Showing posts with label Iran. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Iran. Show all posts

Thursday, June 25, 2009

Two Roads Divided

It is difficult to know how to support the Iranian protesters.

I wouldn't know where to send them money, nor is money what they need.  I am not of soldier age (nor was I trained as one), so I can't abandon my family and head there as some sort of mercenary, nor is that wanted.  I don't have access to a stockpile of weapons, nor any means of shipping them to Iran if I did.

What the Iranian protesters need is for all free people to stand united with them--to promise to boycott all Iranian goods, to blockade their shipments, for all governments to censure the illegitimate government, and to speak in one voice that all people have a right to free and honest elections.

The very least I could do was write this post and to put a silly little blurb on this blog to offer my support.  I'm just one voice, just one person, and as Robert Frost once said, "...that has made all the difference."

We all have a voice and a choice.  Will we stand united with the Iranian people?

Wednesday, June 24, 2009

Real Principles

Glenn Reynolds (Instapundit) links to a post by Eric Dondero (Libertarian Republican, When Conservatives are more Libertarian, than the Libertarians, June 23, 2009) focusing on the lack of support from the libertarian camps for the protesters in Iran.  The post itself is very good, but the comment by "Junyo" sums it up perfectly:
Short version of Libertarian philosophy: I got mine, fuck you.

If the French had "minded their own business" we'd all be living in South Canada. And of course there's the love of the Confederacy among freedom loving Libertarians, because damn that Lincoln and his interfering with the right of people to own other people.

If Libertarians were saying 'it's a great idea to support these people, but I'm not sure that [insert specific mechanism of helping] would be effective' that would be one thing. But the blanket hostility to the basic idea betrays it for what it is, xenophobia and narrow minded selflessness masquerading as principle.

I do quite a bit of libertarian bashing here, but there's a reason for that, and the above is exactly why.  Far too many libertarians ascribe quite a bit of meaning to the idea of non-interventionism. That's a wonderful principle to have when the issue is whether to conquer a free people, commit genocide to rid the land mass of the indigenous, and to make the new territory your own.  That's a far cry from responding to someone shouting "FIRE!"  Not responding to a cry for help is wrong and shows a lack of principle.

"Non-intervention" is a subject that has been discussed since our nation was founded. Washington (and others) were quite adamant about avoiding "foreign entanglements," but like all things from the Founding Fathers, it is important to keep them in the context of the time, based on the the world at the time.

At the time, Europe was a series of nations under feudal control. The Royals were a small band of uncles, aunts, and cousins. They were continually feuding with one another and had no qualms about raising armies to fight with one another over a slight, or to make their empires larger out of greed. There are regions of Europe that have been fought over for centuries, for exactly these reasons. The outcome of these battles were for King X to steal the land from his cousin Queen Y. It had nothing to do with an oppressed people throwing off the shackles of tyranny. The people themselves were not at war with their government. Their tyrannical leaders were at war with other tyrannical leaders.

It was those petty squabbles that the Founding Fathers wanted to avoid, and was the context of the "foreign entanglement" principle of Washington (from his Farewell Address):
"Why, by interweaving our destiny with that of any part of Europe, entangle our peace and prosperity in the toils of European ambition, rivalship, interest, humor or caprice?"

And:

"I am for free commerce with all nations, political connection with none, and little or no diplomatic establishment. And I am not for linking ourselves by new treaties with the quarrels of Europe, entering that field of slaughter to preserve their balance, or joining in the confederacy of Kings to war against the principles of liberty."


- Thomas Jefferson, 1799



(Emphasis mine.)

When it came to supporting a people in doing what we had done (separating ourselves from King George), the Founders were quite united in showing support.  If (as the French had done in our case) the people who were in a state of revolution were doing so with the purpose (and the ability) to form a new government, founded on the principle of liberty for all, and had a chance of success (i.e., were large enough and united in their desire), we were duty-bound to support it.  How we might support it was the subject of debate, not if we were obliged to help them.
"Countries... have a right to be free, and we a right to aid them, as a strong man has a right to assist a weak one assailed by a robber or murderer."

- Thomas Jefferson to James Monroe, 1816



Not all libertarians operate with the same set of principles, or interpret the dogma in the same way, but far too many (as Mr. Dondero accurately describes) take the non-intervention philosophy too far and in the wrong direction, not understanding the specific context of the "no foreign entanglements" idea.

Moral relevancy is a problem, in general, and it rears its ugly head among the Left, Right, and Middle, but libertarians have taken it to a high art.  Equating the rescue of the oppressed and desperate with imperialism (or "foreign entanglement") is quite a leap, and defies the basic tenets of the responsibility of free people to act to protect and support each other.

Libertarians, in general (not universally) have a problem with obligations and duties, and that is why they will be forever marginalized as a group interested not in liberty for all, but a group focused on liberty for me, but none for thee.

I realize that libertarians are not conservatives, but the basic principles of liberty, of a psychically-moral human being, cannot be better stated than from the well known quote from Edmund Burke:
"All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing."

Libertarians can choose to incorporate that principle into their ideology, or they can identify themselves as being nothing more than mooches, living off the goodness and courage of others.

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

We CAN Handle the Truth

From Peter Wehner (Commentary Magazine, Let Us Not Comfort Cruel Men), June 16, 2009):
G.K. Chesterton once referred to “easy speeches to comfort cruel men.” Leaders like Reagan (and his contemporary, Margaret Thatcher) were not terribly interested in providing comfort to cruel men. They instinctively identified with the victims of oppression rather than the oppressors — and they were, more often than not, willing to give those views public voice. What we are dealing with is a cast of mind, a disposition toward words, their power and meaning, and their capacity to shape events.

Mr. Wehner links to an article by Bret Stephens (WSJ, Wanted: 'Hope' for Iran, June 16, 2009):
Here's a recent comment from one Iranian demonstrator posted on the Web site of the National Iranian American Council. "WE NEED HELP, WE NEED SUPPORT," this demonstrator wrote. "Time is not on our side... The most essential need of young Iranians is to be recognized by US government. They need them not to accept the results and do not talk to government as an official, approved one."

Someday a future president may have to apologize to Iranians for Mr. Obama's nonfeasance, just as Mr. Obama apologized for the Eisenhower administration's meddling. But the better Eisenhower parallel is with Hungary in 1956. Then as now a popular uprising coalesced around a figure (Imre Nagy in Hungary; Mir Hossein Mousavi in Iran), who had once been a creature of the system. Then as now it was buoyed by inspiring American rhetoric about freedom and democracy coming over Voice of America airwaves.

This is the real test of Obama:  Will he ignore the pleas for help and recognition from Iran's desperate citizens yearning to be free in their own nation, or will he remain silent and impotent?

H/t Instapundit.

Cyberwar Guide for Iran elections

Instapundit links to a post by Omri (Mere Rhetoric, Cyberwar Guide To Helping The Iranian Protesters, June 16, 2009):
The purpose of this guide is to help you participate constructively in the Iranian election protests through Twitter.

  1. Do NOT publicise proxy IP's over twitter, and especially not using the #iranelection hashtag. Security forces are monitoring this hashtag, and the moment they identify a proxy IP they will block it in Iran. If you are creating new proxies for the Iranian bloggers, DM them to @stopAhmadi or @iran09 and they will distributed them discretely to bloggers in Iran.

  2. Hashtags, the only two legitimate hashtags being used by bloggers in Iran are #iranelection and #gr88, other hashtag ideas run the risk of diluting the conversation.

  3. Keep you bull$hit filter up! Security forces are now setting up twitter accounts to spread disinformation by posing as Iranian protesters. Please don't retweet impetuosly, try to confirm information with reliable sources before retweeting. The legitimate sources are not hard to find and follow.

  4. Help cover the bloggers: change your twitter settings so that your location is TEHRAN and your time zone is GMT +3.30. Security forces are hunting for bloggers using location and timezone searches. If we all become 'Iranians' it becomes much harder to find them.

  5. Don't blow their cover! If you discover a genuine source, please don't publicise their name or location on a website. These bloggers are in REAL danger. Spread the word discretely through your own networks but don't signpost them to the security forces. People are dying there, for real, please keep that in mind...


Via @allahpundit, the State Department apparently asked Twitter to delay their scheduled downtime to help out the protesters. A very nice move, especially considering the lukewarm support the Obama administration has voiced elsewhere (via @jswtx).

I don't know what all of the above means, but changing Twitter settings to Tehran seems like a small action to help a great cause.