Showing posts with label Polls. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Polls. Show all posts

Monday, June 22, 2009

Good Sign

From Rasmussen Reports™ (Daily Presidential Tracking Poll, June 22, 2009):
The Rasmussen Reports daily Presidential Tracking Poll for Monday shows that 33% of the nation's voters now Strongly Approve of the way that Barack Obama is performing his role as President. Thirty-four percent (34%) Strongly Disapprove giving Obama a Presidential Approval Index rating of -1. Today is the second straight day the President’s rating has been below zero (see trends).

[caption id="attachment_771" align="aligncenter" width="400" caption="Rasmussen Reports: President Approval Index"]Rasmussen Reports: President Approval Index[/caption]

This is a good sign (for the country) and is change we can believe in.

H/t Instapundit.

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

The Chosen Ones

Being "chosen" must get tiring and irksome.  

Via Drudge: (Breitbart/AFP, Half of Israelis back immediate strike on Iran, May 24, 2009):
Just over half of Israelis back an immediate attack on the nuclear facilities of arch-foe Iran but the rest want to wait and see the results of US diplomacy, according to a poll released on Sunday.

The above, combined with Iran's sabre rattling and their announcement that they reject compromise proposals makes it a certainty that, once again, God's chosen people will be the ones who have the burden and the hutzpah to do what is necessary to keep the world safe, by attacking Iran's nuclear facilities.

There was a time when America had that kind of leadership and backbone, but no more.

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Careful There

Via Instapundit, a report on new college graduates employment (ABC News, Fewer Than 20% of Grads Land Job Offers, May 20, 2009):
According to a survey from National Association of Colleges and Employers, the class of 2009 is leaving campus with fewer jobs in hand than their 2008 counterparts. The group's 2009 Student Survey found that just 19.7 percent of 2009 graduates who applied for a job actually have one.

In comparison, 51 percent of those graduating in 2007 and 26 percent of those graduating in 2008 who had applied for a job had one in hand by the time of graduation.

[Emphasis mine.]

First, let's be careful what we quote here. The report doesn't say "less than 20% of graduates find work," as the ABC News article suggests by its title. The percentage is qualified with who applied for a job.

What could be a remarkable change is the difference from 2007 (51%) and 2009 (19.7%); however, we must still be cautious about making too much out of it.  We would need to know:

  • If the majors changed dramatically, such as a larger number of Business or Finance majors. Those degrees would have less marketability this year because of the contraction in the financial sector, as well as new business development in a cash-strapped economy.

  • If a higher number of graduates applied for work: If there were more graduates in the job market, the market for college graduates would be over-saturated. If, for example, 40% of college graduates applied for work in 2007, 50% of them securing a job would be 20% of the graduate pool. If, however, 80% of recent graduates applied for work in 2009, and 20% found a job, then 40% of the graduate pool found work. The net of that type of scenario would indicate that more graduates were employed in 2009 than in 2007:


40% of 1,000 Graduates = 400 * 50% = 200 employed

80% of 1,000 Graduates = 800 * 20% = 400 employed

If there is something close to the latter above, it could be that more college graduates are employed than in recent years. We do not know that from the report. It is fuzzy reporting from ABC News (because most journalists know very little about statistics, or it would appear to be the case, based on how badly they generally report on such things).
Bryan Hopkins, a senior at the University of Florida, calls the situation frustrating. "You feel frustrated because you feel now that was it all worth it," he said. "In a perfect world, I would have walked right off the stage and into a full time job in my field, but I mean I have the degree now and I am still waiting."

It would be interesting to know how many of those students voted for Obama. If so, it is a situation they helped bring on themselves. If they received business related degrees and they voted for Obama as a way of securing their futures, they should have their degrees revoked (as they obviously learned nothing).

It could be that there are other changes in the market that are causing this (although it is reasonable to suspect that market contraction is having an impact across the board). If there are too many software engineers and business/finance majors being churned out of universities, a glut of unemployed workers would develop overtime, even in a strong economy. Perhaps, just perhaps, software engineers and business and finance majors have gone the route of buggy-whip makers (the report would tend to support this line of thinking, as it details gluts of graduates from previous years).  The reporting doesn't allow us to conclude anything like that with certainty, but it is reasonable to speculate that there are too many of a particular type of major on the market, and (we can therefore assume) too little of something else.

You don't always get what you want, and the fact that someone wants a job in their chosen major doesn't mean there are opportunities in that field. Better major choices should be considered.

Summary: I detest reports like this one, as it gives too little information to come to any meaningful conclusion. I link to it to illustrate just how nonsensical these news reports can be, allowing anyone to spin it however they want. That's not science. That's propaganda.

Friday, May 15, 2009

IMHO: First Cut

Lydia Saad reports on a recent Gallup poll ( More Americans “Pro-Life” Than “Pro-Choice” for First Time , May 15, 2009):
PRINCETON, NJ -- A new Gallup Poll, conducted May 7-10, finds 51% of Americans calling themselves "pro-life" on the issue of abortion and 42% "pro-choice." This is the first time a majority of U.S. adults have identified themselves as pro-life since Gallup began asking this question in 1995.

The poll information is interesting, but it is missing a significant piece of the meaning of the majority data. The poll shows that a majority of people lean to the "pro life" side, but 51% are not "pro life" for all reasons/causes.

My suspicion is that recent headlines have caused the shift, with more awareness of the horrors of late-term abortions and some concerns about farming fetal stem cells.  Those who are “guardedly” pro-life appear to represent the largest group:
Additionally, a recent national survey by the Pew Research Center recorded an eight percentage-point decline since last August in those saying abortion should be legal in all or most cases, from 54% to 46%.

However, guardedly “pro life” is not “pro life.” The person believes that abortion should be legal in some cases, i.e., that "choice” is an option, in some set of circumstances. That would make them, by default, “pro choice.”

It is how we define “choice” that matters.  It is a fairly black and white issue:  

  • Choice:  There are a set of circumstances or types of abortion that should be legal.

  • Life:  Abortion should not be a choice in any situation or any type or abortion.


We don't have any data in this article to give any meat to what that really means to the polling group. We do not have data to determine what "most cases" means to people, or if there a problem with the survey questions to explain that gap.

If, for example, a person believes that "saving the life of the mother" or "rape and incest" are legitimate reasons for an abortion, they might have answered the questions differently from someone who would permit legal abortions to occur, except when the fetus shifts to being viable (able to exist on its own, outside the mother), regardless of the life of the mother, or rape or incest issues. In both those cases, the person could be classified as either "pro life" or "pro choice" depending on how they wanted to appear, but having no consistent basis in meaning.

Asking those specific questions, to qualify the definition of both of the extremes, as well as the middle ground, is necessary to draw any meaningful conclusions, with which to develop a blueprint to respond to the way the citizens want their legislature to respond to the issue.

Question 1:  Do you want doctors, nurses and the mother to be prosecuted for murder if an abortion is performed at any time, regardless of any other issues (life of the mother, rape, incest, etc.)?

Answer "Yes" = "Pro Life."

Answer "No" = "Pro Choice"

Anything other than a "Yes" to the above is in the realm of "choice."  The degree to which the person would slide more to a "Yes" answer, or the specific asterisks they'd place on it, are what matters in creating law.

You can't infer any meaning from polls unless you cross-check to validate that the definition of the terms that people are being asked to place themselves in (such as "pro life" or "pro choice") have fixed meaning among the polling group.

Specific Positions

[Click on thumbnail image above to enlarge and for source information.]

  • Legal under any circumstances:  54% to 53%, not statistically significant.

  • Legal under certain circumstances:  21% to 23%, not statistically significant.

  • Legal under no circumstances:  22% to 22%, no change, not statistically significant.


If only 22% (or 23%, depending on how you read the above chart) believe that abortion should be illegal in all circumstances, then, by default, 77% believe it should be legal in some circumstances, and are in a "choice" position.

All we've done is alter how we define the two camp's positions.  How it translates to legislative action has not changed at all.  The "legal" position is still in the majority.

Useless.

H/t Drudge.