Showing posts with label Politics: Defining Conservativism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics: Defining Conservativism. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Great Communicator

No, I'm not referring to Ronald Reagan with this title. I'm referring to Bill Whittle (of EjectEjectEject.com and Afterburner on PJTV). Bill's latest Afterburner episode (August 24, 2009) is brilliant!
PJTV: Afterburner, <i>MSNBC and The Great Liberal Narrative: The Truth About The Tyranny of Political Correctness</i>
PJTV: Afterburner, MSNBC and The Great Liberal Narrative: The Truth About The Tyranny of Political Correctness
Bill has a gift. He has the ability to distill history (and make it interesting) to validate his opinions. His optimistic view of America is very similar to Ronald Reagan's... which brings me to another great communicator, Faoud Ajami* who wrote a smashing essay about Obama's Humpty-Dumpty fall from the wall. In the essay (WSJ, Obama's Summer of Discontent, August 25, 2009), Mr. Ajami writes a bit about Ronald Reagan:
At the core of the Reagan mission was the recovery of the nation's esteem and self-regard. Reagan was an optimist. He was Hollywood glamour to be sure, but he was also Peoria, Ill. His faith in the country was boundless, and when he said it was "morning in America" he meant it; he believed in America's miracle and had seen it in his own life, in his rise from a child of the Depression to the summit of political power.
And:
At no time had Ronald Reagan believed that the American covenant had failed, that America should apologize for itself in the world beyond its shores. There was no narcissism in Reagan. It was stirring that the man who headed into the sunset of his life would bid his country farewell by reminding it that its best days were yet to come.
While Mr. Whittle doesn't yet have the wisdom and experience of Ronald Reagan, he certainly shares his optimism and exuberance about America, even if it is occasionally unfounded or rose-colored-glasses idealistic.

(*I had never heard of Faoud Ajami before, but if the WSJ article is an example of his typical writing performance, I can't wait to read more of him. WSJ states that he teaches at the School of Advanced International Studies, The Johns Hopkins University. He is also an adjunct fellow at Stanford University's Hoover Institution.)

But back to Bill Whittle...

I will admit to being a fan, while still maintaining my objectivity (I believe). Mr. Whittle manages to complain about leftist-intellectualism, while still maintaining a connection to average Joe, but he is clearly an intellectual himself (although not of the leftist persuasion).

This contrast sometimes causes a contradiction for Mr. Whittle, such as in his Afterburner episode about Sarah Palin's ill-treatment by the press (The Media, The Left and GOP Elitists vs. Sarah Palin: A Lesson on How to Destroy a Leader, July 27, 2009). Mr. Whittle makes a jab at intellectualism in that episode (transcript from EjectEjectEject.com):
She needs to be destroyed because the one thing that can never be allowed to happen is this: you cannot have a voice in this political debate. You know who I mean. You rubes, you hicks out there in flyover country. Your job is pay taxes, vote for who they have decided over cocktails makes them feel better about themselves, and occasionally provide your inbred idiot sons and daughters for the army or police force or whatever you people without Ivy League educations do with your tawdry little lives.

Meanwhile, the Harvard-educated elitist geniuses will run the country according to their infinitely brighter intellectual and moral lights.
[Emphasis mine.]

I think it unwise to tango with an anti-intellectualism/education message. It is also possible for conservatives to have Ivy League educations and be Harvard-educated elitist geniuses. It is possible to do all of that and not come out of school as a socialist-sympathizing drone. There are some who manage to get into Harvard or other Ivy League schools who don't have the necessary backbone and intellect to become something other than Useful Idiots. The concept of Garbage-In, Garbage-Out applies to their outcome.

While these degrees no longer confer the integrity and value they once had, the degree itself is not a disqualifer. We still have to do our own due diligence, regardless of the letters after a person's name or the letters on their parchment. Let me restate that in a different way: the degrees are neither a qualifier nor a disqualifier, in the sense of conferring superiority over the average Joe, but intellectual superiority exists (it just shouldn't be assumed if a person has a specific name on their college degree).

That intellectual superiority doesn't mean the average Joe has any less right to vote, any less command of his faculties or liberties, or is any less of a good person. It just means that the average Joe doesn't rise to the intellectual capacity of others, and those others include Mr. Whittle himself. That is why we qualify Joe with average when we speak of the majority of people in the country.
The moral sense, or conscience, is as much a part of man as his leg or arm. It is given to all human beings in a stronger or weaker degree, as force of members is given them in a greater or less degree. It may be strengthened by exercise, as may any particular limb of the body. This sense is submitted indeed in some degree to the guidance of reason; but it is a small stock which is required for this: even a less one than what we call Common sense. State a moral case to a ploughman and a professor. The former will decide it as well, and often better than the latter, because he has not been led astray by artificial rules."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1787

That's the contradiction of both Ronald Reagan and Bill Whittle. They manage to cloak their intellectualism in a way that makes it possible for them to communicate with Peoria, Ill. They relate to Peoria and Average Joe without a dumbed-down charade. I do not recall, however, that Ronald Reagan ever dismissed the value of education, in the way that Mr. Whittle did in the his Sarah Palin piece.

What Ronald Reagan never did, that Sarah Palin does (and Bill Whittle slightly stepped over the line in his episode on Sarah Palin) is pandering to the common man. Speaking plainly and directly doesn't mean speaking down to any one, nor does it include speaking in a colloquial manner, almost a stereotypical gum-chewing/smacking manner, as Sarah Palin does. Average Joe deserves more respect than that. The Office she held and the office she sought deserves more respect than that.

It is import to remember that President Bush has a Harvard degree. President Bush's accent and slight speech-impediment prevented him from earning the title of great orator. President Bush was a decent president who nobly rose to the occasion to handle the terrorist attacks of 9/11. He was the minimum standard of the intellectual capacity of a president. We don't have to raise the level to the Winston Churchill standard, but we should go no lower in our expectations with the bar set by George Bush.

If Sarah Palin has a superior intellect, she's done a fairly good job of hiding it. If she rises to the level of President Bush's, it remains to be seen. Reagan didn't hide it, he just didn't wear his intellectual superiority on his sleeve or rub anyone's nose in it.

This is better explained by Rudyard Kipling in his If letter to his son:
If you can talk with crowds and keep your virtue,
Or walk with kings - nor lose the common touch;
If neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you;
If all men count with you, but none too much;
If you can fill the unforgiving minute
With sixty seconds' worth of distance run -
Yours is the Earth and everything that's in it,
And - which is more - you'll be a Man my son!
[Emphasis mine.]

Sarah Palin, by Mr. Kipling's standard is not a man. Of course we know that she is a woman, but the poem's message can apply equally to a woman. It is a poem about duty and responsibility, about both honor and integrity, and dealing with success and failure, and winning and losing with grace and dignity. Man is merely a shortcut for all that is admirable and needed in an individual to live up to his/her human potential.

I accept the basic premise that Sarah Palin got a raw deal with the press and continued to be plagued by nuisance lawsuits while Governor of Alaska. In my opinion, however, she whines too much and allowed what happened yesterday to demonstrate that she fails in the "neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you" Kipling requirement.

It is similar to the way that Obama continues to blame President Bush for all the troubles he faces today, rather than taking ownership for his policies. Harry Truman's famous "the buck stops here" remark sums up the quality so necessary in the President of the United States. Sarah Palin's raw deal is no excuse for her showing weakness to her current and future enemies.

Showing weakness was the quality most dangerous in John F. Kennedy, so much so that it created a dangerous situation for the United States (and resulted in the Russians acting upon the placement of missiles in Cuba). The Russians didn't consider putting missiles in Cuba on Eisenhower's watch (nor would they have considered such a thing under Ronald Reagan's watch). Weakness has proven to create an unncessary danger, encouraging bold actions from our enemies.

The Iranians knew to release the hostages captured during Jimmy Carter's term when Ronald Reagan was sworn in.

Superior strength is not a quality unique to men, in the strength of character and convictions sense, not the physical sense. No one would have found either Margaret Thatcher or Golda Meir lacking strength. Those women had balls!

Strength matters and so does intellect in leadership. It matters not only in our Executive, but in our citizens, but for the latter, not as much.

Sarah Palin may have left the governorship of Alaska for Alaska's sake and benefit, but it did a disserve to the entire country in the longer term. It is akin to the policy of not negotiating with terrorists. It may benefit the 20 or so current hostages to negotiate for their release, but the success of that negotiation, of getting something out of the act, sends a signal that kidnapping and terrorism is a worthwhile venture. So, too, with Sarah Palin's resignation as governor of Alaska, by sending the message that a form of legal terrorism can be successful. We all lose when swarms of nuisance lawsuits cause officials to leave their elected posts. Expect to see much more of it as a result of Sarah Palin surrendering to it.

Sarah Palin should have recognized that long term risk, and the fact that she didn't demonstrates that she didn't have the backbone, nor the foresight of the bigger, long term picture. It is those bigger, long-term pictures that education provides, once unique to the Ivy League schools, but possible to be gleaned from lesser known institutions, or by those driven to achieve greatness in intellectual development by self study and perseverance.

"That every man shall be made virtuous by any process whatever is, indeed, no more to be expected than that every tree shall be made to bear fruit, and every plant nourishment. The brier and bramble can never become the vine and olive; but their asperities may be softened by culture, and their properties improved to usefulness in the order and economy of the world."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1822

Not everyone is capable of rising to the same level. That is not a handicap for being a good person or a good citizen, but it should be a handicap for higher office.

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it."

- George Santayana

Obama fails the test on every count, but that is no excuse for conservatives to lower the bar, or dismiss the value of intellect, strength, and education. Let the Democrats pander to the common man, but require that our own, we conservatives, respect and speak directly (and honestly) to the average Joe, while simultaneously recognizing his intellectual limits.
"Above all things I hope the education of the common people will be attended to, convinced that on their good sense we may rely with the most security for the preservation of a due degree of liberty."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1787

As Ronald Reagan commanded that politicians "never speak ill of another Republican," the additional commandment I would add is: "Conservatives should never speak ill of education."

The glorification of ignorance and pandering will be our undoing.
"The mass of our citizens may be divided into two classes -- the laboring and the learned. The laboring will need the first grade of education to qualify them for their pursuits and duties; the learned will need it as a foundation for further acquirements."

- Thomas Jefferson , 1814

Bill Whittle, I believe, made a few mistakes in his Sarah Palin episode, but he demonstrates that he has the ability to deliver to a praiseworthy performance in his piece on MSNBC/Political Correctness—the latter is a five star package. Sarah Palin, on the other hand, has yet to demonstrate greatness, stamina, strength of conviction, or an understanding of the value of education and the intellectual grounding it provides to see the big picture, and to avoid history's mistakes. She may do so at some point, as Mr. Whittle has done in his episode of yesterday, but Sarah hasn't done it yet... and I refuse, absolutely refuse, to lower the bar for conservatives, simply because the Democrats have done so.



H/t Instapundit.

Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Sunday, August 23, 2009

Keep Yours

I cannot claim to military service and officially taking the oath to protect and defend the Constitution from enemies both foreign and domestic, but I agree with the sentiment. I think the gentleman in this YouTube video is one example of where Americans have found their voice.



If more Americans speak up and speak out as this gentleman has, perhaps documenting the decline and fall of this website's mission will be unnecessary.

The most important thing is to vote—and vote for candidates who understand the strict limits of the Constitution. The Federal government has no authority to regulate health care or to create a universal health care plan, but if we do not elect representatives who comply with those limits, it doesn't matter what the Constitution says.

Here is the beginning and the end of what the Constitution authorizes Congress to do:
Article I: Section 8:
  • To borrow Money on the credit of the United States;
  • To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes;
  • To establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization, and uniform Laws on the subject of Bankruptcies throughout the United States;
  • To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures;
  • To provide for the Punishment of counterfeiting the Securities and current Coin of the United States;
  • To establish Post Offices and post Roads;
  • To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries;
  • To constitute Tribunals inferior to the supreme Court;
  • To define and punish Piracies and Felonies committed on the high Seas, and Offences against the Law of Nations;
  • To declare War, grant Letters of Marque and Reprisal, and make Rules concerning Captures on Land and Water;
  • To raise and support Armies, but no Appropriation of Money to that Use shall be for a longer Term than two Years;
  • To provide and maintain a Navy;
  • To make Rules for the Government and Regulation of the land and naval Forces;
  • To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections and repel Invasions;
  • To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States, reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress;
  • To exercise exclusive Legislation in all Cases whatsoever, over such District (not exceeding ten Miles square) as may, by Cession of particular States, and the Acceptance of Congress, become the Seat of the Government of the United States, and to exercise like Authority over all Places purchased by the Consent of the Legislature of the State in which the Same shall be, for the Erection of Forts, Magazines, Arsenals, dock-Yards, and other needful Buildings;--And
  • To make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof.
There is nothing in there that allows Congress to take over the health care industry or to provide health insurance to anyone. The Congress has the authority to regulate commerce between states, but not to regulate all commerce. It is merely the authority to resolve inter-state issues and conflicts, as they occur, but nothing in-state.

If the people in a given state wish to entertain such an idea, it is within their authority to do so, but not at the Federal level.
Amendment X:

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
Cross posted at From the Maenianum Secundum (comments are open there).

Monday, August 10, 2009

Chamber Music

In this little symphony by Andrew Klavan (City Journal, Romanticon by Andrew Klavan, August 10, 2009), he manages to merge the old and the new in a way that leaves the soul yearning for more:
It was, for Wordsworth, what the failure of Communism was for the radicals of a later day. He could no longer deny the error inherent in “speculative schemes— / That promised to abstract the hopes of Man.” He saw the Revolution as a dream that “flattered the young, pleased with extremes” and made “Reason’s naked self / The object of its fervour.” Confused by pure reason’s failure as a moral guide, he “lost / All feeling of conviction” and “yielded up moral questions in despair.” Slowly, he began to do the brave and difficult thing: to admit he had been wrong and change his mind.

RTWT.

We can only hope that the revolutionaries of our day will find the courage to "change his mind."

When conservatives fret about having to rebuild their party, they should take heart. None of this is new. If, however, they attempt to recreate the sensationalism of the Democrat's success and continue to fall victim to the cult of personality and populism, rather than an earnest rebuilding effort of our intellectual principles based on Western Civilization's values, we will fail.
Now, just as American reaction to the blatant political failures of sixties radicalism led to the Reagan revolution and the long dominance of political conservatism here, so, too, British reaction to the French Revolution led to 20 years of Tory rule. But neither Reaganism nor Toryism could ultimately disguise the fact that a profound and fundamental change in human outlook and attitude had taken place—a change that the sixties and the French Revolution represented rather than caused. When the smoke cleared, those who still believed in Western history, traditions, and institutions had to reestablish their relevance and rebuild their foundations in what was essentially a new world.

Thursday, July 30, 2009

What We Can Do

Subtitle: The Hope and Change the rest of us desire.

The purpose of this site is to document the events of the day. Few read it and fewer still take what is written here to heart. Mostly, it is cynical. It is the view of the world as one might view a train wreck before it happens, reporting on the screeching wheels and metal before the train hits the wall.

For just a moment I'm going to step out of the role as cynic and reporter of our demise and propose a few ideas that could turn this impending tragedy around, avoiding the train wreck. It isn't inevitable, but it is likely, given the direction we're heading. That direction needs to change.

The United States Constitution is an amazing document, both for its forward-thinking and its clarity. The few aberrations, including slavery and limited suffrage, were corrected by the sweat and blood of patriots, others were corrected peacefully. What we have left is a miracle -- a kind of road-map to preserving our treasured liberties.  It is only as useful as it is used and respected.

In some cases (the minutia I'll leave to another day) we screwed things up. For all the good intentions and lofty goals, prohibition was a bad idea, and it was later reversed. The Sixteenth Amendment was enacted to give Congress the ability to collect taxes on income (not wages), for the purposes of paying war debt. The balance of power between the States and the Federal government was severely harmed by the passage of the Seventeenth Amendment, changing the election of Senators from state selection by the respective state legislature, to popular vote. It, too, was invented with the goal of correcting a perceived wrong, but it created far more trouble than it benefited us.

I fully expect that those Amendments will be eventually overturned, viewed through the lens of history as mistakes as great and obvious as prohibition proved to be. In some cases the Constitution is fine as it is today, but it has been interpreted to mean something other than it was intended to mean.  The Fourteenth Amendment, for example, was enacted to gaurantee that the Bill of Rights, the respect of individual rights, and the status of U.S. citizen were uniform throughout the states, not that all other laws between the states had to be uniform.

Whether those Amendments will be overturned (or the interpretations of others limited to their original intent) will happen in my lifetime or later is the question. The larger question is if we'll exist long enough to reverse them.

Those are important, but trivial compared to what remains intact, based on the Founders exquisite understanding of the purpose of government and how government can be prevented from becoming the tyrannical state.

The Founders made it quite clear that the Federal government had limited powers -- that it derived its powers from The People -- and that all the powers not specifically granted to the Federal government remained with The People (individually) or collectively, by the States. On the whole, the Constitution doesn't limit what the people or the Several States may do; on the contrary, the Constitution limits and articulates what the Federal government may do.  In all cases, however, the Founders made it quite clear that we retained the rights we temporarily delegated to the Federal government.  At any time we could rescind their authority, or grant it additional powers, but only through Constitutional Amendment (not, as far too many believe, by doing whatever they damn well please).

There was fear that the Federal government would attempt to trump State powers, but more concern that larger states would attempt to trample the smaller ones. There were "checks and balances" as well, dividing the Federal government into three branches: Legislature, Executive, and Justice.

Each branch had their specific role and authority. The legislature was empowered to make laws and to lay taxes for the express purpose of carrying out those laws and their duties, but what laws they could create was strictly limited to those articulated. The Executive, beyond its primary directive of foreign affairs and domestic security, was empowered to make sure that the laws enacted by Congress were carried out. Justice was the arbiter between the states, and was the last hope when justice could not be found elsewhere.

All of the above was carefully worded in the various Articles. Article I addresses the Congress. Article II describes the Executive role. Article III describes the role of the judiciary. The remaining Articles (IV through VIII) address specific matters, such as how the Constitution may be altered, how new states may be admitted into the union, etc.

After the initial draft was presented to the people for their review, individually and by their respective state governments, a great debate ensued. (Actually, many debates ensued.) The most important one were the debates between the "Federalists" and the "Anti-Federalists." These are known as The Federalist Papers and The Anti-Federalist Papers. There can be no doubt of the Founders original intent when understood through those debates.

In Federalist 37, Madison framed the argument by describing the difficulties, goals, and the outcome of the Constitutional Convention:
The genius of republican liberty seems to demand on one side, not only that all power should be derived from the people, but that those intrusted with it should be kept in dependence on the people, by a short duration of their appointments; and that even during this short period the trust should be placed not in a few, but a number of hands. Stability, on the contrary, requires that the hands in which power is lodged should continue for a length of time the same. A frequent change of men will result from a frequent return of elections; and a frequent change of measures from a frequent change of men: whilst energy in government requires not only a certain duration of power, but the execution of it by a single hand.

Heretofore I have described the authority granted by the people to the Federal government. More importantly, however, is the balance of power between the Federal government and the States. Madison also describes the difficulties of this in Federalist 37:
To the difficulties already mentioned may be added the interfering pretensions of the larger and smaller States. We cannot err in supposing that the former would contend for a participation in the government, fully proportioned to their superior wealth and importance; and that the latter would not be less tenacious of the equality at present enjoyed by them. We may well suppose that neither side would entirely yield to the other, and consequently that the struggle could be terminated only by compromise. It is extremely probable, also, that after the ratio of representation had been adjusted, this very compromise must have produced a fresh struggle between the same parties, to give such a turn to the organization of the government, and to the distribution of its powers, as would increase the importance of the branches, in forming which they had respectively obtained the greatest share of influence. There are features in the Constitution which warrant each of these suppositions; and as far as either of them is well founded, it shows that the convention must have been compelled to sacrifice theoretical propriety to the force of extraneous considerations.

In Federalist 44, Madison addresses some of the ant-Federalist criticisms. In the passage below, he addresses the powers granted to Congress and the concerns that Congress would, at some future date, enlarge or expand on their limited powers (as they have done today):
If it be asked what is to be the consequence, in case the Congress shall misconstrue this part of the Constitution, and exercise powers not warranted by its true meaning, I answer, the same as if they should misconstrue or enlarge any other power vested in them; as if the general power had been reduced to particulars, and any one of these were to be violated; the same, in short, as if the State legislatures should violate the irrespective constitutional authorities. In the first instance, the success of the usurpation will depend on the executive and judiciary departments, which are to expound and give effect to the legislative acts; and in the last resort a remedy must be obtained from the people who can, by the election of more faithful representatives, annul the acts of the usurpers.

In Federalist 45, Madison details the concerns of too much state power, but what was concerning them at the time was an attempt by a powerful state to invade/control another state, not the Federal government encroaching on all the states. For this reason, state powers were not specifically articulated, but some state sovereignty was limited. Reading it today, however, is almost laughable. The checks and balances against encroachment of state authority has happened so pervasively and extensively, that remarks about how the numbers of people employed at the state level providing a buttress against the "few" at the Federal level, makes it absolutely clear that we have allowed all power-balancing strategies to be entirely eliminated. Madison was certain that the people would raise the alarm, and go to the guns, to address encroaching Federal powers long before they got to the point where we are today.

In Federalist 46, Madison addresses the concerns that the usurpation of state autonomy (or individual autonomy) would get so bad as to destroy the spirit and the literal powers of the States:
The only refuge left for those who prophesy the downfall of the State governments is the visionary supposition that the federal government may previously accumulate a military force for the projects of ambition. The reasonings contained in these papers must have been employed to little purpose indeed, if it could be necessary now to disprove the reality of this danger. That the people and the States should, for a sufficient period of time, elect an uninterupted succession of men ready to betray both; that the traitors should, throughout this period, uniformly and systematically pursue some fixed plan for the extension of the military establishment; that the governments and the people of the States should silently and patiently behold the gathering storm, and continue to supply the materials, until it should be prepared to burst on their own heads, must appear to every one more like the incoherent dreams of a delirious jealousy, or the misjudged exaggerations of a counterfeit zeal, than like the sober apprehensions of genuine patriotism.

Madison scoffed at the concerns, believing that the people would never stand for it, but all those fears have become our reality. We allowed all the worst-case scenarios to occur and that was something that Madison could never have fathomed.

So what do we do and what powers remain?

Before I address the best option, I'd like to address a concern: In many states the Second Amendment is in full force. For many of us, however, we wish to use that as a last resort, and attempt to restore the powers of the people and the respective States without resorting to war (or even some sort of agreed-upon, peaceful secession). The war option is far from being the only option, and surely the least desirable, when other options are still open to us.

There are a variety of suggestions to address the encroachment of Federal powers. Some have gone so far as to suggest we need to restate the limitions again, perhaps in new words, to make the point that the Constitution limits what the Federal government may do. This is the equivalent of applying bolds, asterisks, and underlines to what is already written. While I would not be opposed to these options, as I would support any and all peaceful attempts to address the problem, I do not think it is our best option.

The Constitution, in Amendments Ninth and Tenth, already state that the powers not specifically listed as granted to the Federal government remain with the states and/or the people. Saying it again is not going to change the status quo.  The Federal government is already ignoring what was written, so writing something else to be ignored is a futile gesture. We're past words. It is time for action.

The option that is open to us is state disobedience, but I use disobedience to better explain the idea rather than the word as a value judgement. It is the state-collective equivalent of civil disobedience. In truth, it is the Federal government that has been disobedient, by exercising powers they have not been granted. The only effective way to put meat into the limitations imposed on the Federal government is for the states to ignore actions, measures, and laws that are extra-constitutional. Only those actions, measures, initiatives, and laws that are specifically articulated in the Constitution as belonging to the Federal government will be respected by the several States, and by The People.

To this end, some state legislatures are passing "State Sovereignty" measures to restate their authority and limit Federal authority. These involve restatements of the Ninth and Tenth Amendments, which are:
Amendment IX
The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.

Amendment X
The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.

While we shouldn't ignore Congressional elections, it is more important now to pay attention to state elections, including the legislatures and the governor. It is time for governors (with agreement by the state legislatures) to refuse to abide by unconstitutional Federal encroachment. This includes:

  • Refusing all TARP funds/invasions of Federal officers in local businesses.

  • Refusing all Stimulus funding.

  • Refusing all education funding and federal legislation regarding education (and all other unconstitutional government departments).

  • Exercise the option to call out the National Guards to protect our borders if our Federal government continues to refuse to exercise their primary directive.


It is time for states to refuse to comply and also refuse the bribe money that comes with it, while protecting state citizens from unconstitutional taxes and penalties.

It is the responsibility of our state legislatures and our governors to exercise the authority we have granted to them. It is time we work locally to elect representatives who will restore the balance of power between the Federal and State governments and reject all invasions and encroachments of Federal authorities.

The following is the kind of speech that every governor of every state should deliver on the day he or she is sworn into office:
The People of this state have graciously elected me as their Governor, and I understand fully the responsibilities and authorities they have entrusted to me, as well as the limitations of that power within our state, and those entrusted to the Federal government. There are strict lines of delineation, between the counties and cities within our state; the powers granted to the local mayors and city/town councils; the unique relationships we have with neighboring states, and the authority we recognize as belonging to the Federal government.

The authority we have granted to the Federal government is strictly limited to those items articulated in the U.S. Constitution. The Federal government has the responsibility and authority to declare war, to provide for the common defense, to coin money, to regulate the seas, oceans and post roads, and to protect the products and arts by providing copyright and patent laws, and the judiciary may intervene on matters between us and other states. The Federal government has no other powers or authority. As part of my oath today I swore to uphold and protect not only our State Constitution, but the Federal Constitution. I take that oath seriously. Beginning today, I will issue an order which returns all funds received from the Federal government that goes beyond their authority. I reject all laws enacted by Congress that goes beyond their specifically limited authority. I will refuse, with force if necessary, the invasion of Federal officers, in whatever department or uniform, to exercise authority not specifically granted to them.

For too long states have remained passive, gradually morphing from free and sovereign states to lowly beggars, looking to the Federal government for hand-outs and to do the job that governors were intended to perform. That transition into a lowly beggar class ends now.

  • If the Federal government does not perform its duty with respect to protecting our borders, I will call out our National Guard to do so.

  • If the Federal government attempts to send agents to interfere with our peaceful commerce within our state, I will stop them at the border, with force, if necessary.

  • If the Federal government attempts to arrest or in any way interfere with our citizens' refusal to pay taxes on anything other than their incomes (not wages) or taxes imposed equally among the states, but only for the percentage of Federal government budget that is Constitutional, I will issue orders to stop them. Our state officers, police, and National Guard will be called upon to intervene to protect our citizens from arrest or property seizure, if necessary.

  • I will call upon neighboring and friendly states to assist us if necessary, and I will respond to calls for assistance from other states, if they should need our assitance.


It is time, finally, for the State governors to exercise the powers they have been granted, to protect thier citizens in their respective states from invasions of their liberty by the extra-Constutional acts of the Federal government, and for the Several States to refuse to abide by unjust and unconstitutional laws.

Today, the liberty and values established by the Founders will be restored in this state, and I hope many others.

That is what is necessary. That is the change of direction I introduced in my opening paragraphs to alter the course of the train to prevent the wreck. Although patience is required, anything else or short of that is a guarantee that our republican government will cease to exist.

Chances it will happen? Zero. But Americans love the underdog and this post is supposed to be my non-cynical view of the future. Despite the fact that I clearly and carefully stated that "going to the guns" was not an option, I suppose that my suggestions would classify me as a terrorist to some.  Oh, well.  So much for being optimistic.

Sunday, June 14, 2009

In Praise of Burke

From Kenneth Anderson (Volokh Conspiracy), If They Can Find Time for Feminist Theory, They Can Find Time for Edmund Burke, June 13, 2009) we find a link to a wonderful post by Peter Berkowitz (The Wall Street Journal, Conservatism and the University Curriculum, June 13, 2009):
That constellation begins to come into focus at the end of the 18th century with Edmund Burke's "Reflections on the Revolution in France." It draws on the conservative side of the liberal tradition, particularly Adam Smith and David Hume and includes Tocqueville's great writings on democracy and aristocracy and John Stuart Mill's classical liberalism. It gets new life in the years following World War II from Friedrich Hayek's seminal writings on liberty and limited government and Russell Kirk's reconstruction of traditionalist conservatism. And it is elevated by Michael Oakeshott's eloquent reflections on the pervasive tendency in modern politics to substitute abstract reason for experience and historical knowledge, and by Leo Strauss's deft explorations of the dependence of liberty on moral and intellectual virtue.

Unbeknownst to far too few, the conservative tradition is vast, and its guises, the bastardization of the word conservatism, and the distortions of its meaning and principles is why we are in the mess we are in today.

"They didn't teach me that" is no excuse for ignorance. The libraries, (virtual and brick and mortar) are still, last I looked, free.

Wednesday, June 10, 2009

100% Wrong

While there is much to agree with in this post by Douglas Young (Samizdata.net, America: closing her door to freedom, June 8, 2009), the sentence (below) is so wrong, so historically daft, that it reduces the credibility of his earlier points to dust:
Never forget that we are the heirs of the most libertarian, God-fearing revolutionaries in history.

The Founding Fathers were not even remotely libertarian.  They were Republican (uppercase R).  They believed that the People have complete control and power to form a government of their choosing, regardless of what it looked like, or how outwardly tyrannical it may be or appear.  They gave us the structure in which to do whatever we wanted, and to limit or grant the government the ability to do anything we desire it to do.  While the Founders hoped that the people would make laws with a "wholesome descretion," it was a hope not a requirement or limitation on the people's authority.
"The catholic principle of republicanism [is] that every people may establish what form of government they please and change it as they please, the will of the nation being the only thing essential."

- Thomas Jeffersons, 1792


"What government [a nation] can bear depends not on the state of science, however exalted, in a select band of enlightened men, but on the condition of the general mind."


- Thomas Jefferson, 1817



The right of "self-government of and by the people" has nothing to do with the notions of libertarianism.  If people think that, or believe that, they have missed entirely what the Founders gave us and others fought and died for.  People may disagree with the direction the nation has taken, or the policies and schemes that we live under, but to assert that the people have no right to do what they have done (or will do) reveals themselves as tyrants in disguise, however englightened they may think themselves.
"The first principle of republicanism is that the lex majoris partis is the fundamental law of every society of individuals of equal rights; to consider the will of the society enounced by the majority of a single vote as sacred as if unanimous is the first of all lessons in importance, yet the last which is thoroughly learnt. This law once disregarded, no other remains but that of force, which ends necessarily in military despotism."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1817


Tuesday, June 9, 2009

Gradually and Carefully: The Essence of Conservatism

I am returning to a subject I wrote about here, but with a different purpose. The original post addressed the subject of conservatism, and what it means from a political perspective (not, as is often the case, from a religious or personal perspective). Here I wish to expand on that, and lightly touch upon some of the issues that we face today that divide us. I'm afraid these aren't subjects that can be addressed in a few paragraphs.

Conservatism is, in a nutshell, political restraint and political practicality. It says that change is possible (and often desirable), but it must occur gradually and naturally, reflecting, like a mirror, what society has become on its own, not the society imposed on us by the government. Government evolves with a given society. Government may be a little slow to respond (and it should be slow and thoughtful), and lagging behind where society is at any given moment, but it will eventually catch up. It is society that leads the change, not the government. But government, in hand with society, isn't a ship lost at sea, or one without a charted/pre-determined course. There is a kind of ultimate destination we hope we'll all reach together, even if some among us lag behind or slow our progress.

That ultimate destination is where we agree or disagree politically and ideologically.

Conservatives want the ultimate destination to be a society with much more freedom than it has today, but it is also a society that must earns those freedoms.

It is like a child growing into a teenager and then an adult, who is given a longer and longer rope, as she demonstrates that she has the self-restraint and wisdom to handle the responsibilities of more freedom, and to make good choices. If she wobbles, then the rope is shortened a bit, and the trust factor has to be reestablished before that same level of trust is extended again.

At times, it can be one step forward and then two steps backwards, until the right balance of trust and freedom is determined, based on the character, integrity, and moral fortitude of the individual (or in this case, the sum total of those characteristics of the society as a whole). It is give and take, where trust is earned and thoughtful use of that trust develops and earns more trust.

"More freedom" doesn't mean license to do whatever someone wants to do. In fact, it means just the opposite. The goal of more liberty isn't a nation of libertines. It means we reach a point where more freedom doesn't result in more libertines. If, for example, we reach the point where recreational drugs are decriminalized, it won't be because people have decided that recreational drugs are socially and morally acceptable. It will be because people have shown the wisdom of restraint and force of will to reject them, and their use is so small, so infinitesimally irrelevant, that we no longer find it necessary to have laws on the books to make their use illegal.

Society evolves to the point where it looks at those drug laws and says "Why do we have those? That's not something we have to deal with, as society has shown itself wise enough to reject their use, making laws like this unnecessary."

There are dozens (perhaps hundreds) of similar examples where society can evolve to a new standard of respect of freedom and of the body—where it rejects activities and pursuits that are damaging/dangerous to the society as a whole, and are damaging to the individual (in spirit/morality which is the source of real "self esteem," and respect of the physical body as a temple).

The decriminalization of something (the act of wiping the laws of it off the books) were not done by the Father of Conservatism and his allies and should not be done now with the intention of announcing to society that this thing, once illegal, is now condoned and socially acceptable (although there are examples of that, such as the elimination of laws that once banned interracial marriage or blue laws that no longer apply to our religiously diverse population, but these were exceptions, as they were temporary aberrations of law, and were "unjust" laws that we corrected). It is done because society no longer engages in these actions so the laws become unnecessary.

It is when we make swift, unearned/unnatural changes to society (imposed on it), and enact laws that go against the decades-long tested history of Common Law or other historical guidelines, where we end up having to reverse them, because they were mistakes. They were social reengineering actions that were unnaturally imposed on society, and that is always a mistake often seen only through the wisdom of hindsight, unfortunately.

If we were to erase a myriad of laws that attempt to constrain society (such as divorce laws, pornography prohibitions, etc.), it will not be because we now believe that divorce is "OK" or pornography as innocent and acceptable as playing Bridge. It will be because people make wise decisions in marriage and live up to their commitments (never needing a divorce), or society has realized that pornography is damaging to the psyche and chooses not to participate as the buyer or creator.

Those are the ideals, the direction, and our actions today and the laws we create to punish them, and the incentives we create to reward the rejection of them, are to move us in the direction of that ideal, not to impose it by judicial or legislative fiat. We realize we may never achieve the goal or get to our ideal destination, but we work towards it, gradually and carefully.

"That every man shall be made virtuous by any process whatever is, indeed, no more to be expected than that every tree shall be made to bear fruit, and every plant nourishment. The brier and bramble can never become the vine and olive; but their asperities may be softened by culture, and their properties improved to usefulness in the order and economy of the world."


-Thomas Jefferson, 1822



That was the great reformation that Edmund Burke began, which gave birth to the idea of conservatism. He and his fellows went through English law and began eliminating those laws which were no longer needed. It erred on the side of liberty for the individual, given the emotional, intellectual, character, and force of will/restraint of the society that the action would affect.

Further, Edmund Burke understood fully (and better than most others) that these types of actions could not be applied universally, and never imposed on a society that hadn't already got there on its own (or by itself). All laws were not stripped away. Only those laws that were no longer necessary were erased. To do otherwise defeated the purpose and the wisdom entirely, and was counter to what conservatism meant.

These actions were taken with an intimate and thorough understanding of the society in which it was occurring. Removing the laws in England did not mean that those same laws could be abandoned in other places in the world, as other nations and societies/cultures are always at different stages of their evolution. What works in one place may work in another, but it is because the societies and cultures are similar, not because the action/idea is portable to all immediately.

This is why, when faced with the revolutionaries in France, Edmund Burke (who had been a champion of American Independence) rejected the French version. It was not because he was opposed to liberation and revolution as a method of achieving liberty, but because he understood fully that the French were simply not ready for it.
I flatter myself that I love a manly, moral, regulated liberty as well as any gentleman of that society, be he who he will; and perhaps I have given as good proofs of my attachment to that cause, in the whole course of my public conduct. I think I envy liberty as little as they do, to any other nation. But I cannot stand forward, and give praise or blame to anything which relates to human actions, and human concerns, on a simple view of the object, as it stands stripped of every relation, in all the nakedness and solitude of metaphysical abstraction. Circumstances (which with some gentlemen pass for nothing) give in reality to every political principle its distinguishing colour and discriminating effect. The circumstances are what render every civil and political scheme beneficial or noxious to mankind. Abstractedly speaking, government, as well as liberty, is good; yet could I, in common sense, ten years ago, have felicitated France on her enjoyment of a government (for she then had a government) without inquiry what the nature of that government was, or how it was administered? Can I now congratulate the same nation upon its freedom? Is it because liberty in the abstract may be classed amongst the blessings of mankind, that I am seriously to felicitate a mad-man, who has escaped from the protecting restraint and wholesome darkness of his cell, on his restoration to the enjoyment of light and liberty? Am I to congratulate a highwayman and murderer, who has broke prison, upon the recovery of his natural rights? This would be to act over again the scene of the criminals condemned to the galleys, and their heroic deliverer, the metaphysic knight of the sorrowful countenance.

When I see the spirit of liberty in action, I see a strong principle at work; and this, for a while, is all I can possibly know of it. The wild gas, the fixed air, is plainly broke loose: but we ought to suspend our judgment until the first effervescence is a little subsided, till the liquor is cleared, and until we see something deeper than the agitation of a troubled and frothy surface. I must be tolerably sure, before I venture publicly to congratulate men upon a blessing, that they have really received one. Flattery corrupts both the receiver and the giver; and adulation is not of more service to the people than to kings. I should therefore suspend my congratulations on the new liberty of France, until I was informed how it had been combined with government; with public force; with the discipline and obedience of armies; with the collection of an effective and well-distributed revenue; with morality and religion; with the solidity of property; with peace and order; with civil and social manners. All these (in their way) are good things too; and, without them, liberty is not a benefit whilst it lasts, and is not likely to continue long. The effect of liberty to individuals is that they may do what they please: we ought to see what it will please them to do, before we risk congratulations, which may be soon turned into complaints. Prudence would dictate this in the case of separate, insulated, private men; but liberty, when men act in bodies, is power. Considerate people, before they declare themselves, will observe the use which is made of power; and particularly of so trying a thing as new power in new persons, of whose principles, tempers, and dispositions they have little or no experience, and in situations, where those who appear the most stirring in the scene may possibly not be the real movers.

- Edmund Burke, Reflections on the French Revolution, 1790



Their revolution would lead to anarchy because they did not yet have the foundations of laws (and respect for them), nor the social traditions of Common Law, as the American revolutionaries had with their two-hundred year history of respect for law and assimilation of the English Common Law in their society and culture.

Without a respect for law, the recognition of the equal rights of all, and a culture of respect for legal and cultural precedent, anarchy would surely be the result, followed by totalitarian tactics which become necessary to restore order from madness. Burke believed it would be a brutal, bloody disaster and he was right on all counts, as are so many conservatives when they apply the lessons of history to newly presented "fresh" and "new" concepts, but which have proven to be doomed to failure.

Which brings me to today and how gradualism has been twisted by progressives and manipulated by those not quite so sympathetic to government changing to reflect the current-evolved society.

With progressives (and they may be called "liberals" or "Left" interchangeably) they desire to make new laws and eliminate old ones, but not in the same way, or using the same criteria/methods of conservatives. Progressives attempt to change society with government, i.e., the government acting as Jack Booted Thug to alter and reengineer society into the ideal progressives desire, which is tyranny, regardless of its flavor as communism, socialism or fascism.

Progressives impose change on society with gradualism to achieve their objectives. Conservatives recognize changes in the society itself, and respond to them gradually, and most importantly, carefully, with the goal of greater responsibility and liberty for all.

Liberty and responsibility cannot be separated.  Well, they can, but the result is not liberty, but chaos. True liberty is realized when it comes with the wisdom and the force of will to accept the responsibility for exercising those liberties, and the acceptance of all the consequences that go with it. A liberated individual (psychically aware) does not choose actions which put himself at unnecessary risk, but more importantly, he doesn't engage in actions that put others at risk. More liberty comes with the associated responsibilities.  Without a full-boat acceptance of those responsibilities, liberty is a simply a guise for degeneracy.
"When [the moral sense] is wanting, we endeavor to supply the defect by education, by appeals to reason and calculation, by presenting to the being so unhappily conformed, other motives to do good and to eschew evil, such as the love, or the hatred, or the rejection of those among whom he lives, and whose society is necessary to his happiness and even existence; demonstrations by sound calculation that honesty promotes interest in the long run; the rewards and penalties established by the laws; and ultimately the prospects of a future state of retribution for the evil as well as the good done while here. These are the correctives which are supplied by education, and which exercise the functions of the moralist, the preacher, and legislator; and they lead into a course of correct action all those whose depravity is not too profound to be eradicated."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1814



If we take a particular issue, I may better illustrate the two approaches:

Progressives wish to change civil marriage, not with the goal of strengthening a social institution they respect, understand, and admire, but to shatter it, with the goal of its eventual elimination. Progressives wish to eliminate the social institution of marriage by gradually hammering away at its foundation.

Conservatives, on the other hand, wish to strengthen marriage, as conservatives recognize that social institutions such as marriage are the foundations of a healthy society.

The social institution of marriage has beneficial outcomes for society as a whole, but it also has the much more important desired impact of creating stable and productive citizens, and psychology/socially well-adjusted children; thus, the product of marriage is what is desired, not the title/deed of being married itself. It is not a title, such as "doctor" or "emperor." It is an institution, which has a high bar for entry and continued membership.

There is an old saying (unattributed) that goes "that which you sanction/condone you get more of." It is something we understand with our common sense, to the degree that we have any. When you make something cheaper or easier to buy/acquire, such as pornography or bread, you get more customers for it, and more producers of it, since the market for it is now larger.

When you make divorce easier, you get more divorce. The effect on marriage is also painfully obvious for those who use their common sense: Since marriage is easier to get out of, it is entered in to more carelessly and thoughtlessly. Making divorce harder (painfully difficult as it was until the 1960s) meant that people chose more carefully. They had longer courtships, longer engagements, and the institution was respected because once entered into, it was understood it was a life commitment, i.e., until death did them part.

There were rules in the civil marriage commitment. It required fidelity, responsibility (in many forms), and trust between the couple. Divorce was possible if there were grounds for divorce, which didn't include trivialities such as "we decided we don't like each other anymore."

Because divorce was so difficult and so shattering to one's social standing and financial stability, couples had to demonstrate restraint with each other. They couldn't allow an argument to escalate from smoldering embers to blazing firestorm. They knew they'd have to face each other the next day, and the day after that, and there was no escape from each other. This demanded of them an approach of rationality, of respectfully discussing their differences, of learning to come to a compromise, and the necessity of developing, above all else, a friendship between themselves.

Love may or may not last as the titillation of infatuation and romance may gradually fade, but the friendship can and must endure, as well as the respect and trust the friendship/bond engenders. That friendship/bond, in itself, may have kept the passion-embers burning, but even if it didn't, and all that remained was a friendly and cordial friendship/bond, that was enough, and was important and valued.

When divorce is easy, there is no need to show restraint, no need to develop that trust and bond, and the marriage crumbles. When the emphasis of marriage is one of physical "fun," indulgence, and passion only, it cannot endure the trials and tribulations of day to day life, and the fading of youth and beauty, and it will end badly. Marriage doesn't live up to the advertising of "fun" or "romantic" but it was never advertised as that in the past.

Easier divorce means more divorce and it makes marriage less happy for those who enter into it, yielding even more divorce. A viscous, horrid cycle is created.

It ends badly for all of us. The disastrous financial impact of divorce is well understood. Single mothers are the ones who make up the lowest quintiles of the economic tables. Their children fill the psychiatric hospitals, the courts, and the juvenile jails.

Divorced men (who may or may not have the ability or fortitude to support their children by court order) see the physical manifestations of their hard work and financial achievements irrevocably split and splintered, and their loss of daily contact with their children creates a distance and a sadness, all of which result in a loss of face, happiness, and self-esteem. This makes men demonstrate behaviors of brooding, anger, and selfishness, contrasted with the stereotypical role of the woman as victim, resulting in whining, bitterness, and desire for revenge.

These stresses and strains have grave consequences for the individuals involved, as well as the society in which they live. They use more services, such as family courts, psychiatrists, and police as the psychological impacts of divorce lead to all sorts of other undesired behaviors and outcomes.

The above are the least important, as the institution of marriage was honed and perfected over the millennium with the goal of raising healthy and productive offspring. Civil marriage (originally religious-only, or Royal-sanctioned marriage for those couples who had demonstrated their fertility) has the main goal of producing offspring—offspring that will give society a new generation, allowing the society itself to endure. Marriage, therefore, is the vehicle/method by which society continues and prospers.

Children of divorce are not as well off as their stable-family peers. This is also well documented, with statistics that prove that even a peaceful and cooperative, mutually-agreed-upon divorce affects children negatively. Stepmothers or stepfathers help, but they don't eliminate all the negative outcomes. A single-parent household is the worst, regardless of it being a single woman or man.

Other than homes with physical and/or emotional abuse (a violation of the marriage contract in itself), children really are better off with both parents in the home, even if they aren't madly in love with each other.

Ideally, we wish that all married couples are as delightfully and passionately in love on their 50th anniversary as they were on their wedding day, but mutual respect and friendship is not a bad outcome either. The latter, while not the advertised outcome in today's "marriage is about love and passion only" propaganda, is a thoroughly reasonable and normal outcome of marriage for some couples. The recognition that the purpose of marriage (that existed for hundreds and hundreds of years) is that marriage's purpose is to have the outcome of delivering to society children who grow up to be productive, happy, and prosperous individuals. It was once thought of as an ideal, with the friendship/bond of the couple a marvelous, life-sustaining and fulfilling outcome, but a side benefit. Marriage was always for the children, not the parents. Children will be better off in every measurable way, and society will be better off in every measurable way if the couple stays married.

That is why conservatives value the institution of marriage and reject any progressive notions of changing it to carelessly bring more people into it, or to make it more casual (even easier to get out of than it is today), or to redefine the desired outcome to something akin to "sexually and selfishly satisfying and all other expectations be damned, and can be discarded like a used Kleenex if it no longer feels good."

Marriage should be difficult to get into and have a reasonable degree of exclusivity (with minor exceptions of chance and circumstance) to those who promise to deliver to society the desired outcome of marriage: healthy, prosperous, happy, and productive children.

It is civil society, through their government not by their government, that grants and recognizes a couple as "married." It is a reciprocal relationship, between the society and the couple who lives within that society. It is recognized, sanctioned, and granted with expectations—expectations that are rewarded because of the known benefits the relationship provides, if the couple lives up to their commitment to each other and the society who bears witness to their promises. The rewards/benefits that society confers on a couple are stripped from them if they break their promises to each other and the society that witnessed and allowed it.

Marriage isn't a "right," as so many progressives assert. It never has been. It is an institution, and it is a "privilege" to be allowed into it, only by those willing to accept and live up to the requirements and rules.

The marriage example is an ideal one, because it demonstrates so clearly the cause and effect, tit for tat, and benefit/reward ratio of an individual (or in the case of marriage, a couple) and society. Government has no role in this, except to recognize society's goals and desires and to codify what society wants more of by creating rewards/benefits or punishment. "What we sanction/condone we get more of" and "what we prohibit/criminalize we get less of."

There are hundreds of examples of this: when welfare is easy and comes with no stigma, we get higher welfare rolls; when bastard children are condoned and the mother supported in it, we get more unwed mothers and negatively affected children (and more crime, depression, anxiety and suicides of those children); and when indulgencies and immoral/casual/selfish acts are condoned and accepted, we get more pornography, more drug use, more idleness, and more casual sex (and the negative psychological/social impacts of those actions which create a burden on productive members of society, as well as the creation of diseases and the higher risk of pandemics that effect all of society, not just those who engage in risky behaviors), and when having children is considered an act of "self-fulfillment," rather than a duty and a responsibility, we get fewer children, and fewer healthy/happy children, as well as a change in how society views children (and larger families), and the society itself is at risk.

Society is burdened with the outcome of irresponsible behavior so it has every right to demand that its government do all that is reasonably necessary to adjust the laws to prevent or reduce risky behaviors, and encourage healthy, responsible, and productive behaviors.

The family unit has lost much, but not all of its value. There are wondrous and miraculous holdouts of happy, prosperous and productive marriages and families, despite so many laws and actions that work against them. Those family units are the ultimate protection and defender against tyranny.

Man is a social animal and he will form bonds and allegiances out of necessity and instinct. Without a family unit to be protected, respected, and nurtured, he will find surrogates and form unhealthy allegiances with cults, racketeers, gangs, and most importantly (for the progressive goal of communism, fascism, or socialism) a bond with the State, as the replacement for the figurehead and security of Mother and Father, or of being Mother or Father.

Without a strong family bond to which there is the ultimate and sacred allegiance (that no man may put asunder), any family/tribe replacement is possible. History has borne this out, with the allegiances to the SS, and the communist party thugs in Russia and China. All of these abominations and horrific genocidal actions began with the careful and premeditated destruction of the family, elevating the State as the replacement for it, with propaganda infused with the banner of protecting family and children. These are/were brilliant acts of family destruction, under the guise of family protection, by appealing to the worst fears and traits of humankind.

This is why National Socialism (NAZIs) took children from their parents (the "Hitler Youth"), to be raised by strangers of the State, who punished them for demonstrating individualist ideas and compassion, rather than responsibility for family and children. The allegiance was no longer to the family, but to the "Fatherland."

It was cult/brainwashing taken to the universal level. The team/group was elevated above the individual, and respect for the sanctity of individual conscience and individual-healthy pride was punished. Nationalism replaced patriotism. The State replaced mother and father and the family itself. Without the moral, ethical and social restraints of family shame and pride, the worst characteristics of human beings could be brought to bear against others. It was premeditated.

This is why the education of Cuban, Soviet, and Chinese children (and all socialist, communist, and totalitarian regimes) are performed exclusively by government schools, with state-required curriculum (originally designed by John Dewey, but revised and rejected by the Russians because they realized that it resulted not in socialist drones, but in irresponsible hoodlums and thugs) that proceeded these nation's desires and attempts of world domination, by force, if necessary.

It is, as I stated, the family unit itself that is the ultimate barrier against complete State control and all that the outcome of that creates: tyranny, misery, and illusions of grandeur that enable totalitarian domination of the individual, and consumes the society itself.

Idealistically wrong-headed and progressive ideas of "all getting along" and "all speaking in one voice" are dangerous. Unity is necessary in a society when it is threatened from the outside, but unity and "one voice" are contrary to individual liberty and respect of conscience. There must be allowed in society family units that have different opinions and ideas, who educate and raise their children differently, as long as those opinions and ideas do not become exceptionally hurtful or harmful to the children in their care. It is the bond and protection of a hundred million individual family households, valued and having primacy above the State, all having unique and respected ideals and values, competing and speaking their minds, and coming to a compromise that allows all to coexist that creates a compact of a society for the mutual protection of their individual families, and the individual members of those families.

It is in the family where an individual learns to compromise, to make allowances for the differences of others, while still accepting and loving them. We learn forgiveness, tolerance, and the delight of diversity from family, not from artificially imposed, statistical-based laboratories that attempt to create diversity and tolerance on the outside. Yes, exposure to people of different backgrounds and views can be beneficial to a child, but only after he has become immune to propaganda and manipulation.

Allow me to switch issues to define and detail a problem, with suggestions of gradual and careful adjustments to address it.

The gravest of issues is the one of abortion, not simply because it is such a charged issue and so politically divisive, but because of its impact on society. That degree of divisiveness is not a healthy thing for society, but the way that abortion has changed society's direction with respect to loving and delighting in children is its worst impact.

Yes, abortion itself is a horrible thing (even if some agree that it is a necessity at times), but the greater impact is longer term, even longer than the lifetime of the child lost in the choice to abort, or the life of the mother who chooses it.

We could move, gradually and carefully, in a direction where abortion is limited in cases where a significant majority of us recognize its practice as an abomination.

Most of us realize that a late-term abortion, where there is no risk to the life of the mother and the baby is viable on its own, is wrong. While making it illegal (unless, as I stated, it is a life threatening situation for the mother and if the baby is at viable stage), is one way of addressing the issue, we (more importantly) need  to agree (despite our differences of opinion of the legality of abortion) that gradually moving to a reduction in the number of abortions is the direction we all want to go.

  • We need to do more than addressing it only in criminalization of the practice in extreme circumstances (or even getting to the point where it is criminalized, if society moves in tandem in that direction).

  • We need to make adoption easier.

  • We need to work towards reducing the stigma of "bad mother" when a woman decides to put the child's well-being above her selfish desire to raise the child on her own.

  • We need to respect, laud, and support a pregnant woman who tells us that she is giving the child up for adoption!

  • We need to, gradually and carefully, move the ball backwards a bit on this issue by reasserting and reestablishing that a family of children does not necessarily mean that they are all the biological children of the parents. We need to respect paternity (and therefore "parental rights") by marriage exclusively, not by biology.

  • We also need to make adjustments in other aspects of our laws and policies to make housing for larger families easier (and cheaper), and not be shocked or alarmed when we see large families. We should applaud them.  Perhaps we could allow multi-family dwelling permits or make easier to obtain, so when a single mother wishes to live amongst a larger family unit, to (at minimum) give her own child exposure to a mother/father unit, even at arm's length, she would be able to do it. If that single mother cannot find the courage to give her child fully to an intact family, perhaps she could live among them. We could also make adoption faster, easier, and free.

  • It is also the stigma of adoption, and the idea that children will be forever damaged by adoption that we need to work on to eliminate it from the zeitgeist. That is often why women choose abortion, rather than carrying the child to term and giving the child the chance of a life, and a better life, with a family who recognizes that all children are gifts. There are families who desperately desire more children, who will raise the child as their own, and society benefits and endures when it has another life to cherish and nurture.


These are not radical changes, as they were once the norm, and the direction that we have reengineered in society is the abomination we should work to destroy. We can and should do it carefully, without reintroducing the flaws that caused us to eliminate it in the first place, which led us in this wrong direction, with all its unintended, but predicted consequences.

Those are just a few of the issues and I hope the above illustrates the conservative approach to addressing them, as opposed to the progressive method of imposing artificial values on us that undermine our authority, as well as distort our ability to live happily.

What I have described above is secular conservatism, where secular retains its original meaning and is not (as it is often used today) a euphemism or guise for being "anti-religious." Secular is defined as distinctly different from religion, i.e., that which is not religious, but it is like an agnostic, who recognizes that the secular realm and the religious realm must and can co-exist.

Our values and our culture may have been passed along by religion initially, but it evolved into a secular culture and society, that coexists with religion (and religious diversity). Co-existence demands that each be respected, but each resides in a separate sphere, even if they may also co-reside in the head of a single individual. Co-existance does not mean that one has primacy over the other, only that the spheres do not cross or intrude where one is not appropriate.
"And Jesus answering said unto them, Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's. And they marvelled at him."

- The Book of Mark 12:17, New Testament (King James version)



People may continue to choose to believe that the source of our culture and values is religion and their God's Commandments, but there is also secular evidence to prove that their ways are often the better ways, and better directions and destination. The data demonstrates so convincingly and without exception that family and children are the way to go, and the only way that our liberated and free society can endure.

When I read of progressive ideas of using judicial activism to alter society in the direction of socialism or communism, I reflect on how dangerous and anti-liberty and anti-freedom that is.

Freedom cannot be given to people, as one might pass out chocolate. It is so simple, but it is so easily missed and misunderstood: Liberty must be earned and maintained with respect for law, mutual liberty, and the property of others.

Liberty, prosperity, and happiness is something that an individual in a society earns, supported, encouraged, and enabled by a society's foundations for respect of the pursuit of happiness.

An individual (their soul, self-esteem, and respect) is destroyed when these things are handed to them without conditions and without effort.

Happiness is not defined by license, of doing all that feels good and making selfish choices, or being handed the things that others have without earning them, but in recognition that we are temporary, that what we are/have is what we earned ourselves, and it is for future generations (and our own) that we restrain ourselves, and guide all that we do.

Being stewards of liberty requires a respect for individual conscience (both religious and secular), the love of children, respecting the property and privacy of others, and the protection of the sacred and valuable intuition of marriage. It is in those values and ideals where true happiness (not temporary satiation) is found. It may not be the same degree of sacredness or joy, or even the same definitions or rules for everyone, but marriage, and the responsibility for our progeny is what we must, gradually and carefully, return to.

"We" end when we stop producing children. Society and our culture is precious and anything we do or wish to achieve must be done carefully, and gradually, and we must earn and rise to it.

We protect and allow our society to continue by demanding that government respond to what we want and desire. We reject a government that initiates change on its own. We determine the change we want, without government meddling, unless we specifically ask for it.

Society's goals and the direction that society chooses to go have not been ceded to the government to determine for us. We must refuse to progressives the goals of eroding our values, of using government as the method of imposing change on us, or to force their failed ideologies and restrictions on the liberty and prosperity that we have ourselves earned.

We must reject all incarnations and intrusions of it, forcefully.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

When a Rose Stinks

From Veronique de Rugy quoting Gov. Mark Sanford (The Corner on National Review Online, Gov. Mark Sanford in Defense of Libertarians, May 18, 2009):
"...Throw me in that briar patch, I’m guilty. I love liberty... I’ve been accused of being a libertarian, and I... wear it as a badge of honor. Because I do love, believe in, and want to support liberty."

That would all be puppies and kittens if it made any sense, but since libertarianism is wholly inconsistent with conservatism, it doesn't: Any form of radicalism is inconsistant with conservatism.

Low-Hanging Fruit

The reference, I assume, relates to the allegiances within the Republican Party tent. In that sense, including libertarians isn't a bad thing, anymore than including conservative Democrats is inconsistent with furthering our shared goals. If, however, we're defining conservatism, libertarian has no place in the definition.

Suggesting that libertarians are the only ones who get to claim a love of liberty is a bit specious (as well as arrogant). It would be as if someone suggested that only those in the Republican Party love our republic, or only those in the Democratic Party support a democratic outcome of elections. Simply because you share a word origin with a lofty concept, it doesn't mean you have exclusive rights and claim to to the root word.

It's the Type, Stupid

Within the social universe there are many types and categories of liberty, but I'll not focus on those here. What we're discussing is the socio-political aspect of liberty.

  1. Emotionally Glorified, Unfettered Liberty: Libertarianism focuses on Utopian or unfettered liberty, where a society has no moral claim or right to restrict the actions of another person, except by the artificial and ideologically-invented construct of causing physical harm. Libertarianism uses the infamous cliche, "your right to swing your arm stops at my nose," to define the outward limit of the restraint of liberty. Libertarianism is an ideological theory of how liberty should be applied universally, with an idealized version of liberty, having no bearing on reality or praticality, and no downside. It's a nice pipe dream, but it doesn't help us very much other than to make us feel proud of ourselves, or morally superior to the ideology of others. Feelings have no place in establishing or evaluating the effects of public policy.
     
     

  2. Pragmatic Liberty: Conservatism can be as emotionally-charged with marketing memes as the next political theory, but that generally focuses on conservatism in the abstract, not as it was defined by the men who first championed the idea: as an approach to how government should align itself with the people of a given society and culture. Ordered liberty (an oxymoron in the philosophy of libertarianism) is the goal of conservatism, i.e., the outcome of public policy should be good for most, without unnecessarily restraining the few, while recognizing and trying to find a balance of the practicality of imposing a change on a society that does not have the social history or mores to handle it.




Cause and Effect

If a blind man is put in a room he has never been in before without his cane, it would be reasonable to posit that he would bang his shins. Depending on the capriciousness of man, he could go so far as to fall and break his leg, or split his head open from a fall, and die. We could go so far as to suggest that it might not be the best way to introduce the man to his new surroundings. It would be theoretically pure, from the perspective of recognizing his liberty, to allow him to do it. Ideological purity belongs in church pews and children's fairy tales, not in the analysis of public policy.

Conservatives then, are not interested in recognizing the man's liberty alone. They balance his liberty with his ability. Conservatives would ask that the blind man's introduction to the room be with his cane, or with a trusted friend or family member to acclimate him to his surroundings, before he is left alone to explore it further. It isn't necessary to go so far as to coddle him, but it is necessary to recognize his blindness as a factor in our approach.

There are degrees of blindness, just as there are degrees of sightedness. A one-size-fits-all policy for the above doesn't work, either for the blind or the sighted: A policy that assumes that all are blind would unnecessarily restrain the sighted. Conversely, one that assumes that all men are sighted would unnecessarily allow harm to come to the blind. Theoretically then, it requires nuance to find a balance of liberty for each person, based on his abilities.

So, too, with cultures and societies. All societies and cultures are not the same, nor do they share the same experiences to allow them to handle the world in the same way. It is, therefore, just as cruel and wrongheaded to impose too much liberty on a society as it is to impose too much rigidity and structure.  Societies and cultures evolve, so it is necessary for a government to evolve with it, but nothing should be imposed (too quickly, carelessly or too soon).  If there is a change of law or policy, the person who hears about it should be surprised that it wasn't always that way, as the person's beliefs, opinions and experience should have evolved to the point of acceptance, without conflict or apprehension.  If the response is one of shock or alarm, then the society/individual has not evolved to it. It may be ready in a year, a decade, or never, depending on the severity of the change suggested, and the evolution of the society/culture in their historical and social path.

The French Revolution Debates

During the French Revolution, a great debate occurred among the Founding Fathers (specifically Washington, Adams, Jefferson, Paine, and Hamilton), and also foreign intellectual theorists and statesmen, including Alexander de Toqueville, the Marquis de Lafayette ("General Lafayette") and the father of modern conservatism, Edmund Burke. The debate was not without controversy, nor were all the men involved restrained in their actions to destroy the character of those on the opposite side of the issue.  In other words, it got ugly and nasty, but with oh, such much more panache and flare than our petty and vulgar disagreements today.

What all the men agreed on was the idea/ideal of a liberated France. In that sense, they were more in agreement on the big issue than Americans are today on the idea/ideal of a free society.   In contrast, however, America, England ("Britain" in the larger sense), and France were at different stages of their evolution:

  • America had fought, won, and was in the process of keeping its liberated society, after a previous 200 year history of self-government and self-reliance, fostered by the distance of the mother country, and accidental brilliance on the part of the early Puritan settlers to form social compacts, rather than tyrannical structures of order.

  • England had limited the powers and authority of its monarch, establishing an elected parliament, while still maintaining the monarchy as a figurehead for social consistency.  It had decades of experience in developing statesmen and had a populace who had grown accustomed to restraining itself.

  • France, on the other hand, had no such history.   It was about as pure as a monarchy as a society can get.  While there were up and comers, men who had supported and assisted America during its revolution, and certainly no shortage of passionate intellectuals and theorists, it had no statesmen ready to assume authority with the experience necessary to show restraint, nor any mechanism by which to accelerate the machinations necessary to create them.  France had no history of a constitution, a bill of rights, nor a social compact.


France, unlike America or Britain, was just not ready for liberation, and the fact that they quickly dissolved into a murderous mob and assumed authoritarian-rule as quick as a blink, demonstrated the wisdom of those who thought, at the time, that they just weren't ready for it.

The debates at the time included accusations that the men who were unwilling to support France were hypocrites or authoritarians (impugning their character), but that was simply not the case.  There were also arguments (mostly from Jefferson) that suggested that Americans owed a debt to France, because of their assistance in our Revolution, but that argument was one of emotion, not pragmatics. Jefferson, after seeing how quickly the guillotine replaced the gavel and round table, wavered in his support of the French, but his idealism for the spread of liberty was consistent throughout his life. It is clear from his writing at different times of his life, however, that he'd have wished the outcome could have been otherwise:
&quot;It is difficult to conceive how so good a people, with so good a King [as Louis XVI of France], so well-disposed rulers in general, so genial a climate, so fertile a soil, should be rendered so ineffectual for producing human happiness by one single curse--that of a bad form of government. But it is a fact; in spite of the mildness of their governors, the people are ground to powder by the vices of the form of government. Of twenty millions of people supposed to be in France, I am of opinion there are nineteen millions more wretched, more accursed in every circumstance of human existence than the most conspicuously wretched individual of the whole United States.&quot; --Thomas Jefferson to Elizabeth Trist, 1785. ME 5:81, Papers 8:568 

"It is difficult to conceive how so good a people, with so good a King [as Louis XVI of France], so well-disposed rulers in general, so genial a climate, so fertile a soil, should be rendered so ineffectual for producing human happiness by one single curse--that of a bad form of government. But it is a fact; in spite of the mildness of their governors, the people are ground to powder by the vices of the form of government. Of twenty millions of people supposed to be in France, I am of opinion there are nineteen millions more wretched, more accursed in every circumstance of human existence than the most conspicuously wretched individual of the whole United States."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1785




"In the struggle which was necessary [in France], many guilty persons fell without the forms of trial, and with them some innocent. These I deplore as much as anybody, and shall deplore some of them to the day of my death. But I deplore them as I should have done had they fallen in battle."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1793 



There was a desire to spread the cause of freedom.  That passion is understandable, but it is also wrong-headed, without the social and political fabric in place to support it.  The other side of the debate felt that Europe dissolving into repeated and unsuccessful revolutions would be destabilizing, for the nations involved, as well as our own interests abroad.  

It was Jefferson who championed the idea of Manifest Destiny, and it is the destiny of the world.  Destiny, like liberty itself, cannot be imposed, but it can be fostered and nurtured.  It must reveal itself as a seedling, with good soil and loving care, breaks through the soil to breathe free.

From these debates we can learn two things (as well as many others, but irrelevant to this topic):

  1. The Founding Fathers were not against "foreign entanglements" in the abstract.  They were against intrusion into the petty disagreements between monarchs.  Just as France was unwilling to assist the Americans in revolution, until there was a reasonable prospect of success, the Founding Fathers were unwilling to engage in fueds between warlords, but they were perfectly willing to support liberation, if it had a chance of success and brought long term stability.

  2. Freedom is earned.


Learning to Walk

When we teach a child to walk we remain close by during their initial steps. In the strictest sense, we are coddling the child, but our motivation and intentions are not to coddle, but to protect and encourage the goal of walking. That protection prevents the child from hurting themselves so they are not discouraged from walking. If we protect too much then the child doesn't learn the outcome of a misstep or the dangers of walking too much, too soon. The goal, of course, is that the child will eventually walk on his own, without harnesses, crash helmets, or bumper guards. When we stand clear, and how soon we give the child greater latitude, depends not on an artificial construct of development charts and median outcomes, but on the specific child who is learning to walk. So, too, with liberty: You have to earn it, not by an artificial construct of how much is the ideologically pure amount, but how much a person can handle without the extremes coddling or recklessness.

The ultimate goal of conservatism is liberty, but it is practically limited to what an individual and society can handle at a given time in their development/evolution. In other words, conservatives are patient in their pursuit, like the tortoise against the contrast of the libertarian-hare.  The goal of libertarianism is liberty, too, but it wants to drop it on society as the blindman is thrown into a new room. It is unnecessarily harsh and reckless, and its outcome will not be liberty. It will be chaos and then tyranny... just like post-revolutionary France.

Customized Approach and Intellectual Laziness

It is not uncommon for libertarians to assume the moral high ground. After all, they're the ones who champion liberty... to the exclusion of all others, they assume.  The arrogance in Gov. Sanford's statement is just the type of presumption of superiority that typifies the claim to moral higher ground to which I refer.  

When one confronts the libertarian-indoctrined, it is not unusual to find them spewing forth with platitudes about the purity of the theory, believing it to be a blueprint for how we should all behave, lest we be lumped in with other less-than-intellectual dunderheads: If we understood it, then we would, of course, be libertarians ourselves. Since we conservatives do not share their faith in unfettered liberty, we are, by default, simplistic, socialist and/or fascist desiring overloads, incapable of intellectual thought or reason. Conservatives do not disagree with the goal, only the way the goal is achieved.

It is libertarianism that is intellectually lazy, as it provides a one-size-fits-all, faith-based rule to determine whether an action is good or bad.  Faith is the bastion of belief, without the requirement of analysis, evaluation or proof.  The evaluation of issues by libertarians is done in a vacuum, without the messy details of reality or recent- or long term- history.  It can ignore sociology, psychology, and physics as well.  Libertarianism has it all sewed up in a nice neat box: if it is liberty, then it is good.  If it is not liberty, then it is bad. There are no shades of gray or nuance, and no practical analysis of the cause and effect, nor any recognition that there are unintended consequences. In fact, it is most often in the libertarian campsites where the concept of unintended consequences is pushed in the logical fallacy closet, rather than the cause and effect light of day.

There is no one-size-fits-all analysis and contemplation for every issue, problem, or challenge that faces an individual or a society. Each one has to be evaluated on its own, with a careful, honest, and unemotionally-charged analysis of its pros and cons, its strengths and weaknesses, and its reasonableness as it applies to the given society or culture it would be placed on.  In other words, analysis isn't trumped by ideologically purity, nor a slogan.  It isn't easy to do that work every time, which is why the hard work is least favored over the mantras and memes of faith-based ideologies such as libertarianism. Just as Democrats like to refer to conservatives as "the party of NO" libertarians share the belief that saying "no" to unfettered liberty is a distraction rather than a requirement of the thoughtful, reasonable, and intelligent.

It is possible for libertarians and conservatives to share a political tent, and work together to fend off the tide of fascism and progressivism, but it is ridiculous to propose that two ideological opposite approaches to the making of public policy are consistent, or that one is a subset/subordinate of the other.

Radicalism, either to impose liberty or tyranny, has no place in the definition of conservatism.

Why and how to achieve it, not what you believe in or support is what matters in the definitions.

"You hope, Sir, that I think the French deserving of liberty.  I certainly do.  I certainly think that all men who desire it deserve it.  It is not the reward of merit, or the acquisition of our industry. It is our inheritance. It is the birthright of our species. We cannot forfeit our right to it but by what forfeits our title to the privileges of our kind. I mean abuse, or oblivion, of our rational faculties, and a ferocious indocility which makes us prompt to wrong and violence, destroys our social nature, and transforms us into something little better than the description of wild beasts. To men so degraded, a state of strong constraint is a sort of necessary substitute for freedom; since, bad as it is, it may deliver them in some measure from the worst of all slavery--that is, the despotism of their own blind and brutal passions.


You have kindly said that you began to love freedom from your intercourse with me.  Permit me then to continue our conversation, and to tell You what the freedom is that I love and that to which I think all men intitled. It is not solitary, unconnected, individual, selfish Liberty. As if every Man was to regulate the whole of his Conduct by his own will. The Liberty I mean is a social freedom. It is in that state of things in which Liberty is secured by the equality of Restraint; A Constitution of things in which the liberty of no one Man, and no body of Men and no Number of men can find Means to trespass on the liberty of any Person or any description of Persons in the Society. This kind of liberty is indeed but another name for Justice, ascertained by wise Laws, and secured by well constructed institutions. I am sure, that Liberty, so incorporated, and in a manner, identified, with justice, must be infinitely dear to every one, who is capable of conceiving what it is. But whenever a separation is made between Liberty and Justice, neither is, in my opinion, safe.  I do not believe that men ever did submit, certain I am sure they never ought to have submitted, to the arbitrary pleasure of one man; but, under circumstances in which the arbitrary pleasure of many persons in the community pressed with an intolerable hardship upon the just and equal rights of their fellows, such a choice might be made, as among evils.  The moment will is set above reason and justice, in any community, a great question may arise in sober minds in what part or portion of the community that dangerous dominion of will may be the least mischievously placed.


If I think all men who cultivate justice entitled to liberty, and, when joined in states, entitled to a constitution framed to perpetuate and secure it, you may be assured, sir, that I think your countrymen eminently worthy of a blessing which is peculiarly adapted to noble, generous, and humane natures. Such I found the French when, more than fifteen years ago, I had the happiness, though but for too short a time, of visiting your country; and I trust their character is not altered since that period.


I have nothing to check my wishes towards the establishment of solid and rational scheme of liberty in France.  On the subject of the relative power of nations I may have my prejudices; but I envy internal freedom, security, and good order to none. When, therefore, I shall hear that, in France, the citizen, by whatever description he is qualified, is in the perfect state of legal security with regard to his life, to his property, to the uncontrolled disposal of his person, to the free use of his industry and his faculties: when I hear that he is protected in the beneficial employment of estates to which, by the course of settled law, he was born, or is provided with a fair compensation for them, that he is maintained in the full fruition of the advantages belonging to the state and condition of life in which he had lawfully engaged himself, or is supplied with a substantial, equitable, equivalent: when I am assured that a simple citizen may express his sentiments upon public affairs without hazard to his life or safety, even though against a predominant and fashionable opinion: when I know all this of France, I shall be well pleased as everyone must be who has not forgot the general compense, fear, and humiliation, they shall not be put to judge on the lives, liberties, properties, or estimate of their fellow-citizens; when they are not called upon to put any man to his trial upon undefined crimes of state, not ascertained by any previous rule, statute, or course of precedent; when victims shall not be snatched from the fury of the people to be brought before a tribunal, itself subject to the effects of the same fury, and where the acquittal of parties accused might only place the judge in the situation of the criminal; when I see tribunals placed in this state of independence of everything but law, and with clear law for their direction, as a true lover of equal justice (under the shadow of which alone true liberty can live) I shall rejoice in seeing such a happy order established in France, as much as I do in my consciousness than an order of the same kind, or one not very remote from it, has been long settled, and I hope on a firm foundation, in England.  I am not so narrow-minded as to be unable to conceive that the same object may be attained in many ways, and perhaps in ways very different from those which we have followed in this country.  If this real practical liberty, with a government powerful to protect, impotent to evade it, be established, or is in a fair train of being established in the democracy, or rather collection of democracies, which seems to be chosen for the future frame of society in France, it is not my having long enjoyed a sober share of freedom, under a qualified monarchy, that shall render me incapable of admiring and praising your system of republics.  I should rejoice, even though England should hereafter be reckoned only as one among the happy nations, and should no longer retain her proud distinction, her monopoly of fame for a practical constitution in which the grand secret had been found of reconciling a government of real energy for all foreign and domestic purpose with the most perfect security to the liberty and safety of individuals.  That government, whatever its name or form may be, that shall be found substantially and practically to unite these advantages will most merit the applause of all discerning men."


Edmund Burke, (Letter to Charles Jean-Francois Depont on the French Revolution), 1789



H/t Instapundit.