Showing posts with label Taxes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Taxes. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 2, 2009

Neo-Federalists and Competition

Wendell Cox provides us with proof that New York's current government policies are driving people from the state (City Journal, Escape from New York, September 1, 2009):
Not only is New York losing talented people to the rest of the country, then; it is also losing enormous financial resources at a time when it can least afford to.

Mr. Cox also details where the people in New York are migrating to, which includes:
  • Florida
  • New Jersey
  • Pennsylvania
  • North Carolina
  • Georgia
  • Connecticut
  • Virginia
  • South Carolina
  • Maryland
  • Texas
It would be reasonable to conclude that some of the people who are leaving New York to go to Florida are doing so as part of their retirement strategy (Florida, humorously referred to as "God's Waiting Room"). Some of the outmigration is for retirement, but not all of it. This means that people are discovering that there are greater freedoms and prosperity in other states in the nation.

California has similar outmigration statistics (with more productive citizens leaving the state than going to it).

That's all fine. If people want to move to other states in the nation, they have every right to do so. When looking at the unemployment statistics, it is easy to understand why people are leaving some states (New York, California, Michigan, etc.) in greater numbers than those going to them.

That's what competition is all about. States, like Texas, have become "business friendly" to encourage more people to come to the state to work and to create new businesses. This, of course, irritates the Democratic-majority states, because it means that there will come a point where their onerous taxes and regulations cause a person to run to a state without those burdens. It also means that these states will be left with the whey and not curds of society.

States have the right (and some would include duty) to make their state attractive to their current residents and to future residents. They can do this in many ways, but the significant methods include low taxation, recognition of rights, and greater job opportunities in traditional employment and in starting new businesses. When a state puts in place onerous restrictions on starting a new business, or penalizes the self-employed/small business owner over the employed-by-others citizens, it is not surprising that entrepreneurs are going to respond to the carrots being offered in other states.

This is why the Left has been doing its darndest to level the playing field. Neo-Federalists attempt this by inventing Federal authority to regulate more and more areas at the Federal level.

The recent attempts to Federalize health insurance and health care is just one example. As more and more of the entitlement dollars are fed through the Federal coffers (rather than through State coffers as the Constitution clearly stipulates), the competition between the states for productive and entrepreneurial citizens is diminished.

The goal of Neo-Federalists is to make the states indistinguishable so that their ideas of entitlements and socialism are imposed on all states, making escape from these types of tax burdens moot. In other words, the Neo-Federalist goal is to homogenize America by intruding on the legislative authority of the individual states.

Some states have or have attempted to make laws to weigh outmigrants with the tax burdens of the state, long after they have left the state. New York, for example, wanted to make it a requirement that businesses who move out of the state have to continue to pay New York taxes for 10 years. The idea that a one state can impose taxation on a business or individual who establishes residency in another state is a kind of indentured servitude (and it is unconstitutional).

Unfortunately, the Federal government has done just that, by rejecting residency as the single condition of tax liability. For example, if a U.S. citizen leaves the country and establishes a business in another country, they are liable for U.S. taxes. They are liable for those taxes, regardless of country of residency. All other countries rely on residency rules for taxation, not citizenship. Further, if that citizen renounces their citizenship, taking citizenship of another country, they are still liable for U.S. taxes for a period of ten years. We are the only country to do that.

That type of tax liability discourages people from starting businesses in a particular state, or in the U.S. in general. We also have one of the highest corporate taxes in the world, discouraging foreigners (and citizens) from creating new businesses in the U.S.

We must compete with other states and with other countries for tax dollars based on incentives, not punitive measures, if we want to stop the John Galt effect and the exodus of productive and creative entrepreneurs from our nation. Each state has the right to legislate their tax code in any manner they choose. They also have the right to regulate commerce in their state, imposing onerous rule and requirements or to be "business friendly."

Today, U.S. citizens have the right to vote with their feet, as many in New York are doing in response to the onerous regulations and taxes in New York. We must do everything possible to keep it this way. Reversing the trend and schemes of Neo-Federalists would be even better, restoring the legislative and taxation authority to the states, but that will require a Republican-party super-majority in the Congress.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Friday, June 5, 2009

Great Analysis

From Curtis S. Dubay (Heritage Foundation, Income Tax Will Become More Progressive Under Obama Tax Plan, June 1, 2009).
A decreasing number of high-income taxpayers are increasingly paying the entire income tax bill. According to the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), the top 20 percent of all income earners paid 86.3 per cent of all income taxes in 2006. This was an all-time high and significantly higher than in 2000, before the 2001 and 2003 tax cuts went into effect.

The linked article (h/t Tax Professor and Instapundit) is very dry, but it does a great analysis of the tax stats and is worth bookmarking for the sources.  Mr. Dubay makes the case for a flat tax.

My personal preference is a national sales tax (with an Amendment to invalidate the 16th Amendment), as it would restore the spirit of the privacy protections of the 4th Amendment and require that no one declare their income to the government (which should be none of their business).

How we solve the progressive tax system is debatable.  The fact that it is broken today and eroding our econonic freedoms and growth is a certainty.


Amendment 16:
Passed by Congress July 2, 1909. Ratified February 3, 1913.

Note: Article I, section 9, of the Constitution was modified by amendment 16.

The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration.

Amendment 4:
The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

I'll Take That Bet

From Ryan J. Donmoyer (Bloomberg.com, Ballmer Says Tax Would Move Microsoft Jobs Offshore, June 3, 2009):
Microsoft Corp. Chief Executive Officer Steven Ballmer said the world’s largest software company would move some employees offshore if Congress enacts President Barack Obama’s plans to impose higher taxes on U.S. companies’ foreign profits.

“It makes U.S. jobs more expensive,” Ballmer said in an interview. “We’re better off taking lots of people and moving them out of the U.S. as opposed to keeping them inside the U.S.”

And pass it will, just like all the other bad legislation the Democrats have gotten through the Congress.

Something Ross Perot once said about NAFTA comes to mind...
“It’s just a question of how much will the Dow come down,” Ballmer said. “It’s not about companies anyway; we’re talking about shareholders.”

And those shareholders include all those people who make less than $250,000 a year who live on pensions and stock income... the ones that Obama said he wouldn't increase taxes... directly.

Did people really think that passing taxes on other people wouldn't eventually trickle to them?

It was a rhetorical question.  Of course people were that stupid (and selfish).
“It is a little bit ironic that most of our most significant trading partners and partners globally have taken the tack that they’ll reduce corporate tax rates to stimulate economic growth and not raise corporate tax rates,” Thompson said.

What's truly ironic is that in places near Seattle, those whose jobs will be going bye-bye supported Obama.  How's that working out so far?

Friday, May 29, 2009

New Normal

From Jeannine Aversa (AP Economics Writer, Economy's fall still bad - even if less steep, May 29, 2009):
The Commerce Department is set to release a report Friday that's expected to show the economy shrank at an annualized rate of 5.5 percent from January to March. If Wall Street analysts' forecasts are correct, it would mark a small improvement from the 6.1 percent annualized first-quarter drop the government initially estimated a month ago.

There are all sorts of old jokes that are similar to the above. They often start with "Do you want the good news or the bad news" and end with a wife or cat being killed in a fire.

The summation of the Commerce Department's report is that the economy contracted, again. It twisted the presentation to make it appear as a good thing: since it only contracted 5.5%, when it could have been 6.1%, we're supposed to infer that things are better.

The cat is still dead.

There are a number of factors that are going to prevent the economy from recovering, unless we tackle those issues. We need to tackle:

  • Entitlement spending (specifically Social Security). We will need to gradually eliminate it, beginning with means-testing.

  • Deficit spending (beyond entitlement spending).

  • Replacing private investment with government spending (across the board).


There is no political will to do any of the above, until it is too late, and excruciatingly painful.

The financial sites are full of predictions that suggest that we'll recover in the Fall, or next year, or things are already recovering, etc. What I don't expect to see is the truth: That there will be no recovery. This is the new normal. Our children and grandchildren will not have life as easy and prosperous as we did. Mostly, that is our fault (and the fault of our parents and grandparents).

Social Security is the biggest contributor because we allowed a Ponzi scheme to rake-in cash for decades and we allowed the government to maintain the ruse that there was some sort of trust fund, rather than the fact that the government spent all the money. That allowed previous generations to maintain the fiction that we had been more fiscally responsible in the past. The fiction that FICA is not a tax, just like any other tax, continues to this day.

Any report that says that "X % of Americans don't pay any tax" perpetuates that lie. If someone has FICA taxes deducted from their paycheck, they are paying taxes. That tax is put into the General Fund and is spent each year... and that has happened since the program's inception.

This has been a long time in coming. Previous Administrations are constantly blamed for deficit spending, but the real culprits of the deficits are never addressed. Even when Bush ran in his second term on fixing Social Security, the Congress wouldn't touch it. With AARP and similar organizations representing the largest special interest groups, politicians realize that reducing Social Security spending will end their careers.

Federal spending has clearly gotten out of control.  Social Security and Medicare has been a net gain to the budgets for decades, but in a few years, it will be a net drain, compounding an already serious problem.

The chart below shows Federal spending for Social Security and Medicare, and all other spending, in 2000 constant dollars:

[caption id="attachment_593" align="alignnone" width="468" caption="Spending 1976 to 2010 (in 2000 Constant $)"]Spending 1976 to 2010 (in 2000 Constant $)[/caption]

Thursday, May 21, 2009

Meme Check: Concern about Deficits

I'm sure I'm not the only one who has found the Democratic talking point meme of:
"Why are you concerned about deficits by Obama, when you didn't complain during Bush when he [insert a variety of the meme strains here]."

I find it most amusing in its audacity, as well as its frequency in the commentosphere.

It is not without irony.

The irony of the remark is that "where we were" wasn't in the voting booth supporting John McCain, which is why their guy got in in the first place!

Conservatives were so angry about the shift to the middle of the taxation road that many conservatives stayed home in 2008, ceding the election to Obama by default.  They also stayed home, rather than elect Republican-In-Name-Only/GOP Congressional candidates, which is also why the Democrats have a majority in Congress.

Now one could argue that it wasn't the best approach, given that Obama's deficits are exponentially greater than that of Bush's (in only the first few months of Obama's presidency) or anyone else in recorded history, but the reality is that the GOP candidate lost, partly because conservatives didn't think him fiscally (or otherwise) conservative enough. Conservatives were angry enough to stay home.

We were screaming all during the Bush years, and during the Clinton years, and the Bush years before that.  In fact, conservatives have been screaming about deficits for decades.  It's what we do.

We need a new law to handle this meme.  I don't mean a real law.  I mean something along the lines of Godwin's Law (where someone in a comment thread automatically loses the debate when they call their opponent Hitler).  

With online information sources such as Wikipedia, it is quite easy for a new term like this to gain traction and documentation.  

I propose that we call this new law "Klein's Law" after the infamous Ezra Klein, who manages the JournoList listserv where some of this type of spin originates.

Following on with the Godwin Law rule, anyone who suggests that conservatives were unconcerned or did not scream loudly about deficits in the past loses the debate.  (I'd suggest that we have them also receive 30 lashes for lying, but that's just me.)

Other naming suggestions are welcome.  I would name it after myself, but "Herself's Law" is just silly, and frankly, it would not be the type of notoriety I would welcome, even anonymously.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Slight Edit

In a post by Dan Riehl (Riehl World View, All The Taxes Money Can't Buy, May 20, 2009) focusing on the "no" votes to the California tax increases:
It is imperative that Republicans not become aligned with Obama's moves and forge prudent alternatives people will one day accept to roll back the ongoing destruction of America's economic engine by this administration. 

It's so close to perfect that I'm reluctant to mention it, but...
It is imperative that Republicans not become aligned with Obama.

Full stop.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

A Laffer Laugh

I lack the blogging credibility of Instapundit to link to something without comment and expect people to read it because I say so, especially if I am pointing to something Mr. Reynolds pointed out himself.

I would be lax, however, if I did not mention the article, as it is a brilliant smackdown on the "100 Economists" who have urged Obama to raise taxes on the rich (WSJ Online, Soak the Rich, Lose the Rich, May 18, 2009) by the esteemed Arthur Laffer and no-neophyte Stephen Moore:
Mr. Quinn and other tax-raising governors have been emboldened by recent studies by left-wing groups like the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities that suggest that "tax increases, particularly tax increases on higher-income families, may be the best available option." A recent letter to New York Gov. David Paterson signed by 100 economists advises the Empire State to "raise tax rates for high income families right away."

Here's the problem for states that want to pry more money out of the wallets of rich people. It never works because people, investment capital and businesses are mobile: They can leave tax-unfriendly states and move to tax-friendly states.

It would appear that the outcome of raising taxes is logical and a viable alternative to a group from the progressive "Center for Budget and Policy Priorities."  How incredibly daft of them to conclude that the wealthy, or anyone, will continue to be fleeced when there are better pickin's somewhere else.

Fleecing the rich has never worked, so how they conclude that it may be the "best option" leads to speculation on how they came to that conclusion.  The reasonable assumption is that they can't figure out any other option (such as lowering taxes on the rich or reducing deadbeat social spending).  They are ideologically blind to those options, as it is contrary to their addiction to the idea of redistributionism, and punishing the successful.

Mr. Laffer and Mr. Moore present a bounty of evidence to rebut the "studies" performed by the "Center for Budget and Policy Priorities." Studies are wonderful things, if you have to invent evidence where no evidence exists (such as studies to determine if a new drug therapy does what it is supposed to do).  If, however, there are decades of actual evidence to look to, it is not necessary to conduct additional research... unless you want to circumvent the established evidence for other than lofty objectives.   What, pray tell, could they have possibly studied to come to the opposite conclusion than the historical evidence proves to be correct?

It is also unworkable to suggest that people want to soak the rich and restribute their wealth to others, as a means of making things fair. What the people may want and what actually works are not always aligned.  If the people, whoever they may be, want a better life for themselves, then they have to morally and logically understand that you don't get there by making someone else the bearer of the burden, or ask them to make a contribution you are unable or unwilling to make yourself.

As Misters Laffer and Moore detail, the rich will simply take their toys and go to a new home, if they are not treated fairly and equitably. When they take their toys, they take the toys they share with others to play with, that affords the lifestyle to which others have grown accustomed.

If given a choice between a $20.00 ice cream cone, and the exact same one for $3.00, which one would you buy?  It's just common sense... no "studies" required.

Friday, May 15, 2009

Captain Obvious

I was hesitant to comment on Obama's latest ramblings, as it seems to defy commentary...

From Roger Runningen and Hans Nichol (Bloomberg Press, Obama Says U.S. Long-Term Debt Load ‘Unsustainable’ (Update2), May 14, 2009):
May 14 (Bloomberg) -- President Barack Obama, calling current deficit spending “unsustainable,” warned of skyrocketing interest rates for consumers if the U.S. continues to finance government by borrowing from other countries.

Obama was supposed to be able to hit the bricks running.  Either this is news to him (and he's a nincompoop) or he thinks this is news to the rest of us (and he thinks we're all nincompoops).  

Solution:  Stop spending and then we won't need to borrow any more money.  Something about "getting the horse out of the barn before the fire" or "carrots and carts" comes to mind.  If I could work "feathers" and "tar" into it, I would, but that would make me a terrorist (according to the Department of Homeland Security).

H/t Drudge.

Garbage Out Damn Spot

From Dick Brennan (MYFOXNY.com, Dead People Get Stimulus Checks, May 14, 2009):
This week, thousands of people are getting stimulus checks in the mail. The problem is that a lot of them are dead. A Long Island woman was shocked when she checked the mail and received a letter from the U.S. Treasury -- but it wasn't for her.

The above story (h/t Drudge) is all over the news.  The fact that the government sent out checks to dead people is a serious problem, but not the main problem.

The U.S government doesn't have accurate records of who we all are, nor should it.  Unless we initiate contact with the government (to get a passport, a social security number, file our taxes, etc.) the government needs to mind its own business.

I'm fully aware that this hands-off/butt-out idea makes it very difficult when the government wants to do things like send out checks or gather other information, but that's just too damned bad.  The Fourth Amendment hasn't been reversed.  The government has no authority to keep lists like these.  They are forbidden from doing so.

What is most concerning about these types of reports is that it lends an air of suspicion to other contact points.  Are these long dead people showing up on voting rolls?  Are there people getting Social Security or other entitlement checks in these people's names? Somehow these names got on a list, and we can only speculate on how that happened or the nefarious uses for those lists.

This is another reason why the government engaging in something like a blanket send of checks is such a bad idea (without first requiring that the citizens engage in a validation process to ensure that they are qualified to receive them).  Obviously, the dead people receiving these checks didn't file a tax return and haven't qualified for Social Security either (for a long time). Why were they on the list?

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

When a Cut is Not a Cut

From John D. McKinnon (The WSJ, Higher Tax Would Hit at $235,000 [unlinked as registration required], May 12, 2009):
Administration officials also defended a related plan to limit the value of deductions for people making $250,000 and up, as a way to help pay for the cost of overhauling the health-care system. The plan would cap the value of deductions at 28%. It has run into serious opposition on Capitol Hill. But a senior administration official said it could yet become a viable solution, if other ways to pay for health care can't be found. "Nobody rushes to do the hard things," the official said.

Nobody rushes?  Right.  Never let a castrastrophe go to waste.
Business leaders have been sharply critical of the administration's proposed crackdown on offshore tax avoidance, including limits on companies' ability to defer U.S. taxes on their overseas income, which was intended to put overseas operations of U.S. companies on the same footing as their foreign counterparts. The administration estimated it could raise a total of $210 billion in the decade from its crackdown.

"The proposed tax increases on U.S. companies by the Treasury threaten the jobs of tens of millions of U.S. workers and our future economic growth," said John Castellani, president of the Business Roundtable. "Adopting these changes will hamstring American competitiveness....We need to work together on comprehensive tax reform that will restore competitive balance for U.S. workers and companies."

That is one way to make the Europeans love us:  Cripple our ability to compete with them, raising our already highest-in-the-industrialized-world corporate tax rates even higher.  Who saw that coming?  [Well, besides everyone who wasn't a fool.]

If someone was intentionally setting out to destroy our economy and businesses and to put us into a depression-rate unemployment situation, you couldn't find better ways to do it.

Intentional?  It doesn't really matter.  The outcome is the same.

The End is Near

The End is Near

From Martin Crutsinger (AP, Annual report due for Social Security and Medicare, May 12, 2009):
Fewer people working means less being paid into the trust funds for Social Security and Medicare.

The obfuscation that Social Security collections go into a "trust fund" continues. The reality is that, since its inception, the collections for Social Security have gone into the General Fund. The "General Fund" is the set of monies the Federal government may use for anything and everything.

The bait-and-switch is that there is a notation of the amount that was collected for Social Security, but no money is actually transferred to a special account ("lockbox") for this purpose. It would be unlawful to do so. The Feds are required to spend that money each year and are prevented from setting it aside (where it could earn interest for future recipients).  This has always been to the Feds advantage, until very soon:
For years, the Social Security trust fund has taken in more than it spent on benefits, resulting in a cushion of billions of dollars that the government could spend on other programs while giving the trust fund an IOU.

The FICA deduction has always been a way for the Federal government to fill the coffers with a tax paid by anyone who collects a paycheck (half paid by the employee and half the employer), all the while claiming that a certain segment of taxpayers (the bottom feeders) didn't pay any taxes.

As the linked article goes on to explain:
The Congressional Budget Office recently projected that Social Security will collect just $3 billion more in 2010 than it will pay out in benefits.

This means that in 2011 (with just a $3 billion delta between collections and payouts in 2010) Social Security will begin to drain the Federal receipts swamp.  Add the "Galt Effect" with many choosing to opt out of the earning side of the equation sooner, and this could get ugly.

The flip of the pyramid (where the amount paid out to those collecting exceeds the amount collected) will also occur for Medicare earlier than expected.

Inverted Social Security Pyramid



Combined with the baby boomers entering their retirement years and the high unemployment rate, the Federal government will be bankrupt sooner rather than later.

Without the Social Security surpluses to feed upon, the Federal spending in Obama's budget will incur even greater borrowing and an even higher deficit than announced in February, re-announced yesterday, and recalculated upward (on a near-daily basis).

Without Social Security reform (means-testing recipients, raising the age of eligibility, lowering the amounts paid, or raising FICA taxes) the Feds will have to deal with an ever-shrinking pool of taxpayer money to play with. The problem with all the reform ideas is that it will make a lot of people very, very angry.  Social Security won't be quite the sacred cow it was, once it causes the swamp to drain, rather than providing a surplus with which to engage in other unconstitutional spending activities.

George Bush had Social Security reform on his second-term platform, but no one would touch it.

This should be fun!