Showing posts with label Principles. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Principles. Show all posts

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

Power

From Heather B. Armstrong comes a post about the power of Twitter (Number 26, Containing a capital letter or two, August 28, 2009). I won't quote it, but ask that you read the whole thing.

The post is about a mother with a newborn who went through two months of Hell trying to get her brand new washing machine fixed. But that isn't really what the post is about. The details of her purchase and repair history is background for the result.

The result is that after an exhausting battle to get her new and expensive washing machine repaired, she resorted to complaining about the company on Twitter. That Twitter lashing worked.

For decades, most people were helpless. They had no recourse and no power to spread the word about bad customer service or a company failing to live up to its obligations. Social networking sites, like Twitter, have given the ordinary person the ability to get the attention they shouldn't need to get, just to get a company to do what they should do, without sounding an alarm that can be heard by nearly everyone in the world.

When Thomas Jefferson looked to the future of America, he hoped that a Free Press would enable citizens to call attention to failure, to Charlatans, and to a time when everyone had a voice. It took us over 200 years to develop the mechanisms whereby every citizen had the ability to publish truthful reports of their experiences, but it was worth the wait. Thomas Jefferson was focused on the people having the power to shed light government actions, but I think he'd be just as thrilled with these powers being used to further the experiment of an empowered people:
"No experiment can be more interesting than that we are now trying, and which we trust will end in establishing the fact, that man may be governed by reason and truth. Our first object should therefore be, to leave open to him all the avenues to truth. The most effectual hitherto found, is the freedom of the press. It is, therefore, the first shut up by those who fear the investigation of their actions."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1804

"The selfish spirit of commerce... knows no country, and feels no passion or principle but that of gain."

-Thomas Jefferson, 1809

Everyone now has a voice and access to a Free Press, and if that's what it takes to reform American industry, to make them accountable for what they do and what they sell, great.

It shouldn't require the Herculean efforts Mrs. Armstrong went through. Companies should have a moral code that prevents them from putting their customers through Hell. But they don't. But we'll make them restore that moral code and we'll use whatever lawful means necessary to do so.

It may seem like a trivial thing, making a stand about a faulty washing machine, but these things matter. They matter in big ways, because for too long companies could get away with this sort of thing... but they can't get away with it anymore.

We have the mechanisms to shed light on their failures. The Iranian government attempted to shut down communications through Twitter. The dissenters in Iran used Twitter and demonstrated that it is possible to use these tools as a communications organ to coordinate an organized, justified revolution against a tyrannical government. It is also possible to use these tools for evil. Using them to shed light on injustices, however grand or bland, is a power for the good, and we'll take the bad, because the power to do good is so much more valuable.

We have power unlike any we've ever had before.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).


H/t Instapundit.

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Great Communicator

No, I'm not referring to Ronald Reagan with this title. I'm referring to Bill Whittle (of EjectEjectEject.com and Afterburner on PJTV). Bill's latest Afterburner episode (August 24, 2009) is brilliant!
PJTV: Afterburner, <i>MSNBC and The Great Liberal Narrative: The Truth About The Tyranny of Political Correctness</i>
PJTV: Afterburner, MSNBC and The Great Liberal Narrative: The Truth About The Tyranny of Political Correctness
Bill has a gift. He has the ability to distill history (and make it interesting) to validate his opinions. His optimistic view of America is very similar to Ronald Reagan's... which brings me to another great communicator, Faoud Ajami* who wrote a smashing essay about Obama's Humpty-Dumpty fall from the wall. In the essay (WSJ, Obama's Summer of Discontent, August 25, 2009), Mr. Ajami writes a bit about Ronald Reagan:
At the core of the Reagan mission was the recovery of the nation's esteem and self-regard. Reagan was an optimist. He was Hollywood glamour to be sure, but he was also Peoria, Ill. His faith in the country was boundless, and when he said it was "morning in America" he meant it; he believed in America's miracle and had seen it in his own life, in his rise from a child of the Depression to the summit of political power.
And:
At no time had Ronald Reagan believed that the American covenant had failed, that America should apologize for itself in the world beyond its shores. There was no narcissism in Reagan. It was stirring that the man who headed into the sunset of his life would bid his country farewell by reminding it that its best days were yet to come.
While Mr. Whittle doesn't yet have the wisdom and experience of Ronald Reagan, he certainly shares his optimism and exuberance about America, even if it is occasionally unfounded or rose-colored-glasses idealistic.

(*I had never heard of Faoud Ajami before, but if the WSJ article is an example of his typical writing performance, I can't wait to read more of him. WSJ states that he teaches at the School of Advanced International Studies, The Johns Hopkins University. He is also an adjunct fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institution.)

But back to Bill Whittle...

I will admit to being a fan, while still maintaining my objectivity (I believe). Mr. Whittle manages to complain about leftist-intellectualism, while still maintaining a connection to average Joe, but he is clearly an intellectual himself (although not of the leftist persuasion).

This contrast sometimes causes a contradiction for Mr. Whittle, such as in his Afterburner episode about Sarah Palin's ill-treatment by the press (The Media, The Left and GOP Elitists vs. Sarah Palin: A Lesson on How to Destroy a Leader, July 27, 2009). Mr. Whittle makes a jab at intellectualism in that episode (transcript from EjectEjectEject.com):
She needs to be destroyed because the one thing that can never be allowed to happen is this: you cannot have a voice in this political debate. You know who I mean. You rubes, you hicks out there in flyover country. Your job is pay taxes, vote for who they have decided over cocktails makes them feel better about themselves, and occasionally provide your inbred idiot sons and daughters for the army or police force or whatever you people without Ivy League educations do with your tawdry little lives.

Meanwhile, the Harvard-educated elitist geniuses will run the country according to their infinitely brighter intellectual and moral lights.
[Emphasis mine.]

I think it unwise to tango with an anti-intellectualism/education message. It is also possible for conservatives to have Ivy League educations and be Harvard-educated elitist geniuses. It is possible to do all of that and not come out of school as a socialist-sympathizing drone. There are some who manage to get into Harvard or other Ivy League schools who don't have the necessary backbone and intellect to become something other than Useful Idiots. The concept of Garbage-In, Garbage-Out applies to their outcome.

While these degrees no longer confer the integrity and value they once had, the degree itself is not a disqualifer. We still have to do our own due diligence, regardless of the letters after a person's name or the letters on their parchment. Let me restate that in a different way: the degrees are neither a qualifier nor a disqualifier, in the sense of conferring superiority over the average Joe, but intellectual superiority exists (it just shouldn't be assumed if a person has a specific name on their college degree).

That intellectual superiority doesn't mean the average Joe has any less right to vote, any less command of his faculties or liberties, or is any less of a good person. It just means that the average Joe doesn't rise to the intellectual capacity of others, and those others include Mr. Whittle himself. That is why we qualify Joe with average when we speak of the majority of people in the country.
The moral sense, or conscience, is as much a part of man as his leg or arm. It is given to all human beings in a stronger or weaker degree, as force of members is given them in a greater or less degree. It may be strengthened by exercise, as may any particular limb of the body. This sense is submitted indeed in some degree to the guidance of reason; but it is a small stock which is required for this: even a less one than what we call Common sense. State a moral case to a ploughman and a professor. The former will decide it as well, and often better than the latter, because he has not been led astray by artificial rules."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1787

That's the contradiction of both Ronald Reagan and Bill Whittle. They manage to cloak their intellectualism in a way that makes it possible for them to communicate with Peoria, Ill. They relate to Peoria and Average Joe without a dumbed-down charade. I do not recall, however, that Ronald Reagan ever dismissed the value of education, in the way that Mr. Whittle did in the his Sarah Palin piece.

What Ronald Reagan never did, that Sarah Palin does (and Bill Whittle slightly stepped over the line in his episode on Sarah Palin) is pandering to the common man. Speaking plainly and directly doesn't mean speaking down to any one, nor does it include speaking in a colloquial manner, almost a stereotypical gum-chewing/smacking manner, as Sarah Palin does. Average Joe deserves more respect than that. The Office she held and the office she sought deserves more respect than that.

It is import to remember that President Bush has a Harvard degree. President Bush's accent and slight speech-impediment prevented him from earning the title of great orator. President Bush was a decent president who nobly rose to the occasion to handle the terrorist attacks of 9/11. He was the minimum standard of the intellectual capacity of a president. We don't have to raise the level to the Winston Churchill standard, but we should go no lower in our expectations with the bar set by George Bush.

If Sarah Palin has a superior intellect, she's done a fairly good job of hiding it. If she rises to the level of President Bush's, it remains to be seen. Reagan didn't hide it, he just didn't wear his intellectual superiority on his sleeve or rub anyone's nose in it.

This is better explained by Rudyard Kipling in his If letter to his son:
If you can talk with crowds and keep your virtue,
Or walk with kings - nor lose the common touch;
If neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you;
If all men count with you, but none too much;
If you can fill the unforgiving minute
With sixty seconds' worth of distance run -
Yours is the Earth and everything that's in it,
And - which is more - you'll be a Man my son!
[Emphasis mine.]

Sarah Palin, by Mr. Kipling's standard is not a man. Of course we know that she is a woman, but the poem's message can apply equally to a woman. It is a poem about duty and responsibility, about both honor and integrity, and dealing with success and failure, and winning and losing with grace and dignity. Man is merely a shortcut for all that is admirable and needed in an individual to live up to his/her human potential.

I accept the basic premise that Sarah Palin got a raw deal with the press and continued to be plagued by nuisance lawsuits while Governor of Alaska. In my opinion, however, she whines too much and allowed what happened yesterday to demonstrate that she fails in the "neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you" Kipling requirement.

It is similar to the way that Obama continues to blame President Bush for all the troubles he faces today, rather than taking ownership for his policies. Harry Truman's famous "the buck stops here" remark sums up the quality so necessary in the President of the United States. Sarah Palin's raw deal is no excuse for her showing weakness to her current and future enemies.

Showing weakness was the quality most dangerous in John F. Kennedy, so much so that it created a dangerous situation for the United States (and resulted in the Russians acting upon the placement of missiles in Cuba). The Russians didn't consider putting missiles in Cuba on Eisenhower's watch (nor would they have considered such a thing under Ronald Reagan's watch). Weakness has proven to create an unncessary danger, encouraging bold actions from our enemies.

The Iranians knew to release the hostages captured during Jimmy Carter's term when Ronald Reagan was sworn in.

Superior strength is not a quality unique to men, in the strength of character and convictions sense, not the physical sense. No one would have found either Margaret Thatcher or Golda Meir lacking strength. Those women had balls!

Strength matters and so does intellect in leadership. It matters not only in our Executive, but in our citizens, but for the latter, not as much.

Sarah Palin may have left the governorship of Alaska for Alaska's sake and benefit, but it did a disserve to the entire country in the longer term. It is akin to the policy of not negotiating with terrorists. It may benefit the 20 or so current hostages to negotiate for their release, but the success of that negotiation, of getting something out of the act, sends a signal that kidnapping and terrorism is a worthwhile venture. So, too, with Sarah Palin's resignation as governor of Alaska, by sending the message that a form of legal terrorism can be successful. We all lose when swarms of nuisance lawsuits cause officials to leave their elected posts. Expect to see much more of it as a result of Sarah Palin surrendering to it.

Sarah Palin should have recognized that long term risk, and the fact that she didn't demonstrates that she didn't have the backbone, nor the foresight of the bigger, long term picture. It is those bigger, long-term pictures that education provides, once unique to the Ivy League schools, but possible to be gleaned from lesser known institutions, or by those driven to achieve greatness in intellectual development by self study and perseverance.

"That every man shall be made virtuous by any process whatever is, indeed, no more to be expected than that every tree shall be made to bear fruit, and every plant nourishment. The brier and bramble can never become the vine and olive; but their asperities may be softened by culture, and their properties improved to usefulness in the order and economy of the world."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1822

Not everyone is capable of rising to the same level. That is not a handicap for being a good person or a good citizen, but it should be a handicap for higher office.

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."

- George Santayana

Obama fails the test on every count, but that is no excuse for conservatives to lower the bar, or dismiss the value of intellect, strength, and education. Let the Democrats pander to the common man, but require that our own, we conservatives, respect and speak directly (and honestly) to the average Joe, while simultaneously recognizing his intellectual limits.
"Above all things I hope the education of the common people will be attended to, convinced that on their good sense we may rely with the most security for the preservation of a due degree of liberty."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1787

As Ronald Reagan commanded that politicians "never speak ill of another Republican," the additional commandment I would add is: "Conservatives should never speak ill of education."

The glorification of ignorance and pandering will be our undoing.
"The mass of our citizens may be divided into two classes -- the laboring and the learned. The laboring will need the first grade of education to qualify them for their pursuits and duties; the learned will need it as a foundation for further acquirements."

- Thomas Jefferson , 1814

Bill Whittle, I believe, made a few mistakes in his Sarah Palin episode, but he demonstrates that he has the ability to deliver to a praiseworthy performance in his piece on MSNBC/Political Correctness—the latter is a five star package. Sarah Palin, on the other hand, has yet to demonstrate greatness, stamina, strength of conviction, or an understanding of the value of education and the intellectual grounding it provides to see the big picture, and to avoid history's mistakes. She may do so at some point, as Mr. Whittle has done in his episode of yesterday, but Sarah hasn't done it yet... and I refuse, absolutely refuse, to lower the bar for conservatives, simply because the Democrats have done so.



H/t Instapundit.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Friday, August 14, 2009

Half Right

Bill Whittle's latest PJTV Afterburner segment (Beyond the Angry Mobs: Only You Can Bring Congress Back From the Abyss of Corruption, August 10, 2009) focuses on the idea that people should participate in government, by considering a run for office.  It is half right.

I agree with the concept of more "regular" citizens responding to a call to serve. Where I disagree is with Mr. Whittle's assertion that it was never the Founding Fathers' intention for public service to be a life long career. In fact, just the reverse is true.

It is necessary to differentiate between the Founders' understanding that an educated populace was necessary for the concept of self government (i.e., a government of and by the people) to work and preparedness for public office. Both require education, but one is not the other and we should never conflate the two.

  1. Regarding the first concept, of educating the people so that they could maintain vigilance on their elected leaders:


"I do most anxiously wish to see the highest degrees of education given to the higher degrees of genius and to all degrees of it, so much as may enable them to read and understand what is going on in the world and to keep their part of it going on right; for nothing can keep it right but their own vigilant and distrustful superintendence."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1795



"A popular Government, without popular information, or the means of acquiring it, is but a prologue to a farce or a tragedy; or, perhaps, both. Knowledge will forever govern ignorance; and a people who mean to be their own governors must arm themselves with the power which knowledge gives."

- James Madison, 1822



"Every government degenerates when trusted to the rulers of the people alone. The people themselves, therefore, are its only safe depositories. And to render even them safe, their minds must be improved to a certain degree."

- Thomas Jefferson, Notes on Virginia, 1782



"If a nation expects to be ignorant and free in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1816



"[The] provision [in the new constitution of Spain] which, after a certain epoch, disfranchises every citizen who cannot read and write... is the fruitful germ of the improvement of everything good and the correction of everything imperfect in the present constitution. This will give you an enlightened people and an energetic public opinion which will control and enchain the aristocratic spirit of the government."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1814



"And say, finally, whether peace is best preserved by giving energy to the government or information to the people. This last is the most certain and the most legitimate engine of government. Educate and inform the whole mass of the people. Enable them to see that it is their interest to preserve peace and order, and they will preserve them. And it requires no very high degree of education to convince them of this. They are the only sure reliance for the preservation of our liberty."

- Thomas Jefferson to James Madison, 1787



2.  Regarding the second concept, of creating long-serving public servants through education:



"Nor must we omit to mention among the benefits of education the incalculable advantage of training up able counselors to administer the affairs of our country in all its departments, legislative, executive and judiciary, and to bear their proper share in the councils of our national government: nothing more than education advancing the prosperity, the power, and the happiness of a nation."

- Thomas Jefferson, Report for University of Virginia, 1818



"The aim of every political constitution is, or ought to be, first to obtain for rulers men who possess most wisdom to discern, and most virtue to pursue, the common good of the society; and in the next place, to take the most effectual precautions for keeping them virtuous whilst they continue to hold their public trust."

- James Madison, Federalist No. 57



"The tendency of a longer period of service would be to render the body more stable in its policy, and more capable of stemming popular currents taking a wrong direction, till reason and justice could regain their ascendancy.

- James Madison, Notes on Suffrage, 1810



"Laws will be wisely formed and honestly administered in proportion as those who form and administer them are wise and honest; whence it becomes expedient for promoting the public happiness that those persons whom nature has endowed with genius and virtue should be rendered by liberal education worthy to receive and able to guard the sacred deposit of the rights and liberties of their fellow citizens; and that they should be called to that charge without regard to wealth, birth or other accidental condition or circumstance. But the indigence of the greater number disabling them from so educating at their own expense those of their children whom nature has fitly formed and disposed to become useful instruments for the public, it is better that such should be sought for and educated at the common expense of all, than that the happiness of all should be confined to the weak or wicked."

- Thomas Jefferson, Diffusion of Knowledge Bill, 1779



"I will not say that public life is the line for making a fortune. But it furnishes a decent and honorable support, and places one's children on good grounds for public favor. The family of a beloved father will stand with the public on the most favorable ground of competition. Had General Washington left children, what would have been denied them?"

- Thomas Jefferson, 1808



As I stated at the beginning, the idea of people responding to a call of public service is a noble one. I quibble only with the idea that the Founders were against the idea of a career of public service and, by extension, that everyone is capable (having the "genius" Jefferson spoke of) to do it wisely, and the character necessary to perform the duties with restraint.

We should never discount the importance of an educated populace entering the voting booth. If we believe that our elected leaders are not properly performing their duties, the problem is with the mass of voters, not the system (or the concept of a perpetual public servant). We have far too many ignorant citizens exercising the vote. The solution is not to limit how long our representatives may serve, but to educate the citizens so they exercise their vote in such a way as to replace their elected representatives with people better qualified to serve.

If we are capable and called, it is our duty to serve, for as long as that service is needed and useful. There is no time limit or fixed amount of time that one may serve, or a magic number that suggests that one has served too long.
"The man who loves his country on its own account, and not merely for its trappings of interest or power, can never be divorced from it, can never refuse to come forward when he finds that she is engaged in dangers which he has the means of warding off."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1797



The Founders were examples of career politicians themselves, and became a permanent class of elected officials.
"Though I... am myself duly impressed with a sense of the arduousness of government and the obligation those are under who are able to conduct it, yet I am also satisfied there is an order of geniuses above that obligation and therefore exempted from it. Nobody can conceive that nature ever intended to throw away a Newton upon the occupations of a crown. It would have been a prodigality for which even the conduct of Providence might have been arraigned, had he been by birth annexed to what was so far below him. Cooperating with nature in her ordinary economy, we should dispose of and employ the geniuses of men according to their several orders and degrees."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1778



The critical part is that the Founders were not at all concerned with a permanent ruling class, as they were the first generation to do so. They required a permanent ruling class of geniuses of good character. That is not every citizen, by any stretch. Those not endowed with genius or the ability to be restrained in their behavior to good character may vote, and that is enough, and more charitable than the Founders' intended by discussing limits to the franchise, such as to those only able to read and write.

Finally, there are many ways to serve one's country. Service is not exclusive to public office.  Mr. Whittle himself provides public service, by educating the populace through his website and Afterburner broadcasts.

Monday, August 10, 2009

Chamber Music

In this little symphony by Andrew Klavan (City Journal, Romanticon by Andrew Klavan, August 10, 2009), he manages to merge the old and the new in a way that leaves the soul yearning for more:
It was, for Wordsworth, what the failure of Communism was for the radicals of a later day. He could no longer deny the error inherent in “speculative schemes— / That promised to abstract the hopes of Man.” He saw the Revolution as a dream that “flattered the young, pleased with extremes” and made “Reason’s naked self / The object of its fervour.” Confused by pure reason’s failure as a moral guide, he “lost / All feeling of conviction” and “yielded up moral questions in despair.” Slowly, he began to do the brave and difficult thing: to admit he had been wrong and change his mind.

RTWT.

We can only hope that the revolutionaries of our day will find the courage to "change his mind."

When conservatives fret about having to rebuild their party, they should take heart. None of this is new. If, however, they attempt to recreate the sensationalism of the Democrat's success and continue to fall victim to the cult of personality and populism, rather than an earnest rebuilding effort of our intellectual principles based on Western Civilization's values, we will fail.
Now, just as American reaction to the blatant political failures of sixties radicalism led to the Reagan revolution and the long dominance of political conservatism here, so, too, British reaction to the French Revolution led to 20 years of Tory rule. But neither Reaganism nor Toryism could ultimately disguise the fact that a profound and fundamental change in human outlook and attitude had taken place—a change that the sixties and the French Revolution represented rather than caused. When the smoke cleared, those who still believed in Western history, traditions, and institutions had to reestablish their relevance and rebuild their foundations in what was essentially a new world.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

What We Can Do

Subtitle: The Hope and Change the rest of us desire.

The purpose of this site is to document the events of the day. Few read it and fewer still take what is written here to heart. Mostly, it is cynical. It is the view of the world as one might view a train wreck before it happens, reporting on the screeching wheels and metal before the train hits the wall.

For just a moment I'm going to step out of the role as cynic and reporter of our demise and propose a few ideas that could turn this impending tragedy around, avoiding the train wreck. It isn't inevitable, but it is likely, given the direction we're heading. That direction needs to change.

The United States Constitution is an amazing document, both for its forward-thinking and its clarity. The few aberrations, including slavery and limited suffrage, were corrected by the sweat and blood of patriots, others were corrected peacefully. What we have left is a miracle -- a kind of road-map to preserving our treasured liberties.  It is only as useful as it is used and respected.

In some cases (the minutia I'll leave to another day) we screwed things up. For all the good intentions and lofty goals, prohibition was a bad idea, and it was later reversed. The Sixteenth Amendment was enacted to give Congress the ability to collect taxes on income (not wages), for the purposes of paying war debt. The balance of power between the States and the Federal government was severely harmed by the passage of the Seventeenth Amendment, changing the election of Senators from state selection by the respective state legislature, to popular vote. It, too, was invented with the goal of correcting a perceived wrong, but it created far more trouble than it benefited us.

I fully expect that those Amendments will be eventually overturned, viewed through the lens of history as mistakes as great and obvious as prohibition proved to be. In some cases the Constitution is fine as it is today, but it has been interpreted to mean something other than it was intended to mean.  The Fourteenth Amendment, for example, was enacted to gaurantee that the Bill of Rights, the respect of individual rights, and the status of U.S. citizen were uniform throughout the states, not that all other laws between the states had to be uniform.

Whether those Amendments will be overturned (or the interpretations of others limited to their original intent) will happen in my lifetime or later is the question. The larger question is if we'll exist long enough to reverse them.

Those are important, but trivial compared to what remains intact, based on the Founders exquisite understanding of the purpose of government and how government can be prevented from becoming the tyrannical state.

The Founders made it quite clear that the Federal government had limited powers -- that it derived its powers from The People -- and that all the powers not specifically granted to the Federal government remained with The People (individually) or collectively, by the States. On the whole, the Constitution doesn't limit what the people or the Several States may do; on the contrary, the Constitution limits and articulates what the Federal government may do.  In all cases, however, the Founders made it quite clear that we retained the rights we temporarily delegated to the Federal government.  At any time we could rescind their authority, or grant it additional powers, but only through Constitutional Amendment (not, as far too many believe, by doing whatever they damn well please).

There was fear that the Federal government would attempt to trump State powers, but more concern that larger states would attempt to trample the smaller ones. There were "checks and balances" as well, dividing the Federal government into three branches: Legislature, Executive, and Justice.

Each branch had their specific role and authority. The legislature was empowered to make laws and to lay taxes for the express purpose of carrying out those laws and their duties, but what laws they could create was strictly limited to those articulated. The Executive, beyond its primary directive of foreign affairs and domestic security, was empowered to make sure that the laws enacted by Congress were carried out. Justice was the arbiter between the states, and was the last hope when justice could not be found elsewhere.

All of the above was carefully worded in the various Articles. Article I addresses the Congress. Article II describes the Executive role. Article III describes the role of the judiciary. The remaining Articles (IV through VIII) address specific matters, such as how the Constitution may be altered, how new states may be admitted into the union, etc.

After the initial draft was presented to the people for their review, individually and by their respective state governments, a great debate ensued. (Actually, many debates ensued.) The most important one were the debates between the "Federalists" and the "Anti-Federalists." These are known as The Federalist Papers and The Anti-Federalist Papers. There can be no doubt of the Founders original intent when understood through those debates.

In Federalist 37, Madison framed the argument by describing the difficulties, goals, and the outcome of the Constitutional Convention:
The genius of republican liberty seems to demand on one side, not only that all power should be derived from the people, but that those intrusted with it should be kept in dependence on the people, by a short duration of their appointments; and that even during this short period the trust should be placed not in a few, but a number of hands. Stability, on the contrary, requires that the hands in which power is lodged should continue for a length of time the same. A frequent change of men will result from a frequent return of elections; and a frequent change of measures from a frequent change of men: whilst energy in government requires not only a certain duration of power, but the execution of it by a single hand.

Heretofore I have described the authority granted by the people to the Federal government. More importantly, however, is the balance of power between the Federal government and the States. Madison also describes the difficulties of this in Federalist 37:
To the difficulties already mentioned may be added the interfering pretensions of the larger and smaller States. We cannot err in supposing that the former would contend for a participation in the government, fully proportioned to their superior wealth and importance; and that the latter would not be less tenacious of the equality at present enjoyed by them. We may well suppose that neither side would entirely yield to the other, and consequently that the struggle could be terminated only by compromise. It is extremely probable, also, that after the ratio of representation had been adjusted, this very compromise must have produced a fresh struggle between the same parties, to give such a turn to the organization of the government, and to the distribution of its powers, as would increase the importance of the branches, in forming which they had respectively obtained the greatest share of influence. There are features in the Constitution which warrant each of these suppositions; and as far as either of them is well founded, it shows that the convention must have been compelled to sacrifice theoretical propriety to the force of extraneous considerations.

In Federalist 44, Madison addresses some of the ant-Federalist criticisms. In the passage below, he addresses the powers granted to Congress and the concerns that Congress would, at some future date, enlarge or expand on their limited powers (as they have done today):
If it be asked what is to be the consequence, in case the Congress shall misconstrue this part of the Constitution, and exercise powers not warranted by its true meaning, I answer, the same as if they should misconstrue or enlarge any other power vested in them; as if the general power had been reduced to particulars, and any one of these were to be violated; the same, in short, as if the State legislatures should violate the irrespective constitutional authorities. In the first instance, the success of the usurpation will depend on the executive and judiciary departments, which are to expound and give effect to the legislative acts; and in the last resort a remedy must be obtained from the people who can, by the election of more faithful representatives, annul the acts of the usurpers.

In Federalist 45, Madison details the concerns of too much state power, but what was concerning them at the time was an attempt by a powerful state to invade/control another state, not the Federal government encroaching on all the states. For this reason, state powers were not specifically articulated, but some state sovereignty was limited. Reading it today, however, is almost laughable. The checks and balances against encroachment of state authority has happened so pervasively and extensively, that remarks about how the numbers of people employed at the state level providing a buttress against the "few" at the Federal level, makes it absolutely clear that we have allowed all power-balancing strategies to be entirely eliminated. Madison was certain that the people would raise the alarm, and go to the guns, to address encroaching Federal powers long before they got to the point where we are today.

In Federalist 46, Madison addresses the concerns that the usurpation of state autonomy (or individual autonomy) would get so bad as to destroy the spirit and the literal powers of the States:
The only refuge left for those who prophesy the downfall of the State governments is the visionary supposition that the federal government may previously accumulate a military force for the projects of ambition. The reasonings contained in these papers must have been employed to little purpose indeed, if it could be necessary now to disprove the reality of this danger. That the people and the States should, for a sufficient period of time, elect an uninterupted succession of men ready to betray both; that the traitors should, throughout this period, uniformly and systematically pursue some fixed plan for the extension of the military establishment; that the governments and the people of the States should silently and patiently behold the gathering storm, and continue to supply the materials, until it should be prepared to burst on their own heads, must appear to every one more like the incoherent dreams of a delirious jealousy, or the misjudged exaggerations of a counterfeit zeal, than like the sober apprehensions of genuine patriotism.

Madison scoffed at the concerns, believing that the people would never stand for it, but all those fears have become our reality. We allowed all the worst-case scenarios to occur and that was something that Madison could never have fathomed.

So what do we do and what powers remain?

Before I address the best option, I'd like to address a concern: In many states the Second Amendment is in full force. For many of us, however, we wish to use that as a last resort, and attempt to restore the powers of the people and the respective States without resorting to war (or even some sort of agreed-upon, peaceful secession). The war option is far from being the only option, and surely the least desirable, when other options are still open to us.

There are a variety of suggestions to address the encroachment of Federal powers. Some have gone so far as to suggest we need to restate the limitions again, perhaps in new words, to make the point that the Constitution limits what the Federal government may do. This is the equivalent of applying bolds, asterisks, and underlines to what is already written. While I would not be opposed to these options, as I would support any and all peaceful attempts to address the problem, I do not think it is our best option.

The Constitution, in Amendments Ninth and Tenth, already state that the powers not specifically listed as granted to the Federal government remain with the states and/or the people. Saying it again is not going to change the status quo.  The Federal government is already ignoring what was written, so writing something else to be ignored is a futile gesture. We're past words. It is time for action.

The option that is open to us is state disobedience, but I use disobedience to better explain the idea rather than the word as a value judgement. It is the state-collective equivalent of civil disobedience. In truth, it is the Federal government that has been disobedient, by exercising powers they have not been granted. The only effective way to put meat into the limitations imposed on the Federal government is for the states to ignore actions, measures, and laws that are extra-constitutional. Only those actions, measures, initiatives, and laws that are specifically articulated in the Constitution as belonging to the Federal government will be respected by the several States, and by The People.

To this end, some state legislatures are passing "State Sovereignty" measures to restate their authority and limit Federal authority. These involve restatements of the Ninth and Tenth Amendments, which are:
Amendment IX
The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.

Amendment X
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

While we shouldn't ignore Congressional elections, it is more important now to pay attention to state elections, including the legislatures and the governor. It is time for governors (with agreement by the state legislatures) to refuse to abide by unconstitutional Federal encroachment. This includes:

  • Refusing all TARP funds/invasions of Federal officers in local businesses.

  • Refusing all Stimulus funding.

  • Refusing all education funding and federal legislation regarding education (and all other unconstitutional government departments).

  • Exercise the option to call out the National Guards to protect our borders if our Federal government continues to refuse to exercise their primary directive.


It is time for states to refuse to comply and also refuse the bribe money that comes with it, while protecting state citizens from unconstitutional taxes and penalties.

It is the responsibility of our state legislatures and our governors to exercise the authority we have granted to them. It is time we work locally to elect representatives who will restore the balance of power between the Federal and State governments and reject all invasions and encroachments of Federal authorities.

The following is the kind of speech that every governor of every state should deliver on the day he or she is sworn into office:
The People of this state have graciously elected me as their Governor, and I understand fully the responsibilities and authorities they have entrusted to me, as well as the limitations of that power within our state, and those entrusted to the Federal government. There are strict lines of delineation, between the counties and cities within our state; the powers granted to the local mayors and city/town councils; the unique relationships we have with neighboring states, and the authority we recognize as belonging to the Federal government.

The authority we have granted to the Federal government is strictly limited to those items articulated in the U.S. Constitution. The Federal government has the responsibility and authority to declare war, to provide for the common defense, to coin money, to regulate the seas, oceans and post roads, and to protect the products and arts by providing copyright and patent laws, and the judiciary may intervene on matters between us and other states. The Federal government has no other powers or authority. As part of my oath today I swore to uphold and protect not only our State Constitution, but the Federal Constitution. I take that oath seriously. Beginning today, I will issue an order which returns all funds received from the Federal government that goes beyond their authority. I reject all laws enacted by Congress that goes beyond their specifically limited authority. I will refuse, with force if necessary, the invasion of Federal officers, in whatever department or uniform, to exercise authority not specifically granted to them.

For too long states have remained passive, gradually morphing from free and sovereign states to lowly beggars, looking to the Federal government for hand-outs and to do the job that governors were intended to perform. That transition into a lowly beggar class ends now.

  • If the Federal government does not perform its duty with respect to protecting our borders, I will call out our National Guard to do so.

  • If the Federal government attempts to send agents to interfere with our peaceful commerce within our state, I will stop them at the border, with force, if necessary.

  • If the Federal government attempts to arrest or in any way interfere with our citizens' refusal to pay taxes on anything other than their incomes (not wages) or taxes imposed equally among the states, but only for the percentage of Federal government budget that is Constitutional, I will issue orders to stop them. Our state officers, police, and National Guard will be called upon to intervene to protect our citizens from arrest or property seizure, if necessary.

  • I will call upon neighboring and friendly states to assist us if necessary, and I will respond to calls for assistance from other states, if they should need our assitance.


It is time, finally, for the State governors to exercise the powers they have been granted, to protect thier citizens in their respective states from invasions of their liberty by the extra-Constutional acts of the Federal government, and for the Several States to refuse to abide by unjust and unconstitutional laws.

Today, the liberty and values established by the Founders will be restored in this state, and I hope many others.

That is what is necessary. That is the change of direction I introduced in my opening paragraphs to alter the course of the train to prevent the wreck. Although patience is required, anything else or short of that is a guarantee that our republican government will cease to exist.

Chances it will happen? Zero. But Americans love the underdog and this post is supposed to be my non-cynical view of the future. Despite the fact that I clearly and carefully stated that "going to the guns" was not an option, I suppose that my suggestions would classify me as a terrorist to some.  Oh, well.  So much for being optimistic.

Friday, July 24, 2009

Soylent Green is People!

Reading through the Twitter posts from Peter Fleckstein, posted by Savage (Little Green Footballs, Inside the Health Care Bill, aka HR3200, July 22, 2009), that's the thought that kept popping into my head:
PG 425: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 4-12 Government mandates Advance Care Planning Consult. Think Senior Citizens end of life

Pg 425: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 17-19 Government will instruct and consult regarding living wills, durable powers of attorney. Mandatory!

PG 425: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 22-25, 426 Lines 1-3 Government provides approved list of end of life resources, guiding you in death!

PG 427: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 15-24 Government mandates program for orders for end of life. The Government has a say in how your life ends!

Pg 429: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 1-9 An “advance care planning consultant” will be used frequently as patients health deteriorates.

PG 429: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 10-12 “advance care consultation” may include an ORDER 4 end of life plans. AN ORDER from GOV

Pg 429: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 13-25 – The Government will specify which Doctors can write an end of life order.

PG 430: SEC. 1233. ADVANCE CARE PLANNING CONSULTATION Lines 11-15 The Government will decide what level of treatment you will have at end of life.

(For people who don't understand the reference, Soylent Green was a film based on a dystopic novel [Make Room! Make Room! by Harry Harrison] where government mandated that people submit themselves to be killed on their 65th birthday. Set in a future where pollution prevented crop growth, there were food shortages. It was determined that the government-issued green wafers given to the people as nourishment was made from the bodies of the elderly.)

There is a point, however, where arguing the details is counterproductive. The bottom line is that government, especially the Federal government, has no authority to "reform" health care. It should be rejected on principle, regardless of the details.

H/t comment by katablog.com (James Pethokoukis, Reuters Blogs, Why Obama might have just killed Obamacare, July 23, 2009)

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Legacies that Matter

In a column by John McCormack (Weekly Standard, Thank You, America, July 13, 2009), we find an article by Jabr Al Jabouri, Al-Bayyna Al-Jadida [Baghdad], translated into English.

I'm not usually prone to spoilers, but Mr. Al Jabourbi's article ends with:
After six years of liberation, we now know who our friend is and who our foe is. We should not give a chance to those idiots who claim that Iraq is part of the Arab Nation. These idiots should understand that Iraq is part the federal, free and democratic world.

It would be daft to suggest that I agreed with everything President Bush did during his eight years in office, but I never doubted his incredible wisdom, nor wavered in my support, with respect to the "Bush Doctrine," especially when it applied to Iraq.

What happens in Iraq now will be up to the Iraqis themselves, but no one, and certainly not historians, will ever doubt that Iraqis were part of the free and democratic world.

In keeping with this blog's theme that there is nothing new under the sun, the situation in Iraq today reminds me of the interchange between Benjamin Franklin and Mrs. Powel at the conclusion of the Constitutional Convention in 1787:

Mrs. Powel:
"Well, Doctor, what have we got, a republic or a monarchy?"

Benjamin Franklin:
"A republic, if you can keep it."


What the future holds for Iraq is uncertain, but what they have today is a freedom. The future doesn't diminish the significance of the past, nor the noble and courageous actions of President Bush and the military who gave Iraqis a chance to keep it.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

The Right Kind of Elitism

From Heather Mac Donald (Secular Right, Right-wing identity politics, July 10, 2009):
Hanson is absolutely right that liberals and the left should expose themselves to the perils of entrepreneurship. But their own blindness to the economic and social values that undergird American prosperity and stability is no excuse for conservative indifference to the values of achievement, learning, and eloquence that we should expect from our leaders.

This blog's purpose is to document the decline of America's contribution as the last stand of Western Civilization. In centuries future (if a civilized people emerge from the ashes), people will wonder what happened. The above is what happened.

It didn't happen over night. It took decades for the educational establishment to be taken over by socialists, fascists, and communists to indoctrinate the youth into believing a completely contrary definition of the word and principles of liberal. But it wasn't just the word that was redefined. It was the protection of the baton of Western Civilization:

  • The moral duties and responsibilities of individuals and the importance of character, dignity and personal honor.

  • The lessons of over 10,000 years of history.

  • The difference between the role of society and the role of government.

  • The importance of education to improve one's ability to use reason and to immediately recognize propaganda and failed ideas.


It is the last bullet that Dr. Mac Donald addressed most specifically in her post.

We hear a great deal about elitism, having to do with our elected representatives' desires to lord over us, to use their power to treat us all like children, ignoring the fact that they exist to serve us, not to control us. This definition of elitism (from Dictionary.com) is the first definition:
1. practice of or belief in rule by an elite.

There is nothing inherently wrong with being ruled by an elite. It depends on how you define and what you include as "an elite."

Lumped into the elitist bath are the few remaining intellectuals who were educated in such a way as to provide society with wise advice and counsel. This is more akin to the second definition of elitism:
2. consciousness of or pride in belonging to a select or favored group.

The second definition involves belonging to a select group, but in America it isn't selection by birth; rather, it is selection based on merit, most commonly one of education, where there is a requirement to study and achieve in order to be invited into the club. It is a merit based club, not a birthright based club.
"The reward of esteem, respect and gratitude [is] due to those who devote their time and efforts to render the youths of every successive age fit governors for the next."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1810



All Americans are not required to do the heavy lifting with regard to understanding all of history's lessons (nor are all Americans capable of doing so), but because there has always existed a small, select group of intellectuals (synonymous with "Men of Letters") who would warn us if we were walking too closely to the edge of the slippery slope, we were protected. Our culture used to recognize and respect them for the benefits they provided to all of us. But all intellectuals, even those of the right kind, are being tarnished by those of the wrong kind, and are being relegated to the American equivalent of Siberia: irrelevance.
"The most effectual means of preventing [the perversion of power into tyranny are] to illuminate, as far as practicable, the minds of the people at large, and more especially to give them knowledge of those facts which history exhibits, that possessed thereby of the experience of other ages and countries, they may be enabled to know ambition under all its shapes, and prompt to exert their natural powers to defeat its purposes."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1779



Far too many on the right side of politics have decided to paint all intellectuals with the broad brush of manipulators and indoctrinators, and impugning not just the purpose and character of all, but their importance. Education has always been the key to conservative success and the foundation of America's success.
"If a nation expects to be ignorant and free in a state of civilization, it expects what never was and never will be."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1816



Educationally-based (i.e., learned) elitism has gotten a bad wrap. There is a good kind and bad kind. But there exists today an idea that one can be educated too much. We know that one can be indoctrinated instead of educated, but if we destroy the latter to reform the former, we will have accomplished what the Left has been desiring to do for decades: keep our people ignorant, and therefore unprotected, without the ability to recognize the signs of tyranny and what to do to address it.

It's wrong to suggest that a people who have learned only memes and bumper sticker slogans of liberty can defend it. An ignorant populist revolt ends up with a French style revolution where they decapitate everyone who they take a dislike to. If people are incapable of understanding all that liberty requires, the respect of order and law primarily, then they must have the ability to take advice and learn from others, in the old fashioned sense of respecting one's elders or betters. But, we have a movement in this country, a large movement, who believes that all educated people are power hungry and disrespectful of the common, ordinary man.

This type of movement has appeared many times and rather than educating their youth, they eat them. Without a firm commitment to understanding what has come before, we are doomed to repeat history's mistakes.

One of the mistakes that is woven throughout history is the concept of populism, but it is not the populism that appeals to the common man's moral nature or recognizes the rights of every person. When populism is perverted it appeals to man's selfish nature, where one man is pitted against another in a kind of class warfare. Rather than relying on principles or ideas that have been tested, populism offers what feels good rather than what is good, and what temporarily satisfies rather that what works long term. Populism placates. It delivers what people want to hear rather than the truth.

In many cases, populism relies on a scapegoat. With Germany it was the Jews and intellectuals. In Bolshevik Russia it was the aristocracy pitted against the poor or working class. In the Middle East (and elsewhere throughout the world today) it is the ignorant, radical Muslim pitted against moderates (or Western societies).

In nearly all of these scenarios, the "oppressed" are told how noble, special, important or brilliant they are and how they are "due" what others have, simply by existing. The "oppressed" are told they are entitled to the tangible and intangible property of others by birthright (not by hard work or fortitude). It is a kind of populist style of monarchy, i.e., the Divine Right of Everyone In Their Group, regardless of effort or achievement.

In American populism, the enemy of the oppressed common man is the educated, often demonstrated by how well one speaks; therefore, how well one doesn't speak is seen as a badge of honor.

Eloquence is only one demonstrative of a disciplined and educated mind, but the lack of it is often a clear indicator that both are missing. Some people, far too many, don't care about that, to the extreme of loathing it. It is a learned skill and the skill itself should have some recognized value, but it isn't everything.

Eloquence is something we should care about, but what is more important is erudition, for it will be our undoing if we devalue its importance.

Now many people confuse eloquence and erudition, and while sometimes these skills exist in the same person, they don't always. No one, for example, would doubt the erudition of Stephen Hawking, but his eloquence is demonstrated in his writing. Hawking's handicap prevents him from delivering a passionate speech. Similarly, George Bush was incapable of pronouncing the word nuclear, and was wanting with regard to his public speaking, but he was an educated man.

Thomas Jefferson, a man whose erudition is beyond dispute (and was also an eloquent writer), was a terrible speech maker. He had a high-pitched voice and was thought to have a small speech impediment. In Winston Churchill and Ronald Reagan we had both erudition and eloquence.

Far too many have come to associate eloquence with the bad kind of elitism, acquiring the horrid trait of Britons in believing that anyone who speaks properly, and wasn't born into it, is putting on airs.

Americans have swallowed the populist appeals of nefarious politicians and are being bribed, as Romans were with bread and circuses, as Germans were with appeals of vanity, and Islamic fundamentalists are with 70 virgins or the promise of an Islamic Caliphate.

Americans who have come to believe that education isn't important, and that politicians who speak in simplistic tones to demonstrate that they are "one of us" are being duped, and will soon discover that they have chosen badly. Principles matter and one of the enduring principles is that an educated and disciplined mind is more valuable than a snake oil salesman's ability to con a crowd into buying their nonsense.

The trick is in recognizing the difference between eloquence and a con artist, but it requires education to recognize the difference, and if that is missing, it requires respect and trust of an educated elite.
Democracy is the theory that the common people know what they want and deserve to get it good and hard.

- H. L. Mencken


Saturday, July 11, 2009

Questions for Sonia Sotomayor

Deborah O'Malley and Robert Alt provide Key Questions for Sonia Sotomayor (Heritage Foundation, July 10, 2009).

We can hope they're asked, but more importantly that Americans listen to and react appropriately to the answers.

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Trolls on the Flip Side

Dan Riehl (Riehl World View) has a few excellent posts on why Sarah Palin's decision to step down as Governor of Alaska is a sign of weakness including Why It's Time To Move Beyond Sarah Palin and Fund On Palin, July 7, 2009.  But you would think that Mr. Riehl had brutally murdered kittens by the ferocity of some of the comments on his posts.

During the election last year, bloggers who criticized Obama often found themselves being harassed by one or more from a legion of trolls, attacking the messenger of such posts. In few instances the commenters weren't trolls, and had substantive arguments (the definition of someone who isn't a troll), all in all, however, these things got nasty.

I think Mr. Riehl, despite a near-decade long establishment of conservative creds and substantive writing, has found himself the recipient of the Right side's equivalent... by being critical of Sarah Palin.

Mr. Riehl has not attacked Palin's family. He's posted his thoughtful and fact-based opinions about Palin's inferiority as a presidential candidate for 2012 (while still leaving open election wins in the longer term).

I had a troll-like comment on one of my posts criticizing Palin.

While I do not think that the trolls on the Right are an organized band of paid commenters (as they often were when they attacked people who criticized Obama), it is just as inappropriate.

Most of us who watched the blogosphere last year became familiar with "Paul-bots", who, like the paid Obama-supporting trolls, seemed to spend their days scouring the Internet, looking for anyone who had the audacity to question Ron Paul's fitness for office or doubt his sure victory.  The comments became all too familiar, as the substance of their comments seemed to come from some sort of "Comment Response Playbook."  These commenters seldom provided original refutations (with counter evidence).  They just regurgitated their candidate's talking points and used pejoratives to attack the messengers.

I don't think the Paul-bots knew they sounded so ridiculous, as most were merely simpletons who had swallowed the Paul Kool-Aid (or more accurately Kook-Aid).  Most appeared to be young (in their 20s) and had no previous election-participation experience (and, therefore, no historical mindedness when it came to elections). In that sense, they were cute (and I don't mean that to be disparaging).  They were innocent and invigorated, and if it was in Ron Paul where they found the need and desire to participate politically, that isn't a bad thing (if it means that their participation will be a life-long one, and not a flash in the pan).  They found the "community" they were a part of giving them a sense of belonging and purpose, something they seemed to be longing for.

That said, that sense of belonging and "higher purpose" is a dangerous thing.  It is cult-like behavior, as they clustered like seals against a common enemy (the enemy being anyone who didn't share their collective views about Ron Paul).  An individual supporting Ron Paul was not a bad thing at all, but an individual who sets aside reason and a willingness to hear thoughtful opinions and criticism, is no longer thinking like an individual.  They've become a cult member.

While I wouldn't put the Paul-bots in the same camp as those who, in the 1930s, found themselves similarly carried away by the charismatic Adolf Hitler, the behavior was the same, even if the candidates weren't comparable from an evil-quotient perspective.

Paul-bots were certain that their hero was going to defy Washington pundit projections, and sweep the election.  Anyone who said otherwise "would soon find out" just how wrong they were.

With the above, my purpose is to provide examples and to illustrate just how passionate people can be, while still being wrong.  The Internet can exacerbate these things, giving someone a sense of a large numbers of supporters (but they forget that the Internet is a dipstick measurement and the electorate is vast). Finding "thousands" of people with similar views on the Internet does not translate into "millions" of voters for your side. Passion can be a good thing, but it can quickly dissolve into fanaticism, justifying (to themselves) a kind of moral conviction to behave badly.

This should be a lesson for all who wish to go on the attack when anyone on the Right shares an negative opinion on Mrs. Palin's credibility as a candidate in 2012.  More accurately, a reminder to bloggers who find themselves on the receiving end of swarm-like personal attacks.

Cultism and fervor for one's political Messiah will morph into attack of anyone who doesn't join in the Kool-Aid drinking, regardless of the ideological aisle.

Attacks of the messenger are always bad form and they become counterproductive.  If a candidate, regardless of how substantive and qualified they may be, has cult-like followers who behave badly and loudly, their bad behavior reflects negatively on the candidate.

As I said above, comments, in order not to be considered troll-like, must be substantive and not contain personal attacks.  The argument can be fierce, but the focus must be on the argument itself, not personal attacks on the individual who expressed an opinion.

This is going to get ugly, as Mr. Riehl has discovered.  Sarah Palin is the standard-bearer for a group of Americans who believe they have been marginalized (and victimized).  Not all Americans support Sarah Palin for those reasons, but many do, and the decent folks are going to be out-shouted by the Sarah cult members. Criticizing their hero will result in all kinds of improper and rude behavior.

Saturday, July 4, 2009

One of Us?

There are a number of links on Instapundit today about a political run by Sarah Palin. Daily Pundit has a list of suggestions to get her campaign ready. Mark Steyn laments the inability of ordinary people from ordinary states to be accepted rather than scorned among the DC elite. Cynthia Yockey offers advice on how to get David Letterman fired.



Sarah Palin got a raw deal, both from the McCain campaign and the press who savagely attacked her for her ordinariness. Despite that, and Palin's national stage newbie foibles, she continues to click with a large number of conservative voters. Palin, to many, feels like one of us. Many people could relate to her simply because she was more like one of us than more like one of them. She had that tough-broad freshness that many of us know among our circle of friends.

Palin is the real deal. She is the dedicated mother and wife who responded to the call to do something in Alaska. And do something she has done, having considerable support among the Alaskans she represents.

Palin is the every man we know from Frank Capra films. She tugged at our emotions in the same way that Mr. Smith did when he went to Washington.

Americans have always been sympathetic to the every man and the romantic idea that it is one of us who will slay the dragons and demons in Washington to set things to rights.

Not to put too narrow a slant on it, but all of that is a fantasy, but more importantly, it is wrong headed. Conservatives are supposed to be the ones that set idle fantasies aside, dealing with the real world, with logical heads and tested facts. We're not the ones who think that the windmills of our minds, or in our gardens, will end the Left's fabricated-fantasy of global warming. Fantasy and utopia are supposed to be the realm of the Left, not the Right, but with Sarah, we forget ourselves.

One of us is not fit to be the President of the United States, and, I believe, in our heads and not not our hearts, we know the truth of that. What we may want idealistically, and what we know to be what's best, are not always in sync.

This has only been made worse by the egregious attacks against Palin, the unwarranted attacks against her family and her way of life. She wasn't given a fair deal and there is something about the American psyche that wants justice for Sarah and all the Ordinary Joes who were symbolically attacked when Sarah was. That justice, for many, is to back her unquestionably for a run at the White House.

The Washington Elite haven't done too well on Main Street. The Left and the Right have coddled us, taxed us, and are oozing with corruptible ideologies and behavior. It is not surprising then that many believe, in addition to the above, that it's time to throw the bastards out, and replace them with someone just like us. Qualifications, background, political resume, fitness for office are to be dumped along with the bath water. A Madame LaForge political philosophy does not bode well for anyone, especially in an America faced with enemies on all sides, and while we are engaged in a war against terrorism.

Sarah Palin isn't Ronald Reagan. She isn't Harry Truman either. She does share the every man qualities of those men, but this is another time, and time has changed things.

Ronald Reagan and Harry Truman seemed to appear out of nowhere, just like overnight success celebrities. Except, like overnight celebrities, we then notice that they had small parts in small and big films, and worked for a decade or more, paying their dues and working their craft to get to that success point. They weren't overnight successes. It was overnight that we recognized them, but they were always there.

Ronald Reagan was head of a large union (the Screen Actors Guide) before he ran for Governor in California. He'd always been political and for more than two decades bored his actor celebrity friends and acquaintances with talk of little else. He then went on to run one of the largest states in union, with an economy equal to the 5th largest country in the world. When he entered the governor's mansion (if you could call it that) he inherited a huge debt, a state in near financial collapse, and with a corrupt and embittered political machine. When he left office, two terms later, California had a budget surplus, all the politically corrupt had been chased away, and trust in the government had been restored.

Harry Truman was no flash in the pan either. From his offical biography:
From 1905 to 1911, Truman served in the Missouri National Guard. When the United States entered World War I in 1917, he helped organize the 2nd Regiment of Missouri Field Artillery, which was quickly called into Federal service as the 129th Field Artillery and sent to France. Truman was promoted to Captain and given command of the regiment's Battery D. He and his unit saw action in the Vosges, Saint Mihiel and Meuse-Argonne campaigns. Truman joined the reserves after the war, rising eventually to the rank of colonel. He sought to return to active duty at the outbreak of World War II, but Army Chief of Staff General George C. Marshall declined his offer to serve.

Truman was elected in 1922, to be one of three judges of the Jackson County Court. Judge Truman whose duties were in fact administrative rather than judicial, built a reputation for honesty and efficiency in the management of county affairs. He was defeated for reelection in 1924, but won election as presiding judge in the Jackson County Court in 1926. He won reelection in 1930.

In 1934, Truman was elected to the United States Senate. He had significant roles in the passage into law of the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938 and the Transportation Act of 1940. After being reelected in 1940, Truman gained national prominence as chairman of the Senate Special Committee to Investigate the National Defense Program. This committee, which came to be called the Truman Committee, sought with considerable success to ensure that defense contractors delivered to the nation quality goods at fair prices.

In July 1944, Truman was nominated to run for Vice President with President Franklin D. Roosevelt. On January 20, 1945, he took the vice-presidential oath, and after President Roosevelt's unexpected death only eighty-two days later on April 12, 1945, he was sworn in as the nations' thirty-third President.

In summary, he spent 9 years in the military rising to the rank of Colonel. He spent 2 years in Jackson county court. He spent 10 years in the Senate before being tapped to run for Vice President in 1944. All in all, a 21 year career of military and public service before he served for 82 days as Vice President, before becoming the President of the United States, as a war president.

Truman didn't have a college degree (he spent two years in law school), but he did have a battlefield education:
Captain Harry S. Truman was 34 years old when he was put in charge of Battery D, 129th Field Infantry, a rowdy band of undisciplined young soldiers. Truman's mission was to transform the group into a combat-ready unit capable of taking on the German army. The odds were not in Harry's favor. Battery D had a reputation for being tough on commanders, and up to that point Truman had experienced considerable failure in his life.

In 1917, when Truman joined the Second Missouri Field Artillery Regiment to fight in World War I, his luck began to change. Truman adapted well to the discipline of military life. He trained at Camp Doniphan in Oklahoma, where he organized a profitable camp commissary with a fellow soldier named Eddie Jacobson. In 1918, Truman received a captain's commission and shipped out to France.

On July 5, Truman took command of Battery D. The rowdy Kansas City Irishmen of the battery specialized in wearing out commanding officers. Many predicted the bespectacled captain would crumble quickly.

On August 29, 1918, Battery D fired 500 rounds of artillery at a German position. When the Germans returned fire, some of Truman's men panicked and ran. "My greatest satisfaction is that my legs didn't succeed in carrying me away, although they were very anxious to do it," Harry wrote Bess later. Cursing and yelling, Truman drove his men back to their positions, and successfully repositioned two of his four guns. For the remainder of the war, Truman led Battery D across the French countryside, hammering German positions and never losing a man. On the battlefields of Europe, he experienced the success that had long eluded him.

Truman returned from the war as a hero.

While we could apply the label "hero" generically to all men who serve their country, Harry Truman was a real war hero. He wasn't one of us. He was forged on the field of battle to be the great, yet humble, man that he was.

These men spent at least 20 years in dedicated public service, on the battlefield and on the national stage, long before they ever considered a run for the presidency, or any public office. When the time came, there was no doubt about their fitness for office.

Now compare the above with Sarah Palin. Can she lead men? It has nothing to do with her being a woman. Maybe she can, but we don't know that, and we must know that. She certainly hasn't made us proud in her public interviews. We might blame the press for trickery, but a tested and experienced individual wouldn't have made those same mistakes.

Great statesmen aren't born. They are developed through education and experience. They're very different from one of us, exactly because they're able to differentiate themselves from us by their superior leadership abilities, their fortitude, their educations, and their gifts. Both Truman and Reagan were gifted men, with superior intellects, and also gifted with the common touch. We should not confuse that ability to relate to us with that common touch with them being common.

"Laws will be wisely formed and honestly administered in proportion as those who form and administer them are wise and honest; whence it becomes expedient for promoting the public happiness that those persons whom nature has endowed with genius and virtue should be rendered by liberal education worthy to receive and able to guard the sacred deposit of the rights and liberties of their fellow citizens; and that they should be called to that charge without regard to wealth, birth or other accidental condition or circumstance. But the indigence of the greater number disabling them from so educating at their own expense those of their children whom nature has fitly formed and disposed to become useful instruments for the public, it is better that such should be sought for and educated at the common expense of all, than that the happiness of all should be confined to the weak or wicked."


- Thomas Jefferson, 1779



Great Statesmen appear from a culled herd, and we need to get over the fantasy that one of us is just like one of them, capable of being seated as President of the United States. The simple fact is that we are not qualified, and we need to face that, quickly, if we are to allow a real hero, a forged statesmen, to appear from the crowd and lead us to victory in 2012.

Friday, July 3, 2009

Cautions

I stumbled on a virtual reprint of Whittaker Chambers's 1957 review of Ayn Rand's Atlas Shrugged (National Review 50th Anniversary, Big Sister Is Watching You). Being incapable of tolerating Ayn Rand myself and amazed that others are not so immediately inclined, I found the review exhilarating and fascinating. Mr. Chambers so accurately details the dangerous dogma of Rand (and one can delight in the compact, quality writing style of a bygone era).

Some people are easily duped into believing Rand's nonsense, to the point of cultish adherence, leaving aside all reason and logic of what comes next (despite often considering themselves among the Right's intellectual elite):
Of course, Miss Rand nowhere calls for a dictatorship. I take her to be calling for an aristocracy of talents. We cannot labor here why, in the modern world, the pre-conditions for aristocracy, an organic growth, no longer exist, so that the impulse toward aristocracy always emerges now in the form of dictatorship.

Nor has the author, apparently, brooded on the degree to which, in a wicked world, a materialism of the Right and a materialism of the Left first surprisingly resemble, then, in action, tend to blend each with each, because, while differing at the top in avowed purpose, and possibly in conflict there, at bottom they are much the same thing. The embarrassing similarities between Hitler's National Socialism and Stalin's brand of Communism are familiar. For the world, as seen in materialist view from the Right, scarcely differs from the same world seen in materialist view from the Left. The question becomes chiefly: who is to run that world in whose interests, or perhaps, at best, who can run it more efficiently?

I read a lot, but I've never seen a better description of the yin and yang of socialism and Ayn Rand's style of materialism/collectivism. When our focus and ideals shift from the intangibles of virtue to materialism and we become a nation who lauds banal work for work's sake, we are in a precarious position.

I found the above in an article by Gerry Wills on William F. Buckley (The Atlantic, Daredevil).

The contrasts between William F. Buckley and Ayn Rand's heroes in Atlas Shrugged could not be greater. In the contrasts of the two we also find the source (perhaps) of the anti-intellectualism (almost to the point of being anti-education) among Republicans. It is why we miss Buckley so much and why we loathe Rand.

William F. Buckley was a man of principle, religious and secular, and was quite capable of differentiating his religious beliefs from his political ones, i.e., maintaining the difference between a person who is religious, still understanding that our government is secular. Ayn Rand (besides being, or because she was, a lunatic), somehow came to believe that the goal of an individual life was to make money in a "Captains of Industry" mode. Mr. Buckley, on the other hand, was a man who believed in altruism and morality. From Mr. Wills:
He [Buckley] spent a lot of time thinking of what he could do for friends. When he heard that I needed a passport in a hurry, he pulled strings at the State Department to get it for me. On another occasion, when my new bride and I could not find a cheap sea liner to England for our honeymoon, he found a ship for us leaving from Canada. Bill ingeniously invented a way to institutionalize his love for giving special gifts. Because his family was so prolific, he had 49 of what he called “N and Ns” (nieces and nephews). He took care of the education of many of them. But supplying necessities was not enough for him. He set up a fund he called the Dear Uncle Bill Trust (DUBT, soon pronounced “Doubt”), whose administrators gave surprise treats to N and Ns—a valuable guitar to an aspiring musician, a vacation in a favorite spot—on a rotating basis.

"The love of money is the root of all evil" is an oft misunderstood tenant of Judeo/Christianity, and can make Capitalism an anathema if the "love of" is left off (which is how it is often misunderstood). Loving money and hating it have the same result.

Philosophers (religious or otherwise) from inception have warned against an aristocracy of wealth, rather than of character and virtue, and championed lofty pursuits over those of the flesh/ego.

Certainly we all need money, and the more of it we are able to make to find a balance between work and pleasure an important one to pursue. But one's life shouldn't be about making money, and certainly not loving money for money's sake. That leads to all sorts of unsavory traits: greed and selfishness are just two among many.

The idea that someone, like Ayn Rand, would champion a materialistic society, putting merchants, industrialists, and technocrats as some sort of ideal is wrong, so wrong as to defy belief. What do they offer society and what value do they have when they're not at work?  Are they loving fathers and husbands, do they volunteer to help others, do they enjoy music or literature?  In simpler terms, would they make an interesting dinner guest?  If all they wanted to talk about was their businesses and work, they would not make the list.

Left off are the arts or art patronage, and a pursuit of a passion with little material reward.

In Ayn Rand's ideal world, a measure of a man is the size of his bank account, or his empire, so long as he doesn't desire power. But Rand is confused, because she simultaneously admonishes a desire for power, while creating a fiction in which the Captains of Industry become the new, lauded aristocracy:
That Dollar Sign is not merely provocative, though we sense a sophomoric intent to raise the pious hair on susceptible heads. More importantly, it is meant to seal the fact that mankind is ready to submit abjectly to an elite of technocrats, and their accessories, in a New Order, enlightened and instructed by Miss Rand's ideas that the good life is one which "has resolved personal worth into exchange value," "has left no other nexus between man and man than naked selfinterest, than callous "cash-payment."' The author is explicit, in fact deafening, about these prerequisites. Lest you should be in any doubt after 1,168 pages, she assures you with a final stamp of the foot in a postscript:

And I mean it." But the words quoted above are those of Karl Marx. He, too, admired "naked self-interest" (in its time and place), and for much the same reasons as Miss Rand: because, he believed, it cleared away the cobwebs of religion and led to prodigies of industrial and cognate accomplishment. The overlap is not as incongruous as it looks. Atlas Shrugged can be called a novel only by devaluing the term. It is a massive tract for the times. Its story merely serves Miss Rand to get the customers inside the tent, and as a soapbox for delivering her Message. The Message is the thing. It is, in sum, a forthright philosophic materialism. Upperclassmen might incline to sniff and say that the author has, with vast effort, contrived a simple materialist system, one, intellectually, at about the stage of the oxcart, though without mastering the principle of the wheel. Like any consistent materialism, this one begins by rejecting God, religion, original sin, etc., etc. (This book's aggressive atheism and rather unbuttoned "higher morality," which chiefly outrage some readers, are, in fact, secondary ripples, and result inevitably from its underpinning premises.) Thus, Randian Man, like Marxian Man, is made the center of a godless world.

I am not religious, but I understand Mr. Chambers reference to a "godless world" and can commiserate and relate with those who feel that moral values are important, and seriously lacking in today's society.

However, when I hear the "godless" phrase used as a political agitating point, I am just as exasperated as I am when Rand argues from the other side of the coin.

I received an email from Newt Gingrich (not to me personally, but a generic beg letter). In it, Mr. Gingrich writes:
The effort to change America has been systematically executed by a secularist left-wing machine for the last five decades. That effort has eroded our culture, our Godly heritage, and our very history.

The continued success of our nation depends upon a common understanding of our unique culture, our Godly heritage and our American history.

I understand the audience that Mr. Gingrich is appealing to, but it is cheap shot. I got to that point in the email and I clicked off of it, disgusted. If this is the message that Mr. Gingrich thinks will unite conservatives and moderates and yield victory in 2012/2014, he could not be more off the rails.

There is an element of truth to what Mr. Gingrich says. Religious people (specifically Christians) have had their religion and their way of life challenged by mean-spirited secularists, but it is too broad a brush, and confuses the issue.

We have a Christian heritage in this country, and the majority of Americans may consider themselves Christian (to some degree or another), but we have a secular government. People may be religious and their religion (or lack thereof) is protected from government meddle or support. Confusing the two spells disaster for Republicans.
"No provision in our Constitution ought to be dearer to man than that which protects the rights of conscience against the enterprises of the civil authority."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1809



"The error seems not sufficiently eradicated that the operations of the mind as well as the acts of the body are subject to the coercion of the laws. But our rulers can have authority over such natural rights only as we have submitted to them. The rights of conscience we never submitted, we could not submit. We are answerable for them to our God. The legitimate powers of government extend to such acts only as are injurious to others. But it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods, or no God. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg." -

Thomas Jefferson, 1782



Mr. Gingrich should heed Jefferson's advice. Similarly, those on the Left should be put in their place when they attempt to encroach on religious freedom by trying to eradicate it. It may not be supported in the public square, but it cannot be denied either.
"I contemplate with sovereign reverence that act of the whole American people which declared that their Legislature should 'make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof,' thus building a wall of separation between Church and State."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1802



Now if people like Ayn Rand want to go around declaring that religion is evil, she has every right to do so. Similarly, many of the contributors to SecularRight seem to feel that religion really is the opiate of the (stupid) masses.

If so, so be it. We all get to choose our opiates. Being anti-religion has the same result as believing that religion belongs in the government's purview to enforce. Enforcing or denying are the same thing! Religious people aren't broken, needing some sort of fix to make them more desirable citizens.

This all gets terribly confusing and can make one feel as if they're watching a ping pong ball match, with each side banging the religious ball back and forth.

Where it gets even more difficult is when we discuss morality and principles, as opposed to a specific religion's dogma.
"To suppose that any form of government will secure liberty or happiness without any virtue in the people is a chimerical idea."

- James Madison



There was a time in this country when we quibbled over the list of moral laws. Today we seem to be arguing that there are no moral laws, and believing that there are/were as some sort of quaint, outdated concept. This is not a healthy sign and will surely result in misery... and our eventual demise.
"Independence can be trusted nowhere but with the people in mass. They are inherently independent of all but moral law."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1819



Battling the Left and the Right on this issue is fatiguing, as it is where their political ideologies intersect and become the same. Virtue and morality are requirements, but a specific religious test is not. The former exists for our government officials as well as ourselves. We can ignore it, and choose not to be moral nor virtuous, but we cannot eradicate them as requirements.  Rand desires to eradicate these requirements, Buckley only to rememer them, and Gingrich, lastly, to require a religious test, albeit in another name.

I do not know why that is so difficult for people to understand.

Ping. Pong. Ad infinitum.