Showing posts with label Social Security. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Social Security. Show all posts

Friday, August 14, 2009

The End Is Near

Here's a comment I left at Fabius Maximus (Beginning Of The End Of The Republic’s Solvency. Soon Come The First Steps To A Reformed Regime – Or A New Regime, August 14, 2009) regarding health care and entitlement reform.  I was responding to responding to Maximus's comment:
"Fabius Maximus replies: You are ignoring the specfic example I gave of rationing — spending $36,000 on care in the last year of life. Much of it neither increasing lifespan or quality of life. First, I doubt that people will spend that money themselves — or that most Americans could afford it. Second, experience at other nations disproves your theory."

My response:

Means-testing is coming, but I do not think you’ve thought through rationing or the basis of “few can afford it” with respect to the last year of life expenses.


Many seniors, especially the aging Boomers, have property. It is reasonable to require that people use their own assets before dipping into the public troth. The Boomers have not done a good job of managing their wealth for retirement, in the abstract, but many/most have property to sell. I expect to see some sort of reverse mortgage products appearing for the sole purpose of paying medical expenses (or government liens against property for this purpose, payable when the property is sold).


The idea that one retires and is able to maintain the same lifestyle when working is over. In addition, the idea that people “retire” was a temporary glitch of the last 50 years (not a concept that existed before). Boomers might not stay in the workforce in traditional jobs, but they might have to live with their children (say, providing daycare for their grandchildren). The Greatest Generation will be the last to have golfing/vacation style retirements.


It is immoral to think that you can check out of life and live off your children and grandchildren. It may not be what the Boomers want, but it is what they are going to get. It may require that we bankrupt the nation before the reality of the situation sinks in, but the reality is that Boomers will not have the same retirement as their parents. Bankrupt nation or before, the coffers are empty (and always were, by original design of Social Security) and there is no amount of taxation that will produce the amounts required to pay to the Boomers what they think they’re entitled to receive. The unfunded liability for the Boomer’s retirement years is projected to be 120% of GDP. 100% taxation on working people wouldn’t be enough. The Boomers might whine, but it is their fault. They were the stewards of the government for the last 40 years and they didn’t make sure the government was managing the budgets as they should. The Boomers have already spent their retirements by being the most coddled and spoilt generation in history.

Wednesday, July 29, 2009

On Their Watch

Social Security and Medicare are underfunded by $40 trillion.  Saying that they are underfunded is a bit of a bait and switch, as these programs have never been funded. FICA deductions go into the General Fund, with all the other taxes collected by the Feds.

When Bush was campaigning for his second term he focused on Social Security reform, but Congress (now an obvious, not statistical Democrat majority) would have no part of it.  Aggravating blue collar workers and the AARP is political suicide, so Congress did nothing to reform Social Security.

Whether that was cowardice or strategic (to further weaken the economy to bolster a win in 2008) doesn't matter.  The reality is that the Boomers are gradually shifting from the contributing to the receiving line of the FICA deduction, and their mass will shift the FICA budget line from positive to negative as early as 2012.  No more will Democrats have the FICA excess to play around with, which is why they're advocating "health care reform" and infusing it with methods to ration existing entitlement programs, while shoring up the gravy train for other programs.

In the socialized medicine Bills there are plans to begin rationing Medicare (as health care "reform" has little or nothing to do with Medicare).  Someone is going to have to do it eventually.  I'm just glad that the Democrats will have to own it, but I'm certain that they'll figure out a way to blame the Republicans for it.

In in decade it won't matter and AARP and Social Security recipients will be thrown under a bus.  They have to be, as there won't be enough money to pay even a fraction of their total federal entitlement payments.  And rightly, as it is their fault: their generation did nothing to guarantee that the money would be there when they got to retirement age. It won't matter if it was ignorance or malice.  Reality is immune to cause.  It just is.  And "empty" is what the coffers will be.

Tuesday, May 12, 2009

The End is Near

The End is Near

From Martin Crutsinger (AP, Annual report due for Social Security and Medicare, May 12, 2009):
Fewer people working means less being paid into the trust funds for Social Security and Medicare.

The obfuscation that Social Security collections go into a "trust fund" continues. The reality is that, since its inception, the collections for Social Security have gone into the General Fund. The "General Fund" is the set of monies the Federal government may use for anything and everything.

The bait-and-switch is that there is a notation of the amount that was collected for Social Security, but no money is actually transferred to a special account ("lockbox") for this purpose. It would be unlawful to do so. The Feds are required to spend that money each year and are prevented from setting it aside (where it could earn interest for future recipients).  This has always been to the Feds advantage, until very soon:
For years, the Social Security trust fund has taken in more than it spent on benefits, resulting in a cushion of billions of dollars that the government could spend on other programs while giving the trust fund an IOU.

The FICA deduction has always been a way for the Federal government to fill the coffers with a tax paid by anyone who collects a paycheck (half paid by the employee and half the employer), all the while claiming that a certain segment of taxpayers (the bottom feeders) didn't pay any taxes.

As the linked article goes on to explain:
The Congressional Budget Office recently projected that Social Security will collect just $3 billion more in 2010 than it will pay out in benefits.

This means that in 2011 (with just a $3 billion delta between collections and payouts in 2010) Social Security will begin to drain the Federal receipts swamp.  Add the "Galt Effect" with many choosing to opt out of the earning side of the equation sooner, and this could get ugly.

The flip of the pyramid (where the amount paid out to those collecting exceeds the amount collected) will also occur for Medicare earlier than expected.

Inverted Social Security Pyramid



Combined with the baby boomers entering their retirement years and the high unemployment rate, the Federal government will be bankrupt sooner rather than later.

Without the Social Security surpluses to feed upon, the Federal spending in Obama's budget will incur even greater borrowing and an even higher deficit than announced in February, re-announced yesterday, and recalculated upward (on a near-daily basis).

Without Social Security reform (means-testing recipients, raising the age of eligibility, lowering the amounts paid, or raising FICA taxes) the Feds will have to deal with an ever-shrinking pool of taxpayer money to play with. The problem with all the reform ideas is that it will make a lot of people very, very angry.  Social Security won't be quite the sacred cow it was, once it causes the swamp to drain, rather than providing a surplus with which to engage in other unconstitutional spending activities.

George Bush had Social Security reform on his second-term platform, but no one would touch it.

This should be fun!