Thursday, August 13, 2009

Spilt Milk

From Mort Zuckerman (NY Daily News, Drowning in debt: Obama's spending and borrowing leaves U.S. gasping for air, August 9, 2009):
The Government Accountability Office estimates that by 2040, interest payments will absorb 30% of all revenues and entitlements will consume the rest, leaving nothing for defense, education or veterans' pensions.

I know that many economic folks are predicting that we'll recover from this recession on X date or Y quarter, but I think they're wrong.

There is no recovery from this amount of debt. The only recovery is to stop spending and no special interest group is going to give up their entitlements.  More from Mr. Zuckerman:
Everybody is dazed and confused by all this talk of additional indebtedness in the trillions of dollars. Our soaring national debt will require cataclysmic adjustments to accomplish the restoration of a balance in our fiscal position.

Otherwise, we face a dramatic erosion of U.S. economic and financial standing, raising the risk of skyrocketing interest rates and a crash in the value of the dollar. Americans can no longer rely on their stocks and the soaring value of their homes to put their kids through college and support early retirement. For the first time since the Depression, U.S. companies are not only cutting jobs; they are cutting wages. We are undersaved and underpensioned, and we will have to adjust to a more frugal life.

The Social Security nightmare has hit home and until we address that issue, the recession will remain.

From Shannon Love (Chicago Boy, The Dangers of Decompartmentalized Health Care Spending, August 12, 2009):
The elderly consume 70% of all health-care spending.[updated here and here] That means that when it comes to cost control they will bear the brunt of the burden. If we don’t cut spending on the elderly we can’t reduce costs without simply denying care for everyone else. When it comes down to a choice between spending on old people and children, the elderly know full well who we are going to pick. The elderly themselves will choose to spend money on their grandchildren rather than themselves.

It doesn't appear that this Congress or this Administration is serious. Sane people knew that giving the debt keys to a Democratic Congress was a stupid mistake, but this isn't a mistake that can be solved simply by voting in Republicans next term.  The money will be spent and the debt will be there to be paid off.  The debt remains, even if the legislators are no longer home.

And speaking of no longer home (Alan Zibel, AP/Yahoo News, Foreclosures rise 7 percent in July from June, August 13, 2009):
WASHINGTON – The number of U.S. households on the verge of losing their homes rose 7 percent from June to July, as the escalating foreclosure crisis continued to outpace government efforts to limit the damage.

Foreclosure filings were up 32 percent from the same month last year, RealtyTrac Inc. said Thursday. More than 360,000 households, or one in every 355 homes, received a foreclosure-related notice, such as a notice of default or trustee's sale. That's the highest monthly level since the foreclosure-listing firm began publishing the data more than four years ago.

Ugly things are likely to happen before this is truly solved. I'm not advocating it, only forecasting the truth.

H/t Instapundit (here, here, and here.)

Monday, August 10, 2009

Feeding Frenzy

As this article from Freep.com (Detroit Free Press, Tempers flare over health care plan, August 7, 2009), there is a kind of feeding frenzy occurring over the socialized medicine Bill.  Regardless of how this is decided, people are angry.  But the type of bitterness we're seeing over the health care issue is irreconcilable, as there are factions on both sides of the issue who are unwilling to compromise.

One camp believes that health care is a right, and a prosperous nation (like ourselves) has some sort of duty to provide health insurance to every citizen.

The other camp believes that extending health insurance to everyone is a bad idea, while at the same time, crying foul when there are solutions presented to address the insolvency of social security or medicare.

The reality is somewhere in the middle, but "middle" is seldom how these issues are decided, which means that the divide and conquer approach (i.e., the building of waring factions) is how the political class will decide the matter.  Social security and medicare ARE insolvent and some sort of rationing or means testing will have to be decided at some point.  If we'd never created Social Security or Medicare, we wouldn't be having this discussion, nor would we have the problems they create (both economically and politically).  Once we have a government entitlement program, the press (and the politicians) always have a crying mother being stripped of her child or an old granny living on cat food to create photo-ops for the opposing side.    It is damned near impossible to get rid of a government revenue stream once it is in place.

This is not a new method of handling a matter among the political classes.  Creating issues to create a tug-o-war is not unique to the health care debate.

The abortion issue is exactly the same.

  1. We have the not ever camp.

  2. We have the only if camp.

  3. We have the what's wrong with it, abortion shouldn't have moral considerations camp.


We can change the words, ever so slightly, for issues like school prayer.  Education has become political, where the political classes war over the hearts and minds, just as the health care issue is becoming politicized.  Regardless of how the health care issue is eventually decided, there will be winners and losers, if we allow the government to realize the objective of making it something the government involves itself.

Imagine, for just a moment, that there were no public schools. There might be a chattering class arguing for the creation of something like it, but we'd have developed other methods of addressing it.  Most parents, the vast middle class, would pay for cheap schools (probably chain type corporations offering mediocre, but not awful programs at an affordable price).  There would be a larger market for more expensive private schools, with the private sector donating to charities to allow poor children with prowess to attend them. The most the government might do is to allow everyone (rich and poor) to deduct the cost of education from their taxes.  We wouldn't get to the point where we'd discuss the pros and cons of vouchers, because the government wouldn't have inserted itself in the process to make it a compromise solution to a terrible problem.

The larger point is that education would not be a political issue.  There would be no arguments about prayer in school, the teaching of sex education, or if evolution or creationism should be taught. Each parent would make those decisions and it wouldn't create caverns between political camps.  Sure, people would have their opinions on the various subjects, but each wouldn't be able to remake the Jack Booted Thug the enforcer of their opinion.

Abortion is still a huge issue today.  If Roe v Wade had not been decided the way it had, each state would still be making the decision about its legality.  Planned Parenthood and NARAL would be running cheap abortion flights or shuttle buses from Mississippi to California, with protestors standing on the runways to try to prevent women from boarding the planes.  But, it wouldn't be a divisive issue at the national level, creating a situation where one party supports X and the other party supports -X.

I want Y, not the binary choice of X or -X.

If, for no other reason than the above, the health care issue should not become any more political than it is.  When the government controls the issue or delivers the service, the people will always be arguing about who should get what, as sharks fight over prey when they smell blood. They'll stop considering the option of the government not being involved at all, and allowing the private sector to handle the matter.  The private sector will no longer be a viable solution in its entirety, because the government's intrusion in the matter will have broken down parts of the infrastructure which allow it.

We already have enough issues to divide us.  Government-run health care, especially given the enormity of the costs and the life/death aspect adding fuel to emotions, is the last thing we need. In other words, the last thing we need is for the government to get involved at all.  The government will, inevitably, screw it up and where a politician stands on that issue will become a party platform, forcing people to choose one extreme position or the other, with suggestions and schemes on how to fix the mess.  If the government doesn't get involved at all, then there will be nothing to fix.  It will still be a mess, because few things are ever perfect, but the government just makes enemies of us all.

In 20 years, do we really want a politician's worthiness to be determined by how they'd decide on a particular health care rationing decision?  We're protesting for or against inclusion of heart transplants or cesareans at the national level?  That's what will happen if we create any additional government health care entitlements.

Chamber Music

In this little symphony by Andrew Klavan (City Journal, Romanticon by Andrew Klavan, August 10, 2009), he manages to merge the old and the new in a way that leaves the soul yearning for more:
It was, for Wordsworth, what the failure of Communism was for the radicals of a later day. He could no longer deny the error inherent in “speculative schemes— / That promised to abstract the hopes of Man.” He saw the Revolution as a dream that “flattered the young, pleased with extremes” and made “Reason’s naked self / The object of its fervour.” Confused by pure reason’s failure as a moral guide, he “lost / All feeling of conviction” and “yielded up moral questions in despair.” Slowly, he began to do the brave and difficult thing: to admit he had been wrong and change his mind.

RTWT.

We can only hope that the revolutionaries of our day will find the courage to "change his mind."

When conservatives fret about having to rebuild their party, they should take heart. None of this is new. If, however, they attempt to recreate the sensationalism of the Democrat's success and continue to fall victim to the cult of personality and populism, rather than an earnest rebuilding effort of our intellectual principles based on Western Civilization's values, we will fail.
Now, just as American reaction to the blatant political failures of sixties radicalism led to the Reagan revolution and the long dominance of political conservatism here, so, too, British reaction to the French Revolution led to 20 years of Tory rule. But neither Reaganism nor Toryism could ultimately disguise the fact that a profound and fundamental change in human outlook and attitude had taken place—a change that the sixties and the French Revolution represented rather than caused. When the smoke cleared, those who still believed in Western history, traditions, and institutions had to reestablish their relevance and rebuild their foundations in what was essentially a new world.

Friday, August 7, 2009

They're Still Campaigning

(More on the First Amendment violations of the "fishy" email requests by the White House.)

During the run up to the election, the Obama campaign effectively used electronic media. Most of us know how successful that was in getting out Obama's talking points as well as fund raising. Later revelations of the JournoList and the use of paid ACORN protesters were seen as despicable, but they fell within the typical dirty tricks camp of national elections.

What you can do when you're running for office and running a national campaign is entirely different from what you can do once you're in office. The then Senator Obama could not have solicited input on Americans who were exercising their free speech in declaring their concerns about Candidate Obama, but the Democratic Party hacks could have done that.

Seven months into President Obama's Administration, the staff at the White House are still behaving as if they're on the campaign trail. That was obvious to many, as the constant press conferences and stump speeches are signs that President Obama is still behaving as Candidate Obama.

But the White House Blog request for notification of "fishy" communications is unconstitutional for a member of government. I, as a private citizen, could ask for that information because the limitations on Free Speech don't apply to private citizens. I could set up a mechanism for collecting that information (and even pay people who send me the information). The restriction on limiting speech applies only to the government.

The Supreme Court has decided the matter in the past. Federal law prevents keeping a database on private citizens.

I would love to believe that the staffers at the White House Blog were intentionally engaging in a conspiracy to supress the free speech of citizens by setting up the "fishy" reporting mechanism, but that gives this Administration too much credit. They're not that clever. Rather, they're still in campaign mode, and are too stupid to know that they have violated one of American citizens' most precious liberties.

Sen. John Cornyn wrote a letter to the Obama Administration regarding the matter:
Dear President Obama,

I write to express my concern about a new White House program to monitor American citizens' speech opposing your health care policies, and to seek your assurances that this program is being carried out in a manner consistent with the First Amendment and America's tradition of free speech and public discourse.

Yesterday, in an official White House release entitled "Facts are Stubborn Things," the White House Director of New Media, Macon Phillips, asserted that there was "a lot of disinformation out there," and encouraged citizens to report "fishy" speech opposing your health care policies to the White House. Phillips specifically targeted private, unpublished, even casual speech, writing that "rumors often travel just below the surface via chain emails or through casual conversation." Phillips wrote "If you get an email or see something on the web about health insurance reform that seems fishy, send it to flag@whitehouse.gov."
I am not aware of any precedent for a President asking American citizens to report their fellow citizens to the White House for pure political speech that is deemed "fishy" or otherwise inimical to the White House's political interests.

By requesting that citizens send "fishy" emails to the White House, it is inevitable that the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and private speech of U.S. citizens will be reported to the White House. You should not be surprised that these actions taken by your White House staff raise the specter of a data collection program. As Congress debates health care reform and other critical policy matters, citizen engagement must not be chilled by fear of government monitoring the exercise of free speech rights.

I can only imagine the level of justifiable outrage had your predecessor asked Americans to forward emails critical of his policies to the White House. I suspect that you would have been leading the charge in condemning such a program-and I would have been at your side denouncing such heavy-handed government action.

So I urge you to cease this program immediately. At the very least, I request that you detail to Congress and the public the protocols that your White House is following to purge the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and identities of citizens who are reported to have engaged in "fishy" speech. And I respectfully request an answer to the following:

  • How do you intend to use the names, email addresses, IP addresses, and identities of citizens who are reported to have engaged in "fishy" speech?

  • How do you intend to notify citizens who have been reported for "fishy" speech?

  • What action do you intend to take against citizens who have been reported for engaging in "fishy" speech?

  • Do your own past statements qualify as "disinformation"? For example, is it "disinformation" to note that in 2003 you said:"I happen to be a proponent of a single-payer universal health care plan"?


I look forward to your prompt response.

Sincerely,
JOHN CORNYN
United States Senator

I suspect that no criminal charges will be filed, but ignorance of the law is not an excuse (especially by members of the government, and more especially the Office of the President as one of the primary duties of the President is to enforce the laws, not violate them), and the Obama Administration has committed a crime simply by creating this fishing hole (what they do with the information received is adding to the existing crime).

Sen. Cornyn got it exactly right and I hope that his cease and desist letter will be enough to get the program stopped. It won't stop the other crimes, misdemeanors, and constitutional violations being perpetrated by this Administration, but it is a good start.

During the campaign we were told that Obama had sufficient experience to hit the bricks running. The problem, of course, is that he didn't. He's running, but it is a still a campaign not an Administration.
In every stage of these Oppressions We have Petitioned for Redress in the most humble terms: Our repeated Petitions have been answered only by repeated injury. A Prince, whose character is thus marked by every act which may define a Tyrant, is unfit to be the ruler of a free people.

-- Thomas Jefferson, Declaration of Independence


Thursday, August 6, 2009

All Your Emails Belong to Us

The recent news that the White House wants to be sent emails that spread "misinformation" about the socialized medicine bill is too crazy to parody (Macon Phillips, White House Blog, August 4, 2009):
Facts Are Stubborn Things

Opponents of health insurance reform may find the truth a little inconvenient, but as our second president famously said, "facts are stubborn things."

Scary chain emails and videos are starting to percolate on the internet [sic], breathlessly claiming, for example, to "uncover" the truth about the President’s health insurance reform positions.

In this video, Linda Douglass, the communications director for the White House’s Health Reform Office, addresses one example that makes it look like the President intends to "eliminate" private coverage, when the reality couldn’t be further from the truth.

For the record, the President has consistently said that if you like your insurance plan, your doctor, or both, you will be able to keep them. He has even proposed eight consumer protections relating specifically to the health insurance industry.

There is a lot of disinformation about health insurance reform out there, spanning from control of personal finances to end of life care. These rumors often travel just below the surface via chain emails or through casual conversation. Since we can’t keep track of all of them here at the White House, we’re asking for your help. If you get an email or see something on the web about health insurance reform that seems fishy, send it to flag@whitehouse.gov.

[Emphasis mine.]

There are so many ways that the White House could have worded the above to make it appear less Orwellian and Hitlerian.  Just about everything this Administration (and Congress) are doing is like something from The Onion.

The White House Blog includes videos of people saying that the Health Care Bill won't become a single-payer program.

So what does the Bill actually say?

SEC. 102. PROTECTING THE CHOICE TO KEEP CURRENT COVERAGE (pg 16):
(a) GRANDFATHERED HEALTH INSURANCE COVERAGE DEFINED.—Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, for purposes of establishing acceptable coverage under this division, the term ‘‘grandfathered health insurance coverage’’ means individual health insurance coverage that is offered and in force and effect before the first day of Y1 if the following conditions are met:

(1) LIMITATION ON NEW ENROLLMENT.—


(A) IN GENERAL.—Except as provided in this paragraph, the individual health insurance issuer offering such coverage does not enroll any individual in such coverage if the first effective date of coverage is on or after the first day of Y1.



[Emphasis mine.]

So it is "misinformation" to suggest that the Bill doesn't gradually eliminate private insurance policies, yet the Bill itself requires that no new members are added to the rolls of private insurance after "Y1" date.

Pg 19:
(1) IN GENERAL.—Individual health insurance coverage that is not grandfathered health insurance coverage under subsection (a) may only be offered on or after the first day of Y1 as an Exchange-participating health benefits plan.

To decipher what the above means, we have to go to pg. 10:
(13) HEALTH INSURANCE EXCHANGE.—The term ‘‘Health Insurance Exchange’’ means the Health Insurance Exchange established under section 201.

Alright, I'll play.  What does section 201 include?

Section 201 says (pg. 74):
(c) TRANSITION.—Individuals and employers shall only be eligible to enroll or participate in the Health Insurance Exchange in accordance with the following transition schedule:

(1) FIRST YEAR.—In Y1 (as defined in section 100(c))


(A) individuals described in subsection (d)(1), including individuals described in paragraphs (3) and (4) of subsection (d); and (B) smallest employers described in subsection (e)(1).


(2) SECOND YEAR.—In Y2—



(A) individuals and employers described in
paragraph (1); and (B) smaller employers described in subsection (e)(2).

(3) THIRD AND SUBSEQUENT YEARS.—


In Y3 and subsequent years—



(A) individuals and employers described in
paragraph (2); and

(B) larger employers as permitted by the
Commissioner under subsection (e)(3).


Good Lord! What in the Hell does that mean?  It becomes circular, to the point of distraction.  If single-payer is not the ultimate goal, why do the programs (for which an individual is eligible to enroll) change in Years 1, 2, and 3? It makes no sense.  It appears to read that if you're in a private plan now, you can keep it (unless the government later determines it doesn't meet a standard--and it is up to the Commissar to determine what that standard is), but is it is blurry regarding a job/insurance change after the Bill goes into effect.

Beginning on pg 82, there is a description of a survey that must be conducted by the Health Czar Commissioner.  Later we discover what the survey "report" will enable the Commissioner to do:
(3) REPORT.—Not later than January 1 of Y3, in Y6, and thereafter, the Commissioner shall submit to Congress on the study conducted under this subsection and shall include in such report recommendations regarding changes in standards for Exchange eligibility for individuals and employers.

So, basically, the Commissioner will conduct a study to determine what employers are providing in their health care plans and then the Commissioner will recommend whether or not those programs are adequate to remain eligible.

Based on what criteria?

There are "BASIC, ENHANCED, AND PREMIUM PLANS" described, but not the costs/benefits which must be included as each is up to the Commissioner (not the employer or individual consumer) to determine (pg 85):
IN GENERAL.—The Commissioner shall establish the following standards consistent with this subsection and title I.

At this point, you'd think that the various categories of Small, Medium and Large would be defined, but they're not. They're just descriptive categories that the Commissioner can codify anyway he/she damn well pleases, as long as the benefits/cost sharing get bigger in Medium and Large.

This Bill is long, but its substance is lacking.

In order for an insurance carrier to be included as an "Exchange" provider (and that means any private insurance program, not the one offered by the Federal government or various other public programs), there is a long list of requirements, including (pg 91):
(7) CULTURALLY AND LINGUISTICALLY APPROPRIATE SERVICES AND COMMUNICATIONS.—The entity shall provide for culturally and linguistically appropriate communication and health services.

Orwell is laughing his ass off.

I'm sorry this post is discombobulated, but that's because the Bill is incomprehensible. You can argue just about anything in this Bill, because anything is how it is written (pg. 92).
(4) OVERSIGHT AND ENFORCEMENT RESPONSIBILITIES.

—The Commissioner shall establish processes, in coordination with State insurance regulators, to oversee, monitor, and enforce applicable requirements of this title with respect to QHBP offering entities offering Exchange-participating health benefits plans and such plans, including the marketing of such plans.



And (pg. 88):
(a) CONTRACTING DUTIES.—In carrying out section 201(b)(1) and consistent with this subtitle:

(1) OFFERING ENTITY AND PLAN STANDARDS.—The Commissioner shall—


(A) establish standards necessary to implement the requirements of this title and title I for—


(i) QHBP offering entities for the offering of an Exchange-participating health benefits plan; and (ii) for Exchange-participating health benefits plans; and (B) certify QHBP offering entities and qualified health benefits plans as meeting such standards and requirements of this title and title I for purposes of this subtitle.



They might as well have written "to be determined by the Health Czar at some future date, based on any criteria he/she pleases" on every page after the introduction.

The requirements put on private insurance companies is simply mind-boggling as they're written, with wriggle room for the Health Czar to add any additional requirements they want, at their sole discretion. The Commissioner can deny a carrier based on dozens of defined and yet-to-be-defined criteria, and require Herculean levels of reporting and red tape. Anyone suggesting that this government bureaucracy will reduce medical costs is a liar. The paperwork alone will triple the costs.

There are many doctors who are refusing to take Medicare patients now, because the paperwork is too cumbersome to manage and the payments can take a 120+ days to process.  This Bill burdens the insurance carriers and doctors, by providing greater reporting and "accountability," but "accountability" is to be determined.

It is not unreasonable to speculate that the solution to the red tape created in this Bill would later be "fixed" by creating government-run hospitals (similar to the Veteran's Administration hospitals) with no paperwork requirements--just open the doors and let everyone in.  The result would be something like the Post Office or DMV, with the "quality" of service those institutions are famous for not delivering, or the Dickensian-like monstrosities of the VA.  This is speculation of course, but it is impossible to see how creating this regulatory bureaucracy could be seen as a benefit or cost saver by anyone.  If we don't pass this Bill there would be no regulatory bureaucracy to fix, so let's just skip to the end and not do it at all.

It is just common sense.  If you add more bureaucracy, an additional layer between the consumer and the supplier, of course your costs are going to increase.  In addition, the Bill requires the establishment of a Health Commissioner and staff to handle all the paperwork, conduct studies, review insurance carriers offerings and employer insurance plans and mandate their compliance.  For what benefit?  If the goal is to cover the uninsured then create a Bill that does just that.

If the goal is to also provide bridge insurance (when someone is between jobs), there is already legislation (COBRA) that requires an insurance company to allow a person to pay their own premiums (for two years, I believe) during their unemployment period (until they have a new job with insurance).  At the point a person is uninsured (either becuase they never had insurance, they couldn't afford their COBRA, etc.), there would be a plan they could get through the Feds. If that's the goal, then write a Bill that does just that, and/or the above.  This Bill goes far beyond any of that, requiring that everyone have health insurance (and a person will be taxed for it, if they don't pay for one on their own, or are provided a government-approved plan by their employer).

I'm not recommending any of the above, only suggesting that the sound bytes about what this Bill is supposed to provide does not jive with what the Bill would create.  This Bill mandates health insurance in some form and creates a regulatory bureaucracy of all insurance carriers and employers' health care offerings.  That's not "cost savings."  That's growing the size/cost of government.

Someone, please, report me to the White House for spreading "misinformation."  Anyone who quotes the Bill could be accused of that.

Monday, August 3, 2009

Not So Fast, Einstein

In an article by Yuri Kageyama (AP Business/Yahoo! News, Nissan rolls out electric car at new headquarters, August 2, 2009):
"This car represents a real breakthrough," Ghosn told reporters and guests at a showroom in the new headquarters.

He said the new car and new office building in Yokohama, southwest of Tokyo, marked two fresh starts for Nissan, which hopes to take the lead in zero-emission vehicles.

Has the world gone completely nuts?  The car may be zero-emissions, but producing the electricity needed for it to run produces all sorts of emissions, depending on how the electricity is produced.

We have emissions from creating energy (in a gas-powered car the emissions are created when the car is driven, in electric-powered cars the emissions are created when the energy is produced).  The fact that the energy needed for this car to run is emitted before it is used in the car, doesn't mean that the car has the net result of being "zero-emission."

This is propaganda at its finest. The debate will continue about how to produce electricity (and how to produce more electricity as the need for it rises, especially if we are producing and buying cars that need electricity to run). In general, however, distributive processing is a better idea. All the combustion engine cars on the road are producing the energy they need, and are not reliant on the strained power grid. Increasing the demand on the power grid will require considerable investment, as well as produce emissions in its overhaul, and the fuel source that runs it.

If an electrical plant runs on gasoline (or fossil fuels) or coal, and a car uses the power it produces to run, is the car really zero-emission?

Of course not!  It seems that the concept of "net effect" is lost on most people.

H/t Drudge.

Dangerous?

Glenn Reynolds linked to the article below (Kathianne Boniello, New York Post, Jobless Grad Sues College for 70G Tuition, August 2, 2009) with the succinct question: Dangerous Precedent?
The Monroe College grad wants the $70,000 she spent on tuition because she hasn't found gainful employment since earning her bachelor's degree in April, according to a suit filed in Bronx Supreme Court on July 24.

If I'm reading the article correctly (and the journalist got the facts correct), Trina Thompson is suing Monroe College because they did not provide employment assistance as advertised.

Two issues make this troublesome:

  1. Suing is generally a bad idea. We've become all too quick to go to the courts to settle our differences. It is not clear if Miss Thompson attempted to reconcile the problem on her own. Miss Thompson may be labeled "sue happy" and if she is, she's doomed her future success (justifiably).

  2. The article's title (and the comments) make it appear that Miss Thompson is suing because she didn't feel her education was up to snuff, but that doesn't appear to be the issue on which she is basing her lawsuit. Her issue seems to be that Monroe College made promises regarding employment assistance:


The information-technology student blames Monroe's Office of Career Advancement for not providing her with the leads and career advice it promised.

At the conclusion of the article we find the basis of Miss Thompson's claim:
The college's Office of Career Advancement advertises lifetime free service for graduates, and boasts on the school's Web site: "We have many resources available for students at any stage of their college career, and even after graduation."

This is an interesting situation. If a company enters into a contract to deliver services and those services are not delivered, then a person has a right to get their money back (or sue, if the company refuses to refund the money). What makes this different, but I don't think it should, is that it is a college. Miss Thompson received an education and was awarded a degree, but it doesn't appear that Miss Thompson attended college (specifically Monroe College) with that goal in mind. She seems to believe that the education and degree were superfluous. What she was after was a guarantee of job placement and believed that Monroe College made that commitment as part of her enrollment.

It will be up to the courts to decide if Monroe College made false claims or failed to deliver a service. Further, it will be determined if the claims of providing job placement services were part of the contract Monroe College committed to as part of their enrollment agreement with Miss Thompson.

This case doesn't appear to be about the quality of education Miss Thompson received, nor does it appear to be about how qualified Miss Thompson might be as a job applicant (or how well she interviews). What is interesting is that Monroe College granted Miss Thompson a degree and it would be reasonable to conclude that the degree meant something (especially given that Miss Thompson received a technical degree in Information Technology).

If students attend college in a major that is job-training specific (as opposed to more lofty pursuits) then it seems reasonable that the degree should mean something. If it doesn't, if having the degree is not transferable to getting a job (keeping the job is another matter and up to Miss Thompson), then what value does the degree have? If it means nothing, if it doesn't translate to job offers, then the degree isn't worth the paper on which it is printed, nor should Miss Thompson have to have paid for it.

That seems reasonable to me. Colleges (and universities) have chosen to become job training centers, as opposed to educational institutions, and engage in a type of collusion with employers to require degrees for employment. Schools could have remained bastions of knowledge of Western Civilization, providing students with an education, rather than job training. But they didn't choose that. They chose to be placement centers, with large fees for their services. They should be held accountable for what they claim and what they promise, as any other business would.

As to Prof. Reynolds question: I do not think it is a dangerous precedent. It think it is an about damned time precedent. Schools have been charging ridiculous fees for sub-standard educations (often for sub par students).  It's time they're put on notice.

Miss Thompson appears to have learned something of value (whether she learned it at Monroe College or not): that when you pay for something advertised, the company must deliver those services or refund your money.  I applaud Miss Thompson's actions. Perhaps this will put the fear of God in these mostly useless institutions, and be the basis of true educational reform in this country.