Thursday, May 21, 2009

Meme Check: Concern about Deficits

I'm sure I'm not the only one who has found the Democratic talking point meme of:
"Why are you concerned about deficits by Obama, when you didn't complain during Bush when he [insert a variety of the meme strains here]."

I find it most amusing in its audacity, as well as its frequency in the commentosphere.

It is not without irony.

The irony of the remark is that "where we were" wasn't in the voting booth supporting John McCain, which is why their guy got in in the first place!

Conservatives were so angry about the shift to the middle of the taxation road that many conservatives stayed home in 2008, ceding the election to Obama by default.  They also stayed home, rather than elect Republican-In-Name-Only/GOP Congressional candidates, which is also why the Democrats have a majority in Congress.

Now one could argue that it wasn't the best approach, given that Obama's deficits are exponentially greater than that of Bush's (in only the first few months of Obama's presidency) or anyone else in recorded history, but the reality is that the GOP candidate lost, partly because conservatives didn't think him fiscally (or otherwise) conservative enough. Conservatives were angry enough to stay home.

We were screaming all during the Bush years, and during the Clinton years, and the Bush years before that.  In fact, conservatives have been screaming about deficits for decades.  It's what we do.

We need a new law to handle this meme.  I don't mean a real law.  I mean something along the lines of Godwin's Law (where someone in a comment thread automatically loses the debate when they call their opponent Hitler).  

With online information sources such as Wikipedia, it is quite easy for a new term like this to gain traction and documentation.  

I propose that we call this new law "Klein's Law" after the infamous Ezra Klein, who manages the JournoList listserv where some of this type of spin originates.

Following on with the Godwin Law rule, anyone who suggests that conservatives were unconcerned or did not scream loudly about deficits in the past loses the debate.  (I'd suggest that we have them also receive 30 lashes for lying, but that's just me.)

Other naming suggestions are welcome.  I would name it after myself, but "Herself's Law" is just silly, and frankly, it would not be the type of notoriety I would welcome, even anonymously.

Stand Down, For Now

From Jillian Bandes (TownHall.com Obama May Grab for Guns, May 20, 2009):
Yesterday’s passage of legislation that revoked the longstanding ban on guns in national parks proved that this treaty would probably fall by the wayside once more, said Larry Pratt, President of Gun Owners of America. But the fact that Obama voiced his support for it speaks volumes about the President’s view of the Second Amendment, after his famous claim to not “take away guns” from law-abiding Americans.

We already knew how Obama felt about guns. His "clinging to guns and bibles" remark was consistent with his often "present," but sometimes "no" votes on gun rights issues.

Obama can sign a million treaties, but unless Congress ratifies them, it makes no difference at all. The Executive's only power in this arena (which can be trumped by Congress) is Executive Order, but he can't use Executive Order to ratify treaties.

There is plenty to be nervous about with Obama, but until Congress considers legislation that curb gun rights, I will remain unconvinced that there is an imminent threat to gun rights. Gun rights advocates have done a stellar job of letting Congress know that their votes on gun issues decide elections.

Vigilance is always a good thing, but it shouldn't give way to paranoia.

Careful There

Via Instapundit, a report on new college graduates employment (ABC News, Fewer Than 20% of Grads Land Job Offers, May 20, 2009):
According to a survey from National Association of Colleges and Employers, the class of 2009 is leaving campus with fewer jobs in hand than their 2008 counterparts. The group's 2009 Student Survey found that just 19.7 percent of 2009 graduates who applied for a job actually have one.

In comparison, 51 percent of those graduating in 2007 and 26 percent of those graduating in 2008 who had applied for a job had one in hand by the time of graduation.

[Emphasis mine.]

First, let's be careful what we quote here. The report doesn't say "less than 20% of graduates find work," as the ABC News article suggests by its title. The percentage is qualified with who applied for a job.

What could be a remarkable change is the difference from 2007 (51%) and 2009 (19.7%); however, we must still be cautious about making too much out of it.  We would need to know:

  • If the majors changed dramatically, such as a larger number of Business or Finance majors. Those degrees would have less marketability this year because of the contraction in the financial sector, as well as new business development in a cash-strapped economy.

  • If a higher number of graduates applied for work: If there were more graduates in the job market, the market for college graduates would be over-saturated. If, for example, 40% of college graduates applied for work in 2007, 50% of them securing a job would be 20% of the graduate pool. If, however, 80% of recent graduates applied for work in 2009, and 20% found a job, then 40% of the graduate pool found work. The net of that type of scenario would indicate that more graduates were employed in 2009 than in 2007:


40% of 1,000 Graduates = 400 * 50% = 200 employed

80% of 1,000 Graduates = 800 * 20% = 400 employed

If there is something close to the latter above, it could be that more college graduates are employed than in recent years. We do not know that from the report. It is fuzzy reporting from ABC News (because most journalists know very little about statistics, or it would appear to be the case, based on how badly they generally report on such things).
Bryan Hopkins, a senior at the University of Florida, calls the situation frustrating. "You feel frustrated because you feel now that was it all worth it," he said. "In a perfect world, I would have walked right off the stage and into a full time job in my field, but I mean I have the degree now and I am still waiting."

It would be interesting to know how many of those students voted for Obama. If so, it is a situation they helped bring on themselves. If they received business related degrees and they voted for Obama as a way of securing their futures, they should have their degrees revoked (as they obviously learned nothing).

It could be that there are other changes in the market that are causing this (although it is reasonable to suspect that market contraction is having an impact across the board). If there are too many software engineers and business/finance majors being churned out of universities, a glut of unemployed workers would develop overtime, even in a strong economy. Perhaps, just perhaps, software engineers and business and finance majors have gone the route of buggy-whip makers (the report would tend to support this line of thinking, as it details gluts of graduates from previous years).  The reporting doesn't allow us to conclude anything like that with certainty, but it is reasonable to speculate that there are too many of a particular type of major on the market, and (we can therefore assume) too little of something else.

You don't always get what you want, and the fact that someone wants a job in their chosen major doesn't mean there are opportunities in that field. Better major choices should be considered.

Summary: I detest reports like this one, as it gives too little information to come to any meaningful conclusion. I link to it to illustrate just how nonsensical these news reports can be, allowing anyone to spin it however they want. That's not science. That's propaganda.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Slight Edit

In a post by Dan Riehl (Riehl World View, All The Taxes Money Can't Buy, May 20, 2009) focusing on the "no" votes to the California tax increases:
It is imperative that Republicans not become aligned with Obama's moves and forge prudent alternatives people will one day accept to roll back the ongoing destruction of America's economic engine by this administration. 

It's so close to perfect that I'm reluctant to mention it, but...
It is imperative that Republicans not become aligned with Obama.

Full stop.

Why Not 3,000 Miles to the Gallon?

From Tom Krisher (My Way New, Obama's new rules will transform US auto fleet, May 19, 2009):
Some soccer moms will have to give up hulking SUVs. Carpenters will still haul materials around in pickup trucks, but they will cost more. Nearly everybody else will drive smaller cars, and more of them will run on electricity. The higher mileage and emissions standards set by the Obama administration on Tuesday, which begin to take effect in 2012 and are to be achieved by 2016, will transform the American car and truck fleet.

No, it won't.  Setting standards for American car makers does nothing to require foreign car makers to reach the same goals.  If foreign cars are cheaper, Americans will buy more foreign cars, without the magical MPG requirement... thus doing more to kill American car makers.

But that's not the point.  The real point I want to make is why 35.5 MPG?  Why not, if we don't care about the laws of physics or the realities of technological improvement methodologies, just set the MPG requirement to 3,000 MPG?  Pick any number, any number will do.  What's so magical about 35.5?  Is it the numerology equivalent of B.O. or something?

It's lunacy and a ruse to placate the greens.  These targets are never met and they're adjusted to jive with whatever happens in the future.  

In addition, they're outside the Obama Administration's electoral control... it's wonderful and sleazy to make a standard that you won't be around to take responsibility for (2016), when it doesn't happen.  

Obama has no problem taking credit for something that won't happen (or doing the opposite of what he says he's going to do).  Everyone who follows these things knows it won't happen, but we're all supposed to be celebrating the announcement of a standard that won't be met, a plan that would put the final nail in the U.S. auto maker's coffin if enforced, an action that adds unnecessary costs, and reeks of totalitarian, central-planning control of our purchase decisions.

Simply put to these unconstitutional regulations of business:  F.O.!

Color me unimpressed and not celebrating this nonsense.

Update:  He says it much better: “…And Sawtooth Gearing On The Belgian Design!” (Francis W. Porretto - Eternity Road, May 20, 2009):
Your Curmudgeon, a physicist by education, is not amused. Not this time. As Steven Milloy points out, there will be consequences. Some of those consequences will be fatal.

The internal combustion engine, despite its seeming shortcomings, is the most advanced powerplant available to the automotive industry. Its combination of compactness, performance, efficiency, and safety has every other method of generating kinetic energy from a portable fuel beat all to Hell. If you need evidence to this effect, consider how doggedly -- and futilely -- the world's automakers have struggled to obsolete this device. They've tried steam engines, Stirling engines, electric motors, gas turbines, fuel cells...everything but sorcery. The IC engine still rules the road.

RTWT.

Obama Care: Rationing and Reform

From Jeffrey H. Anderson (Weekly Standard, Three Strikes Against ObamaCare, May 20, 2009):
Once private insurers are driven out of the market, medical professionals will no longer be able to shift costs to them, and the government will have only one option to cut costs: ration care.

Rationing really is the hidden nightmare of government run healthcare. There are people who are so desperate for everyone to be covered that they dismiss (or refuse to accept) that rationing is what always happens.

A government run program cannot, like private insurers, cancel someone who abuses the plan. In addition, it is also known that when people get something "free" that they use it, and abuse it, running to the doctor for every sniffle or cough. So whatever the cost of medical treatment is today, double it, or triple it, and then you will have a more realistic price tag for what the first few years of ObamaCare would be like.

Those costs are not sustainable. There will have to be methods used to reduce the costs, or our taxes will be so high that no one was any room to maneuver. The is never any efficiency or "economies of scale" found in anything the government does. The government does things less efficiently and with higher costs than the private sector:
But it's hard to see through the lens of zealotry. Daschle actually proclaims that government-run health care would not only reduce costs but would be "much more likely to be innovative."

Government as an engine of affordability? Since 1970, Medicare's per-beneficiary costs have risen 34 percent more than the costs of all health care in America aside from Medicare and Medicaid--and that's even without including the costs of the Medicare prescription drug benefit. Government as an engine of innovation? Government lumbers like a walrus and is as flexible as a mule.

What Mr. Anderson does not address, that I will attempt to address here, is the real opportunities for reforming the cost of medical treatment: getting government and tort lawyers out of the process.

Every reasonable person recognizes that there is such a thing as "malpractice." It's meaning has changed over time, to become something equivalent to an idealized, almost magical thinking when it comes to medical treatment. We're all going to die. It isn't if. It is when and how. A patient who dies after receiving a heart transplant, does not mean that malpractice occurred. It means that reality occurred.

Medicine is not a science. It is an art, as there are variables that go beyond our human understanding, against the odds, and despite all efforts to change the outcome. Two exact same procedures can be performed on two different people and one will die and the other thrive. The death of the one doesn't imply or even suggest malpractice.

The public has a lot of responsibility to bear for all of this. We've become a nation of greedy... of seeing a car accident, an unwanted scar, or a broken ladder as an opportunity to win the lottery through a court settlement... passing along the costs of their winnings to all of us, involuntarily.

Certainly damages should be awarded when damage, malicious and intentional, is done. But even there, punitive awards go both ways and the individuals (and the lawyers) who receive those multi-million dollar awards have lost their souls in the receipt of it. They must remain eternal victims, never healing or recovering from their ordeal, lest they must admit to themselves that they're not entitled to the money they received.

We all want evil punished, but a predicable and reliable outcome of medical treatment is unrealistic.

We need tort reform as the best method of reducing medical costs. The ideas of universal care and insuring the "uninsured" are distractions to the real reforms that we need to address. It is not surprising that Congress won't act to reform where reform is necessary, because they're all lawyers, many who made their living as ambulance chasers, and have sold their own souls in the cases they've handled, and the awards they've deposited in their bank accounts.

To admit that we need tort reform would be to admit that they have bloody hands. Chances are good that they'll do anything else, including foisting the scheme of "universal heath care" on all of is, instead of admitting that they were complicit in evil and greed.

Tuesday, May 19, 2009

A Laffer Laugh

I lack the blogging credibility of Instapundit to link to something without comment and expect people to read it because I say so, especially if I am pointing to something Mr. Reynolds pointed out himself.

I would be lax, however, if I did not mention the article, as it is a brilliant smackdown on the "100 Economists" who have urged Obama to raise taxes on the rich (WSJ Online, Soak the Rich, Lose the Rich, May 18, 2009) by the esteemed Arthur Laffer and no-neophyte Stephen Moore:
Mr. Quinn and other tax-raising governors have been emboldened by recent studies by left-wing groups like the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities that suggest that "tax increases, particularly tax increases on higher-income families, may be the best available option." A recent letter to New York Gov. David Paterson signed by 100 economists advises the Empire State to "raise tax rates for high income families right away."

Here's the problem for states that want to pry more money out of the wallets of rich people. It never works because people, investment capital and businesses are mobile: They can leave tax-unfriendly states and move to tax-friendly states.

It would appear that the outcome of raising taxes is logical and a viable alternative to a group from the progressive "Center for Budget and Policy Priorities."  How incredibly daft of them to conclude that the wealthy, or anyone, will continue to be fleeced when there are better pickin's somewhere else.

Fleecing the rich has never worked, so how they conclude that it may be the "best option" leads to speculation on how they came to that conclusion.  The reasonable assumption is that they can't figure out any other option (such as lowering taxes on the rich or reducing deadbeat social spending).  They are ideologically blind to those options, as it is contrary to their addiction to the idea of redistributionism, and punishing the successful.

Mr. Laffer and Mr. Moore present a bounty of evidence to rebut the "studies" performed by the "Center for Budget and Policy Priorities." Studies are wonderful things, if you have to invent evidence where no evidence exists (such as studies to determine if a new drug therapy does what it is supposed to do).  If, however, there are decades of actual evidence to look to, it is not necessary to conduct additional research... unless you want to circumvent the established evidence for other than lofty objectives.   What, pray tell, could they have possibly studied to come to the opposite conclusion than the historical evidence proves to be correct?

It is also unworkable to suggest that people want to soak the rich and restribute their wealth to others, as a means of making things fair. What the people may want and what actually works are not always aligned.  If the people, whoever they may be, want a better life for themselves, then they have to morally and logically understand that you don't get there by making someone else the bearer of the burden, or ask them to make a contribution you are unable or unwilling to make yourself.

As Misters Laffer and Moore detail, the rich will simply take their toys and go to a new home, if they are not treated fairly and equitably. When they take their toys, they take the toys they share with others to play with, that affords the lifestyle to which others have grown accustomed.

If given a choice between a $20.00 ice cream cone, and the exact same one for $3.00, which one would you buy?  It's just common sense... no "studies" required.