Showing posts with label Society and Culture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Society and Culture. Show all posts

Saturday, September 19, 2009

Irving Kristol

From Myron Magnet (City Journal, The Godfather, R.I.P., September 18, 2009).
Irving Kristol, who died today at 89, was famously the godfather of neoconservatism, and he was the godfather of City Journal, too, having urged the Manhattan Institute’s then-president Bill Hammett 20 years ago to start a magazine.
R.I.P indeed. My condolences to his friends and family.

It would be a wonderful thing to face your last breaths knowing that you did everything you could to make the world a better place. In that sense only, Mr. Kristol's death was a wonderful thing.

His was a truly magnificent life and the world will be poorer for his passing.



Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Wednesday, September 9, 2009

Oh, Lady Lay, Get Over Yourself

For someone so smart, she sure gets it wrong. I will admit that I read Camille Paglia as the last sound voice among Democrats, hoping upon hope that someone who identifies with that Party will show themselves to be something other than a tool fool. At least she writes with an HL Mencken style panache. She is my only guilty pleasure and is the only Democrat to whom I give the time of day, but really it is to remind myself of how morally vacuous they truly are. Reading her is like believing that a cheating husband really means it this time when he says he'll straighten out.

Paglia disappoints again with her latest screed (Salon, Too late for Obama to turn it around?, September 9, 2009):
Democrats have managed to destroy the national coalition that elected Obama and that is unlikely to be repaired. If Obama fails to win reelection, let the blame be first laid at the door of Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, who at a pivotal point threw gasoline on the flames by comparing angry American citizens to Nazis.
The only national coalition that existed was a fantasy in the mind of Democrats. While they constantly state Obama's election in terms of "landslide," the reality is that the margin of victory was incredibly narrow and was due to the masses of religious-conservatives (formerly Yellow-Dogs) staying home out of protest that McCain, of McCain-Feingold, was their Party's standard-bearer. The conservatives stayed home to teach Republicans a lesson, but the only one getting the punishment good and hard is, well, all of us.

Paglia may have believed that magic coalition was going to put an end to politics as usual, as Obama said he would do, but only fools believed him. What politician hasn't promised that? It was a classic case of wink-wink, nudge-nudge, as everyone to the Left of McGovern ssh'd their actual plans, and said whatever was necessary to fool the masses into temporarily allowing the Democrats a flash of majority. But like a child who has been caught with the neighbor's stolen toy, it will be ripped from their crying hands and returned to the rightful owner.

It seems that Paglia believed it, and more sadly, still believes the 1960s hype that Democrats have ever been about liberty rather than libertinism, and insipid emotionalism of the Baby Boomers pouting-ascendancy to Peter Pan-like adulthood, regardless of Lucy and her Diamonds:
I always thought that the Democratic Party is the freedom party -- but I must be living in the nostalgic past. Remember Bob Dylan's 1964 song "Chimes of Freedom," made famous by the Byrds? And here's Richie Havens electrifying the audience at Woodstock with "Freedom! Freedom!" Even Linda Ronstadt, in the 1967 song "A Different Drum," with the Stone Ponys, provided a soaring motto for that decade: "All I'm saying is I'm not ready/ For any person, place or thing/ To try and pull the reins in on me."
It isn't a nostalgic past. It is a fantasy past. Bob Dylan and Linda Ronstadt were always pandering commies, of the Guthrie school of serial wife-abandonment and alcohol abuse. Paglia is stuck in the 1960s vision of a world without bad stuff and the dazzling marketing of it being about peace, rather than getting a piece. Somehow, she manages to forget that the peace her comrades delivered came with the death of millions in the Killing Fields, and mass executions in South Vietnam. But what's a few million brown people dying have to do with that cool dream of a world without war, eh?

You'd think that after all this time, with the bodies piled up for all to see, she'd have figured it out.
Why has the Democratic Party become so arrogantly detached from ordinary Americans? Though they claim to speak for the poor and dispossessed, Democrats have increasingly become the party of an upper-middle-class professional elite, top-heavy with journalists, academics and lawyers (one reason for the hypocritical absence of tort reform in the healthcare bills).
I can't tell if she actually believes that nonsense or if she's repeating it like a mantra in hopes of convincing herself of a past that never was, and a Party that never has been.

The Democrats since Truman have been about one thing, and one thing only: Power. They actually admire the world's thugocracies and authoritarian societies as models of what is possible, rather than something to avoid. She sees it in the current crop of Democratic powerful, but refuses to look into the crystal-ball of history to notice that it was ever thus:
Weirdly, given their worship of highly individualistic, secularized self-actualization, such professionals are as a whole amazingly credulous these days about big-government solutions to every social problem. They see no danger in expanding government authority and intrusive, wasteful bureaucracy. This is, I submit, a stunning turn away from the anti-authority and anti-establishment principles of authentic 1960s leftism.
Because, Camille, self-actualization as practiced by the Baby Boomers has never been anything other than elevating the self above every other self., i.e, I matter and I have power and that comes by taking yours, rather than recognizing that there is abudance enough for everyone, if they just work for it. That's always been what the Me-generation believed, and there's no evidence to suggest that the most spoiled and coddled generation will ever be about anything else except blatant selfishness and materialistic gain. The expanding government authority will be their authority, so it won't be the same authority of their parents, so it will be different, this time! They still don't get that self-actualized, applied to everyone, means that no one is special, and no one gets to elevate their lusts above everybody else's lusts. Self-actualization is about overcoming and controlling lusts, not elevating them as some sort of laudable achievement. I have a really difficult time accepting that she doesn't see this.

The 1960s Democrats don't care about the poor and starving masses yearning to be free and they never did. That was just an excuse for a party and a reason to get high. They just want to have moon-lit parties at the base of the statue as a great backdrop as a party theme. They care about getting laid, getting high, and getting and doing everything else they want, without one shred of recognition that those things have consequences. In fact, it is the consequences of bad decisions that they've been battling with their entire lives. If they wish it really, really hard, perhaps they can continue to escape the banal reality that living life without a net means you really don't have a net, and it will hurt like Hell when the high wears off. They still want someone else to bear the burden of the consequences and feel their pain. The goal has been to figure out a way to make the high permanent.
But dreaming in the 1960s and '70s had a spiritual dimension that is long gone in our crassly materialistic and status-driven time.
No, it didn't. It was always about crass materialistic selfishness, but Paglia didn't see that through the pot fog and the marketing by music companies who released the peacenik-millionaires' pathetic music...

And sadly, she still doesn't.


Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Tuesday, September 1, 2009

Power

From Heather B. Armstrong comes a post about the power of Twitter (Number 26, Containing a capital letter or two, August 28, 2009). I won't quote it, but ask that you read the whole thing.

The post is about a mother with a newborn who went through two months of Hell trying to get her brand new washing machine fixed. But that isn't really what the post is about. The details of her purchase and repair history is background for the result.

The result is that after an exhausting battle to get her new and expensive washing machine repaired, she resorted to complaining about the company on Twitter. That Twitter lashing worked.

For decades, most people were helpless. They had no recourse and no power to spread the word about bad customer service or a company failing to live up to its obligations. Social networking sites, like Twitter, have given the ordinary person the ability to get the attention they shouldn't need to get, just to get a company to do what they should do, without sounding an alarm that can be heard by nearly everyone in the world.

When Thomas Jefferson looked to the future of America, he hoped that a Free Press would enable citizens to call attention to failure, to Charlatans, and to a time when everyone had a voice. It took us over 200 years to develop the mechanisms whereby every citizen had the ability to publish truthful reports of their experiences, but it was worth the wait. Thomas Jefferson was focused on the people having the power to shed light government actions, but I think he'd be just as thrilled with these powers being used to further the experiment of an empowered people:
"No experiment can be more interesting than that we are now trying, and which we trust will end in establishing the fact, that man may be governed by reason and truth. Our first object should therefore be, to leave open to him all the avenues to truth. The most effectual hitherto found, is the freedom of the press. It is, therefore, the first shut up by those who fear the investigation of their actions."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1804

"The selfish spirit of commerce... knows no country, and feels no passion or principle but that of gain."

-Thomas Jefferson, 1809

Everyone now has a voice and access to a Free Press, and if that's what it takes to reform American industry, to make them accountable for what they do and what they sell, great.

It shouldn't require the Herculean efforts Mrs. Armstrong went through. Companies should have a moral code that prevents them from putting their customers through Hell. But they don't. But we'll make them restore that moral code and we'll use whatever lawful means necessary to do so.

It may seem like a trivial thing, making a stand about a faulty washing machine, but these things matter. They matter in big ways, because for too long companies could get away with this sort of thing... but they can't get away with it anymore.

We have the mechanisms to shed light on their failures. The Iranian government attempted to shut down communications through Twitter. The dissenters in Iran used Twitter and demonstrated that it is possible to use these tools as a communications organ to coordinate an organized, justified revolution against a tyrannical government. It is also possible to use these tools for evil. Using them to shed light on injustices, however grand or bland, is a power for the good, and we'll take the bad, because the power to do good is so much more valuable.

We have power unlike any we've ever had before.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).


H/t Instapundit.

Monday, August 31, 2009

Living Alone

I recently had a casual, personal, business dealing with a seemingly wonderful middle-aged woman. She lives alone. She didn't blurt out her living status, but the nature of our business transaction, and the conversation surrounding it, made it obvious. In lieu of a roommate or significant other, she had several pets.

The truth be told, I'd never really thought about this subject before (in this context). The idea that a middle-aged woman, who wasn't crazy and who was reasonably attractive and stable, should be living alone seemed tragic to me. Because I have children and a husband at home, the idea that I could be alone, totally alone (as this woman was), was something that began to fester in my mind.

So much of my socializing is focused on my family. There are constant, small interchanges: what's for dinner, is there coffee, the announcements of comings and goings, do we need milk or bread, and the usual assortment of good night/good morning greetings. Every night I share my bed with my husband and all the happiness and security that provides enables a kind of reset on the day's trials and tribulations.

The woman I met had none of that, although I'm certain she mimicks those family niceties and interchanges with her pets.

Man is a social animal and it has always been my belief that a madness of solitude can develop when people do not have an intimate social group (i.e., family). It keeps us humble, sane, and provides a minimum standard of happiness that everyone should enjoy. Research on couples has been interesting in this regard. Many of the studies I've read conclude that couples have the ability to keep each other on the straight and narrow.

Our culture has changed so radically in the last 50 years that I fear we're tinkering with disaster. When we look at programs (such as Social Security), the idea that people live alone and bear the entire burden of their housing and living costs, is something that is unsustainable. Living alone is not a state that will be able to continue once Social Security is modified, reduced, or means-tested. From that perspective, we need to be prepared for our social reeingineering to correct itself when these economic realities are forced on our culture.

Looking at it purely from an economic perspective, it is very wrong-headed, but looking at it in dollars and cents seems a bit callous. That said, living alone is an indulgence—a living arrangement that for economic reasons never existed before (in any great numbers).

There is no reason for that woman to be living alone, except that our culture has changed so dramatically that having a stable mate, or living with extended family, are no longer the norm. This is primarily a result of us having smaller families. At one time, this woman would have moved in with her sister, brother, or her parents if she found herself without a mate. She would have helped raise the children of her siblings or cousins. She might also have moved in with a long time friend (the stereotype of the two spinsters comes to mind), but the decision to live alone would not have been acceptable (because people from previous generations, although not as cool and progressively-minded as we are today, somehow knew that people were better off living among a stable family). That is not to suggest that women have never lived alone, only that it wasn't the norm.

Now it is difficult to explain why the various studies on couples show the data that they do (that couples are more mentally and emotionally stable than their single peers, as well as more financially stable and successful). Is the relationship itself casual to the outcome, or are the people casual to a successful relationship? It is possible that the reason couples remain couples is because of their generally good emotional health. It could be that the people who are prone to abuse their children, or prone to abuse themselves, find themselves as single parents (or single without children) because of those tendencies and issues. That said, it seems to be a reasonable conjecture that the everyday burdens of life are less of a burden with the cradle of stability of a relationship, even if the people themselves are more vulnerable to psychological instability, and it is that stability of the relationship itself that prevents those daily-life-burdens from diminishing our psychological health, when they are shared with another person. Couples tend to prop each other up.

I just can't get the woman's predicament out of my mind. What happened to our culture that enabled a sweet and nice lady to be so alone?

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Friday, August 28, 2009

Dark Humor/Play on Words

Yesterday my husband read a post about Ted Kennedy's death (I do not know where he saw it) that included the Latin phrase:

"De mortuis nil nisi bonum"

It literally translates to:

"Of the dead say nothing but good"

It is the source of the the English phrase, "Never speak ill of the dead."

But, applying the Latin literally to Ted Kennedy's death, the poster responded:

Ted Kennedy is dead?

-Good.

I was chuckling about it all day.
Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Monday, August 3, 2009

Not So Fast, Einstein

In an article by Yuri Kageyama (AP Business/Yahoo! News, Nissan rolls out electric car at new headquarters, August 2, 2009):
"This car represents a real breakthrough," Ghosn told reporters and guests at a showroom in the new headquarters.

He said the new car and new office building in Yokohama, southwest of Tokyo, marked two fresh starts for Nissan, which hopes to take the lead in zero-emission vehicles.

Has the world gone completely nuts?  The car may be zero-emissions, but producing the electricity needed for it to run produces all sorts of emissions, depending on how the electricity is produced.

We have emissions from creating energy (in a gas-powered car the emissions are created when the car is driven, in electric-powered cars the emissions are created when the energy is produced).  The fact that the energy needed for this car to run is emitted before it is used in the car, doesn't mean that the car has the net result of being "zero-emission."

This is propaganda at its finest. The debate will continue about how to produce electricity (and how to produce more electricity as the need for it rises, especially if we are producing and buying cars that need electricity to run). In general, however, distributive processing is a better idea. All the combustion engine cars on the road are producing the energy they need, and are not reliant on the strained power grid. Increasing the demand on the power grid will require considerable investment, as well as produce emissions in its overhaul, and the fuel source that runs it.

If an electrical plant runs on gasoline (or fossil fuels) or coal, and a car uses the power it produces to run, is the car really zero-emission?

Of course not!  It seems that the concept of "net effect" is lost on most people.

H/t Drudge.

Dangerous?

Glenn Reynolds linked to the article below (Kathianne Boniello, New York Post, Jobless Grad Sues College for 70G Tuition, August 2, 2009) with the succinct question: Dangerous Precedent?
The Monroe College grad wants the $70,000 she spent on tuition because she hasn't found gainful employment since earning her bachelor's degree in April, according to a suit filed in Bronx Supreme Court on July 24.

If I'm reading the article correctly (and the journalist got the facts correct), Trina Thompson is suing Monroe College because they did not provide employment assistance as advertised.

Two issues make this troublesome:

  1. Suing is generally a bad idea. We've become all too quick to go to the courts to settle our differences. It is not clear if Miss Thompson attempted to reconcile the problem on her own. Miss Thompson may be labeled "sue happy" and if she is, she's doomed her future success (justifiably).

  2. The article's title (and the comments) make it appear that Miss Thompson is suing because she didn't feel her education was up to snuff, but that doesn't appear to be the issue on which she is basing her lawsuit. Her issue seems to be that Monroe College made promises regarding employment assistance:


The information-technology student blames Monroe's Office of Career Advancement for not providing her with the leads and career advice it promised.

At the conclusion of the article we find the basis of Miss Thompson's claim:
The college's Office of Career Advancement advertises lifetime free service for graduates, and boasts on the school's Web site: "We have many resources available for students at any stage of their college career, and even after graduation."

This is an interesting situation. If a company enters into a contract to deliver services and those services are not delivered, then a person has a right to get their money back (or sue, if the company refuses to refund the money). What makes this different, but I don't think it should, is that it is a college. Miss Thompson received an education and was awarded a degree, but it doesn't appear that Miss Thompson attended college (specifically Monroe College) with that goal in mind. She seems to believe that the education and degree were superfluous. What she was after was a guarantee of job placement and believed that Monroe College made that commitment as part of her enrollment.

It will be up to the courts to decide if Monroe College made false claims or failed to deliver a service. Further, it will be determined if the claims of providing job placement services were part of the contract Monroe College committed to as part of their enrollment agreement with Miss Thompson.

This case doesn't appear to be about the quality of education Miss Thompson received, nor does it appear to be about how qualified Miss Thompson might be as a job applicant (or how well she interviews). What is interesting is that Monroe College granted Miss Thompson a degree and it would be reasonable to conclude that the degree meant something (especially given that Miss Thompson received a technical degree in Information Technology).

If students attend college in a major that is job-training specific (as opposed to more lofty pursuits) then it seems reasonable that the degree should mean something. If it doesn't, if having the degree is not transferable to getting a job (keeping the job is another matter and up to Miss Thompson), then what value does the degree have? If it means nothing, if it doesn't translate to job offers, then the degree isn't worth the paper on which it is printed, nor should Miss Thompson have to have paid for it.

That seems reasonable to me. Colleges (and universities) have chosen to become job training centers, as opposed to educational institutions, and engage in a type of collusion with employers to require degrees for employment. Schools could have remained bastions of knowledge of Western Civilization, providing students with an education, rather than job training. But they didn't choose that. They chose to be placement centers, with large fees for their services. They should be held accountable for what they claim and what they promise, as any other business would.

As to Prof. Reynolds question: I do not think it is a dangerous precedent. It think it is an about damned time precedent. Schools have been charging ridiculous fees for sub-standard educations (often for sub par students).  It's time they're put on notice.

Miss Thompson appears to have learned something of value (whether she learned it at Monroe College or not): that when you pay for something advertised, the company must deliver those services or refund your money.  I applaud Miss Thompson's actions. Perhaps this will put the fear of God in these mostly useless institutions, and be the basis of true educational reform in this country.

Thursday, July 23, 2009

Title Not Found

With regard to the Amazon/1984 stories: The ignorance of how databases work and what data-syncing is continues. This article and comments at Network World illustrate the ignorance.

Background: Kindle users were able to buy an ebook that was distributed without copyright authorization. As soon as Amazon was made aware of the problem, they removed the title (Orwell's 1984, to make the story interesting) from their catalog.

That's the back-story. What happened next should be a surprise only to people who don't understand how these things work, and I'm not referring to how ebooks are created or sold (or anything having to do with copyrights or license agreements).

A database is a collection of tables. Tables are a collection of records. Records are a collection of fields. Fields are made up of bits/characters.

(A record may be synonymous with a "transaction" but it isn't always.)

I'll start with a single table.

A database like Amazon's contains customers. Customers have certain characteristics, such as names, shipping and billing addresses, join dates, last purchase date, phone numbers, etc. Some of those characteristics will be stored in a "customer" table, some will be stored in subordinate tables, but they're only subordinate because we think of them that way. They're just tables. The relationships the tables have to each other (if any) is because of our understanding of how the data relates, not because computers/databases have any inherent understanding of these relationships.

The Amazon database also contains a "products" table. Those products make up their catalog. Products have characteristics of their own, such as supplier, unit of sale, weight, description, name, etc.

The "supplier" of an item will also be a record in a "supplier" table. That table will have the contact information for the supplier, their main contact address, as well as any other data elements Amazon might wish to maintain at that level.

Amazon will also have a price file (or a "price table") because all retailers do. They'll also have some sort of inventory tracking table (either maintained locally for the items they stock in their own warehouse or combined with a hook into the supplier's inventory system, if inventory is maintained by the supplier). In an operation like Amazon, inventory is all over the place, so a combination of methods is used.

Customer and supplier records are reasonably static. That doesn't mean that they don't ever change. They do change, because suppliers and new customers are always added, in addition to keeping them updated when suppliers and customers move. Transaction tables are constantly changing... that's why they're called "transactions."

When you log on to Amazon you sign in with your email address, but because email addresses can change, that isn't your customer number. (Some database designers are stupid enough to use an email address as a customer record number, but as I said, they're stupid.) It is a given that every customer has a customer record number and every supplier has a supplier record number. Each product in the Amazon catalog has a product number, too, which can be a single item, or a combination of items sold as part of a bundle. (Think of a computer that may be sold in a bundle that includes a laptop computer, a power cord, and instruction manuals--each having unique part numbers, but when combined create a unique product number.)

Let's say that my customer record number is C001. I'll keep it simple and we'll assume that I only have one billing and one shipping address (we know that Amazon customers can store dozens of each, but we'll ignore that).

I initiate an order for product P001.

A transaction table exists to create a relationship record of that order. That record says that customer C001 bought P001. Nothing in the transaction table knows what a P001 is, nor does the transaction table know that C001 is me. It is just linking the two together with other information to keep the transaction unique (such as assigning it a transaction number, the date the purchase was made, the date the transaction was created, etc.).

On the front end, Amazon displays a report of this transaction to me and sends it in the form of an order confirmation in email. That order confirmation will include the name of item I purchased because reports can be programmed to "look up" data from other tables and other databases. Since we have a product number (P001), we have the descriptive information for that item from the products table. Since we have a hook from products to suppliers, the report can also display details about the supplier, such as:

On 7/23/2009 you purchased Qty: 1, Item #: P001-Databases for Morons from "Technical Publishers."

If I purchased more than one item, it would list the additional items purchased.

The above might give the appearance that the transaction order contains the descriptive information, but it doesn't. It only contains record numbers and dates. A table that contains redundant data, such as a transaction table that contains anything but the record number of a product or customer is referred to as "denormalized." That redundancy is bad, not only because it uses more space in the database than it needs to, but because it can quickly create "out of balance" or "out of sync" situations (depending on the transaction type). When a customer changes their name, for example, their customer record is updated, and only that record. If the order table copied the customer name to the table when an order was created, it won't get notified/changed when the name change occurs (without redundant/unnecessary programming). So this stuff is kept simple, i.e., normalized.

On the backend, a bunch of things happen when a customer clicks "submit" on their order. Something equivalent to a packing slip or pull order is created for the items in Amazon's warehouse. For items not in Amazon's warehouse, the equivalent of a pull order is sent to the drop shipper/supplier. Once the item(s) are pulled from inventory, a transaction is created to reduce inventory for the quantity of items purchased. A shipper order number is created (with a vendor such as UPS or Fedex) once the package is boxed. Debits are processed against my credit card. At each stage of the order fulfillment process a status change is noted in the transaction record that triggers an update in an email sent to me:
1. Order acknowledgement
2. Order processing
3. Order filled/shipping order assigned

If there are any glitches, such as a delay in processing, a discovery that an out of stock conditions exists, etc., an exception will be generated.

When a system is first designed the developers try to trap as many exceptions as they can. When programming changes are required later, it usually has nothing to do with bugs in programming code, as those are caught and corrected early. It is generally because there are new exceptions (where human beings get involved in the process and make mistakes). It is also because there are new types of product offerings that didn't exist when the system was initially created.

Reprogramming is always more problematic than initial programming. This is because there are hundreds (sometimes thousands) of hooks into different tables, databases, and systems that need to be adjusted when changes are made in one place that have to be cascaded to other parts of the process. The programmer responsible for making the changes doesn't know what all those hooks are, and exceptions/mistakes occur when the system encounters a condition that wasn't adjusted.

One of the processes that retailers have to account for is removals from catalog. There are dozens of reasons why a retailer may wish to "de-list" a product. It could have been a limited run, special pricing, a supplier goes out of business, the supplier wasn't reliable, a new supplier had the item available at a better profit margin, etc. A one-size-fits-all method of handling this won't work, because there isn't a one-size-fits-all reason. That makes things even more complicated for a programmer, but that's why they make the big $$$.

If a supplier is determined to be unreliable, the supplier won't be used and that includes delisting all the products they sold. If an item is no longer made, the supplier is still used for other items, just not that item.

The point being that (regardless of why or how it is done) retailers are constantly changing their catalog offerings.

You can't delete records. Well, you can, technically, but you don't because that creates a "title not found" condition. If, for example, a supplier record is deleted from the supplier table, when I look through my order history at Amazon, the spot that was originally filled in with "Technical Publishers" will be blank (or filled in with the error message "title not found"). If a customer record is deleted, when Amazon attempts to reconcile their credits from the credit card companies, they won't be able to tie back to a specific customer. Because of this, records are not deleted. They're "closed." This can be as simple a step as changing a status flag from "O" ("Open") to "C" ("Closed").

If I asked Amazon to delete my account, they wouldn't actually delete it. They'd "close" it, because deleting it would create havoc throughout their system (as well as create havoc from an accounting standpoint, because all the history associated with my account would be lost, and that's a no-no from a bookkeeping/accounting standpoint).

Now some folks might get upset that their data isn't deleted, but that's just tough. Before computers came into the picture to track these things, companies kept ledgers of all this stuff. No one would have suggested that a company go through 15 years of ledgers and take scissors to their books of record. The fact that people don't make the logical leap from ledger to computer record is their stupid fault, not the fault of the retailer. Not only would a company not want to delete your record, in many cases (where book of record requirements exist) it could be unlawful to do so.

So Amazon got into the ebook business. Their systems were initially designed for the sale of tangible items. There was certainly a lot of reprogramming required to offer this new service. One of the main changes is that Amazon had to create a storage account, where all the items a customer has purchased can be stored. And this is where this (obviously) gets confusing for some people.

They didn't literally create a storage box for each customer, as we might buy a new physical hard-drive to store additional data. A literal storage device would mean that Amazon would store the same item over and over again, hundreds of times, in each customer's unique storage box. That would be redundant and unnecessary, and the physical storage requirements would be mind-boggling. What they created was a virtual (meaning, "not real") storage box, similar to an order transaction record. Amazon has one pointer to a copy of each electronic media they sell, each with a unique part number.  When customer A001 buys one, they create a transaction which is equivalent to an e-book storage table so it shows up in my storage box list. It is a virtual library of "my" stuff. The physical copy is stored in one location. The list of books in my storage box is an index (akin to a "link") to the file name and location of the item.

What I do not know for certain, but I would guess, is that Amazon doesn't have all the e-book files on their own servers. I would guess that they point to files on servers Amazon doesn't maintain themselves, as they have distributors who stock items for them (and I have some inside knowledge to validate my suspicion that they do this). What the record of each item would include would be the file name and the server location where it was stored. Whether the item was stored on Amazon's servers or on a supplier's server would be invisible to a customer, as customers are also unaware that their storage box is virtual, not literal.

A customer's Kindle is linked to their virtual storage box. When a customer buys a new item, a transaction is created that displays the item in the virtual storage box that, in turn, allows the item to be downloaded to the Kindle device. The customer can choose which items they want to have on their Kindle, up to the maximum storage of the device itself. This allows a customer to buy more items than the Kindle device can literally store, and can control which items are physically stored at any given time.

When a Kindle customer has their device radio on, the system will sync the list of items in their virtual storage with the list of items currently on the device. This is similar to doing a manual, physical inventory check every now and again.

To put this in perspective, let's say that you went to the library. You go to the card catalog. You find the book you want in the catalog and the Dewey Decimal system locator. You go to that section of the library but the book isn't there.

If you immediately assert that Ninjas broke into the library, knowing that you wanted to read that book, and took that book to a fire pit and burned it so you couldn't read it, might others think your conspiracy theory a bit daft (and you a bit scary), given that it could simply be that someone else had already checked the booked out of the library? The librarian could have put the book in the wrong place. The card for the book could have had the wrong identifier number typed on it. The library may have delisted the book, but forgot to take the card index out of the card file. Where human beings are involved mistakes will be made, most often, innocently. Yes, it could be that Ninjas did all that, but until we have evidence of that, Occam's Razor requires we go with the simplest and most common explanation first.

What happens when Amazon delists an e-book item because the supplier is found to have been in violation of copyright law, with respect to some or all of the titles they sell? Did Amazon Ninjas break into your house and purposely destroy an ebook or is some other, more reasonable explanation plausible?

Was the supplier record deleted or closed? Was the product number deleted, or closed, and what happens to the titles listed in the virtual storage on Amazon when that happens? Was the file deleted from Amazon's servers? Was the link to the supplier's server deleted from the e-book's record?

Regardless of the dozens of innocent technical glitches that could have caused this, the title was no longer available on Amazon's catalog; therefore, the item was no longer available in the Kindle virtual storage box. When a customer synced their device to their virtual storage, the item was no longer there. Amazon didn't, despite the protests of idiots everywhere, send Ninjas out to reach into each customer's Kindle and run some sort of delete/destroy routine. The item itself, or the link to the item or the item's server no longer existed, so it was no longer in the index of the Kindle device.

Amazon will have to reprogram their system so this doesn't happen again. They said that, and apologized for the glitch. They refunded the money for the items purchased.

Folks who think that Amazon virtually broke into their Kindle to delete files have no clue how databases work, what virtual storage boxes are, or what syncing means.

Amazon discovered what happens when you de-list an item, in a way that worked for tangible items, in a process that had not been programmed to handle it, and they're fixing it. Maybe Oswald did it, but until we have evidence of that, let's assume a programming glitch because those happen thousands and thousands of times every day: no conspiracy or grand-theft illusions required.

Please, if you do not understand the above, shut up. You're embarrassing yourself.

Monday, July 20, 2009

License

The blogosphere is full of commentary on the Amazon deletion of books on the Kindle. I do not remember where I saw it, but someone had some excellent advice: Download all purchases to your computer, copy them to the Kindle via USB (managing the storage yourself), and leave the radio on the Kindle turned off.  That prevents syncing and all downloads stored on a computer are protected (and can be backed up).

That seems like a low tech, simple solution to a not-so-complex situation.

I really don't understand why there's been so much brouhaha over the deletion. The word "sync" is clearly misunderstood by many people.

There is also much confusion over the difference between buying a license to use versus the purchase of a tangible item.  Most of the grumbling about this seems to come from people who don't see any reason to own a book reading device, preferring the tactile experience of printed book. These are people who must not travel much (especially overseas), where it is difficult to carry a dozen or more books to enjoy on vacation. These non-travelers and technical-phobic are not the target market for a Kindle (or related device) so their commentary is superfluous.

Sunday, July 5, 2009

Regarding the "King of Pop"

I don't care.  Whatever the report, I couldn't care less.

Friday, July 3, 2009

Ignorance is not a virtue, nor a get out of jail free card

While I agree that the Lori Drew case has troubling and difficult aspects, the article by Kim Zetter (Wired.com, Judge Acquits Lori Drew in Cyberbullying Case, Overrules Jury, July 2, 2009) contained an even more troubling issue than the charge of "cyber-bullying":
Wu also doubted that MySpace provided sufficient notice to members to hold them responsible. If a user didn’t read the terms of service, the judge asked prosecutor Krause, could they still be charged with violating them?

Krause struggled to respond to Wu’s questions, emphasizing that not every terms-of-service violation would be prosecuted as a crime. In Drew’s case, he said, there was sufficient evidence to suggest that she knew what she was doing was wrong.

But Wu disputed this, pointing out that the government’s star witness — Ashley Grills — had testified that she never read the terms of service before clicking on a button agreeing to them.

(Emphasis mine.)

Since when is ignorance of the rules or law a get out of jail free card?  It isn't (and shouldn't be) in any aspect of law.  While some are lauding the case because of the concerns that "Terms of Service" should not constitute a crime if violated, dimissing that one is compelled (at least as a civil matter) to comply with contracts signed, even if unread, is a long established principle.

Ashley Grills admitted that she clicked the button, which is the virtual equivalent of signing a contract.  It is Ashley Grills's bad luck if she chose not to read the contract she was executing.

It is absurd that MySpace should have to provide any additional "sufficient notice to members to hold them responsible" besides an "I agree" button below the contract (or a link to it). These are the types of nanny-style protections of the stupid and immoral that those of us on the conservative side of the aisle loathe so much. They coddle people and attempt to excuse them of responsibility for their actions and never attempt to deny liberties to those who demonstrate they can't handle them responsibly.

There is a huge difference between being unable to understand a law (or the language in a contract) and that violations of it are wrong (the legal definition of insanity or mental deficiency) and ignorance of the law, especially when the executor refuses to read the rules when it is passed under their nose.

The only defense for Ashley Grill is that she is mentally deficient or insane. In either case, she should be denied access to computers (and perhaps her freedom) if she is so mentally daft that she cannot understand that she is agreeing to a Terms of Service, read or not.

Regarding the morally vacuous parent, Lori Drew, who participated in this ghastly deceit, I can only blame the prosecutors for their failure to recognize a fraud case when they see one. Falsity with malicious intent is a crime, and always has been.  The criminality of the action is not limited to money. The defendant in this case admitted that they were intent on getting private and personal information from Megan Meier, and that is just as much a theft as any other type.

Thursday, July 2, 2009

Not Following the Money

Liam Julian reviews (City Journal, The Private Schools No One Sees, June 19, 2009) The Beautiful Tree: A Personal Journey Into How the World’s Poorest People Are Educating Themselves, by James Tooley.  Mr. Julian provides a summary of Mr. Tooley's incredible findings:
“Development experts,” as Tooley calls them, have long believed that if citizens of developing countries are to be educated, their governments, helped by heaps of money from rich nations, must invest in free and universal public schooling. If the resultant public education is lousy—as it is in India, for instance—then it must simply be reformed through more money and more regulation. Meanwhile, the poor must be patient.

But the poor have run short of patience, Tooley found, and so they have rejected the development experts’ failed syllogism and created one of their own: You open a school, and we’ll pay you to teach our children. If they don’t learn, we’ll stop paying. Therefore, you will ensure that our children receive a solid education.

Americans have done something similar by homeschooling, but Americans have difficulty opening underground schools like these because of the culture of regulation that would shut them down. Like American home-schools, however, these underground schools post results far above their public establishments.  They also share something else in common with home-schools:  they have critics who will say and do anything to try to discount them.
The Beautiful Tree is a refreshing aberration in the stolid ranks of development literature. Tooley writes engagingly and obviously finds the story he tells exciting. His enthusiasm is contagious. One cannot help but think that Tooley has provided the rudimentary outline of how education can be brought to many more millions of the world’s poorest.

Government schools were Jefferson's greatest failure, not because he didn't get it right, but because educating the youth (rather,  indoctrinating them) is too enticing for tyrants to ignore, and all the safeguards that Jefferson established were bulldozed.
"We are now trusting to those who are against us in position and principle, to fashion to their own form the minds and affections of our youth... This canker is eating on the vitals of our existence, and if not arrested at once, will be beyond remedy."

- Thomas Jefferson to James Breckinridge, 1821



The Beautiful Tree is definitely on my wish list.

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Letterman's Not Funny Joke

Regarding Letterman's terribly inappropriate joke about Sarah Palin's 14 year old daughter:  He should be ashamed of himself.

This has nothing to do with political correctness.  Candidates' children are off limits and "knocked up" jokes about kids aren't funny.

That aside, what really gets my goat about some of the commentary on the Internet is the constant insertion of the meme of Letterman's supports: "Don't you value Free Speech?"

Of course Republicans value Free Speech.  People can say whatever they want, except false speech.

What they cannot expect to exclude, which goes hand in hand with exercising rights, are public consequences. The government cannot put him in jail for telling a bad joke or insulting someone, but the public is certainly within their right to respond with Free Speech and Free Action of their own, to call for Letterman's head on a proverbial platter.

If that means he's stripped of his job because people boycott Letterman's advertisers, or they tune-out of his show, putting his rankings in the tank, that, too is Free Speech.  The public is free to respond with their remote control, to write and complain to the network, and to boycott CBS's advertisers.

Freedom of expression cuts both ways.

Thursday, June 11, 2009

Where They Go We Follow

From Steve Doughty (Daily Mail/Mail Online, The seven evils that scar British society: Report blames greed and moral collapse, June 11, 2009):
Britain is beset by seven social evils that undermine all the good brought by prosperity, one of the countrys leading research groups said yesterday.

Greed, collapsing moral values and the decline of old-fashioned virtues such as honesty and tolerance were named as blights on the lives of millions.

The article is a very good read, but it leaves out the fundamental problem with British society, and the "sin" that has gradually come to our nation, brought like the Black Death was once spread by stowaway rats, this time carried by human cargo: immigrants, academia and broadcast by world media. That pervasive, dominate and the deadliest of sins in Britain is envy.

Envy is what defeats Britain at every turn. It pervades their media and their attitudes so casually and so completely that the majority of folks no longer recognize it, or would even consider it an evil trait. They don't even know they're doing it.

Someone will say "no one needs that much/many [fill in blank]" when the British rags present pictures and stories about some celebrity living in a big house, or buying another car. It is an absolute certainty that the comments of such articles will be full of nonsense like that. No one is immune from it. There is no recognition, not even an inkling of it, that no one has to justify or feel any shame for what they have, or buy anything based on need. If you can afford it and want it, go for it. It is no one's business.

Yes, there can be a downside to living one's life in a constant buying frenzy. We can recognize and identify the difference between spoiling oneself with stuff we like and love, and someone who is in a death spiral of self-loathing, which causes them to acquire stuff to fill a void that can never be filled. Those, however, are exceptions. It doesn't apply to the latest starlet's million pound movie deal, the hot football player who just signed a ten million pound contract, or the entrepreneurs who risked it all to make fortunes such as Richard Branson.

It extends to other issues, beyond wealth, including those who stand up against evil in other forms. No one is allowed to be self-sufficient or stand the tide of evil in any form. It is why the poor fellow, Tony Martin, who shot burglars who had repeatedly terrorized his home, was ravaged and punished by a crowd not unlike those who stood before Potius Pilate. How dare he strike back?! Commoners are not allowed to do that! That is the government's job! Lop off his head!

They're a nation of Madame LaFarges, sitting in front of their TV sets or computers, enjoying the spectacle.

The loathing is palpable and it drips casually from their tongues and pervades their behavior like a sickening, festering wound. It is pure evil and it is so common, so commonplace and accepted, that is it difficult to know where to begin to purge the evil from the little Isles.

As is well understood by Alcoholics Anonymous and any other recovery program, the first step in recovery is acceptance, of owning up to the fact that you have a problem. The British, however, are in such a deep void of denial of their acceptance of envy, it is difficult to think they will ever recover from it.

The Britons have a long history of a class system: of have-nots and haves. Envy and anger are easy to sympathize with when a nation is ruled by a monarchy, and there is no possibility that the have-nots could ever rise above their station.

But it ended more than a century ago and it continues not by the royals' actions, but by the people themselves.

It is now possible for anyone in Britain to do what Richard Branson has done, or at least rise above the station of their parents and grandparents. They achieve it by education, fortitude, hard work, and taking the dare to risk it all for something better. More importantly, however, they achieve it by believing, knowing, and accepting that they can.

They simply don't.
Others feel that people's 'moral compass' has failed them, and that too many people claim rights but assume no responsibilities.

They're caught in envy's tendrils, wanting the wealth of others handed to them, delivered like Salome's gift of the head of St. John the Baptist. They want it in the same way the royals had it handed to them in previous generations, and are perfectly willing to have it stolen from those who have it now, and dolled out to others by a government complicit to act as Robin Hood. There is simply no recognition that the Queen or any other Lord or Baron owns outright what they have, that their wealth is not in the public domain. Britons, simply, have no respect or recognition of the concept of private property. They're still caught in the past, carrying on the anger and resentment of their parents and grandparents. They must let it go to be able to get on with it.

They don't want a society of prosperous people based on a societal foundation of encouragement to work for it. They want revenge. They want the heads of the wealthy on platters, and they demonstrate their desires for that by the fact that they have no hesitation to boo and hiss at those who have wealth, however they've acquired it. They'll use the tax collector as their henchman, without a trace of shame.

The first step in achieving a culture of prosperity and happiness is being pleased and excited about the prosperity and happiness of others. There's enough to go around, and the wealth bathtub can never be too full or run out of water to allow everyone to be prosperous, if they are willing to do the heavy lifting to get there.

There are just too few Britons who are not infected by envy to make a difference in the outcome.

"Attaboy!" and "Cool!" must be the reaction to the success of others. "I want to do that, too" is the healthy/moral reaction to seeing success.

That attitude has never existed in Britain and it only gets worse as time goes on. It is an attitude that once existed in America, but it is, sadly, no longer the norm here either. There were a few who "went off to seek their fortunes" and returned with it. It pervades English literature, but few read it or allow it to be tought anymore.

When Obama says "fairness" it is a guise for wealth redistribution schemes where he is playing into the envious streak of too many Americans, and it is dangerous, and it is an evil that must be purged if we are to continue to exist as free people.

Where Britain goes, we follow, unless we recognize it and put an end to it.

Monday, June 8, 2009

George Foreman Defeats Williams and Sonoma

On a lighter note, I have a confession:  I absolutely love kitchen tools/gadgets and treat the arrival of the latest Williams and Sonoma catalog like a 3 year old on Christmas morning.

I also love Sur la Table.

The other part of the confession is that I don't always buy my kitchen gadgets from those stores, as they are pricey, but I use/abuse their suggestions to find a cheaper solution.  I can spend hours at those stores, fondling the merchandise.

The latest Williams and Sonoma catalog included a bunch of new items (that I don't have... yet).  It was the first time a catalog required that I admit to my husband that "I would buy EVERYTHING in it."  Well, not everything, of course, but all of the new items were truly exciting.  The fajita plates (with a dozen uses) and the wire mesh pans for grilling were things I now covet (but will be unable to purchase for decades).

The catalog also included a panini press with a nosebleed price of $99.95. W&S has had panini presses for a long tme, but I think their prices on them are ridiculous.  Cheaper solutions may not be as sexy or chic as the W&S ones, but their prices put them out of reach for most people.

If you own a George Foreman grill (and who doesn't?) it IS a panini press, and there is no reason to buy another one, especially one that is priced so high.  The large Foreman grill is available (on Amazon) for $39.95. Although the larger size makes it difficult to store, it adds versatility and convenience, making it possible to make multiple sandwiches at once.  If you're a single or a double family, then you can get a smaller one (for $19.95 on Amazon).

Just thought I'd mention it, in case it isn't obvious.  The George Foreman grill is a marvelous product, with uses beyond those it generally advertises.

I Can Relate

There have been a flurry of posts and discussions on the outing of a previously anonymous blogger. I think the best summary I've seen is by Rand Simberg (Transterrestrial Musings, On Pseudonymity, June 7, 2009 [H/t Instapundit]):
I would also say that I agree that there is an important distinction between pseudonymous and anonymous blogging. The former establishes an identity and a reputation that must be both established, and upheld. After a while, people will respect, or not, posts or comments from such a person, regardless of whether or not they know the real name/profession/location, etc. An anonymous commenter/blogger, on the other hand, has the potential to be a drive-by arsonist, and many are. In the space Internet world, Tommy Lee Elifritz is perhaps the best example of this, who changes his nom de plume more often than he probably changes his underwear, at places like Space Politics, NASA Watch and Rockets’n'Such. Of course, in his case, the vile style is quite distinctive.

I like Mr. Simberg's distinction between pseudonymous and anonymous blogging. I hope that I am the former and am not tarnished by the "drive-by arsonists" who frequent the blogosphere anonymously.

When I started this blog I knew that using a pseudonym would make it difficult to develop trust with readers, and I also knew that starting a new blog was the last thing the world needed, and I would (mostly) be one of a million voices shouting into the wind. To compensate, I make every attempt to source (to the point of irritation) and to provide context and historical references.

I used to be of the opinion that pseudonymous bloggers were cowards, until I became one, of course. It was a choice of being a pseudonymous-blogger or not blogging. The personal risks were just too great to blog openly, and the topics and subjects I could write about would be limited if I used my real name, based on non-disclosure contracts and not wishing employer and friends/associates to feel or be at-risk by what I say here. I would never, as Mr. Simberg describes, use my pseudonymous status to go on the attack. In general, I believe that attacking a person is the height of moral increptitude.  Attack the argument/idea, not the person is a personal rule that I hope to always live up to.  I would never "out" my employer by name either, as that would defeat my purpose, as well as give clues as to my real identity.

In a world where personal attack and rampant libel dominates a medium, I came to accept that pseudonymous was the only way to go. I wish it could be otherwise, but it isn't. Sans a windfall by a rich Uncle or a titled-Royal who decides I'm their one and only heir (that I do not know about) or a lottery win that would enable me to disengage from the working world, pseudonymous is how it has to be.

Friday, June 5, 2009

Greatest Film Ever Made

It may not be to everyone's taste, but I highly recommend The Curious Case of Benjamin Button.

The film is a gem and uses technology of the film crafts in a way it should be used.  We've come to expect the continuous cadre of science fiction, with its bleeps, booms, and unreal aliens using CGI and other bleeding edge technologies, where the technology is the excuse for making the film. In Button, the technology is used in an entirely new way:  to tell a story of life and death, love and respect of all life, and of the distortions of the bookends of life.  It makes you think about truth, which is art's loftiest goal.  In Button, they achieved it.

Unlike other uses of these new techno-arts, they're not the story or the motivation.  They enable this story, which is how technology should be used.

When it was over I realized how other composers felt when they heard Beethoven, and realized they could never compose anything of that level of mastery (some committed suicide because the realization was so great and so moving).

Suicide isn't necessary in this case, but there was an incredible sense that the bar of "art film" had been raised, not only by how effectively technology was used, but because of the performances of the actors, the director, the cinematographer, editor, and most especially the adaption of the F. Scott Fitzgeralds's short story (on which the film was based).

Only in The Last Tycoon has Hollywood come close to getting what F. Scott Fitzgerald was all about (but the critics panned the film, because they didn't get it either).

Hollywood generally treats Fitzgerald's characters as glorious and glamorous, completely missing the mark.  They've been treated as if they were special, but it is the fact that they weren't special that was the point. Fitzgerland was of the Southern school, made up of other writers such as Capote, Twain, Flannery O'Connor, and Tennessee Williams.  These writers and the Southern literary tradition treats eccentricity as a curiosity, not a blight nor stigma.  It doesn't do it to shock or entertain.  These authors just present these people as they are. It neither glorifies nor criticizes eccentricity, in all its forms. It casually accepts it and delights in it, and draws real people who make life interesting and worth living.  There is an acceptance of the usual person as normal (only the English have a similar treatment of those who live life accepting the peculiar as normal).

I had the sense that Fitzgerland would have approved, and been comforted by the fact that someone, most likely the "screen story author" (Eric Ross) got him... finally.

The film treated the dark subject lightly, as well as painting characters in a close to fourth dimensional way.  There were no Spielberg-like attempts to propagandize the subject matter, nor toy and tug at your emotions.  It presented the characters gently, and the actors delivered their performances with incredible restraint and mastery.  It was art and mastery of all the crafts that create film, in the tradition of Fellini, Ashby, and Truffaut.  We get to discover the story and the poignancy of the characters drawn (if there is any), by ourselves.

As I said, it will not be to everyone's taste, but it is a jewel. I have said to some that it is the greatest film I have ever seen and the makers have given something great to the world.  If those involved with its creation died today, they could die in peace, knowing that greatness was achieved in their lifetimes. I could go out of this world today in peace, knowing that I lived to see that kind of bar-raising in my own lifetime.

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

Heavy Hearts

Via Drudge, the speculation of a bomb threat brings heavier hearts to the Air France disaster.

From Momento 24 (cached from Google, Bomb threat on Air France flight, May 27, 2009):
The airport safety delayed an Air France flight this evening before departring [sic] for Paris immediately after the company received a bomb threat over the phone at the airport of Ezeiza.

Knowing the cause of the crash won't lesson the pain of the families who lost their loved ones, but investigations of problems with airplanes helps save others. Bombs, however, especially when there were might have been warnings will cause the families even greater angst while they're coping with their loss.

I'm certain there are bomb threats all the time. How many is irrelevant. Let's hope it wasn't a bomb and that we are able to find a reason that can be solved to prevent future disasters like this.

Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Rights Versus Privileges

The California Supreme Court issued its ruling on the same-sex marriage issue. They decided that the citizens (who voted twice on the issue) get to decide. We should all be celebrating this decision. It would be nice if same-sex marriage advocates accepted the defeat gracefully, and avoided the expense of putting the matter to a vote repeatedly, but that is not likely.

One (of the many) issues clouding the debate on this issue is the subject of rights versus privileges.

Rights: Rights, which may be reasonably restricted (such as the prohibition against shouting "fire" not limiting your protected right to express opinions, as the First Amendment intended) may not be universally denied. Government shall/should/must.

Privileges: Actions and benefits which may be granted, based on a set of requirements or restrictions. Government may/could/might.

Driving is the easiest example of a privilege, not a right. In order to get a drivers' license, which is required to operate a motor vehicle on the public streets, a person must pass a written test, a driving competency test, and other restrictions which include age, safe driving record, sightedness, etc.

An individual (in most states) is not denied the ability to operate a motor vehicle on their private property or on the property of someone else who allows it, i.e., a child can drive his father's truck on the father's farm without a license. If the child drives the vehicle onto the public street, the child can be issued a citation (and the parent may be prosecuted for failing to properly supervise the child).

Similarly, an individual who, for whatever set of reasons, does not want to drive or cannot pass the requirements for a driver's license, may get an ID card. That is not uniform or available in all the states, but it is true for some, including California.

Civil marriage is not a right. It is a privilege. That's why it requires a license. The fact that it requires a license is the huge, flashing clue that it is not a right. Rights, by definition, cannot require a license. It is the ability to get the license, to change the requirements of couples wishing to get a marriage license, that the same-sex marriage advocates are fighting for. The citizens of California get to decide this matter, as it is (primarily) a monetary issue.

California law is entirely consistent (now) on this issue, as it is with other privileges that are handled by the issuance of a license.

No two people of the same sex can get a marriage license, regardless of their sexual orientation: gays, lesbians, and straights cannot get a license to marry someone of the same sex. In that sense, there is no discrimination on this issue.

Two (or more) people of the same sex can live together, just as individuals can drive on their own property without a license. They can commit to each other in a private ceremony (of religious or secular nature). They can initiate vows, contracts, and any other private arrangement to solidify and sanctify their relationship in the private sphere (among their family and friends, and all else who wish to validate and recognize their relationship).

Just as with driving, their inability to obtain a civil marriage license means they cannot take their relationship into the "public street," with official recognition of their status as "married," and thusly, afforded all the privileges and protection of a civil marriage.

In California, same-sex couples can get the equivalent of an ID card (in lieu of a drivers' license) for like reasons, which recognizes their relationship, but is distinct from marriage. The couple (or any multiple of parties) may create contracts such as a Durable Power of Attorney, Wills, or property ownership contracts. They can buy property together, and specify who owns what or what portion if the contract is cancelled/revoked by any of the parties.

The distinction (and separate definitions) of rights versus privileges seems to be lost on some people (commenter "Stealth," The Volokh Conspiracy, California Prop. 8 Upheld, But Held Not To Affect Existing Same-Sex Marriages, May 26, 2009):
The court essentially ruled that a simple majority of the state electorate can prohibit a minority from exercising a fundamental right, and that's not something to get outraged about?

The "simple majority" is how California decided to handle matters such as this. The "simple majority" did not deny anyone a "fundamental right" because marriage is a privilege, not a right. Regardless, same-sex marriage was not denied to a minority. Same-sex marriage was denied by the voters of California (twice) to all citizens of California, regardless of age, religion, race, creed, gender, or sexual orientation.

The majority of Californians could have decided differently. They could have voted to allow same-sex marriage to all its citizens (regardless of age, religion, race, creed, gender, or sexual orientation), but they didn't. Californians have not denied couples (or multiples) of the same sex the abiltity cohabitate, declare their love, devotion or admiration for each other, nor denied them any function or access such as establishing contracts, bonds, or making vows or commitments.

It's just the financial benefits and the official status of "marriage" that has been denied to all same-sex couples.

If you support the right of the citizenry to establish laws and constitutions, then you should be pleased that it worked in California; the courts did not attempt to legislate away the rights of the people of California to decide these matters through the ballot box and the majority prevailing. You don't have to agree with how the majority decided, only to recognize the right of majorities to decide these matters.
"If we are faithful to our country, if we acquiesce, with good will, in the decisions of the majority, and the nation moves in mass in the same direction, although it may not be that which every individual thinks best, we have nothing to fear from any quarter."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1808


Jack Sprat

From Phoenix Business Journal (Producer price index rises 0.3 percent, May 14, 2009):
The Producer Price Index climbed 0.3 percent after declining 1.2 percent in March. Food prices rose 1.5 percent in April, the biggest increase since January 2008.

Something is missing/not right. I realize that the plural of anecdote is not data, but food prices seem to be much higher than that. Meat and poultry prices (except pork) have been rising since last Fall.

Consumers are responding to the economic situation in their food purchases by:

  • Consuming less (either by producing smaller meals or extending meals)

  • Spending less (either by choosing cheaper brands or being more attuned to sale priced items)


The typical response to economic hard times is to hoard ("pantry load"), but people generally hoard shelf-stable products and comfort foods (usually higher in starch and sugar). Eventually, however, the pantry needs to be replenished, but replenished with what?

There were reports that consumers are responding to lower prices at the fast food venues, and those businesses have lowered their prices (and in some cases, their product sizes). Fast food venues have seen an increase in their bottom lines, by volume. The slight 1.5% increase has to be showing up in a much greater percentage in particular grocery categories.

From Bill Lapp (NY Times, The Drivers of Inflation, May 16, 2009):
The Bureau of Labor Statistics has reported that the producer price index rose by a modest 0.3 percent from last month, and is 3.7 percent below a year ago. However, while overall inflation at the wholesale levels remains subdued, the wholesale cost of food products continues to rise.

The P.P.I. for finished food rose by 1.0 percent during April compared with the previous month. The jump in prices was led by a 21 percent gain in egg prices. The surge in egg prices likely will reverse itself in the coming months.

Even in the middle of recession, the corn factor raises prices on everything from beef to processed food.

However the underlying strength in the wholesale price of other food products is unlikely to abate. Just as we experienced during 2007 and early 2008, increases in the price of underlying commodities (such as corn, wheat and vegetable oil) are driving wholesale costs higher.

Ultimately if this upward pressure on wholesale costs continues (as I anticipate), the higher prices will be passed on to consumers, resulting in an acceleration of consumer food inflation.

Grain costs, especially with so much of the corn crop going into the energy sector rather than the wholesale food sector, is running up meat production costs (and eventually those increases are passed on to consumers, but there is a delay in that increase).

That doesn't explain the increases in lamb prices (generally grass-fed coming from New Zealand). Retail lamb prices have tripled in the last year (as a lamb eating family this has taken quite a bite in our food budget, as well as forcing us to shift to lower cost meats and other food items to balance the increase).

From Owen Hembry (The New Zealand Herald, Record prices but flocks shrinking, May 18, 2009):
The national sheep flock is now down to levels not seen since 1950.

Rabobank's latest Agribusiness Review said farm gate lamb prices had strengthened since January, hitting levels more than 50 per cent up on last year.

Rabobank senior analyst Hayley Moynihan said prices would be enough to improve profitability but were probably not enough to encourage more investment.

The smaller flock had pushed up prices, she said.

"Our sheep flock has fallen so much because producers have got out because it's unprofitable, but they're not yet at the point where producers are going to start expanding the flock numbers again.

Pork has remained affordable, but only in comparison with other meat items (probably, but not substantiated, by the swine flu causing ignorant consumers to avoid pork, causing prices to decline).

From Derrell S. Peel (Cattle Network, Cow Calf: Beef & Cattle Markets Try To Maintain Seasonal Strength, May 22, 2009):
Total beef production is down 4.5 percent so far in 2009 compared to last year. The reasons for decreased production have changed in recent weeks. In the first quarter of the year, reduced cattle slaughter pulled beef production down despite sharply higher carcass weights. In recent weeks, slaughter has increased, as is typical of this time of year, but carcass weights have dropped to levels only slightly higher than a year ago.

Beef and lamb production is down, which has to drive up prices, but the selling price is dropping to appeal to poorer buyers, so buying is down.

Scarcity drives up prices, but less demand drives prices down, so there is a strange balancing act occuring. My hunch was that people (like my personal situation) are buying less meat/poultry, which is killing the producers, who are responding (appropriately) by producing less.  The result is less, for everyone.

Our pantries will eventually need to be replenished, but prices will have to eventually rise as decreased production and profits eventually effect producers (some will fold, others will contract).

Leaner times are ahead, not unexpectedly, but hungry people do strange things.
Jack Sprat
Could eat no fat,
His wife could eat no lean;
And so,
Betwixt them both,
They licked the platter clean.

- Mother Goose Nursery Rhymes