Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Science. Show all posts

Saturday, July 11, 2009

The Cap and Trade Experience

Ben Lieberman (Heritage Foundation, The European Experience with Cap and Trade, July 10, 2009) gave testimony before the Committee on Foreign Relations, United States Senate. In his testimony we find all the data necessary to accurately describe any Cap and Trade proposal in the U.S. an unproductive waste of our time and money, with disastrous effect on our economy:
To the limited extent European nations have reduced emissions below business-as-usual levels, it has hurt their economies. Almost every Western European nation has had higher unemployment and energy costs than America, and a weaker overall economy, even as emissions were still rising. Far from seeing evidence of the bright new green economy some are now promising, we are seeing that cap and trade has contributed to the harm. For example, Spain has been cited repeatedly as the example of a successful clean energy economy and source of green jobs, but it is rarely mentioned that Spain currently has 18 percent unemployment.

RTWT.

Monday, July 6, 2009

Pet Peeve

Sean Trende (Real Clear Politics–TIME.com, What Emerging Progressive Majority?, July 6, 2009) addresses one of my pet peeves.
The only problem with this theory is that, to claim the country is shifting to the left, you first need to establish a baseline. Teixeira's study doesn't have any baseline off of which to operate. It merely asks its questions, then concludes that America is now center-left. Of course, without such a baseline (i.e., a study of American attitudes in, say, the 1980s, at conservatism's height), it is impossible to say with any certainty whether America has moved right, left, or stayed the same.

Unfortunately, Mr. Trende goes on to cite numerous polls that show that the country is trending Right, not Left, but the data is still not conclusive.

Let me be clear: Mr. Trende is correct to impugn the results of the Americans For Progress study, because their study was also attitudinal (as are the Pew and Rasmussen studies referenced to refute the claim). It is an appropriate apples to apples refutation.

Mr. Trende is also correct to require a baseline for comparison, but that is still not enough.

It's all garbage.

Why? Because asking a person to rate themselves on a scale, or to choose from a list of political descriptions doesn't tell us anything other than what the person thinks or hopes they are.

If you asked people to rate themselves according to honesty, the study is going to show that the majority of people think themselves reasonably honest (or greater). The majority could think that cheating on their taxes doesn't make them dishonest, or bringing home a few pens or pencils from work is "OK" because "everyone else does it." Have they or do they routinely download pirated software, copyrighted materials, or ever participated in sending along an email chain letter? Have they or do they routinely cheat on their spouse or "lusted for another in their heart"? Do they tell small lies to avoid embarassment or save face? Have they or do they routinely call in "sick" for work, when they're not? If the answer to any of those conjoint questions is "yes," their honesty quotient is wanting, and doesn't jive with their response.

Anyone who works with this kind of data knows that people are going to pick the rating or the item that they most want to be, but has no actual reality.

What is needed, that isn't out there, is quantitative/conjoint analysis of the results.

The reason I know that all the studies are bunk is because it doesn't jive with other studies and facts.

If, for example, a majority of Americans consider themselves conservative or conservative-leaning, then how did Obama get elected, why does Congress have a Democratic majority, how did Obama's initial approval rating get so high, why do a majority of Americans support some form of socialized medicine (even if titled "reform"), a desire to keep the status quo with respect to Social Security, like the Prescription Drug Program, like farm subsidies, approve of limited forms of trade protections, support regulation of "evil" businesses and corporations, or can't/couldn't understand the Bush Doctrine to save their lives?

There is no fixed definition in the public square to define what "conservative" means, especially defined for them when people respond to attitudinal polls.

Their responses to what they think they are needs to be validated based on how they feel about specific issues. Until that is done, and we have a baseline to establish the error rate of these types of polls, it's all feel-good nonsense.

If the country really is "majority conservative" then why hasn't the majority donned pitchforks and dragged Congress into the streets for a little tar and feathering?

The only data we can rely on with any certainty is that the majority of Americans are getting dumber/apathetic (see above studies/facts) and poorer (see everything Obama and this Democratic Congress has done so far).

Monday, June 29, 2009

A Lefty Complains

Instapundit links to an article by Clive Crook (FT.com, Obama is choosing to be weak, June 28, 2009).  The title being what it is, I was expecting something about Iran or Obama's other goofs with respect to foreign relations. Oh, no. This article is about the cap and trade and healthcare reform. Mr. Crook's complaints are not that Congress is considering these intrusive and unconstitutional measures. His complaints are that they're not horrible enough.

On cap and trade:
The cap-and-trade bill is a travesty. Its net effect on short- to medium-term carbon emissions will be small to none. This is by design: a law that really made a difference would make energy dearer, hurt consumers and force an economic restructuring that would be painful for many industries and their workers. Congress cannot contemplate those effects. So the Waxman-Markey bill, while going through the complex motions of creating a carbon abatement regime, takes care to neutralise itself.

"Hurt consumers."  Spoken like a true Jack Booted Thug.

On socialized medicine:
If you regard universal access to health insurance as an urgent priority, as I do, the draft healthcare bills are easier to defend as at least a step in the right direction. Nonetheless, the same evasive mindset – the appetite for change without change – has guided their design. If you are happy with your present insurance, the bills’ designers keep telling voters, you will see no difference.

Mr. Crock seems to believe that cap and trade was ever anything besides a tax. He also speaks of climate change as if it is a fact. Either he's been duped by the propaganda or he's furthering it.  On healthcare, he seems to think that universal health insurance is a good idea, as if insurance is what is needed.

Every American has access to medical care.  No one is denied access to emergency care.  A hospital denying emergency treatment would get fined out of existence.  If it isn't an emergency, there are many other options from paying for the treatment (if the patient is flush enough to do so) to medicaid (if the patient is poor), with much wiggle room in the middle.

As Regulation magazine recently reported, 95% of American are satisfied with the medical care they receive.  Americans are considering some sort of safety net coverage, not because they want it for themselves, but because they've been duped into believing that 46,000,000 others want it/need it:
If you take the Kaiser/ABC News/USA Today survey's estimate of 13.4 percent of Americans being uninsured and that 17.5 percent of the uninsured are "very dissatisfied" with the care that they are receiving, just 2.3 percent of Americans are both uninsured and "very dissatisfied" with the care they receive. That amounts to 5 million people. Including all uninsured raises the total to 8.4 million. This is a far cry from the 46 million number that is frequently bandied about by politicians and media to count the uninsured.

Unlike Mr. Crock, I happen to believe that government is there to serve the people's interests and desires, not to use government as a means of punishment by fleecing everyone.  Government's purpose is not be a change agent and parent.

Americans do not need universal health insurance, nor did we need cap and trade.  Unlike Mr. Crock, I'm pleased that Congress/Obama didn't go far enough.  I just wish they hadn't gone there at all.

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Missing the Missing Link Link

At the dinner table last evening we were discussing recent headlines. Two of us, including me, were quite surprised that we missed any mention of the discovery of the missing link (National Geographic News, "MISSING LINK" FOUND: New Fossil Links Humans, Lemurs?, May 19, 2009):  
The fossil, he says, bridges the evolutionary split between higher primates such as monkeys, apes, and humans and their more distant relatives such as lemurs.

"This is the first link to all humans," Hurum, of the Natural History Museum in Oslo, Norway, said in a statement. Ida represents "the closest thing we can get to a direct ancestor." 

Having that discovery found at all (which was never a certainty) is quite astonishing.  Having it found during my lifetime is something personal to celebrate. (I'm old enough to consider that breakthroughs that have been worked on during my lifetime will not complete before I die, but not this one!)

I would have expected special news bulletins would have accompanied the announcement, as the finding is as important and remarkable as "Mars creatures land on earth" would be.

I missed the missing link news completely, which surprised me, as I'm quite a news junkie.  

I shall attempt to rectify missing the missing link news by becoming even junkier in the future.