Showing posts with label Amendment 4. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Amendment 4. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

Dog in This Fight

From Frances Gibb (Times Online, Ruling on NightJack author Richard Horton kills blogger anonymity, June 17, 2009):
But Mr Justice Eady said that the mere fact that the blogger wanted to remain anonymous did not mean that he had a “reasonable expectation” of doing so or that The Times was under an enforceable obligation to him to maintain that anonymity.

There are aspects of this case (and this ruling) that are difficult.  I can understand the argument about a reasonable expectation of privacy not being met when someone blogs.  However:
In the first case dealing with the privacy of internet bloggers, the judge ruled that Mr Horton had no “reasonable expectation” to anonymity because “blogging is essentially a public rather than a private activity”.

Does this mean that someone who gives information to a newspaper, that is also "a public rather than a private activity" should expect the same?  Newspapers are public, too.  If we extend this decision to its logical conclusion, that would mean that "unnamed sources" have no reasonable expectation of privacy either.  The court seems to be saying that--using the argument that having someone in the press makes moot any desire for privacy.  That's seems to be the end justifies the mean argument.

I'm surprised the Times UK would want the courts to come to that conclusion.

If someone wants to spend time trying to figure out who I am, more power to them. I haven't said anything controversial or named any names, so I doubt someone would bother.  As a thought experiment though, I would make no attempts to sue or use the courts to prevent them from disclosing that information, but it follows then that no one should have a reasonable expectation of privacy when they say or tell anything to a reporter or any press outlet.  Everyone is now fair game.

I doubt the Times UK would find that a desirable outcome. They appear to have won the battle, but lost the war.

Friday, May 15, 2009

Garbage Out Damn Spot

From Dick Brennan (MYFOXNY.com, Dead People Get Stimulus Checks, May 14, 2009):
This week, thousands of people are getting stimulus checks in the mail. The problem is that a lot of them are dead. A Long Island woman was shocked when she checked the mail and received a letter from the U.S. Treasury -- but it wasn't for her.

The above story (h/t Drudge) is all over the news.  The fact that the government sent out checks to dead people is a serious problem, but not the main problem.

The U.S government doesn't have accurate records of who we all are, nor should it.  Unless we initiate contact with the government (to get a passport, a social security number, file our taxes, etc.) the government needs to mind its own business.

I'm fully aware that this hands-off/butt-out idea makes it very difficult when the government wants to do things like send out checks or gather other information, but that's just too damned bad.  The Fourth Amendment hasn't been reversed.  The government has no authority to keep lists like these.  They are forbidden from doing so.

What is most concerning about these types of reports is that it lends an air of suspicion to other contact points.  Are these long dead people showing up on voting rolls?  Are there people getting Social Security or other entitlement checks in these people's names? Somehow these names got on a list, and we can only speculate on how that happened or the nefarious uses for those lists.

This is another reason why the government engaging in something like a blanket send of checks is such a bad idea (without first requiring that the citizens engage in a validation process to ensure that they are qualified to receive them).  Obviously, the dead people receiving these checks didn't file a tax return and haven't qualified for Social Security either (for a long time). Why were they on the list?