Tuesday, June 2, 2009

Personalizing the Impersonal

From Jeff Plungis and Keith Naughton (Bloomberg.com, Americans ‘Don’t Care’ About GM, Bankruptcy-Stung Detroit Says, June 2, 2009):
“It’s a sad blow to our egos,” Smith said.

‘They Don’t Care’

Dobski, the retired GM executive, says he recently went to Washington with a group of “Main Street bondholders,” lobbying Congress for more say about the deal the government was cutting with GM.

Both Republicans and Democrats seemed to dislike the company, if for different reasons, Dobski said. Their staffs didn’t seem to understand the industry’s reach, he said.

When a business attempts to tug at our emotions, rather than presenting a good product, no, we don't care. Emotional appeals can backfire, as it has for GM... and any other industry/business that's tried it.

For decades we heard these same appeals from the U.S. steel industry. Democrats attempted to keep the industry going by giving them bailouts. We were warned about how devastating it would be to the economy. "Too big to fail" weren't the exact words used, but the message was the same.

What emerged, after we allowed the industry to fail after decades of throwing money at it, was a better steel industry. Americans produce boutique steels now, in cleaner, more prosperous plants. Other industries moved in to fill the void - industries that are also cleaner/safer.

A business can't rest on its laurels. It doesn't matter if they produced a popular product 10 years ago. What it is doing today is what matters. Personalizing it is a huge mistake.

Capitalism works, when it is left alone to work. Half-way Capitalism isn't Capitalism at all.
“I think about all the times we went on strike to better the middle class,” said Larry Maykowski, a GM retiree who gathered with other workers yesterday at National Coney Island, a restaurant across from the Tech Center.

Auto workers went on strike to use collusion and coercion to satisfy their own greed. Assembly-line work may be boring, but it isn't difficult. If someone wants a "middle class" income then they have to develop marketable skills; improving oneself is how to improve your income. Coercion may work for a while, but it isn't lasting. It is the result of strikes and government meddle that enabled foreign businesses to compete more effectively against us. That is always the way, despite the deniers hopes that this time the same mistakes can be made, with a different outcome.

You can't regulate against competition. Well, you can, but it will always fail.

Monday, June 1, 2009

Still No

From AP (Breitbart, Schumer: Sotomayor is 'filisbuster-proof', June 1, 2009):
WASHINGTON (AP) - A leading Democratic senator says that President Barack Obama's Supreme Court nominee is "filibuster-proof" when his colleagues look at her record.

Sen. Chuck Schumer of New York said Sunday that Sonia Sotomayor's nomination is heading toward confirmation. He says she has a compelling history and a moderate record.

Of course she's filibuster proof.  The democrats have a filibuster-proof majority. Remember that the next time someone refers to a democrat as a "centrist," "moderate" or a "conservative-democrat."

The fact that she's filibuster-proof doesn't mean that every real conservative should ignore their responsibilities.  Vote "no."

Bold?

From PR Newswire (Breitbart, Thousands of Progressives To Gather This Week To Forge 'America's Future Now', June 1, 2009):
WASHINGTON, May 31 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Energized by last year's elections and more organized and unified than ever, thousands of progressive leaders and activists will gather at the Omni Shoreham Hotel in Washington this week for the Campaign for America's Future's "America's Future Now" conference, formerly known as "Take Back America."

They refer to Obama's schemes as "bold." That wouldn't be the word I would use. I'd prefer:

  • Fascist

  • Unconstitutional

  • Reckless

  • Traitorous


But that's just me.

Friday, May 29, 2009

New Normal

From Jeannine Aversa (AP Economics Writer, Economy's fall still bad - even if less steep, May 29, 2009):
The Commerce Department is set to release a report Friday that's expected to show the economy shrank at an annualized rate of 5.5 percent from January to March. If Wall Street analysts' forecasts are correct, it would mark a small improvement from the 6.1 percent annualized first-quarter drop the government initially estimated a month ago.

There are all sorts of old jokes that are similar to the above. They often start with "Do you want the good news or the bad news" and end with a wife or cat being killed in a fire.

The summation of the Commerce Department's report is that the economy contracted, again. It twisted the presentation to make it appear as a good thing: since it only contracted 5.5%, when it could have been 6.1%, we're supposed to infer that things are better.

The cat is still dead.

There are a number of factors that are going to prevent the economy from recovering, unless we tackle those issues. We need to tackle:

  • Entitlement spending (specifically Social Security). We will need to gradually eliminate it, beginning with means-testing.

  • Deficit spending (beyond entitlement spending).

  • Replacing private investment with government spending (across the board).


There is no political will to do any of the above, until it is too late, and excruciatingly painful.

The financial sites are full of predictions that suggest that we'll recover in the Fall, or next year, or things are already recovering, etc. What I don't expect to see is the truth: That there will be no recovery. This is the new normal. Our children and grandchildren will not have life as easy and prosperous as we did. Mostly, that is our fault (and the fault of our parents and grandparents).

Social Security is the biggest contributor because we allowed a Ponzi scheme to rake-in cash for decades and we allowed the government to maintain the ruse that there was some sort of trust fund, rather than the fact that the government spent all the money. That allowed previous generations to maintain the fiction that we had been more fiscally responsible in the past. The fiction that FICA is not a tax, just like any other tax, continues to this day.

Any report that says that "X % of Americans don't pay any tax" perpetuates that lie. If someone has FICA taxes deducted from their paycheck, they are paying taxes. That tax is put into the General Fund and is spent each year... and that has happened since the program's inception.

This has been a long time in coming. Previous Administrations are constantly blamed for deficit spending, but the real culprits of the deficits are never addressed. Even when Bush ran in his second term on fixing Social Security, the Congress wouldn't touch it. With AARP and similar organizations representing the largest special interest groups, politicians realize that reducing Social Security spending will end their careers.

Federal spending has clearly gotten out of control.  Social Security and Medicare has been a net gain to the budgets for decades, but in a few years, it will be a net drain, compounding an already serious problem.

The chart below shows Federal spending for Social Security and Medicare, and all other spending, in 2000 constant dollars:

[caption id="attachment_593" align="alignnone" width="468" caption="Spending 1976 to 2010 (in 2000 Constant $)"]Spending 1976 to 2010 (in 2000 Constant $)[/caption]

Apples in a Barrel

From Jonathan Martin (POLITICO.com, Barack Obama: Now or never on health care, May 29, 2009):
President Obama exhorted his supporters on a conference call Thursday to help lobby for his health care plan, warning, “If we don’t get it done this year, we’re not going to get it done.”

That seems simple enough.  "Not" works.

Thursday, May 28, 2009

Merits and Mercy

From Thomas Sowell (JWR, ‘Empathy’ in Action, May 27, 2009) writing about the Sonia Sotomayor nomination to the Supreme Court:
If you were going to have open heart surgery, would you want to be operated on by a surgeon who was chosen because he had to struggle to get where he is or by the best surgeon you could find— even if he was born with a silver spoon in his mouth and had every advantage that money and social position could offer?

As usual, Thomas Sowell gets it exactly right. We want the best, in all things, not the affirmative action candidate.

Sowell didn't get it right because he is Black, nor should Sonia Sotomayor be considered as a Supreme Court judge because she's a woman. Their race or gender are superfluous, or those characteristics should be.

The double-standard of Sotomayor's nomination is grating: She was nominated because she is a woman, but if we criticize her for her abilities or lack thereof, there are accusations of misogyny. Nice pedestal women have created for themselves.

I thought the idea of equality was about the destruction of pedestals and that everyone had equal opportunity to demonstrate that they could cut it and compete in the big leagues, without handicapping for being a woman or a member of privileged class.

That isn't the thing that bothers me the most about all of this. What is truly maddening is referring to anything a judge should do as having an element of "empathy," especially having empathy for women over men, or minorities over majorities.

Justice is supposed to be blind.

A judge is supposed to determine that laws are followed, not that empathy is meted out.

Acting as the referee for the law has nothing to do with empathy. The word that people are looking for is mercy; as in, "throwing themselves on the mercy of the court."

Mercy has a completely different meaning from empathy. Mercy, unlike empathy, flows from someone admitting their mistakes, of owning up to what they have done, and asking the courts for leniency based on the admission of guilt.

Empathy concerns itself with something else. It considers the feelings of those who stand before the law, regardless of what the law says or if the person has admitted their guilt, and told the whole truth. A judge cannot dismiss the law in determining guilt or innocence, but it can show mercy when meting out fines and punishments. Guilt or innocence is binary.

Absolution follows confession and penance, not the other way around.

The Supreme Court is liberty's last refuge, and empathy has no place in the Court's decisions. If the Court has done their job, and the society determines the law to be too cruel or harsh, it is the society who can change the laws under which the Court is bound.

The quality that judges must fight to expunge from themselves, to properly execute their duties as a judge of the law (not of the person), is empathy; otherwise, there is one law for me, and other for thee. That's not justice and that is not the liberty we stand for as a nation.
"The most sacred of the duties of a government [is] to do equal and impartial justice to all its citizens."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1816



"Let mercy be the character of the lawgiver, but let the judge be a mere machine."

- Thomas Jefferson, 1776


Wednesday, May 27, 2009

It Isn't "Gay"

From Brian York (Washington Examiner, Ted Olson goes to court on behalf of gay marriage, May 26, 2009), quoting Ted Olsen:
"I personally think it is time that we as a nation get past distinguishing people on the basis of sexual orientation, and that a grave injustice is being done to people by making these distinctions," Olson told me Tuesday night.  "I thought their cause was just."

Personally, I agree that we "as a nation get past distinguishing people on the basis of sexual orientation."  It would be nice if Mr. Olsen tried that approach himself, especially as it applies to this issue.

The arguments for same-sex marriage often focus on overturning the discrimination against homosexuals (in addition to the argument that suggests that marriage is a right, not a privilege, as I detailed in an earlier post).

The issue of same-sex marriage has nothing to do with sexual orientation, although many who support it are championing "gay marriage."  That, however, is how we bypass the problems of unintended consequences (by sidestepping them accidentally or intentionally).

It would be discriminatory (and an intrusion of privacy) to suggest that homosexuals cannot marry, or that Blacks can't marry Whites, or tall people can't marry short people, etc.  What the law says is that a marriage must consist of a man and a woman.  It doesn't go beyond that to apply a religious or moral test (although there is a health screening test in some states as well as an "adult" requirement), a racial test, or a sexual preference test.  It applies equally to all... as would same-sex marriage.

In order to avoid discriminitory practices, we need to apply rules universally, and California has in this case.  It is discrimination in marriage that "gay marriage" advocates are wanting (or they're avoiding the sticky issue that homosexuals can marry today, as traditional marriage is not denied to homosexuals).

Same-sex marriage is denied to everyone in California, regardless of sexual orientation, just as opposite-sex marriage is available to all, regardless of sexual orientation.

Calling it "gay" marriage doesn't avoid the obstacle, nor does the revised term in describing it, as opposed to legislating it, mask the deception of those who make the argument that way.  If same-sex marriage is made lawful in a state, it doesn't and can't restrict same-sex marriage to "between homosexuals" anymore than opposite-sex marriage can be restricted to "between heterosexuals."

How would you enforce such a restriction... have a "gay test"?  So if someone's favorite singer is Judy Garland, then they can have a same-sex marriage, but if someone prefers Nine Inch Nails they can't?

How ridiculous.

(For the humor-challenged, that was a joke.)

It isn't "gay" marriage.  It is "same-sex" marriage that we're arguing about.  Sexual orientation is irrelevant, as it would be impossible (as well as peculiarly invasive) to ask or determine factually someone's sexual preference as a prerequisite to issuing a marriage license.

I doubt that homosexuals who are in opposite-sex marriages would welcome such a requirement.

Be careful what you ask for... you may get it.

H/t Instapundit.