising. Later revelations of the JournoList and the use of paid ACORN protesters were seen as despicable, but they fell within the typical dirty tricks camp of national elections.

What you can do when you're running for office and running a national campaign is entirely different from what you can do once you're in office. The then Senator Obama could not have solicited input on Americans who were exercising their free speech in declaring their concerns about Candidate Obama, but the Democratic Party hacks could have done that.

Seven months into President Obama's Administration, the staff at the White House are still behaving as if they're on the campaign trail. That was obvious to many, as the constant press conferences and stump speeches are signs that President Obama is still behaving as Candidate Obama.

But the White House Blog request for notification of "fishy" communications is unconstitutional for a member of government. I, as a private citizen, could ask for that information because the limitations on Free Speech don't apply to private citizens. I could set up a mechanism for collecting that information (and even pay people who send me the information). The restriction on limiting speech applies only to the government.

The Supreme Court has decided the matter in the past. Federal law prevents keeping a database on private citizens.

I would love to believe that the staffers at the White House Blog were intentionally engaging in a conspiracy to supress the free speech of citizens by setting up the "fishy" reporting mechanism, but that gives this Administration too much credit. They're not that clever. Rather, they're still in campaign mode, and are too stupid to know that they have violated one of American citizens' most precious liberties.

Sen. John Cornyn wrote a letter to the Obama Administration regarding the matter:
Dear President Obama,

I write to express my concern about a new White House program to monitor American citizens' speech opposing your health care policies, and to seek your assurances that this program is being carried out in a manner consistent with the First Amendment and America's tradition of free speech and public discourse.

Yesterday, in an official White House release entitled "Facts are Stubborn Things," the White House Director of New Media, Macon Phillips, asserted that there was "a lot of disinformation out there," and encouraged citizens to report "fishy" speech opposing your health care policies to the White House. Phillips specifically targeted private, unpublished, even casual speech, writing that "rumors often travel just below the surface via chain emails or through casual conversation." Phillips wrote "If you get an email or see something on the web about health insurance reform that seems fishy, send it to flag@whitehouse.gov."
I am not aware of any precedent for a President asking American citizens to report their fellow citizens to the White House for pure political speech that is deemed "fishy" or otherwise inimical to the White House's political interests.

By requesting that citizens send "fishy" emails to the White House, it is inevitable that the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and private speech of U.S. citizens will be reported to the White House. You should not be surprised that these actions taken by your White House staff raise the specter of a data collection program. As Congress debates health care reform and other critical policy matters, citizen engagement must not be chilled by fear of government monitoring the exercise of free speech rights.

I can only imagine the level of justifiable outrage had your predecessor asked Americans to forward emails critical of his policies to the White House. I suspect that you would have been leading the charge in condemning such a program-and I would have been at your side denouncing such heavy-handed government action.

So I urge you to cease this program immediately. At the very least, I request that you detail to Congress and the public the protocols that your White House is following to purge the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and identities of citizens who are reported to have engaged in "fishy" speech. And I respectfully request an answer to the following:

  • How do you intend to use the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and identities of citizens who are reported to have engaged in "fishy" speech?

  • How do you intend to notify citizens who have been reported for "fishy" speech?

  • What action do you intend to take against citizens who have been reported for engaging in "fishy" speech?

  • Do your own past statements qualify as "disinformation"? For example, is it "disinformation" to note that in 2003 you said:"I happen to be a proponent of a single-payer universal health care plan"?


I look forward to your prompt response.

Sincerely,
JOHN CORNYN
United States Senator

I suspect that no criminal charges will be filed, but ignorance of the law is not an excuse (especially by members of the government, and more especially the Office of the President as one of the primary duties of the President is to enforce the laws, not violate them), and the Obama Administration has committed a crime simply by creating this fishing hole (what they do with the information received is adding to the existing crime).

Sen. Cornyn got it exactly right and I hope that his cease and desist letter will be enough to get the program stopped. It won't stop the other crimes, misdemeanors, and constitutional violations being perpetrated by this Administration, but it is a good start.

During the campaign we were told that Obama had sufficient experience to hit the bricks running. The problem, of course, is that he didn't. He's running, but it is a still a campaign not an Administration.
In every stage of these Oppressions We have Petitioned for Redress in the most humble terms: Our repeated Petitions have been answered only by repeated injury. A Prince, whose character is thus marked by every act which may define a Tyrant, is unfit to be the ruler of a free people.

-- Thomas Jefferson, Declaration of Independence


Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Speak the Speech I Pray You

Mickey Kaus (Kausfiles, Wellstone's Curse: Undoing the Right Thing, June 30, 2009):
Hasen predicts a near nuclear disaster for the goo-goo campaign finance lobby: SCOTUS will nix the whole decades-long attempt to keep corporate and union money out of campaign ads--in effect declaring that it's OK if for-profit corporations and unions use their unlimited funds to run spots attacking specific candidates.

I can't quite figure out how Mr. Kaus thinks that the Supreme Court would be "undoing the right thing" when they finally get around to protecting the First Amendment.  Any limitations, regulations, or restrictions on political contributions is unconstitutional. Period.  End of discussion.  The lawyers can debate this ad infinitum, but the First Amendment says what it says, and we don't need lawyers to explain to us what it means.

The only asterisk in the First Amendment is false/slanderous/treasonous speech.  There is no asterisk for the following:

  • It doesn't say that only individuals can petition their government.

  • It doesn't say that groups, profitable or otherwise, should be restrained from exercising their right to speak, with the funds to make their voices louder.

  • It doesn't say that individuals or groups have to declare themselves. Anonymity is a right we all maintain.


If it is difficult to track who is giving money to whom, too bad.  If it makes it more difficult for some people to win against the large contributions from corporations, tough.  If there are "deep pockets" that will sway elections, so be it.

Rights and the protection of our Constitution do get inconvenient and troublesome at times.

If these things were easy, if they weren't sometimes inconvenient, there would have been no reason for the Founding Fathers to write it down.

H/t Instapundit.

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Letterman's Not Funny Joke

Regarding Letterman's terribly inappropriate joke about Sarah Palin's 14 year old daughter:  He should be ashamed of himself.

This has nothing to do with political correctness.  Candidates' children are off limits and "knocked up" jokes about kids aren't funny.

That aside, what really gets my goat about some of the commentary on the Internet is the constant insertion of the meme of Letterman's supports: "Don't you value Free Speech?"

Of course Republicans value Free Speech.  People can say whatever they want, except false speech.

What they cannot expect to exclude, which goes hand in hand with exercising rights, are public consequences. The government cannot put him in jail for telling a bad joke or insulting someone, but the public is certainly within their right to respond with Free Speech and Free Action of their own, to call for Letterman's head on a proverbial platter.

If that means he's stripped of his job because people boycott Letterman's advertisers, or they tune-out of his show, putting his rankings in the tank, that, too is Free Speech.  The public is free to respond with their remote control, to write and complain to the network, and to boycott CBS's advertisers.

Freedom of expression cuts both ways.

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

Oh, Man!

"A coalition of sentiments is not for the interest of printers. They, like the clergy, live by the zeal they can kindle and the schisms they can create. It is contest of opinion in politics as well as religion which makes us take great interest in them and bestow our money liberally on those who furnish aliment to our appetite... So the printers can never leave us in a state of perfect rest and union of opinion. They would be no longer useful and would have to go to the plough."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1801



From Drudge Reports (flash):
ABC TURNS PROGRAMMING OVER TO OBAMA; NEWS TO BE ANCHORED FROM INSIDE WHITE HOUSE

Tue Jun 16 2009 08:45:10 ET

On the night of June 24, the media and government become one, when ABC turns its programming over to President Obama and White House officials to push government run health care -- a move that has ignited an ethical firestorm!

Highlights on the agenda:

ABCNEWS anchor Charlie Gibson will deliver WORLD NEWS from the Blue Room of the White House.

The network plans a primetime special -- 'Prescription for America' -- originating from the East Room, exclude opposing voices on the debate.

When conservatives warned that Obama was a dangerous socialist, people scoffed at us, and called us rubes.  Who is the rube now?

Again from Drudge Reports:
ABCNEWS Senior Vice President Kerry Smith on Tuesday responded to the RNC complaint, saying it contained 'false premises':

"ABCNEWS prides itself on covering all sides of important issues and asking direct questions of all newsmakers -- of all political persuasions -- even when others have taken a more partisan approach and even in the face of criticism from extremes on both ends of the political spectrum. ABCNEWS is looking for the most thoughtful and diverse voices on this issue.

"ABCNEWS alone will select those who will be in the audience asking questions of the president. Like any programs we broadcast, ABC News will have complete editorial control. To suggest otherwise is quite unfair to both our journalists and our audience."

We shall see. ABC hasn't had a great track record with impartiality.

If the Stupid Party weren't, they'd be demanding airtime on ABC to present the contrary view. If they cannot get it through the use of "equal time" rules, then they must buy the time. It will be almost impossible to overturn socialized medicine once in place. It is far easier (and cheaper) to do everything in our power to defeat it now.
"Nothing can now be believed which is seen in a newspaper. Truth itself becomes suspicious by being put into that polluted vehicle. The real extent of this state of misinformation is known only to those who are in situations to confront facts within their knowledge with the lies of the day."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1807




"I really look with commiseration over the great body of my fellow citizens who, reading newspapers, live and die in the belief that they have known something of what has been passing in the world in their time, whereas the accounts they have read in newspapers are just as true a history of any other period of the world as of the present, except that the real names of the day are affixed to their fables. General facts may indeed be collected from them... but no details can be relied on."


- Thomas Jefferson, 1807



There is nothing new under the sun. The free press has never performed its Constitutionally defined duty.  It is up to us, individually and collectively, to spread facts and truth.