Wednesday, May 13, 2009

The Fate of Conservative Intellectualism

No, that isn't an oxymoron, except perhaps to Richard Posner (The Becker-Posner Blog, Is the Conservative Movement Losing Steam?, May 10, 2009) as he laments what he sees as the anti-intellectualism bent of the current crop of self-labeled conservatives:
My theme is the intellectual decline of conservatism, and it is notable that the policies of the new conservatism are powered largely by emotion and religion and have for the most part weak intellectual groundings. That the policies are weak in conception, have largely failed in execution, and are political flops is therefore unsurprising.

I find no fault with many of Judge Posner's conclusions (although I disagree with much of his ideology). The Intel is severely lacking in much of what passes for conservative discourse. As some in the comments of the post suggest, it is not unique to conservatism, and the same claims can be made about those on the opposite side of the political spectrum. I don't care about the liberal-fascist's house because it is not my house. I choose to live on the other side of the aisle and in another town with respect to fascism, and will restrain my comments to putting our own house in order.

There is a considerable affection for the everyman persona, never before so laudably glorified by anyone as well as Frank Capra; popularized in men like President Truman; his hopeless, downtrodden plight painfully detailed in fiction in the Jobes family and Willy Lohmax, and seen as the base of the conservative spectrum.

The everyman has always been at war with Oceania.

Americans have a unique regard and sympathy for the losing side, and have long been suspicious of too much success, while at a same time, desperate to achieve it (and believing it is possible for everyone to do it). Rocky was the ultimate, simplistic underdog and America likes the underdog.  (If there was ever a simplistic explanation for John McCain's victory as the Republican candidate, there it is:  The Underdog.  He even resembled him.)

One of the interesting aspects of the discussion during Obama's candidacy was the positive spin it gave to Black children: the fascination with the idea that Black children could now be raised with the self-esteem booster of "you, too, could be President of the United States someday, if you work hard and apply yourself."  Some of Obama's victory was tied to delivering that message to Black children.

The unspoken part of that discussion was the suggestion Black children had not been told that by their parents before, or that without proof, it was not a reasonable expectation. This was news to many people, including me. I could not fathom that the parents of Black children were not being given the same praise and encouragement being given by not-Black parents. Live and learn.

The reality is that not all children are capable of being President of the United States, regardless of race.  In that sense, most parents are lying to their children when they say it, so what does reality matter in that sense. We know this in our hearts and our heads. That doesn't mean we don't and shouldn't use the same words to encourage children, regardless of their ethnicity or intelligence. What it does mean is that the pool from which to draw to develop great statesmen and leaders will always be small, having nothing to do with race or gender, and everything to do with the inherent capabilities of the individual, regardless of how hard they work or how well they apply themselves.

We can defer reality for a while and wait to see if a child demonstrates a keen intellect and other statesmen-like qualities. A reality-check can be performed only when we have data to determine what is real and possible, then we can tailor the message, and offer direction to more suitable and achievable pursuits.

Conservatism (and any other political ideology) requires a majority of voters to serve at its feet in order for the ideology to have political dominance. That does not mean that everyone will be capable of understanding it fully, or participating in heady-discussions of its roots and history, nor contribute in any meaningful way to the volumes of literature on the subject. In order to gain favor with the masses, sufficient to garner a majority, a dumbing-down of the message is required in order to reach people who would be just as vulnerable to the dumbing-down of any other political philosophy. There will always be a segment (large or small) of the population who are incapable of understanding or accepting anything other than a primer version, with simplistic platitudes to appeal to their sense of fairness and/or opportunism.

People, generally, do not like to be spoken down to, nor do they want masters. At the same time, there are obviously large segments of the population that buys into the liberal message, without any substantiation of fact or use of logic to validate their opinions. Memes work. Speaking down to people has worked for the other side, and despite this blatantly obvious fact, people like Judge Posner and those who make up the conservative intelligentsia are loath to do it.

Populists, however, have no such qualms about appealing to the everyman's baser instincts. We see evidence of this in the high audience ratings of people like Rush Limbaugh, Bill O'Reilly, Sean Hannity, and more recently, Glenn Beck. These men have not replaced the intellectual standard bearer, William Buckley. They never appealed widely to the same audience.

While Bill Buckley had a large following among a certain demographic, his popularity was never as vast as the audience that tuned into Lawrence Welk or Hee Haw. Other misconceptions about popular appeal and ad populum abound. The music rags were astounded when they learned just how popular country music was, when the datsets of top artists was changed to record sales, rather than call-in radio requests from large markets (generally Northern) radio stations. Country music was more popular than any of the non-country recording artists. Who knew?

Harry Truman knew. Harry Truman knew that messages such as "A chicken in every pot" would resonate with voters, without requiring any substantiation of policy directives that would make that a reality. Harry Truman also saw a surge in his popularity when he defended his ugly daughter's pitiful music skills. Even our ugly and miserable daughters were sacred and the lovely ideal of a father protecting his daughter's honor gained favor among the masses, even if they agreed that she was at best comely and should be kept far away from pianos.

Barack Obama knew. Barack Obama knew that messages such as "Hope and Change" and "Yes, We Can" would resonate with voters, again without any draft blueprints for bringing them about. Even when Obama's voting record and spotty history made it clear that his ideology was in direct conflict with the political leanings of most voters, he succeeded by reducing the message to the lowest common denominator.

Ronald Reagan knew, disguising well his intellectualism in his grandpa loves you and cares about you shtick. Even if his persona was genuine and his ideals sound, his ability to communicate and resonate with voters gave him an unmatched and unprecedented victory. Conservatives have been attempting to manufacture the Reagan persona, while men like Judge Posner squirm at the suggestion.

I will admit to a leaning to the squeamishness of appeals to popularity, but it is that squeamishness that limits the favor of conservative ideals.

The comedian Eddy Izzard shared that how you are perceived is 80% conviction, 15% of what you look like, and 5% of what you say. Extrapolating that to the political sphere, we can conclude that only 5% of the population care that what is said actually jives with reality and historical evidence, the bastion of the intellectual house. The remainder want platitudes, even if the 5% are loath to deliver them.

Conservative intellectualism doesn't sell or appeal to the everyman, nor can it be dumbed-down without the speaker losing some of his couth in doing so. Conservative intellectuals have resigned themselves to the losing side of history because it would be radical rather than prudent to do otherwise, and we're not radicals.

Conservatism as an intellectual realm of study was never popular because it can only be understood, appreciated, and championed by a small few, for a small few, and its popularity makes no difference in the grand scheme of history.  Loosely-labeled conservative politics will return to favor when Obama cannot deliver on his platitudes.  Then it will be time for another platitude messenger to give it try, and intellectuals, regardless of their sphere, will be chided for being elitists and out of touch.   Ad nasuem.  Ad infinitum.  

Limiting our dialog to "what will actually work" and "what is realistic to achieve gradually, after careful study and reflection on the specific culture's moraes and habits," just doesn't appeal to the everyman.  There's no shorthand version of that, Cliff Notes, or Conservatism for Dumbies that isn't an oxymoron of its intellectual point.  There's no emotionalism involved, tugging at our heartstrings, our love of drama, or our desire for fairness and righteous retribution. There is no Hollywood ending in real life.
"Do you know what "nemesis" means? A righteous infliction of retribution manifested by an appropriate agent. Personified in this case by an 'orrible cunt... me."

- Bricktop, Snatch, Guy Ritchie, 2000



Conservative intellectualism and discipline requires endless work, study, analysis, reflection, and truth to prepare oneself to decide a matter.  Why go to all the the hassle of that when a chicken in every pot and Democracy. Whiskey. Sexy. are so much more appealing.  Why watch Bill Buckley when Gallagher is on, too?

[Society] is a partnership in all science, a partnership in all art, a partnership in every virtue and in all perfection. As the ends of such a partnership cannot be obtained in many generations, it becomes a partnership not only between those who are living, but between those who are living, those who are dead, and those who are to be born.


- Edmund Burke, "Reflections on the Revolution in France," 1790


Tuesday, May 12, 2009

Thank you

I want to thank those who have linked some of the posts here and added this site to their blogrolls.  This site was launched in March and the site traffic is certainly more than I expected, especially since this blog has been active for such a short time.

Thank you.  Thank you.  Thank you.

- Herself (Anonymous by necessity)

When a Cut is Not a Cut

From John D. McKinnon (The WSJ, Higher Tax Would Hit at $235,000 [unlinked as registration required], May 12, 2009):
Administration officials also defended a related plan to limit the value of deductions for people making $250,000 and up, as a way to help pay for the cost of overhauling the health-care system. The plan would cap the value of deductions at 28%. It has run into serious opposition on Capitol Hill. But a senior administration official said it could yet become a viable solution, if other ways to pay for health care can't be found. "Nobody rushes to do the hard things," the official said.

Nobody rushes?  Right.  Never let a castrastrophe go to waste.
Business leaders have been sharply critical of the administration's proposed crackdown on offshore tax avoidance, including limits on companies' ability to defer U.S. taxes on their overseas income, which was intended to put overseas operations of U.S. companies on the same footing as their foreign counterparts. The administration estimated it could raise a total of $210 billion in the decade from its crackdown.

"The proposed tax increases on U.S. companies by the Treasury threaten the jobs of tens of millions of U.S. workers and our future economic growth," said John Castellani, president of the Business Roundtable. "Adopting these changes will hamstring American competitiveness....We need to work together on comprehensive tax reform that will restore competitive balance for U.S. workers and companies."

That is one way to make the Europeans love us:  Cripple our ability to compete with them, raising our already highest-in-the-industrialized-world corporate tax rates even higher.  Who saw that coming?  [Well, besides everyone who wasn't a fool.]

If someone was intentionally setting out to destroy our economy and businesses and to put us into a depression-rate unemployment situation, you couldn't find better ways to do it.

Intentional?  It doesn't really matter.  The outcome is the same.

The End is Near

The End is Near

From Martin Crutsinger (AP, Annual report due for Social Security and Medicare, May 12, 2009):
Fewer people working means less being paid into the trust funds for Social Security and Medicare.

The obfuscation that Social Security collections go into a "trust fund" continues. The reality is that, since its inception, the collections for Social Security have gone into the General Fund. The "General Fund" is the set of monies the Federal government may use for anything and everything.

The bait-and-switch is that there is a notation of the amount that was collected for Social Security, but no money is actually transferred to a special account ("lockbox") for this purpose. It would be unlawful to do so. The Feds are required to spend that money each year and are prevented from setting it aside (where it could earn interest for future recipients).  This has always been to the Feds advantage, until very soon:
For years, the Social Security trust fund has taken in more than it spent on benefits, resulting in a cushion of billions of dollars that the government could spend on other programs while giving the trust fund an IOU.

The FICA deduction has always been a way for the Federal government to fill the coffers with a tax paid by anyone who collects a paycheck (half paid by the employee and half the employer), all the while claiming that a certain segment of taxpayers (the bottom feeders) didn't pay any taxes.

As the linked article goes on to explain:
The Congressional Budget Office recently projected that Social Security will collect just $3 billion more in 2010 than it will pay out in benefits.

This means that in 2011 (with just a $3 billion delta between collections and payouts in 2010) Social Security will begin to drain the Federal receipts swamp.  Add the "Galt Effect" with many choosing to opt out of the earning side of the equation sooner, and this could get ugly.

The flip of the pyramid (where the amount paid out to those collecting exceeds the amount collected) will also occur for Medicare earlier than expected.

Inverted Social Security Pyramid



Combined with the baby boomers entering their retirement years and the high unemployment rate, the Federal government will be bankrupt sooner rather than later.

Without the Social Security surpluses to feed upon, the Federal spending in Obama's budget will incur even greater borrowing and an even higher deficit than announced in February, re-announced yesterday, and recalculated upward (on a near-daily basis).

Without Social Security reform (means-testing recipients, raising the age of eligibility, lowering the amounts paid, or raising FICA taxes) the Feds will have to deal with an ever-shrinking pool of taxpayer money to play with. The problem with all the reform ideas is that it will make a lot of people very, very angry.  Social Security won't be quite the sacred cow it was, once it causes the swamp to drain, rather than providing a surplus with which to engage in other unconstitutional spending activities.

George Bush had Social Security reform on his second-term platform, but no one would touch it.

This should be fun!


Monday, May 11, 2009

Lost in Found

More from the cornucopia that is BizzyBlog (Lost in Translation: Biz Press Reports Dollar Amounts of Toyota’s Losses, Not Its Sales, May 11, 2009):
Here are the first two paragraphs of Toyota Motor Corporation’s press release announcing its financial results for the year ended March 31, 2009 (most Japanese companies end their fiscal years on March 31; bolds are mine):
Tokyo - TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION (TMC) today announced operating results for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2009.

On a consolidated basis, net revenues for the fiscal year ended March 31, 2009 totaled 20.53 trillion yen, a decrease of 21.9 percent compared to the last fiscal year. Operating income decreased from 2.27 trillion yen to a loss of 461 billion yen, and income before income taxes, minority interest and equity in earnings of affiliated companies was a loss of 560.4 billion yen. Net income decreased from 1.72 trillion yen to a loss of 437 billion yen.

Across the board, the financial press reports I read translated the company’s reported losses expressed in yen into dollars ($4.4 billion in $US for the year, and $7.7 billion in the fourth quarter), but not its revenues (about $207 billion and $35 billion, respectively).

Why is that?

It may have something to do with the fact that Toyota, despite its considerable recent troubles, especially during most recent quarter, is leaving rivals Ford and General Motors in the rear-view mirror. That certainly distracts from the bailout blather about how GM’s and Chrysler’s crises were “unavoidable.”

Just two years ago, Toyota passed GM and became the world’s largest carmaker. In the most recent quarter, Toyota’s top line far exceeded Ford’s and GM’s ($24.8 billion and $22.4 billion, respectively).

BizzyBlog points out an error in reporting that used to be the bastion of government and snake-oil salesmen that is something the press is supposed to find and point out. Now the press is the one doing it.

If you're not a daily reader of BizzyBlog, you should be... if you want an example of the kind of work a firebrand press provides to a the republic. That's the press our Founding Fathers wanted to protect, but has been the left-hand of deceit from their inception.
"One of the amendments to the Constitution... expressly declares that 'Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof, or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press,' thereby guarding in the same sentence and under the same words, the freedom of religion, of speech, and of the press; insomuch that whatever violates either throws down the sanctuary which covers the others."

- Thomas Jeffersons, 1798



"The press is impotent when it abandons itself to falsehood."

-Thomas Jefferson, 1807



"An editor [should] set his face against the demoralizing practice of feeding the public mind habitually on slander and the depravity of taste which this nauseous aliment induces. Defamation is becoming a necessary of life, insomuch that a dish of tea in the morning or evening cannot be digested without this stimulant. Even those who do not believe these abominations, still read them with complaisance to their auditors, and instead of the abhorrence and indignation which should fill a virtuous mind, betray a secret pleasure in the possibility that some may believe them, though they do not themselves. It seems to escape them, that it is not he who prints, but he who pays for printing a slander, who is its real author."

- Thomas Jefferson to John Norvell, 1807



Starving the mainstream press from revenue is the only way to end the deceit.  Support only those presses who are seekers of truth.

How Not to Use Statistics

I was sent a link to an article by John C. Goodman (NRO, Socialized Failure, dated May 25 [sic], 2009) regarding the comparison of U.S. health care to countries that have socialized health care.  The opening paragraph gave me a thrill that the article was going to provide the kind of data we need to educate the public on the dangers and disadvantages of government involvement in health care planning and funding:
A slew of recent articles, published mainly in medical journals, suggest that the health-care systems of other countries are superior to ours on all these fronts. Yet the articles are at odds with a substantial economic literature. 

Mr. Goodman then goes on to cite various studies and statistics that show that we are often comparing apples to oranges.  I don't doubt this at all, as there are countless examples where our diverse population is compared to non-diverse populations (in crime studies, family studies, etc.):
All too often, the heterogeneous population of the United States is compared with the homogeneous populations of European countries. A state such as Utah compares favorably with almost any developed country. Texas, with its high minority population, tends to compare unfavorably.

A call for consistency in data universes is a good thing, but so are rigorous standards in the use of statistics, standards Mr. Goodman did not employ when writing the piece.  The following paragraph is an example of what I mean by not complying with standards in using statistics:
Overall, nearly 1.8 million Britons are waiting for hospital or outpatient treatments at any given time. In 2002–2004, dialysis patients waited an average of 16 days for permanent blood-vessel access in the U.S., 20 days in Europe, and 62 days in Canada. In 2000, Norwegian patients waited an average of 133 days for hip replacement, 63 days for cataract surgery, 160 days for a knee replacement, and 46 days for bypass surgery after being approved for treatment. Short waits for cataract surgery produce better outcomes, prompt coronary-artery bypass reduces mortality, and rapid hip replacement reduces disability and death. Studies show that only 5 percent of Americans wait more than four months for surgery, compared with 23 percent of Australians, 26 percent of New Zealanders, 27 percent of Canadians, and 36 percent of Britons.

Something didn't seem Kosher in the above paragraph and I also felt that presenting statistics in written form (rather than charts and graphs) made it difficult to follow or see the trends and comparisons.  I attempted to graph the data presented, but couldn't, and that's when I became suspicious that Mr. Goldman was cherry-picking the data.

He begins with: "...nearly 1.8 million Britons are waiting for hospital or outpatient treatments at any given time."  There is no comparison to the U.S. (or anywhere else). Without direct comparison to the same summary of data to provide another row in the dataset, it is an interesting factoid, but a  meaningless stat in relation to a conclusion of any kind.

He continues with: "...dialysis patients waited an average of 16 days for permanent blood-vessel access in the U.S., 20 days in Europe, and 62 days in Canada."  That sentence appears to qualify the first, but it picks a particular procedure, rather than the summary universe of the first sentence.  

In the sentence noted directly above, the subset universe was "Europe," but Mr. Goodman changes the universe to a specific country in Europe in the next sentence, "Norwegian patients waited..."  There is no comparison to the U.S., nor any other European country.  The sentence that follows, "Short waits for cataract surgery..." has nothing to do with the statistics under discussion.  It's advice, not data, nor does it show that we do it any better or worse (or that any country does it better or worse).  

In the last sentence, "Studies show that only 5 percent of Americans wait..." Mr. Goodman changes the dataset from hospital or outpatient treatments (first sentence) to surgery.  Are they the same?  I don't know.  It could be shoddy use of aggregate row reference, but I can't assume that "hospital or outpatient treatments" is the same as "surgery" in the latter example. He then goes on to change the data subsets from a Europe summary, to selected countries that haven't been introduced in earlier statistical comparisons, and limits to only one country in Europe, Britain.  

That is shoddy use of statistics.

I don't doubt the validity of the facts/stats that Mr. Goodman has included, but it makes me suspicious of his conclusions because he appears to have selected only the data subsets that confirm his hypothesis, provide remarkable differences, or sensationalism.

He should do better (especially as "president, and CEO of the National Center for Policy Analysis").   If you don't have comparison statistics when trying to make a comparison point, don't use the stats.  Don't be guilty of employing shoddy standards when the subject of your essay is shoddy standards!

Clean Your Own House First

From Stephen Labaton (NYTimes.com, Administration Takes Tougher Antitrust Line, May 11, 2009):
WASHINGTON — President Obama’s top antitrust official announced on Monday that the administration would restore an aggressive enforcement policy against corporations that use their market dominance to elbow out competitors or to keep them from gaining market share.

You mean like sweetheart deals for GM that will negatively effect Ford's marketshare?  

You can't make this stuff up!