Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts

Monday, September 14, 2009

Throwing the 'Bums' Out

One of the common political refrains these days is to throw out all of Congress. It was a recurring theme that ended up on home-painted signs at the March on Washington, D.C. on Sunday. People do not see a difference between Republicans and Democrats, so the response to that inability to see a difference is to throw blame at all members of Congress for the mess we're in today.

While I'm admit that the light that shines between some Republicans and Democrats is as thin as star dust, not all Republicans and Democrats were created equal. What's important to note, however, is that the lack of differences meme works both ways.

If we were to trying to measure how conservative or liberal someone was we might begin to understand that the ideological differences are regional, not Party.

Compare, for example, the voting records of the Blue Dogs versus the Republican contingent from the northeast. The differences are marginal. The Blue Dogs refer to themselves as conservative- or moderate-Democrats and bark when there are programs designed to increase the size of the government's budget.

But that, unfortunately, is where the major differences end. The Blue Dogs might not want to increase the budget of the Federal government, but they have no problem with increasing the power of government (Blue Dog Statement on President’s Address to Congress, September 9, 2009 [pdf]) or behaving like attack dogs in the yards of private industry:
“Blue Dogs believe we have a responsibility to pass health care reform legislation that is deficit neutral, increases the value and quality of care for all Americans, and that takes a responsible approach to controlling costs over the long term."
And:
“Blue Dogs agree with President Obama that the insurance market should be reformed. We must end the practice of denying coverage to individuals with pre-existing conditions, and we must eliminate the waste, fraud and abuse that is currently bankrupting the system."
It is not possible to reign-in health care costs and micromanage the way the Insurance market sets their rates or chooses their clients. If, for example, Congress was to pass legislation which prohibited the auto insurance industry from refusing to insure people with pre-existing auto accidents, it would be clear to everyone that auto insurance would rise for all, to cover the serial accident customer, especially good drivers, because they're the low hanging fruit with respect to raising rates. But somehow, magic would be applied to the health insurance industry to prevent that same outcome.

Congress has no authority to regulate the insurance industry, auto or health, other than applying universal rules to that industry, as they do any other, and that is the issue that few are willing to admit, or tackle. The only authority Congress has with respect to the health insurance industry is to reform Tort and put fraud criminals behind bars. The latter would require that government accept responsibility and actually do something, rather than pointing the finger at evil corporations. The former would target the professions of far too many Democrats in Congress.

A conservative Republican and a conservative Democrat are not the same thing.

Most of this is laziness. People want there to be a number, letter, or other symbol next to a person's name to identify them, to take the guess work out of voting. This is desired for the same reason that some students read Spark Notes rather than reading the text of the book assigned. It might not be forbidden, but it is unethical, and the only person the students are really cheating are themselves.

There are no shortcuts to vetting a candidate before voting for them. Even the ratings services, such as Vote Smart, require more than one search to determine a candidates' voting record or policy positions. Their policy statements often have no basis in fact and a comparison of their record to their policy statements is the only way to determine if they're being honest. But that requires work.

"Throwing the bums out" has been tried before. It never works. Often the new is worse than the old. There are always new bums, but more importantly, the good people get caught in the firestorm. It is simple-mindedness to believe that all of Congress are bad.

I happen to like my Congress folks, especially in my home district. They vote exactly the way I want them to. Why would I desire to throw them out?

"Throwing the bums out" is a punitive act, targeting a group, rather than the guilty. It is borne out of a desire to punish the many for the deeds of the few, and has nothing to do with reforming government. There are no shortcuts here, and the fault is not with Congress, but with us, the voters.



Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Oh, Lady Lay, Get Over Yourself

For someone so smart, she sure gets it wrong. I will admit that I read Camille Paglia as the last sound voice among Democrats, hoping upon hope that someone who identifies with that Party will show themselves to be something other than a tool fool. At least she writes with an HL Mencken style panache. She is my only guilty pleasure and is the only Democrat to whom I give the time of day, but really it is to remind myself of how morally vacuous they truly are. Reading her is like believing that a cheating husband really means it this time when he says he'll straighten out.

Paglia disappoints again with her latest screed (Salon, Too late for Obama to turn it around?, September 9, 2009):
Democrats have managed to destroy the national coalition that elected Obama and that is unlikely to be repaired. If Obama fails to win reelection, let the blame be first laid at the door of Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, who at a pivotal point threw gasoline on the flames by comparing angry American citizens to Nazis.
The only national coalition that existed was a fantasy in the mind of Democrats. While they constantly state Obama's election in terms of "landslide," the reality is that the margin of victory was incredibly narrow and was due to the masses of religious-conservatives (formerly Yellow-Dogs) staying home out of protest that McCain, of McCain-Feingold, was their Party's standard-bearer. The conservatives stayed home to teach Republicans a lesson, but the only one getting the punishment good and hard is, well, all of us.

Paglia may have believed that magic coalition was going to put an end to politics as usual, as Obama said he would do, but only fools believed him. What politician hasn't promised that? It was a classic case of wink-wink, nudge-nudge, as everyone to the Left of McGovern ssh'd their actual plans, and said whatever was necessary to fool the masses into temporarily allowing the Democrats a flash of majority. But like a child who has been caught with the neighbor's stolen toy, it will be ripped from their crying hands and returned to the rightful owner.

It seems that Paglia believed it, and more sadly, still believes the 1960s hype that Democrats have ever been about liberty rather than libertinism, and insipid emotionalism of the Baby Boomers pouting-ascendancy to Peter Pan-like adulthood, regardless of Lucy and her Diamonds:
I always thought that the Democratic Party is the freedom party -- but I must be living in the nostalgic past. Remember Bob Dylan's 1964 song "Chimes of Freedom," made famous by the Byrds? And here's Richie Havens electrifying the audience at Woodstock with "Freedom! Freedom!" Even Linda Ronstadt, in the 1967 song "A Different Drum," with the Stone Ponys, provided a soaring motto for that decade: "All I'm saying is I'm not ready/ For any person, place or thing/ To try and pull the reins in on me."
It isn't a nostalgic past. It is a fantasy past. Bob Dylan and Linda Ronstadt were always pandering commies, of the Guthrie school of serial wife-abandonment and alcohol abuse. Paglia is stuck in the 1960s vision of a world without bad stuff and the dazzling marketing of it being about peace, rather than getting a piece. Somehow, she manages to forget that the peace her comrades delivered came with the death of millions in the Killing Fields, and mass executions in South Vietnam. But what's a few million brown people dying have to do with that cool dream of a world without war, eh?

You'd think that after all this time, with the bodies piled up for all to see, she'd have figured it out.
Why has the Democratic Party become so arrogantly detached from ordinary Americans? Though they claim to speak for the poor and dispossessed, Democrats have increasingly become the party of an upper-middle-class professional elite, top-heavy with journalists, academics and lawyers (one reason for the hypocritical absence of tort reform in the healthcare bills).
I can't tell if she actually believes that nonsense or if she's repeating it like a mantra in hopes of convincing herself of a past that never was, and a Party that never has been.

The Democrats since Truman have been about one thing, and one thing only: Power. They actually admire the world's thugocracies and authoritarian societies as models of what is possible, rather than something to avoid. She sees it in the current crop of Democratic powerful, but refuses to look into the crystal-ball of history to notice that it was ever thus:
Weirdly, given their worship of highly individualistic, secularized self-actualization, such professionals are as a whole amazingly credulous these days about big-government solutions to every social problem. They see no danger in expanding government authority and intrusive, wasteful bureaucracy. This is, I submit, a stunning turn away from the anti-authority and anti-establishment principles of authentic 1960s leftism.
Because, Camille, self-actualization as practiced by the Baby Boomers has never been anything other than elevating the self above every other self., i.e, I matter and I have power and that comes by taking yours, rather than recognizing that there is abudance enough for everyone, if they just work for it. That's always been what the Me-generation believed, and there's no evidence to suggest that the most spoiled and coddled generation will ever be about anything else except blatant selfishness and materialistic gain. The expanding government authority will be their authority, so it won't be the same authority of their parents, so it will be different, this time! They still don't get that self-actualized, applied to everyone, means that no one is special, and no one gets to elevate their lusts above everybody else's lusts. Self-actualization is about overcoming and controlling lusts, not elevating them as some sort of laudable achievement. I have a really difficult time accepting that she doesn't see this.

The 1960s Democrats don't care about the poor and starving masses yearning to be free and they never did. That was just an excuse for a party and a reason to get high. They just want to have moon-lit parties at the base of the statue as a great backdrop as a party theme. They care about getting laid, getting high, and getting and doing everything else they want, without one shred of recognition that those things have consequences. In fact, it is the consequences of bad decisions that they've been battling with their entire lives. If they wish it really, really hard, perhaps they can continue to escape the banal reality that living life without a net means you really don't have a net, and it will hurt like Hell when the high wears off. They still want someone else to bear the burden of the consequences and feel their pain. The goal has been to figure out a way to make the high permanent.
But dreaming in the 1960s and '70s had a spiritual dimension that is long gone in our crassly materialistic and status-driven time.
No, it didn't. It was always about crass materialistic selfishness, but Paglia didn't see that through the pot fog and the marketing by music companies who released the peacenik-millionaires' pathetic music...

And sadly, she still doesn't.


Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Tuesday, September 8, 2009

Reality Land

From Peter Wallsten (latimes.com, Obama is fast losing white voters' support, September 7, 2009):
Still unclear is whether Obama's slide in the polls is due solely to his policies, or questions about his personal background or allegiances.
It is not unclear. It's "all of the above."

The article is swimming in left-wing bias. Take this, for example:
...in which some conservatives accused him of socialism
We've been accusing him of socialism since he entered the race. It's now obvious to anyone with an above 4th-grade reading-level that the accusations (at the time considered smear-tactics) are true.

And then there's:
But the drop in support among whites also comes as some conservatives have stoked controversies...
By stoking controversies, he means, "reporting on the facts," but let's not quibble on the details, eh?
One such episode came to a head Sunday when Van Jones, Obama’s green jobs czar, resigned after a week of criticism over past inflammatory statements and for signing onto conspiracy theories questioning whether the U.S. government played a role in the Sept. 11 attacks. A White House official acknowledged Sunday that Jones had been vetted less rigorously than other officials.
Jones was vetted "less rigorously" than, say, the other dozen people who resigned or couldn't pass Congressional scrutiny. That's rich. The "past inflammatory statements" was a nice touch, too, and lets on to how the Democrats are going to spin that one in the future: It was in the past they'll say, and don't we all have skeletons in our past? It wasn't representative of how he is now. Silly conservatives, always predicting future behavior by actual evidence of the past behavior, rather than those hope-and-changey emotions!

There are a few more examples given how those mean-old conservatives have stoked fires, ending in:
These controversies have followed conspiracy theories that the president was born overseas and is ineligible to hold office, and that his true religion is Islam -- false rumors that some Democrats worry could be affecting the public's view of the president and his party.
Nice one, but the public is no longer buying it. Trying to lump legitimate criticisms in with the small segment of extremists worked until Democrats started accusing Tea Party attendees of being nutters. Those are people's friends and neighbors they've been slandering. The complicit media have to cover the President and hiding Obama's faults and disasters is getting more and more difficult. Blaming someone else for your troubles works for a while, but Americans really do believe that "the buck stops with the President."

What's important to remember is that Americans are willing to give a new President some slack, and expect a few stumbles as they get their Administration staffed. It becomes difficult to continue to blame Obama's mistakes on newness or staff ineptitude. Eventually, the only reasonable conclusion is that the flattering opinion of Obama was a mistake. The flattery was based on Obama being an unknown quantity, with people reading into the blank slate what they wanted to see. That's no longer the case.

During the campaign it was possible for Team Obama to distance the candidate from his socialist sympathies (few actually researched Obama's voting record or took seriously his association with former-criminals, his friendliness for left-wing dictators, or read his American-apologist/ progressive agenda spelled out in his books). But this (despite the White House staff confusion on the matter) is no longer Candidate Obama. He is now President Obama and the people ready to give him a pass for his history can't dismiss the reality appearing on the news every night.

I'll go so far as to make a prediction: While Obama will have a bit of a roller-coaster ride in the polls over the coming years, the general trend will be lead balloon. He won't get renominated by his own Party.

I don't know of a precedent for a President becoming a lame duck in their first year in office, but Obama has always been about beating odds. If Obama is half as smart as his supporters thought he was, he'll feign some sort of illness to allow him to step aside. I'm not certain that a narcissist of Obama's league can handle being loathed by so many.

When a politician can make Joe Biden seem like a brilliant statesman, you have to know how bad things really are in reality land.

H/t Instapundit.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Thursday, September 3, 2009

Succint

From Paul Howard (City Journal, It’s the System, September 3, 2009):
The real health-care problem isn’t moral, as the president claims, but structural.

What he said.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Neo-Federalists and Competition

Wendell Cox provides us with proof that New York's current government policies are driving people from the state (City Journal, Escape from New York, September 1, 2009):
Not only is New York losing talented people to the rest of the country, then; it is also losing enormous financial resources at a time when it can least afford to.

Mr. Cox also details where the people in New York are migrating to, which includes:
  • Florida
  • New Jersey
  • Pennsylvania
  • North Carolina
  • Georgia
  • Connecticut
  • Virginia
  • South Carolina
  • Maryland
  • Texas
It would be reasonable to conclude that some of the people who are leaving New York to go to Florida are doing so as part of their retirement strategy (Florida, humorously referred to as "God's Waiting Room"). Some of the outmigration is for retirement, but not all of it. This means that people are discovering that there are greater freedoms and prosperity in other states in the nation.

California has similar outmigration statistics (with more productive citizens leaving the state than going to it).

That's all fine. If people want to move to other states in the nation, they have every right to do so. When looking at the unemployment statistics, it is easy to understand why people are leaving some states (New York, California, Michigan, etc.) in greater numbers than those going to them.

That's what competition is all about. States, like Texas, have become "business friendly" to encourage more people to come to the state to work and to create new businesses. This, of course, irritates the Democratic-majority states, because it means that there will come a point where their onerous taxes and regulations cause a person to run to a state without those burdens. It also means that these states will be left with the whey and not curds of society.

States have the right (and some would include duty) to make their state attractive to their current residents and to future residents. They can do this in many ways, but the significant methods include low taxation, recognition of rights, and greater job opportunities in traditional employment and in starting new businesses. When a state puts in place onerous restrictions on starting a new business, or penalizes the self-employed/small business owner over the employed-by-others citizens, it is not surprising that entrepreneurs are going to respond to the carrots being offered in other states.

This is why the Left has been doing its darndest to level the playing field. Neo-Federalists attempt this by inventing Federal authority to regulate more and more areas at the Federal level.

The recent attempts to Federalize health insurance and health care is just one example. As more and more of the entitlement dollars are fed through the Federal coffers (rather than through State coffers as the Constitution clearly stipulates), the competition between the states for productive and entrepreneurial citizens is diminished.

The goal of Neo-Federalists is to make the states indistinguishable so that their ideas of entitlements and socialism are imposed on all states, making escape from these types of tax burdens moot. In other words, the Neo-Federalist goal is to homogenize America by intruding on the legislative authority of the individual states.

Some states have or have attempted to make laws to weigh outmigrants with the tax burdens of the state, long after they have left the state. New York, for example, wanted to make it a requirement that businesses who move out of the state have to continue to pay New York taxes for 10 years. The idea that a one state can impose taxation on a business or individual who establishes residency in another state is a kind of indentured servitude (and it is unconstitutional).

Unfortunately, the Federal government has done just that, by rejecting residency as the single condition of tax liability. For example, if a U.S. citizen leaves the country and establishes a business in another country, they are liable for U.S. taxes. They are liable for those taxes, regardless of country of residency. All other countries rely on residency rules for taxation, not citizenship. Further, if that citizen renounces their citizenship, taking citizenship of another country, they are still liable for U.S. taxes for a period of ten years. We are the only country to do that.

That type of tax liability discourages people from starting businesses in a particular state, or in the U.S. in general. We also have one of the highest corporate taxes in the world, discouraging foreigners (and citizens) from creating new businesses in the U.S.

We must compete with other states and with other countries for tax dollars based on incentives, not punitive measures, if we want to stop the John Galt effect and the exodus of productive and creative entrepreneurs from our nation. Each state has the right to legislate their tax code in any manner they choose. They also have the right to regulate commerce in their state, imposing onerous rule and requirements or to be "business friendly."

Today, U.S. citizens have the right to vote with their feet, as many in New York are doing in response to the onerous regulations and taxes in New York. We must do everything possible to keep it this way. Reversing the trend and schemes of Neo-Federalists would be even better, restoring the legislative and taxation authority to the states, but that will require a Republican-party super-majority in the Congress.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Ted Kennedy Dead

Ted Kennedy is dead (Senator Edward Kennedy dies at age 77 - Yahoo! News).

I have nothing good to say about the man and this news comes as no surprise. I have sympathy for his family, but I cannot help but think that his passing is good for America. There is a small chance that his replacement in the Senate will be less liberal than he, but at least there is hope that this illiberal legacy could end.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Wednesday, August 19, 2009

In a Nutshell

From an article by Nat Hentoff (JWR, I am finally scared of a White House administration, August 19, 2009):
"Remember that legislation itself is only half the problem with Obamacare. Whatever bill passes, hundreds of bureaucrats in the federal agencies will have years to promulgate scores of regulations to govern the details of the law.

The above is the beginning and the end of the debate on "Obamacare."

The establishment of a Health Commissioner (and the creation of the department he/she runs), means there is no limit to the regulations and requirements imposed on insurance companies and doctors.

It doesn't matter if "end of life" discussions are in today and out tomorrow, they can be added by the Health Commissioner at a future date.

The various Democratic Bills are not "reform." That's the wrong word. Reform would reexamine Tort law, remake how Medicare works (making it more efficient), and would address issues such as the enormous cost of bringing new medicines to market. Reducing costs would be refusing to pay for the medical expenses of illegal aliens, in concert with border closing measures. Those would be reforms. What these Bills are attempting to do is regulate and nationalize the health insurance and medical industries.

Creating a new government department and a Commissioner is not what America should be doing, regardless of the details in the Bill today. They are, as Mr. Hentof suggests, the health issue slippery slope.

This is not a new thing. The Democrats have always used incrementalism ("baby steps") to get to their ultimate goal. Putting a dozen things in the Bills today, that Americans can point at and fuss about, that are taken out "in the spirit of compromise" are red herrings (see Co-ops: A ‘Public Option’ By Another Name, Michael D. Tanner, CATO @ Liberty August 17, 2009).

What needs to be taken out is the entire concept of a Health Care Bill, and any talk of a Commissioner and government department to oversee and regulate medical insurance. Taking that out would be the same as voting "No" on whatever the Democrats put forward.

The only way to prevent a slippery slope is not to play.

H/t Instapundit.

Saturday, August 15, 2009

Not Stupid This Time

"The materials now bearing on the public mind will infallibly restore it to its republican soundness... if the knowledge of facts can only be disseminated among the people."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1799



The Republicans have been justifiably called the Stupid Party for many reasons, mainly because they've failed to demonstrate they have any balls. But not Jessey Kelly, as this report of a townhall demonstrates:
Rep. Giffords canceled her town hall in Sahuarita/Green Valley and Jesse Kelly scheduled an appearance in the same venue at the same time and place. From the looks of the video below it was very successful. Both sides were allowed to speak for two hours and with no problems. You would think that a 2 term congresswoman could manage to put on a town hall during the one month August recess.

Read/watch the whole thing at Gila Courier and AZ 8th ( Jesse Kelly town hall a great success, August 14, 2009).

My favorite part is when the Democrat steps right into it and says show me where it says that in the Bill and Mr. Kelly proceeds to show her hand-out after hand-out documenting where each of the false accusations are contained in the Democrat's Bill.  I don't often use 21st century jargon, but that's a pOwned if there ever was one. (Or, as Prof. Reynolds would say, "heh"!)

Republicans are often falsely accused of being The Party of "No," but as the video above demonstrates, that is mainly because their counter-proposals don't get media time.

To find out what the Republicans have offered with respect to health care reform, see Health Reform GOP-Style (Jo Ciavaglia, phillyBurbs.com, August 13, 2009).  As mentioned in the link, Kaiser Family Foundation has an interactive tool to allow you to research the various proposals in a side by side format.  A PDF of the various Bills may be viewed here.

The Democrats got away with this sort of thing for decades.  They would get their unchallenged 15-second sound byte on the news (with a complicit media), but the Internet/Blogosphere has changed all that.  The mainstream media still manages to control the major networks and nearly-bankrupt newspapers, but there are now other methods of getting the truth to the American people.

Maybe Republicans are learning. They may have to own-up to and address being the Stupid Party, but that's far better than being the Evil Party.
"The most effectual engines for [pacifying a nation] are the public papers... [A despotic] government always [keeps] a kind of standing army of newswriters who, without any regard to truth or to what should be like truth, [invent] and put into the papers whatever might serve the ministers. This suffices with the mass of the people who have no means of distinguishing the false from the true paragraphs of a newspaper."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1785



H/t Instapundit.

Friday, August 14, 2009

Half Right

Bill Whittle's latest PJTV Afterburner segment (Beyond the Angry Mobs: Only You Can Bring Congress Back From the Abyss of Corruption, August 10, 2009) focuses on the idea that people should participate in government, by considering a run for office.  It is half right.

I agree with the concept of more "regular" citizens responding to a call to serve. Where I disagree is with Mr. Whittle's assertion that it was never the Founding Fathers' intention for public service to be a life long career. In fact, just the reverse is true.

It is necessary to differentiate between the Founders' understanding that an educated populace was necessary for the concept of self government (i.e., a government of and by the people) to work and preparedness for public office. Both require education, but one is not the other and we should never conflate the two.

  1. Regarding the first concept, of educating the people so that they could maintain vigilance on their elected leaders:


"I do most anxiously wish to see the highest degrees of education given to the higher degrees of genius and to all degrees of it, so much as may enable them to read and understand what is going on in the world and to keep their part of it going on right; for nothing can keep it right but their own vigilant and distrustful superintendence."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1795



"A popular Government, without popular information, or the means of acquiring it, is but a prologue to a farce or a tragedy; or, perhaps, both. Knowledge will forever govern ignorance; and a people who mean to be their own governors must arm themselves with the power which knowledge gives."

- James Madison, 1822



"Every government degenerates when trusted to the rulers of the people alone. The people themselves, therefore, are its only safe depositories. And to render even them safe, their minds must be improved to a certain degree."

- Thomas Jefferson, Notes on Virginia, 1782



"If a nation expects to be ignorant and free in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1816



"[The] provision [in the new constitution of Spain] which, after a certain epoch, disfranchises every citizen who cannot read and write... is the fruitful germ of the improvement of everything good and the correction of everything imperfect in the present constitution. This will give you an enlightened people and an energetic public opinion which will control and enchain the aristocratic spirit of the government."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1814



"And say, finally, whether peace is best preserved by giving energy to the government or information to the people. This last is the most certain and the most legitimate engine of government. Educate and inform the whole mass of the people. Enable them to see that it is their interest to preserve peace and order, and they will preserve them. And it requires no very high degree of education to convince them of this. They are the only sure reliance for the preservation of our liberty."

- Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, 1787



2.  Regarding the second concept, of creating long-serving public servants through education:



"Nor must we omit to mention among the benefits of education the incalculable advantage of training up able counselors to administer the affairs of our country in all its departments, legislative, executive and judiciary, and to bear their proper share in the councils of our national government: nothing more than education advancing the prosperity, the power, and the happiness of a nation."

- Thomas Jefferson, Report for University of Virginia, 1818



"The aim of every political constitution is, or ought to be, first to obtain for rulers men who possess most wisdom to discern, and most virtue to pursue, the common good of the society; and in the next place, to take the most effectual precautions for keeping them virtuous whilst they continue to hold their public trust."

- James Madison, Federalist No. 57



"The tendency of a longer period of service would be to render the body more stable in its policy, and more capable of stemming popular currents taking a wrong direction, till reason and justice could regain their ascendancy.

- James Madison, Notes on Suffrage, 1810



"Laws will be wisely formed and honestly administered in proportion as those who form and administer them are wise and honest; whence it becomes expedient for promoting the public happiness that those persons whom nature has endowed with genius and virtue should be rendered by liberal education worthy to receive and able to guard the sacred deposit of the rights and liberties of their fellow citizens; and that they should be called to that charge without regard to wealth, birth or other accidental condition or circumstance. But the indigence of the greater number disabling them from so educating at their own expense those of their children whom nature has fitly formed and disposed to become useful instruments for the public, it is better that such should be sought for and educated at the common expense of all, than that the happiness of all should be confined to the weak or wicked."

- Thomas Jefferson, Diffusion of Knowledge Bill, 1779



"I will not say that public life is the line for making a fortune. But it furnishes a decent and honorable support, and places one's children on good grounds for public favor. The family of a beloved father will stand with the public on the most favorable ground of competition. Had General Washington left children, what would have been denied them?"

- Thomas Jefferson, 1808



As I stated at the beginning, the idea of people responding to a call of public service is a noble one. I quibble only with the idea that the Founders were against the idea of a career of public service and, by extension, that everyone is capable (having the "genius" Jefferson spoke of) to do it wisely, and the character necessary to perform the duties with restraint.

We should never discount the importance of an educated populace entering the voting booth. If we believe that our elected leaders are not properly performing their duties, the problem is with the mass of voters, not the system (or the concept of a perpetual public servant). We have far too many ignorant citizens exercising the vote. The solution is not to limit how long our representatives may serve, but to educate the citizens so they exercise their vote in such a way as to replace their elected representatives with people better qualified to serve.

If we are capable and called, it is our duty to serve, for as long as that service is needed and useful. There is no time limit or fixed amount of time that one may serve, or a magic number that suggests that one has served too long.
"The man who loves his country on its own account, and not merely for its trappings of interest or power, can never be divorced from it, can never refuse to come forward when he finds that she is engaged in dangers which he has the means of warding off."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1797



The Founders were examples of career politicians themselves, and became a permanent class of elected officials.
"Though I... am myself duly impressed with a sense of the arduousness of government and the obligation those are under who are able to conduct it, yet I am also satisfied there is an order of geniuses above that obligation and therefore exempted from it. Nobody can conceive that nature ever intended to throw away a Newton upon the occupations of a crown. It would have been a prodigality for which even the conduct of Providence might have been arraigned, had he been by birth annexed to what was so far below him. Cooperating with nature in her ordinary economy, we should dispose of and employ the geniuses of men according to their several orders and degrees."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1778



The critical part is that the Founders were not at all concerned with a permanent ruling class, as they were the first generation to do so. They required a permanent ruling class of geniuses of good character. That is not every citizen, by any stretch. Those not endowed with genius or the ability to be restrained in their behavior to good character may vote, and that is enough, and more charitable than the Founders' intended by discussing limits to the franchise, such as to those only able to read and write.

Finally, there are many ways to serve one's country. Service is not exclusive to public office.  Mr. Whittle himself provides public service, by educating the populace through his website and Afterburner broadcasts.

The End Is Near

Here's a comment I left at Fabius Maximus (Beginning Of The End Of The Republic’s Solvency. Soon Come The First Steps To A Reformed Regime – Or A New Regime, August 14, 2009) regarding health care and entitlement reform.  I was responding to responding to Maximus's comment:
"Fabius Maximus replies: You are ignoring the specfic example I gave of rationing — spending $36,000 on care in the last year of life. Much of it neither increasing lifespan or quality of life. First, I doubt that people will spend that money themselves — or that most Americans could afford it. Second, experience at other nations disproves your theory."

My response:

Means-testing is coming, but I do not think you’ve thought through rationing or the basis of “few can afford it” with respect to the last year of life expenses.


Many seniors, especially the aging Boomers, have property. It is reasonable to require that people use their own assets before dipping into the public troth. The Boomers have not done a good job of managing their wealth for retirement, in the abstract, but many/most have property to sell. I expect to see some sort of reverse mortgage products appearing for the sole purpose of paying medical expenses (or government liens against property for this purpose, payable when the property is sold).


The idea that one retires and is able to maintain the same lifestyle when working is over. In addition, the idea that people “retire” was a temporary glitch of the last 50 years (not a concept that existed before). Boomers might not stay in the workforce in traditional jobs, but they might have to live with their children (say, providing daycare for their grandchildren). The Greatest Generation will be the last to have golfing/vacation style retirements.


It is immoral to think that you can check out of life and live off your children and grandchildren. It may not be what the Boomers want, but it is what they are going to get. It may require that we bankrupt the nation before the reality of the situation sinks in, but the reality is that Boomers will not have the same retirement as their parents. Bankrupt nation or before, the coffers are empty (and always were, by original design of Social Security) and there is no amount of taxation that will produce the amounts required to pay to the Boomers what they think they’re entitled to receive. The unfunded liability for the Boomer’s retirement years is projected to be 120% of GDP. 100% taxation on working people wouldn’t be enough. The Boomers might whine, but it is their fault. They were the stewards of the government for the last 40 years and they didn’t make sure the government was managing the budgets as they should. The Boomers have already spent their retirements by being the most coddled and spoilt generation in history.

Thursday, August 13, 2009

Spilt Milk

From Mort Zuckerman (NY Daily News, Drowning in debt: Obama's spending and borrowing leaves U.S. gasping for air, August 9, 2009):
The Government Accountability Office estimates that by 2040, interest payments will absorb 30% of all revenues and entitlements will consume the rest, leaving nothing for defense, education or veterans' pensions.

I know that many economic folks are predicting that we'll recover from this recession on X date or Y quarter, but I think they're wrong.

There is no recovery from this amount of debt. The only recovery is to stop spending and no special interest group is going to give up their entitlements.  More from Mr. Zuckerman:
Everybody is dazed and confused by all this talk of additional indebtedness in the trillions of dollars. Our soaring national debt will require cataclysmic adjustments to accomplish the restoration of a balance in our fiscal position.

Otherwise, we face a dramatic erosion of U.S. economic and financial standing, raising the risk of skyrocketing interest rates and a crash in the value of the dollar. Americans can no longer rely on their stocks and the soaring value of their homes to put their kids through college and support early retirement. For the first time since the Depression, U.S. companies are not only cutting jobs; they are cutting wages. We are undersaved and underpensioned, and we will have to adjust to a more frugal life.

The Social Security nightmare has hit home and until we address that issue, the recession will remain.

From Shannon Love (Chicago Boy, The Dangers of Decompartmentalized Health Care Spending, August 12, 2009):
The elderly consume 70% of all health-care spending.[updated here and here] That means that when it comes to cost control they will bear the brunt of the burden. If we don’t cut spending on the elderly we can’t reduce costs without simply denying care for everyone else. When it comes down to a choice between spending on old people and children, the elderly know full well who we are going to pick. The elderly themselves will choose to spend money on their grandchildren rather than themselves.

It doesn't appear that this Congress or this Administration is serious. Sane people knew that giving the debt keys to a Democratic Congress was a stupid mistake, but this isn't a mistake that can be solved simply by voting in Republicans next term.  The money will be spent and the debt will be there to be paid off.  The debt remains, even if the legislators are no longer home.

And speaking of no longer home (Alan Zibel, AP/Yahoo News, Foreclosures rise 7 percent in July from June, August 13, 2009):
WASHINGTON – The number of U.S. households on the verge of losing their homes rose 7 percent from June to July, as the escalating foreclosure crisis continued to outpace government efforts to limit the damage.

Foreclosure filings were up 32 percent from the same month last year, RealtyTrac Inc. said Thursday. More than 360,000 households, or one in every 355 homes, received a foreclosure-related notice, such as a notice of default or trustee's sale. That's the highest monthly level since the foreclosure-listing firm began publishing the data more than four years ago.

Ugly things are likely to happen before this is truly solved. I'm not advocating it, only forecasting the truth.

H/t Instapundit (here, here, and here.)

Monday, August 10, 2009

Feeding Frenzy

As this article from Freep.com (Detroit Free Press, Tempers flare over health care plan, August 7, 2009), there is a kind of feeding frenzy occurring over the socialized medicine Bill.  Regardless of how this is decided, people are angry.  But the type of bitterness we're seeing over the health care issue is irreconcilable, as there are factions on both sides of the issue who are unwilling to compromise.

One camp believes that health care is a right, and a prosperous nation (like ourselves) has some sort of duty to provide health insurance to every citizen.

The other camp believes that extending health insurance to everyone is a bad idea, while at the same time, crying foul when there are solutions presented to address the insolvency of social security or medicare.

The reality is somewhere in the middle, but "middle" is seldom how these issues are decided, which means that the divide and conquer approach (i.e., the building of waring factions) is how the political class will decide the matter.  Social security and medicare ARE insolvent and some sort of rationing or means testing will have to be decided at some point.  If we'd never created Social Security or Medicare, we wouldn't be having this discussion, nor would we have the problems they create (both economically and politically).  Once we have a government entitlement program, the press (and the politicians) always have a crying mother being stripped of her child or an old granny living on cat food to create photo-ops for the opposing side.    It is damned near impossible to get rid of a government revenue stream once it is in place.

This is not a new method of handling a matter among the political classes.  Creating issues to create a tug-o-war is not unique to the health care debate.

The abortion issue is exactly the same.

  1. We have the not ever camp.

  2. We have the only if camp.

  3. We have the what's wrong with it, abortion shouldn't have moral considerations camp.


We can change the words, ever so slightly, for issues like school prayer.  Education has become political, where the political classes war over the hearts and minds, just as the health care issue is becoming politicized.  Regardless of how the health care issue is eventually decided, there will be winners and losers, if we allow the government to realize the objective of making it something the government involves itself.

Imagine, for just a moment, that there were no public schools. There might be a chattering class arguing for the creation of something like it, but we'd have developed other methods of addressing it.  Most parents, the vast middle class, would pay for cheap schools (probably chain type corporations offering mediocre, but not awful programs at an affordable price).  There would be a larger market for more expensive private schools, with the private sector donating to charities to allow poor children with prowess to attend them. The most the government might do is to allow everyone (rich and poor) to deduct the cost of education from their taxes.  We wouldn't get to the point where we'd discuss the pros and cons of vouchers, because the government wouldn't have inserted itself in the process to make it a compromise solution to a terrible problem.

The larger point is that education would not be a political issue.  There would be no arguments about prayer in school, the teaching of sex education, or if evolution or creationism should be taught. Each parent would make those decisions and it wouldn't create caverns between political camps.  Sure, people would have their opinions on the various subjects, but each wouldn't be able to remake the Jack Booted Thug the enforcer of their opinion.

Abortion is still a huge issue today.  If Roe v Wade had not been decided the way it had, each state would still be making the decision about its legality.  Planned Parenthood and NARAL would be running cheap abortion flights or shuttle buses from Mississippi to California, with protestors standing on the runways to try to prevent women from boarding the planes.  But, it wouldn't be a divisive issue at the national level, creating a situation where one party supports X and the other party supports -X.

I want Y, not the binary choice of X or -X.

If, for no other reason than the above, the health care issue should not become any more political than it is.  When the government controls the issue or delivers the service, the people will always be arguing about who should get what, as sharks fight over prey when they smell blood. They'll stop considering the option of the government not being involved at all, and allowing the private sector to handle the matter.  The private sector will no longer be a viable solution in its entirety, because the government's intrusion in the matter will have broken down parts of the infrastructure which allow it.

We already have enough issues to divide us.  Government-run health care, especially given the enormity of the costs and the life/death aspect adding fuel to emotions, is the last thing we need. In other words, the last thing we need is for the government to get involved at all.  The government will, inevitably, screw it up and where a politician stands on that issue will become a party platform, forcing people to choose one extreme position or the other, with suggestions and schemes on how to fix the mess.  If the government doesn't get involved at all, then there will be nothing to fix.  It will still be a mess, because few things are ever perfect, but the government just makes enemies of us all.

In 20 years, do we really want a politician's worthiness to be determined by how they'd decide on a particular health care rationing decision?  We're protesting for or against inclusion of heart transplants or cesareans at the national level?  That's what will happen if we create any additional government health care entitlements.

Friday, August 7, 2009

They're Still Campaigning

(More on the First Amendment violations of the "fishy" email requests by the White House.)

During the run up to the election, the Obama campaign effectively used electronic media. Most of us know how successful that was in getting out Obama's talking points as well as fund raising. Later revelations of the JournoList and the use of paid ACORN protesters were seen as despicable, but they fell within the typical dirty tricks camp of national elections.

What you can do when you're running for office and running a national campaign is entirely different from what you can do once you're in office. The then Senator Obama could not have solicited input on Americans who were exercising their free speech in declaring their concerns about Candidate Obama, but the Democratic Party hacks could have done that.

Seven months into President Obama's Administration, the staff at the White House are still behaving as if they're on the campaign trail. That was obvious to many, as the constant press conferences and stump speeches are signs that President Obama is still behaving as Candidate Obama.

But the White House Blog request for notification of "fishy" communications is unconstitutional for a member of government. I, as a private citizen, could ask for that information because the limitations on Free Speech don't apply to private citizens. I could set up a mechanism for collecting that information (and even pay people who send me the information). The restriction on limiting speech applies only to the government.

The Supreme Court has decided the matter in the past. Federal law prevents keeping a database on private citizens.

I would love to believe that the staffers at the White House Blog were intentionally engaging in a conspiracy to supress the free speech of citizens by setting up the "fishy" reporting mechanism, but that gives this Administration too much credit. They're not that clever. Rather, they're still in campaign mode, and are too stupid to know that they have violated one of American citizens' most precious liberties.

Sen. John Cornyn wrote a letter to the Obama Administration regarding the matter:
Dear President Obama,

I write to express my concern about a new White House program to monitor American citizens' speech opposing your health care policies, and to seek your assurances that this program is being carried out in a manner consistent with the First Amendment and America's tradition of free speech and public discourse.

Yesterday, in an official White House release entitled "Facts are Stubborn Things," the White House Director of New Media, Macon Phillips, asserted that there was "a lot of disinformation out there," and encouraged citizens to report "fishy" speech opposing your health care policies to the White House. Phillips specifically targeted private, unpublished, even casual speech, writing that "rumors often travel just below the surface via chain emails or through casual conversation." Phillips wrote "If you get an email or see something on the web about health insurance reform that seems fishy, send it to flag@whitehouse.gov."
I am not aware of any precedent for a President asking American citizens to report their fellow citizens to the White House for pure political speech that is deemed "fishy" or otherwise inimical to the White House's political interests.

By requesting that citizens send "fishy" emails to the White House, it is inevitable that the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and private speech of U.S. citizens will be reported to the White House. You should not be surprised that these actions taken by your White House staff raise the specter of a data collection program. As Congress debates health care reform and other critical policy matters, citizen engagement must not be chilled by fear of government monitoring the exercise of free speech rights.

I can only imagine the level of justifiable outrage had your predecessor asked Americans to forward emails critical of his policies to the White House. I suspect that you would have been leading the charge in condemning such a program-and I would have been at your side denouncing such heavy-handed government action.

So I urge you to cease this program immediately. At the very least, I request that you detail to Congress and the public the protocols that your White House is following to purge the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and identities of citizens who are reported to have engaged in "fishy" speech. And I respectfully request an answer to the following:

  • How do you intend to use the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and identities of citizens who are reported to have engaged in "fishy" speech?

  • How do you intend to notify citizens who have been reported for "fishy" speech?

  • What action do you intend to take against citizens who have been reported for engaging in "fishy" speech?

  • Do your own past statements qualify as "disinformation"? For example, is it "disinformation" to note that in 2003 you said:"I happen to be a proponent of a single-payer universal health care plan"?


I look forward to your prompt response.

Sincerely,
JOHN CORNYN
United States Senator

I suspect that no criminal charges will be filed, but ignorance of the law is not an excuse (especially by members of the government, and more especially the Office of the President as one of the primary duties of the President is to enforce the laws, not violate them), and the Obama Administration has committed a crime simply by creating this fishing hole (what they do with the information received is adding to the existing crime).

Sen. Cornyn got it exactly right and I hope that his cease and desist letter will be enough to get the program stopped. It won't stop the other crimes, misdemeanors, and constitutional violations being perpetrated by this Administration, but it is a good start.

During the campaign we were told that Obama had sufficient experience to hit the bricks running. The problem, of course, is that he didn't. He's running, but it is a still a campaign not an Administration.
In every stage of these Oppressions We have Petitioned for Redress in the most humble terms: Our repeated Petitions have been answered only by repeated injury. A Prince, whose character is thus marked by every act which may define a Tyrant, is unfit to be the ruler of a free people.

-- Thomas Jefferson, Declaration of Independence


Thursday, August 6, 2009

All Your Emails Belong to Us

The recent news that the White House wants to be sent emails that spread "misinformation" about the socialized medicine bill is too crazy to parody (Macon Phillips, White House Blog, August 4, 2009):
Facts Are Stubborn Things

Opponents of health insurance reform may find the truth a little inconvenient, but as our second president famously said, "facts are stubborn things."

Scary chain emails and videos are starting to percolate on the internet [sic], breathlessly claiming, for example, to "uncover" the truth about the President’s health insurance reform positions.

In this video, Linda Douglass, the communications director for the White House’s Health Reform Office, addresses one example that makes it look like the President intends to "eliminate" private coverage, when the reality couldn’t be further from the truth.

For the record, the President has consistently said that if you like your insurance plan, your doctor, or both, you will be able to keep them. He has even proposed eight consumer protections relating specifically to the health insurance industry.

There is a lot of disinformation about health insurance reform out there, spanning from control of personal finances to end of life care. These rumors often travel just below the surface via chain emails or through casual conversation. Since we can’t keep track of all of them here at the White House, we’re asking for your help. If you get an email or see something on the web about health insurance reform that seems fishy, send it to flag@whitehouse.gov.

[Emphasis mine.]

There are so many ways that the White House could have worded the above to make it appear less Orwellian and Hitlerian.  Just about everything this Administration (and Congress) are doing is like something from The Onion.

The White House Blog includes videos of people saying that the Health Care Bill won't become a single-payer program.

So what does the Bill actually say?

SEC. 102. PROTECTING THE CHOICE TO KEEP CURRENT COVERAGE (pg 16):
(a) GRANDFATHERED HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE DEFINED.—Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, for purposes of establishing acceptable coverage under this division, the term ‘‘grandfathered health insurance coverage’’ means individual health insurance coverage that is offered and in force and effect before the first day of Y1 if the following conditions are met:

(1) LIMITATION ON NEW ENROLLMENT.—


(A) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in this paragraph, the individual health insurance issuer offering such coverage does not enroll any individual in such coverage if the first effective date of coverage is on or after the first day of Y1.



[Emphasis mine.]

So it is "misinformation" to suggest that the Bill doesn't gradually eliminate private insurance policies, yet the Bill itself requires that no new members are added to the rolls of private insurance after "Y1" date.

Pg 19:
(1) IN GENERAL.—Individual health insurance coverage that is not grandfathered health insurance coverage under subsection (a) may only be offered on or after the first day of Y1 as an Exchange-participating health benefits plan.

To decipher what the above means, we have to go to pg. 10:
(13) HEALTH INSURANCE EXCHANGE.—The term ‘‘Health Insurance Exchange’’ means the Health Insurance Exchange established under section 201.

Alright, I'll play.  What does section 201 include?

Section 201 says (pg. 74):
(c) TRANSITION.—Individuals and employers shall only be eligible to enroll or participate in the Health Insurance Exchange in accordance with the following transition schedule:

(1) FIRST YEAR.—In Y1 (as defined in section 100(c))


(A) individuals described in subsection (d)(1), including individuals described in paragraphs (3) and (4) of subsection (d); and (B) smallest employers described in subsection (e)(1).


(2) SECOND YEAR.—In Y2—



(A) individuals and employers described in
paragraph (1); and (B) smaller employers described in subsection (e)(2).

(3) THIRD AND SUBSEQUENT YEARS.—


In Y3 and subsequent years—



(A) individuals and employers described in
paragraph (2); and

(B) larger employers as permitted by the
Commissioner under subsection (e)(3).


Good Lord! What in the Hell does that mean?  It becomes circular, to the point of distraction.  If single-payer is not the ultimate goal, why do the programs (for which an individual is eligible to enroll) change in Years 1, 2, and 3? It makes no sense.  It appears to read that if you're in a private plan now, you can keep it (unless the government later determines it doesn't meet a standard--and it is up to the Commissar to determine what that standard is), but is it is blurry regarding a job/insurance change after the Bill goes into effect.

Beginning on pg 82, there is a description of a survey that must be conducted by the Health Czar Commissioner.  Later we discover what the survey "report" will enable the Commissioner to do:
(3) REPORT.—Not later than January 1 of Y3, in Y6, and thereafter, the Commissioner shall submit to Congress on the study conducted under this subsection and shall include in such report recommendations regarding changes in standards for Exchange eligibility for individuals and employers.

So, basically, the Commissioner will conduct a study to determine what employers are providing in their health care plans and then the Commissioner will recommend whether or not those programs are adequate to remain eligible.

Based on what criteria?

There are "BASIC, ENHANCED, AND PREMIUM PLANS" described, but not the costs/benefits which must be included as each is up to the Commissioner (not the employer or individual consumer) to determine (pg 85):
IN GENERAL.—The Commissioner shall establish the following standards consistent with this subsection and title I.

At this point, you'd think that the various categories of Small, Medium and Large would be defined, but they're not. They're just descriptive categories that the Commissioner can codify anyway he/she damn well pleases, as long as the benefits/cost sharing get bigger in Medium and Large.

This Bill is long, but its substance is lacking.

In order for an insurance carrier to be included as an "Exchange" provider (and that means any private insurance program, not the one offered by the Federal government or various other public programs), there is a long list of requirements, including (pg 91):
(7) CULTURALLY AND LINGUISTICALLY APPROPRIATE SERVICES AND COMMUNICATIONS.—The entity shall provide for culturally and linguistically appropriate communication and health services.

Orwell is laughing his ass off.

I'm sorry this post is discombobulated, but that's because the Bill is incomprehensible. You can argue just about anything in this Bill, because anything is how it is written (pg. 92).
(4) OVERSIGHT AND ENFORCEMENT RESPONSIBILITIES.

—The Commissioner shall establish processes, in coordination with State insurance regulators, to oversee, monitor, and enforce applicable requirements of this title with respect to QHBP offering entities offering Exchange-participating health benefits plans and such plans, including the marketing of such plans.



And (pg. 88):
(a) CONTRACTING DUTIES.—In carrying out section 201(b)(1) and consistent with this subtitle:

(1) OFFERING ENTITY AND PLAN STANDARDS.—The Commissioner shall—


(A) establish standards necessary to implement the requirements of this title and title I for—


(i) QHBP offering entities for the offering of an Exchange-participating health benefits plan; and (ii) for Exchange-participating health benefits plans; and (B) certify QHBP offering entities and qualified health benefits plans as meeting such standards and requirements of this title and title I for purposes of this subtitle.



They might as well have written "to be determined by the Health Czar at some future date, based on any criteria he/she pleases" on every page after the introduction.

The requirements put on private insurance companies is simply mind-boggling as they're written, with wriggle room for the Health Czar to add any additional requirements they want, at their sole discretion. The Commissioner can deny a carrier based on dozens of defined and yet-to-be-defined criteria, and require Herculean levels of reporting and red tape. Anyone suggesting that this government bureaucracy will reduce medical costs is a liar. The paperwork alone will triple the costs.

There are many doctors who are refusing to take Medicare patients now, because the paperwork is too cumbersome to manage and the payments can take a 120+ days to process.  This Bill burdens the insurance carriers and doctors, by providing greater reporting and "accountability," but "accountability" is to be determined.

It is not unreasonable to speculate that the solution to the red tape created in this Bill would later be "fixed" by creating government-run hospitals (similar to the Veteran's Administration hospitals) with no paperwork requirements--just open the doors and let everyone in.  The result would be something like the Post Office or DMV, with the "quality" of service those institutions are famous for not delivering, or the Dickensian-like monstrosities of the VA.  This is speculation of course, but it is impossible to see how creating this regulatory bureaucracy could be seen as a benefit or cost saver by anyone.  If we don't pass this Bill there would be no regulatory bureaucracy to fix, so let's just skip to the end and not do it at all.

It is just common sense.  If you add more bureaucracy, an additional layer between the consumer and the supplier, of course your costs are going to increase.  In addition, the Bill requires the establishment of a Health Commissioner and staff to handle all the paperwork, conduct studies, review insurance carriers offerings and employer insurance plans and mandate their compliance.  For what benefit?  If the goal is to cover the uninsured then create a Bill that does just that.

If the goal is to also provide bridge insurance (when someone is between jobs), there is already legislation (COBRA) that requires an insurance company to allow a person to pay their own premiums (for two years, I believe) during their unemployment period (until they have a new job with insurance).  At the point a person is uninsured (either becuase they never had insurance, they couldn't afford their COBRA, etc.), there would be a plan they could get through the Feds. If that's the goal, then write a Bill that does just that, and/or the above.  This Bill goes far beyond any of that, requiring that everyone have health insurance (and a person will be taxed for it, if they don't pay for one on their own, or are provided a government-approved plan by their employer).

I'm not recommending any of the above, only suggesting that the sound bytes about what this Bill is supposed to provide does not jive with what the Bill would create.  This Bill mandates health insurance in some form and creates a regulatory bureaucracy of all insurance carriers and employers' health care offerings.  That's not "cost savings."  That's growing the size/cost of government.

Someone, please, report me to the White House for spreading "misinformation."  Anyone who quotes the Bill could be accused of that.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

Some of Us

In an interview with AG Eric Holder by Pierre Thomas, Jason Ryan, and Theresa Cook (ABC News, Attorney General Eric Holder Speaks Exclusively to ABC News, July 29, 2009), Holder is quoted:
"The American people would be surprised by the depth of the threat, but also reassured to see the assets that have been deployed around the world," Holder said, adding that the United States interacts closely with its foreign partners.

Some Americans may be surprised at the amount of threats posed by terrorist groups, but not all of us.  Some people chose to respond to the 9/11 attacks by burying their head in the sand, believing it was an isolated incident -- like some sort of fluke of nature.  They also viewed the lack of additional attacks as meaning that there weren't any attempts.

Nothing could be further from reality.

The reality is that there are groups within the larger banner of al Qaeda and outside of its central planning approach who want nothing more than to carry out another 9/11 attack (or something much, much worse).
"Guantanamo is a place that has served as a recruiting tool for those who want to do us harm," he said.

Holder declined to say how many detainees could face trial in the United States, but said U.S. attorney offices around the country have been reviewing the cases for possible prosecution in those districts.

The Democrats continue to treat terrorism as a criminal action rather than as an act of war.  "Facing trial" is for criminal actions. Detaining unlawful combatants is not a criminal justice action. Holding these people (or deciding to put them before a firing squad) is a military matter.

Suggesting that Guantanamo serves as a recruitment vehicle for terrorists is both a strawman and a distraction. Everything we do, from being prosperous to checking passports on inbound passengers could be viewed as a "recruiting tool." Easter egg rolls on the White House lawn could be seen as a recruiting tool as it demonstrates an association with Christianity. The point being, that everything we do as a people, including everything we do to combat terrorism can be used by propagandists to encourage the weak minded to become radicalized.
"The possibility exists that there could be people who are held in a preventative way under the laws of war," he said. "If that happens, we'd only do so by creating a system that had due process.

"I think that by closing Guantanamo, by prosecuting people, be it in Article III courts, or in military commissions, we will make the American people safer than they are now," Holder continued.

In the above, Holder is talking out of both sides of his mouth. If the military commissions are successful at prosecuting illegal combatants, the result will be the firing squad.  How, exactly, would that event appease terrorists?  Appeasing the terrorists would require that the men in detention are found not to be illegal combatants and released. That would prove that our military are bumbling idiots for picking up the wrong people (a characterization much favored by many on the Left) or they're dangerous terrorists who will be released on some sort of technicality. Neither scenario is good for our side.

The fate of an unlawful combatant is death.  There is no other outcome. They aren't given life sentences, as one might receive for murder, or put in some sort of work/release program. Illegal combatants are shot or hanged. Delaying that outcome with detention, as long as the detainees are useful to us, is the best way to protect us.

We're at war, even if the Left continues to try to treat this as a criminal problem, doing anything necessary to avoid a military entanglement. Criminals don't fly suicide missions with the purpose of terrorizing their enemies into submission. Military enemies do that, and it appears that terrorism is working on those on the Left. Submission is their middle name.

None of this is surprising to some of us. The Left has been spewing the criminal justice angle of this matter since the beginning.  The Left knows they can't win elections because of their track record on handling military matters. Republicans are perceived (rightly) as being the best people to have in charge in war time, so the Left worked really hard to distract the public from acknowledging that there is a war on! The media presented the battles as a lost cause and a political battle, not a literal one. They've campaigned that the Bush response was overreach... and now they're trying to tell us that terrorists really are something serious, and something to worry about... and how hard they work everyday to keep us safe.
He noted, however, that the Bush administration "left us an infrastructure that I think is very good," and that national security officials are constantly striving to put the country in a safer position.

Some of us know that, too.

The Bush Administration kept us safe, but they didn't find it necessary to whine about it or constantly toot their own horn for performing their primary directive, doing their job.  Perhaps that was Bush's failing -- he gave the American people too much credit -- perhaps the American people do need to be constantly reminded that there is a war going on, and there really are people out to get us.
Americans are asking: How will we fight and win this war? We will direct every resource at our command -- every means of diplomacy, every tool of intelligence, every instrument of law enforcement, every financial influence, and every necessary weapon of war -- to the disruption and to the defeat of the global terror network.

This war will not be like the war against Iraq a decade ago, with a decisive liberation of territory and a swift conclusion. It will not look like the air war above Kosovo two years ago, where no ground troops were used and not a single American was lost in combat.

Our response involves far more than instant retaliation and isolated strikes. Americans should not expect one battle, but a lengthy campaign, unlike any other we have ever seen. It may include dramatic strikes, visible on TV, and covert operations, secret even in success.

- George W. Bush, Address to the Nation, Washington, DC, September 20, 2001



Some people are surprised that terrorism continues to be a threat. Some aren't. Some people forget what was said and promised. Some of us remember.

We will not waiver, we will not tire, we will not falter, and we will not fail.

H/t Drudge.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

What Matters

Michael Barone (Washington Examiner, Obama has aura but doesn't know how to legislate, July 29, 2009) states the obvious:
In other words, he's [Obama] never done much work putting legislation together -- especially legislation that channels vast flows of money and affects the workings of parts of the economy that deeply affect people's lives. This lack of experience is starting to show. On the major legislation considered this year -- the stimulus, cap and trade, health care -- the Obama White House has done little or nothing to set down markers, to provide guidance, to establish boundaries and no-go areas.

None of this should come as a surprise to anyone. The country elected a neophyte to POTUS (which is why the Republicans shouldn't try to do the same--people will be crying for a Eisenhower/Reagan type Grandpa come 2016, and avoiding game-show-host-charisma style candidates--the party that puts Grandpa out there will win).  If this POTUS has taught us anything, it is that there is no room for learning on the job. Experience matters, in all things, even if it is the illusion of experience.

Petreus / Perry 2016.


Other contenders include (sorry to say that there are no other Governors besides Rick Perry with sufficient experience and wisdom):

Over

From Byron York (Washington Examiner, Obama, playing defense on the stimulus, July 29, 2009):
The speech seems a pretty clear indication that Republicans (and the polls) have put Obama on the defensive.

The polls have him running scared, as it should be.  Americans may have been temporarily fooled by his moderate campaign speak, but nakedness of this Emperor and his true tyrannical stripes are beginning to show.

'We' have Obama on the run and this is only the beginning of his demise. The honeymoon is officially over. The divorce proceedings are going to be ugly.

On Their Watch

Social Security and Medicare are underfunded by $40 trillion.  Saying that they are underfunded is a bit of a bait and switch, as these programs have never been funded. FICA deductions go into the General Fund, with all the other taxes collected by the Feds.

When Bush was campaigning for his second term he focused on Social Security reform, but Congress (now an obvious, not statistical Democrat majority) would have no part of it.  Aggravating blue collar workers and the AARP is political suicide, so Congress did nothing to reform Social Security.

Whether that was cowardice or strategic (to further weaken the economy to bolster a win in 2008) doesn't matter.  The reality is that the Boomers are gradually shifting from the contributing to the receiving line of the FICA deduction, and their mass will shift the FICA budget line from positive to negative as early as 2012.  No more will Democrats have the FICA excess to play around with, which is why they're advocating "health care reform" and infusing it with methods to ration existing entitlement programs, while shoring up the gravy train for other programs.

In the socialized medicine Bills there are plans to begin rationing Medicare (as health care "reform" has little or nothing to do with Medicare).  Someone is going to have to do it eventually.  I'm just glad that the Democrats will have to own it, but I'm certain that they'll figure out a way to blame the Republicans for it.

In in decade it won't matter and AARP and Social Security recipients will be thrown under a bus.  They have to be, as there won't be enough money to pay even a fraction of their total federal entitlement payments.  And rightly, as it is their fault: their generation did nothing to guarantee that the money would be there when they got to retirement age. It won't matter if it was ignorance or malice.  Reality is immune to cause.  It just is.  And "empty" is what the coffers will be.

Friday, July 24, 2009

Soylent Green is People!

Reading through the Twitter posts from Peter Fleckstein, posted by Savage (Little Green Footballs, Inside the Health Care Bill, aka HR3200, July 22, 2009), that's the thought that kept popping into my head:
PG 425: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 4-12 Government mandates Advance Care Planning Consult. Think Senior Citizens end of life

Pg 425: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 17-19 Government will instruct and consult regarding living wills, durable powers of attorney. Mandatory!

PG 425: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 22-25, 426 Lines 1-3 Government provides approved list of end of life resources, guiding you in death!

PG 427: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 15-24 Government mandates program for orders for end of life. The Government has a say in how your life ends!

Pg 429: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 1-9 An “advance care planning consultant” will be used frequently as patients health deteriorates.

PG 429: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 10-12 “advance care consultation” may include an ORDER 4 end of life plans. AN ORDER from GOV

Pg 429: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 13-25 – The Government will specify which Doctors can write an end of life order.

PG 430: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 11-15 The Government will decide what level of treatment you will have at end of life.

(For people who don't understand the reference, Soylent Green was a film based on a dystopic novel [Make Room! Make Room! by Harry Harrison] where government mandated that people submit themselves to be killed on their 65th birthday. Set in a future where pollution prevented crop growth, there were food shortages. It was determined that the government-issued green wafers given to the people as nourishment was made from the bodies of the elderly.)

There is a point, however, where arguing the details is counterproductive. The bottom line is that government, especially the Federal government, has no authority to "reform" health care. It should be rejected on principle, regardless of the details.

H/t comment by katablog.com (James Pethokoukis, Reuters Blogs, Why Obama might have just killed Obamacare, July 23, 2009)

Thursday, July 23, 2009

Title Not Found

With regard to the Amazon/1984 stories: The ignorance of how databases work and what data-syncing is continues. This article and comments at Network World illustrate the ignorance.

Background: Kindle users were able to buy an ebook that was distributed without copyright authorization. As soon as Amazon was made aware of the problem, they removed the title (Orwell's 1984, to make the story interesting) from their catalog.

That's the back-story. What happened next should be a surprise only to people who don't understand how these things work, and I'm not referring to how ebooks are created or sold (or anything having to do with copyrights or license agreements).

A database is a collection of tables. Tables are a collection of records. Records are a collection of fields. Fields are made up of bits/characters.

(A record may be synonymous with a "transaction" but it isn't always.)

I'll start with a single table.

A database like Amazon's contains customers. Customers have certain characteristics, such as names, shipping and billing addresses, join dates, last purchase date, phone numbers, etc. Some of those characteristics will be stored in a "customer" table, some will be stored in subordinate tables, but they're only subordinate because we think of them that way. They're just tables. The relationships the tables have to each other (if any) is because of our understanding of how the data relates, not because computers/databases have any inherent understanding of these relationships.

The Amazon database also contains a "products" table. Those products make up their catalog. Products have characteristics of their own, such as supplier, unit of sale, weight, description, name, etc.

The "supplier" of an item will also be a record in a "supplier" table. That table will have the contact information for the supplier, their main contact address, as well as any other data elements Amazon might wish to maintain at that level.

Amazon will also have a price file (or a "price table") because all retailers do. They'll also have some sort of inventory tracking table (either maintained locally for the items they stock in their own warehouse or combined with a hook into the supplier's inventory system, if inventory is maintained by the supplier). In an operation like Amazon, inventory is all over the place, so a combination of methods is used.

Customer and supplier records are reasonably static. That doesn't mean that they don't ever change. They do change, because suppliers and new customers are always added, in addition to keeping them updated when suppliers and customers move. Transaction tables are constantly changing... that's why they're called "transactions."

When you log on to Amazon you sign in with your email address, but because email addresses can change, that isn't your customer number. (Some database designers are stupid enough to use an email address as a customer record number, but as I said, they're stupid.) It is a given that every customer has a customer record number and every supplier has a supplier record number. Each product in the Amazon catalog has a product number, too, which can be a single item, or a combination of items sold as part of a bundle. (Think of a computer that may be sold in a bundle that includes a laptop computer, a power cord, and instruction manuals--each having unique part numbers, but when combined create a unique product number.)

Let's say that my customer record number is C001. I'll keep it simple and we'll assume that I only have one billing and one shipping address (we know that Amazon customers can store dozens of each, but we'll ignore that).

I initiate an order for product P001.

A transaction table exists to create a relationship record of that order. That record says that customer C001 bought P001. Nothing in the transaction table knows what a P001 is, nor does the transaction table know that C001 is me. It is just linking the two together with other information to keep the transaction unique (such as assigning it a transaction number, the date the purchase was made, the date the transaction was created, etc.).

On the front end, Amazon displays a report of this transaction to me and sends it in the form of an order confirmation in email. That order confirmation will include the name of item I purchased because reports can be programmed to "look up" data from other tables and other databases. Since we have a product number (P001), we have the descriptive information for that item from the products table. Since we have a hook from products to suppliers, the report can also display details about the supplier, such as:

On 7/23/2009 you purchased Qty: 1, Item #: P001-Databases for Morons from "Technical Publishers."

If I purchased more than one item, it would list the additional items purchased.

The above might give the appearance that the transaction order contains the descriptive information, but it doesn't. It only contains record numbers and dates. A table that contains redundant data, such as a transaction table that contains anything but the record number of a product or customer is referred to as "denormalized." That redundancy is bad, not only because it uses more space in the database than it needs to, but because it can quickly create "out of balance" or "out of sync" situations (depending on the transaction type). When a customer changes their name, for example, their customer record is updated, and only that record. If the order table copied the customer name to the table when an order was created, it won't get notified/changed when the name change occurs (without redundant/unnecessary programming). So this stuff is kept simple, i.e., normalized.

On the backend, a bunch of things happen when a customer clicks "submit" on their order. Something equivalent to a packing slip or pull order is created for the items in Amazon's warehouse. For items not in Amazon's warehouse, the equivalent of a pull order is sent to the drop shipper/supplier. Once the item(s) are pulled from inventory, a transaction is created to reduce inventory for the quantity of items purchased. A shipper order number is created (with a vendor such as UPS or Fedex) once the package is boxed. Debits are processed against my credit card. At each stage of the order fulfillment process a status change is noted in the transaction record that triggers an update in an email sent to me:
1. Order acknowledgement
2. Order processing
3. Order filled/shipping order assigned

If there are any glitches, such as a delay in processing, a discovery that an out of stock conditions exists, etc., an exception will be generated.

When a system is first designed the developers try to trap as many exceptions as they can. When programming changes are required later, it usually has nothing to do with bugs in programming code, as those are caught and corrected early. It is generally because there are new exceptions (where human beings get involved in the process and make mistakes). It is also because there are new types of product offerings that didn't exist when the system was initially created.

Reprogramming is always more problematic than initial programming. This is because there are hundreds (sometimes thousands) of hooks into different tables, databases, and systems that need to be adjusted when changes are made in one place that have to be cascaded to other parts of the process. The programmer responsible for making the changes doesn't know what all those hooks are, and exceptions/mistakes occur when the system encounters a condition that wasn't adjusted.

One of the processes that retailers have to account for is removals from catalog. There are dozens of reasons why a retailer may wish to "de-list" a product. It could have been a limited run, special pricing, a supplier goes out of business, the supplier wasn't reliable, a new supplier had the item available at a better profit margin, etc. A one-size-fits-all method of handling this won't work, because there isn't a one-size-fits-all reason. That makes things even more complicated for a programmer, but that's why they make the big $$$.

If a supplier is determined to be unreliable, the supplier won't be used and that includes delisting all the products they sold. If an item is no longer made, the supplier is still used for other items, just not that item.

The point being that (regardless of why or how it is done) retailers are constantly changing their catalog offerings.

You can't delete records. Well, you can, technically, but you don't because that creates a "title not found" condition. If, for example, a supplier record is deleted from the supplier table, when I look through my order history at Amazon, the spot that was originally filled in with "Technical Publishers" will be blank (or filled in with the error message "title not found"). If a customer record is deleted, when Amazon attempts to reconcile their credits from the credit card companies, they won't be able to tie back to a specific customer. Because of this, records are not deleted. They're "closed." This can be as simple a step as changing a status flag from "O" ("Open") to "C" ("Closed").

If I asked Amazon to delete my account, they wouldn't actually delete it. They'd "close" it, because deleting it would create havoc throughout their system (as well as create havoc from an accounting standpoint, because all the history associated with my account would be lost, and that's a no-no from a bookkeeping/accounting standpoint).

Now some folks might get upset that their data isn't deleted, but that's just tough. Before computers came into the picture to track these things, companies kept ledgers of all this stuff. No one would have suggested that a company go through 15 years of ledgers and take scissors to their books of record. The fact that people don't make the logical leap from ledger to computer record is their stupid fault, not the fault of the retailer. Not only would a company not want to delete your record, in many cases (where book of record requirements exist) it could be unlawful to do so.

So Amazon got into the ebook business. Their systems were initially designed for the sale of tangible items. There was certainly a lot of reprogramming required to offer this new service. One of the main changes is that Amazon had to create a storage account, where all the items a customer has purchased can be stored. And this is where this (obviously) gets confusing for some people.

They didn't literally create a storage box for each customer, as we might buy a new physical hard-drive to store additional data. A literal storage device would mean that Amazon would store the same item over and over again, hundreds of times, in each customer's unique storage box. That would be redundant and unnecessary, and the physical storage requirements would be mind-boggling. What they created was a virtual (meaning, "not real") storage box, similar to an order transaction record. Amazon has one pointer to a copy of each electronic media they sell, each with a unique part number.  When customer A001 buys one, they create a transaction which is equivalent to an e-book storage table so it shows up in my storage box list. It is a virtual library of "my" stuff. The physical copy is stored in one location. The list of books in my storage box is an index (akin to a "link") to the file name and location of the item.

What I do not know for certain, but I would guess, is that Amazon doesn't have all the e-book files on their own servers. I would guess that they point to files on servers Amazon doesn't maintain themselves, as they have distributors who stock items for them (and I have some inside knowledge to validate my suspicion that they do this). What the record of each item would include would be the file name and the server location where it was stored. Whether the item was stored on Amazon's servers or on a supplier's server would be invisible to a customer, as customers are also unaware that their storage box is virtual, not literal.

A customer's Kindle is linked to their virtual storage box. When a customer buys a new item, a transaction is created that displays the item in the virtual storage box that, in turn, allows the item to be downloaded to the Kindle device. The customer can choose which items they want to have on their Kindle, up to the maximum storage of the device itself. This allows a customer to buy more items than the Kindle device can literally store, and can control which items are physically stored at any given time.

When a Kindle customer has their device radio on, the system will sync the list of items in their virtual storage with the list of items currently on the device. This is similar to doing a manual, physical inventory check every now and again.

To put this in perspective, let's say that you went to the library. You go to the card catalog. You find the book you want in the catalog and the Dewey Decimal system locator. You go to that section of the library but the book isn't there.

If you immediately assert that Ninjas broke into the library, knowing that you wanted to read that book, and took that book to a fire pit and burned it so you couldn't read it, might others think your conspiracy theory a bit daft (and you a bit scary), given that it could simply be that someone else had already checked the booked out of the library? The librarian could have put the book in the wrong place. The card for the book could have had the wrong identifier number typed on it. The library may have delisted the book, but forgot to take the card index out of the card file. Where human beings are involved mistakes will be made, most often, innocently. Yes, it could be that Ninjas did all that, but until we have evidence of that, Occam's Razor requires we go with the simplest and most common explanation first.

What happens when Amazon delists an e-book item because the supplier is found to have been in violation of copyright law, with respect to some or all of the titles they sell? Did Amazon Ninjas break into your house and purposely destroy an ebook or is some other, more reasonable explanation plausible?

Was the supplier record deleted or closed? Was the product number deleted, or closed, and what happens to the titles listed in the virtual storage on Amazon when that happens? Was the file deleted from Amazon's servers? Was the link to the supplier's server deleted from the e-book's record?

Regardless of the dozens of innocent technical glitches that could have caused this, the title was no longer available on Amazon's catalog; therefore, the item was no longer available in the Kindle virtual storage box. When a customer synced their device to their virtual storage, the item was no longer there. Amazon didn't, despite the protests of idiots everywhere, send Ninjas out to reach into each customer's Kindle and run some sort of delete/destroy routine. The item itself, or the link to the item or the item's server no longer existed, so it was no longer in the index of the Kindle device.

Amazon will have to reprogram their system so this doesn't happen again. They said that, and apologized for the glitch. They refunded the money for the items purchased.

Folks who think that Amazon virtually broke into their Kindle to delete files have no clue how databases work, what virtual storage boxes are, or what syncing means.

Amazon discovered what happens when you de-list an item, in a way that worked for tangible items, in a process that had not been programmed to handle it, and they're fixing it. Maybe Oswald did it, but until we have evidence of that, let's assume a programming glitch because those happen thousands and thousands of times every day: no conspiracy or grand-theft illusions required.

Please, if you do not understand the above, shut up. You're embarrassing yourself.