Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Fair Wind

A few interesting clips from an article by Christopher Booker (Telegraph, Rise of sea levels is 'the greatest lie ever told', March 28, 2009):
The reason why Dr Mörner, formerly a Stockholm professor, is so certain that these claims about sea level rise are 100 per cent wrong is that they are all based on computer model predictions, whereas his findings are based on "going into the field to observe what is actually happening in the real world".

Regarding wind farms:
Britain’s largest windfarm companies are pulling out of wind as fast as they can. Despite 100 per cent subsidies, the credit crunch and technical problems spell an end to Gordon Brown’s £100 billion dream of meeting our EU target to derive 35 per cent of our electricity from “renewables” by 2020.

Meanwhile the Government gives the go-ahead for three new 1,000 megawatt gas-fired power stations in Wales. Each of them will generate more than the combined average output (700 megawatts) of all the 2,400 wind turbines so far built. The days of the “great wind fantasy” will soon be over.

[Emphasis mine.]

Just in case I'm accused of never pointing to any good news... the above should suffice as proof that I'm not good news immune.

Rights Versus Privileges

The California Supreme Court issued its ruling on the same-sex marriage issue. They decided that the citizens (who voted twice on the issue) get to decide. We should all be celebrating this decision. It would be nice if same-sex marriage advocates accepted the defeat gracefully, and avoided the expense of putting the matter to a vote repeatedly, but that is not likely.

One (of the many) issues clouding the debate on this issue is the subject of rights versus privileges.

Rights: Rights, which may be reasonably restricted (such as the prohibition against shouting "fire" not limiting your protected right to express opinions, as the First Amendment intended) may not be universally denied. Government shall/should/must.

Privileges: Actions and benefits which may be granted, based on a set of requirements or restrictions. Government may/could/might.

Driving is the easiest example of a privilege, not a right. In order to get a drivers' license, which is required to operate a motor vehicle on the public streets, a person must pass a written test, a driving competency test, and other restrictions which include age, safe driving record, sightedness, etc.

An individual (in most states) is not denied the ability to operate a motor vehicle on their private property or on the property of someone else who allows it, i.e., a child can drive his father's truck on the father's farm without a license. If the child drives the vehicle onto the public street, the child can be issued a citation (and the parent may be prosecuted for failing to properly supervise the child).

Similarly, an individual who, for whatever set of reasons, does not want to drive or cannot pass the requirements for a driver's license, may get an ID card. That is not uniform or available in all the states, but it is true for some, including California.

Civil marriage is not a right. It is a privilege. That's why it requires a license. The fact that it requires a license is the huge, flashing clue that it is not a right. Rights, by definition, cannot require a license. It is the ability to get the license, to change the requirements of couples wishing to get a marriage license, that the same-sex marriage advocates are fighting for. The citizens of California get to decide this matter, as it is (primarily) a monetary issue.

California law is entirely consistent (now) on this issue, as it is with other privileges that are handled by the issuance of a license.

No two people of the same sex can get a marriage license, regardless of their sexual orientation: gays, lesbians, and straights cannot get a license to marry someone of the same sex. In that sense, there is no discrimination on this issue.

Two (or more) people of the same sex can live together, just as individuals can drive on their own property without a license. They can commit to each other in a private ceremony (of religious or secular nature). They can initiate vows, contracts, and any other private arrangement to solidify and sanctify their relationship in the private sphere (among their family and friends, and all else who wish to validate and recognize their relationship).

Just as with driving, their inability to obtain a civil marriage license means they cannot take their relationship into the "public street," with official recognition of their status as "married," and thusly, afforded all the privileges and protection of a civil marriage.

In California, same-sex couples can get the equivalent of an ID card (in lieu of a drivers' license) for like reasons, which recognizes their relationship, but is distinct from marriage. The couple (or any multiple of parties) may create contracts such as a Durable Power of Attorney, Wills, or property ownership contracts. They can buy property together, and specify who owns what or what portion if the contract is cancelled/revoked by any of the parties.

The distinction (and separate definitions) of rights versus privileges seems to be lost on some people (commenter "Stealth," The Volokh Conspiracy, California Prop. 8 Upheld, But Held Not To Affect Existing Same-Sex Marriages, May 26, 2009):
The court essentially ruled that a simple majority of the state electorate can prohibit a minority from exercising a fundamental right, and that's not something to get outraged about?

The "simple majority" is how California decided to handle matters such as this. The "simple majority" did not deny anyone a "fundamental right" because marriage is a privilege, not a right. Regardless, same-sex marriage was not denied to a minority. Same-sex marriage was denied by the voters of California (twice) to all citizens of California, regardless of age, religion, race, creed, gender, or sexual orientation.

The majority of Californians could have decided differently. They could have voted to allow same-sex marriage to all its citizens (regardless of age, religion, race, creed, gender, or sexual orientation), but they didn't. Californians have not denied couples (or multiples) of the same sex the abiltity cohabitate, declare their love, devotion or admiration for each other, nor denied them any function or access such as establishing contracts, bonds, or making vows or commitments.

It's just the financial benefits and the official status of "marriage" that has been denied to all same-sex couples.

If you support the right of the citizenry to establish laws and constitutions, then you should be pleased that it worked in California; the courts did not attempt to legislate away the rights of the people of California to decide these matters through the ballot box and the majority prevailing. You don't have to agree with how the majority decided, only to recognize the right of majorities to decide these matters.
"If we are faithful to our country, if we acquiesce, with good will, in the decisions of the majority, and the nation moves in mass in the same direction, although it may not be that which every individual thinks best, we have nothing to fear from any quarter."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1808


Jack Sprat

From Phoenix Business Journal (Producer price index rises 0.3 percent, May 14, 2009):
The Producer Price Index climbed 0.3 percent after declining 1.2 percent in March. Food prices rose 1.5 percent in April, the biggest increase since January 2008.

Something is missing/not right. I realize that the plural of anecdote is not data, but food prices seem to be much higher than that. Meat and poultry prices (except pork) have been rising since last Fall.

Consumers are responding to the economic situation in their food purchases by:

  • Consuming less (either by producing smaller meals or extending meals)

  • Spending less (either by choosing cheaper brands or being more attuned to sale priced items)


The typical response to economic hard times is to hoard ("pantry load"), but people generally hoard shelf-stable products and comfort foods (usually higher in starch and sugar). Eventually, however, the pantry needs to be replenished, but replenished with what?

There were reports that consumers are responding to lower prices at the fast food venues, and those businesses have lowered their prices (and in some cases, their product sizes). Fast food venues have seen an increase in their bottom lines, by volume. The slight 1.5% increase has to be showing up in a much greater percentage in particular grocery categories.

From Bill Lapp (NY Times, The Drivers of Inflation, May 16, 2009):
The Bureau of Labor Statistics has reported that the producer price index rose by a modest 0.3 percent from last month, and is 3.7 percent below a year ago. However, while overall inflation at the wholesale levels remains subdued, the wholesale cost of food products continues to rise.

The P.P.I. for finished food rose by 1.0 percent during April compared with the previous month. The jump in prices was led by a 21 percent gain in egg prices. The surge in egg prices likely will reverse itself in the coming months.

Even in the middle of recession, the corn factor raises prices on everything from beef to processed food.

However the underlying strength in the wholesale price of other food products is unlikely to abate. Just as we experienced during 2007 and early 2008, increases in the price of underlying commodities (such as corn, wheat and vegetable oil) are driving wholesale costs higher.

Ultimately if this upward pressure on wholesale costs continues (as I anticipate), the higher prices will be passed on to consumers, resulting in an acceleration of consumer food inflation.

Grain costs, especially with so much of the corn crop going into the energy sector rather than the wholesale food sector, is running up meat production costs (and eventually those increases are passed on to consumers, but there is a delay in that increase).

That doesn't explain the increases in lamb prices (generally grass-fed coming from New Zealand). Retail lamb prices have tripled in the last year (as a lamb eating family this has taken quite a bite in our food budget, as well as forcing us to shift to lower cost meats and other food items to balance the increase).

From Owen Hembry (The New Zealand Herald, Record prices but flocks shrinking, May 18, 2009):
The national sheep flock is now down to levels not seen since 1950.

Rabobank's latest Agribusiness Review said farm gate lamb prices had strengthened since January, hitting levels more than 50 per cent up on last year.

Rabobank senior analyst Hayley Moynihan said prices would be enough to improve profitability but were probably not enough to encourage more investment.

The smaller flock had pushed up prices, she said.

"Our sheep flock has fallen so much because producers have got out because it's unprofitable, but they're not yet at the point where producers are going to start expanding the flock numbers again.

Pork has remained affordable, but only in comparison with other meat items (probably, but not substantiated, by the swine flu causing ignorant consumers to avoid pork, causing prices to decline).

From Derrell S. Peel (Cattle Network, Cow Calf: Beef & Cattle Markets Try To Maintain Seasonal Strength, May 22, 2009):
Total beef production is down 4.5 percent so far in 2009 compared to last year. The reasons for decreased production have changed in recent weeks. In the first quarter of the year, reduced cattle slaughter pulled beef production down despite sharply higher carcass weights. In recent weeks, slaughter has increased, as is typical of this time of year, but carcass weights have dropped to levels only slightly higher than a year ago.

Beef and lamb production is down, which has to drive up prices, but the selling price is dropping to appeal to poorer buyers, so buying is down.

Scarcity drives up prices, but less demand drives prices down, so there is a strange balancing act occuring. My hunch was that people (like my personal situation) are buying less meat/poultry, which is killing the producers, who are responding (appropriately) by producing less.  The result is less, for everyone.

Our pantries will eventually need to be replenished, but prices will have to eventually rise as decreased production and profits eventually effect producers (some will fold, others will contract).

Leaner times are ahead, not unexpectedly, but hungry people do strange things.
Jack Sprat
Could eat no fat,
His wife could eat no lean;
And so,
Betwixt them both,
They licked the platter clean.

- Mother Goose Nursery Rhymes


From the Mount

From Heather Mac Donald (Secular Right, Preaching from reason: a contradiction in terms?, May 24, 2009):
The greatest boon of religion, in my view, is the sermon. It is a formal, regular forum in which to shore up the values required for a stable, law-abiding society.  Those values—patience, forgiveness, and self-discipline, among others–are not religious values, they are human values; religion merely appropriates them and claims them for its own.  But secular society has not evolved a counterpart to the sermon in which to articulate and strengthen its core moral components. 

For a smart woman whose writing is about uncovering myths and deceptions, she certainly missed the obvious on this one.

You are the sermon, Mrs. Mac Donald, as is anyone who preaches the values of patience, forgiveness, and self-discipline from a virtual pulpit.

The Chosen Ones

Being "chosen" must get tiring and irksome.  

Via Drudge: (Breitbart/AFP, Half of Israelis back immediate strike on Iran, May 24, 2009):
Just over half of Israelis back an immediate attack on the nuclear facilities of arch-foe Iran but the rest want to wait and see the results of US diplomacy, according to a poll released on Sunday.

The above, combined with Iran's sabre rattling and their announcement that they reject compromise proposals makes it a certainty that, once again, God's chosen people will be the ones who have the burden and the hutzpah to do what is necessary to keep the world safe, by attacking Iran's nuclear facilities.

There was a time when America had that kind of leadership and backbone, but no more.

Friday, May 22, 2009

An Ill Wind

An ill winde that bloweth no man to good.  

- John Heywood, Proverbes. Part ii. Chap. ix.

So they've done it.

From David A. Fahrenthold (Washington Post, House Panel Passes Limit on Greenhouse-Gas Emissions, May 22, 2009):
A bill to create the first national limit on greenhouse-gas emissions was approved by a House committee yesterday after a week of late-night debates that cemented the shift of climate change from rhetorical jousting to a subject of serious, if messy, Washington policymaking.

[H/t Instapundit.]

The Senate has to consider the matter and come up with their own version, but it would appear there is no stopping this... or anything else for that matter.

We shouldn't be surprised. We should not be surprised by anything this Administration and Congress has done or will do, but I can't help thinking that I'm not the only one who hoped that for once they'd listen to the citizens, think of our national interests (just a tiny bit) before their own, and avoid taking us down this road to ruin.

In just 4 months they've shredded the Constitution so many times it is hard to keep an accurate count. For many of us it takes on the emotional equivalent of being repeatedly raped, eventually becoming immune to the pain, and tuning out the horrors that are occurring again and again and again.

We face the morning news in a constant state of shell shock, unable to handle the reality of what is going on around us.

Unfortunately, what government does takes a while to trickle down. From changing fiscal policy, nationalizing industry, putting a cap and trade on our prosperity, befriending our enemies and ignoring our allies, to taxing us and spending into deficit oblivion, the citizens have not cried out in unison and en masse against these horrors, because their effects are slow in coming. They're packaged as being the solution, rather than making our problems worse, or creating a problem where none actually existed... and nothing but misery will come of it. Once the effects are realized it will be too late, so all we are able to do is steel ourselves for the coming blow.

Calpurnia



Caesar, I never stood on ceremonies,
Yet now they fright me. There is one within,
Besides the things that we have heard and seen,
Recounts most horrid sights seen by the watch.
A lioness hath whelped in the streets;
And graves have yawn'd, and yielded up their dead;
Fierce fiery warriors fought upon the clouds,
In ranks and squadrons and right form of war,
Which drizzled blood upon the Capitol;
The noise of battle hurtled in the air,
Horses did neigh, and dying men did groan,
And ghosts did shriek and squeal about the streets.
O Caesar! these things are beyond all use,
And I do fear them.

Caesar



What can be avoided
Whose end is purposed by the mighty gods?
Yet Caesar shall go forth; for these predictions
Are to the world in general as to Caesar.

Calpurnia



When beggars die, there are no comets seen;
The heavens themselves blaze forth the death of princes.

Caesar



Cowards die many times before their deaths;
The valiant never taste of death but once.
Of all the wonders that I yet have heard.
It seems to me most strange that men should fear;
Seeing that death, a necessary end,
Will come when it will come.

- William Shakespeare, Julius Caesar, Act I, Scene I


Thursday, May 21, 2009

Missing the Missing Link Link

At the dinner table last evening we were discussing recent headlines. Two of us, including me, were quite surprised that we missed any mention of the discovery of the missing link (National Geographic News, "MISSING LINK" FOUND: New Fossil Links Humans, Lemurs?, May 19, 2009):  
The fossil, he says, bridges the evolutionary split between higher primates such as monkeys, apes, and humans and their more distant relatives such as lemurs.

"This is the first link to all humans," Hurum, of the Natural History Museum in Oslo, Norway, said in a statement. Ida represents "the closest thing we can get to a direct ancestor." 

Having that discovery found at all (which was never a certainty) is quite astonishing.  Having it found during my lifetime is something personal to celebrate. (I'm old enough to consider that breakthroughs that have been worked on during my lifetime will not complete before I die, but not this one!)

I would have expected special news bulletins would have accompanied the announcement, as the finding is as important and remarkable as "Mars creatures land on earth" would be.

I missed the missing link news completely, which surprised me, as I'm quite a news junkie.  

I shall attempt to rectify missing the missing link news by becoming even junkier in the future.